Apple hit with app developer class action after US judge's contempt ruling
May 5 (Reuters) - Apple should return hundreds of millions of dollars to developers who claim the iPhone maker defied a U.S. judge's order governing its lucrative App Store, causing them to pay inflated commissions for more than a year, a new lawsuit said.
App developer Pure Sweat Basketball filed the proposed class action on Friday in the Oakland, California, federal court, after a judge ruled last week that Apple defied her order in a lawsuit brought by 'Fortnite' maker Epic Games.
The 2021 injunction in that lawsuit was supposed to give developers more freedom to steer consumers outside Apple's App Store for potentially cheaper purchases. Pure Sweat's lawsuit, opens new tab was filed on behalf of as many as 100,000 developers.
The lawsuit estimated that Apple's conduct cost them "hundreds of millions or even billions" of dollars in damages.
'Apple should be made to disgorge its wrongful profit, and developers are entitled to be made whole,' the complaint said.
Apple did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
In a statement, Steve Berman, a lead attorney for Pure Sweat, said they were focused on 'obtaining justice' against Apple.
The lawsuit follows U.S. District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers' April 30 ruling that said Apple willfully violated her injunction in the Epic Games case, including by charging developers a new 27% fee when Apple customers complete an app purchase outside the App Store. The injunction became effective in January 2024.
Gonzalez Rogers referred Apple and one of its executives to federal prosecutors for a possible criminal contempt investigation.
Apple denied violating Rogers' order, and the company on Monday filed its notice of appeal.
Pure Sweat said Apple blocked the developer in 2023 from publishing an app for education videos and workouts that contained links to purchase content outside of the app.
'Apple schemed to maintain the status quo, as if no Injunction had entered, retaining its billion dollar in-app payments revenue stream while depriving developers of the intended fruits of the Injunction,' the lawsuit said.
Apple faces other consumer and government lawsuits challenging its business practices. In one such case, Hagens Berman is representing consumers accusing Apple of illegally monopolizing the smartphone market.
The case is Pure Sweat Basketball Inc v. Apple Inc, U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, No. 4:25-cv-03858.
For plaintiff: Steve Berman of Hagens Berman Sobol Shapiro; and Eamon Kelly of Sperling Kenny Nachwalter
For Apple: No appearance yet
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
North Wales Chronicle
12 hours ago
- North Wales Chronicle
Millions of iPhone users issued urgent App Store warning
Millions of iPhone users and Android users with Apps downloaded from the App Store or Google Store have been urged to ensure they are making security checks. Lee Elliott, chief product officer at Compare and Recycle, said: "Before installing an app from the App Store or Google Play, always ensure it is a verified app and pay attention to its reviews." Users should ensure apps are updated regularly and remember to install any security patches when prompted, too, Lee said. Mr Elliott said: "If you suspect your device has been infected, the first port of call is to turn off your mobile data or Wi-Fi, and uninstall any suspicious apps you can identify. "You could also perform a factory reset. "On Android phones you can run a built-in scan to search for malware and resolve the issue, but due to the OS architecture out of the box, iPhones are well protected and are not generally susceptible to security breaches. "If you're experiencing any strange pop-ups as an Apple user try clearing your browsing history and cache first, and it'll likely solve the problem." He said: "While staying aware of your surroundings is the least you can do to stop your phone being snatched in the first place, there are simple steps you can take to protect yourself and prevent the worst from happening. Recommended reading: "A lesser-known trick for iPhone users is to disable Control Centre access from the lock screen. "This prevents thieves from quickly switching off Wi-Fi or turning on Airplane Mode if they grab your phone while it's locked, helping you retain the ability to track the device via Find My iPhone and making them more likely to let go of the device. "Simply navigate to 'Face ID & Passcode' in settings and toggle off the option for accessing your control centre when the phone is locked."
Geeky Gadgets
12 hours ago
- Geeky Gadgets
Your iPhone Will Thank You: 12 Things to Quit Doing
Your iPhone is a versatile and powerful device, but certain habits can undermine its performance, security, and longevity. Many users unknowingly engage in practices that expose their devices and personal data to unnecessary risks. By identifying and addressing these behaviors, you can ensure your iPhone operates efficiently and securely. Below are the key habits you should stop immediately to protect your device and enhance its functionality in a new video from AppleDsign. Watch this video on YouTube. 1. Neglecting Lock Screen Optimization The lock screen is more than just a gateway to your iPhone—it's a critical tool for usability and security. If you're still relying on default shortcuts like the camera but rarely use them, consider customizing the lock screen to better suit your needs. Replace unused shortcuts with frequently accessed tools, such as the Calculator, Voice Memos, or even a smart home app. Additionally, simplify gestures to quickly toggle features like Focus Mode, which helps you manage notifications without distractions. A well-optimized lock screen not only saves time but also improves your overall user experience. 2. Using Weak Passcodes Weak passcodes, such as '123456' or '000000,' leave your iPhone highly vulnerable to unauthorized access. Upgrade to a strong alphanumeric passcode to enhance security. For an additional layer of protection, enable Face ID or Touch ID. These measures are especially important in public spaces where someone could observe you entering your passcode. For sensitive apps like banking or email, consider using unique passcodes or biometric authentication to safeguard your personal data in case of a breach. 3. Ignoring Privacy Settings Your iPhone's privacy settings are a powerful tool for protecting your personal information. If you haven't already, disable app tracking in the 'Privacy & Security' menu to prevent apps from collecting unnecessary data. Turn off 'Share iPhone Analytics' to stop sending usage data to Apple. These adjustments not only safeguard your privacy but can also improve battery life by reducing background activity. Regularly reviewing and updating your privacy settings ensures that your data remains secure. 4. Mismanaging Battery Charging Improper charging habits can significantly shorten your iPhone's battery lifespan. Avoid charging your device to 100% regularly; instead, aim to keep the battery level between 20% and 80% for optimal health. Enable 'Optimized Battery Charging' in the settings to slow battery wear over time. Additionally, stop force-closing apps unnecessarily, as reopening them consumes more power than leaving them idle in the background. If your iPhone has an Always On Display feature, consider disabling it to conserve battery life when the phone is not actively in use. 5. Skipping Software Updates Delaying iOS updates can expose your iPhone to security vulnerabilities and performance issues. Apple regularly releases updates that include critical bug fixes, security patches, and performance optimizations. Make it a habit to check for updates and install them promptly. Keeping your software up to date ensures your device remains secure and operates smoothly. 6. Using Public Wi-Fi Without Precautions Public Wi-Fi networks, while convenient, pose significant security risks. They can expose your data to hackers, especially on unsecured connections. Avoid using public Wi-Fi whenever possible, or enable a VPN to encrypt your data and protect sensitive information like passwords and financial details. This simple precaution can prevent unauthorized access to your personal information. 7. Charging on Public USB Ports Public USB charging ports may seem harmless, but they can be exploited for 'juice jacking' attacks, where hackers compromise your device through the connection. To avoid this risk, always carry your own charging cable and adapter or use a portable battery pack. These small adjustments can protect your device from potential security threats. 8. Overlooking App Permissions Many apps request permissions they don't actually need, which can compromise your privacy. Regularly review your app permissions in the 'Privacy & Security' menu. Revoke access to sensitive features like your location, microphone, or camera for apps that don't require them. This not only protects your privacy but also reduces unnecessary background activity, improving overall device performance. 9. Allowing Too Many Notifications Excessive notifications can be both distracting and detrimental to your iPhone's battery life. Take control of your notification settings by customizing them for each app. Disable notifications for non-essential apps and group alerts to minimize interruptions. This simple adjustment can help you stay focused while extending your device's battery life. 10. Forgetting to Back Up Your Data Failing to back up your iPhone regularly puts your data at risk of being lost due to accidental deletion, hardware failure, or other issues. Use iCloud or an external storage solution to back up your data automatically. Regular backups ensure that you can recover important files and information if something goes wrong, providing peace of mind. 11. Keeping Unused Apps Unused apps take up valuable storage space and can slow down your device. Periodically review your app library and delete apps you no longer use. For apps you rarely need but don't want to lose, consider offloading them. This feature allows you to free up storage space while retaining the app's data for future use. 12. Ignoring Storage Management Running out of storage can lead to sluggish performance and prevent you from downloading updates or taking photos. Regularly check your storage usage in the Settings app and clear out unnecessary files, such as old messages, duplicate photos, or large attachments. Use cloud storage options to free up space without losing access to important files. Proactive storage management ensures your iPhone remains fast and efficient. By addressing these common mistakes, you can significantly improve your iPhone's performance, security, and longevity. From optimizing your lock screen to managing app permissions and avoiding risky behaviors, these actionable tips empower you to take control of your device. Start implementing these changes today for a safer, more efficient iPhone experience. Unlock more potential in iPhone battery optimization by reading previous articles we have written. Source & Image Credit: AppleDsign Filed Under: Apple, Apple iPhone, Guides Latest Geeky Gadgets Deals Disclosure: Some of our articles include affiliate links. If you buy something through one of these links, Geeky Gadgets may earn an affiliate commission. Learn about our Disclosure Policy.
The Independent
13 hours ago
- The Independent
Attorneys in NCAA antitrust case to share $475M in fees, with potential to reach $725M
The attorneys who shepherded the blockbuster antitrust lawsuit to fruition for hundreds of thousands of college athletes will share in just over $475 million in fees, and the figure could rise to more than $725 million over the next 10 years. The request for plaintiff legal fees in the House vs. NCAA case, outlined in a December court filing and approved Friday night, struck experts in class-action litigation as reasonable. Co-lead counsels Steve Berman and Jeffrey Kessler asked for $475.2 million, or 18.3% of the cash common funds of $2.596 billion. They also asked for an additional $250 million, for a total of $725.2 million, based on a widely accepted estimate of an additional $20 billion in direct benefits to athletes over the 10-year settlement term. That would be 3.2% of what would then be a $22.596 billion settlement. 'Class Counsel have represented classes of student-athletes in multiple litigations challenging NCAA restraints on student-athlete compensation, and they have achieved extraordinary results. Class Counsel's representation of the settlement class members here is no exception,' U.S. District Judge Claudia Wilken wrote. University of Buffalo law professor Christine Bartholomew, who researched about 1,300 antitrust class-action settlements from 2005-22 for a book she authored, told The Associated Press the request for attorneys' fees could have been considered a bit low given the difficulty of the case, which dates back five years. She said it is not uncommon for plaintiffs' attorneys to be granted as much as 30% of the common funds. Attorneys' fees generally are calculated by multiplying an hourly rate by the number of hours spent working on a case. In class-action lawsuits, though, plaintiffs' attorneys work on a contingency basis, meaning they get paid at the end of the case only if the class wins a financial settlement. 'Initially, you look at it and think this is a big number,' Bartholomew said. 'When you look at how contingency litigation works generally, and then you think about how this fits into the class-action landscape, this is not a particularly unusual request.' The original lawsuit was filed in June 2020 and it took until November 2023 for Wilken to grant class certification, meaning she thought the case had enough merit to proceed. Elon University law professor Catherine Dunham said gaining class certification is challenging in any case, but especially a complicated one like this. 'If a law firm takes on a case like this where you have thousands of plaintiffs and how many depositions and documents, what that means is the law firm can't do other work while they're working on the case and they are taking on the risk they won't get paid,' Dunham said. 'If the case doesn't certify as a class, they won't get paid.' In the request for fees, the firm of Hagens Berman said it had dedicated 33,952 staff hours to the case through mid-December 2024. Berman, whose rate is $1,350 per hour, tallied 1,116.5 hours. Kessler, of Winston & Strawn, said he worked 1,624 hours on the case at a rate of $1,980 per hour. The case was exhaustive. Hundreds of thousands of documents totaling millions of pages were produced by the defendants — the NCAA, ACC, Big Ten, Big 12, Pac-12 and SEC — as part of the discovery process. Berman and Kessler wrote the 'plaintiffs had to litigate against six well-resourced defendants and their high-powered law firms who fought every battle tooth and nail. To fend off these efforts, counsel conducted extensive written discovery and depositions, and submitted voluminous expert submissions and lengthy briefing. In addition, class counsel also had to bear the risk of perpetual legislative efforts to kill these cases.' Antitrust class-action cases are handled by the federal court system and have been harder to win since 2005, when the U.S. Class Action Fairness Act was passed, according to Bartholomew. 'Defendants bring motion after motion and there's more of a pro-defendant viewpoint in federal court than there had been in state court,' she said. 'As a result, you would not be surprised that courts, when cases do get through to fruition, are pretty supportive of applications for attorneys' fees because there's great risk that comes from bringing these cases fiscally for the firms who, if the case gets tossed early, never gets compensated for the work they've done.' ___
