logo
Britain is waging war on Apple – it is already backfiring

Britain is waging war on Apple – it is already backfiring

Yahoo22-02-2025

On Dec 2 2015, Syed Rizwan Farook and his wife Tashfeen Malik left their six-month-old daughter and drove to a Christmas party at the disability support facility where he worked. Armed with assault rifles, they opened fire on the attendees, killing 14 and seriously injuring 22, before being killed in a shoot-out with police.
The shooting was America's deadliest terrorist attack since 9/11. It soon emerged that the two had become radicalised online. Islamic State hailed them as 'soldiers of the caliphate'. FBI agents started investigating their online connections, pursuing signs of a wider network or contacts who might have enabled the attack.
Few would have been inclined to stand up for the couple's privacy. But when the FBI asked Apple to unlock an iPhone 5c belonging to Farook, Tim Cook, Apple's chief executive, refused. He argued that creating a backdoor into the iPhone would compromise the security of its hundreds of millions of other users, causing catastrophe if it fell into the wrong hands.
'We have no sympathy for terrorists,' Cook later said, but added: 'The implications of the government's demands are chilling.'
In the end, both Apple and the government got what they wanted. The FBI eventually cracked the phone with the help of an Australian cybersecurity company. Cook kept his promise to customers never to create a backdoor.
But a decade later, Yvette Cooper has picked the same fight.
This month a bombshell report in The Washington Post revealed that the Home Office had secretly ordered Apple to devise a way to break the securely encrypted version of its iCloud storage service.
On Friday, Apple took the nuclear option.
Rather than obey Britain's order to build a backdoor, the company chose to stop offering what is seen as a vital security feature. The company pulled the iCloud encryption feature, known as Advanced Data Protection, from British iPhones.
The move led to widespread criticism of the Home Office from privacy and security campaigners. Apple said it was 'gravely disappointed' by developments.
Cooper is now set for a fight with the world's biggest company, and potentially, the White House. Apple's British customers, meanwhile, have just had their security downgraded.
The battle with Apple has been 13 years in the making.
During the coalition government, the then home secretary Theresa May's plans for a sweeping surveillance bill were torpedoed by the Lib Dems, who labelled it a 'snooper's charter'. But after David Cameron won a Commons majority in 2015, the plans were revived. The Investigatory Powers Act gave the Home Secretary the power to issue encryption-busting notices, which could only be appealed through a secret tribunal.
Apple opposed the law at the time, warning: 'A key left under the doormat would not just be there for the good guys. The bad guys would find it too.'
As the years passed, the threat of being ordered to break encrypted communications and storage seemed to subside. The technology became ubiquitous in messaging apps, and a string of high-profile cyber attacks and relentless scams appeared to settle the argument. Untampered with encryption was the safest option for everyone.
In December, after a widespread Chinese attack on US telecoms networks, US law enforcement officials recommended for the first time that people use end-to-end encryption wherever possible. The warning was signed by agencies in Australia, Canada and New Zealand. It was a clean sweep of the 'Five Eyes' intelligence-sharing nations, with one notable exception: the UK.
Successive British home secretaries have continued to attack end-to-end encryption plans from companies including Facebook. Last year, the Conservative government tightened up surveillance laws, requiring that in some circumstances companies seek secret approval from the Home Office before launching new security features.
'There's a passionately held view in government that it's just wrong for parts of the internet to be off-limits to those charged with lawful protection,' says one intelligence source.
The Home Office has increasingly found itself at odds with Apple, which has made privacy and security major parts of its marketing. In 2023, the company suggested that it would prefer to shut down services such as iMessage and FaceTime in Britain than weaken their protections. It later accused the Government of seeking powers to 'secretly veto' security features.
Some security experts believe that Apple's increasingly strong rhetoric indicates it has been preparing for a secret order for some time, since the Home Office must consult with companies before issuing them.
While Apple does regularly hand data over to security services when asked, Advanced Data Protection, the Apple feature at the heart of the secret notice, encrypts content such as messages and photos in a way that not even the company can access.
Breaking this – as the Government's secret order requires – could involve developing and then installing a custom piece of software on a target's phone, allowing Apple unfettered access to their cloud storage that it could then hand on to law enforcement.
Reports have suggested that the Home Office has demanded a wider 'blanket' capability to read anyone's backups. Peter Sommer, a cybersecurity expert who advised MPs scrutinising surveillance legislation, says this would be disproportionate and unlikely. 'It's technically entirely feasible to break encryption on a per phone basis,' he says.
However, even if the order was targeted, security experts argue that developing the ability to crack an account, even if of a single terrorist, would put others at risk. Creating a master key for every door in town means it is possible that your own door could be unlocked, no matter how well protected.
Cook has made his position clear. Apple told the Home Office last year that it would 'never build a backdoor' and would prefer to remove features like iCloud encryption in Britain rather than comply. When Apple removed the feature on Friday, ministers could not claim they were not warned.
That will not be the end of it, however.
In theory, Apple must still comply with the order, since it could cover overseas accounts. Even if the order is now dropped, Apple will not be satisfied with the new stalemate, where it is left offering a less secure service in a crucial market.
Diplomacy may be a more likely ending. Ron Wyden and Andy Biggs, a Democratic senator and Republican congressman respectively, have written to Tulsi Gabbard, Donald Trump's new intelligence director, attacking the UK's 'dangerous' and 'short-sighted' efforts, and urging Gabbard to tell the Home Office to back down.
The Trump administration is yet to comment. But Cook, who met the president on Thursday, will be urging him to intervene. While officials reportedly forced Apple to delay the introduction of Advanced Data Protection during Trump's first term, Silicon Valley has since forged strong links with the president, who has vowed to protect them from overseas interference.
Elon Musk, a close adviser to Trump, criticised the UK on Friday, claiming in a post on X that the same thing would have happened in America if last November's presidential election had ended differently.
Ciaran Martin, the former head of GCHQ's National Cyber Security Centre, says that US authorities are unlikely to accept the crackdown.
'If there's no momentum in the US political elite and US society to take on big tech over encryption, which there isn't right now, it seems highly unlikely in the current climate that they're going to stand for another country, however friendly, doing it,' he says.
'The argument is lost. The geopolitical forces and commercial imperatives for the companies make what the Home Office seems to be trying to achieve next to impossible, not just now, but likely in the future.'
By taking on Apple, Cooper may have picked a fight she cannot win. Her Cabinet colleague, Peter Kyle, the Technology Secretary, said last year that tech giants like Apple must be treated as nation states. The Government may be about to get a lesson in what that means.
Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Survivors, victims' families tour Pulse nine years after mass shooting
Survivors, victims' families tour Pulse nine years after mass shooting

Yahoo

time13 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Survivors, victims' families tour Pulse nine years after mass shooting

For Marissa Delgado, the empty Pulse nightclub holds joyful memories of dancing with friends on Latin night and dark reminders of the worst moments of her life. This week, she plans to step into the shuttered club for the first time since the early hours of June 12, 2016 when an armed gunman stormed inside and started firing, killing 49 and injuring scores of others, including Delgado who still carries bullet and shrapnel inside her. Delgado sees the visit as a way to move forward and a chance to ease a bit of the immense grief, sadness and trauma that still weighs on her. But Monday, she admitted, she was still torn about her plans. 'It could help me,' she said. 'It could backtrack me. It could bring back a bad feeling,' she added. 'I don't know. I'm very scared.' The city of Orlando plans to demolish the club's building and erect a memorial on its site. But starting Wednesday afternoon and continuing this week it is offering families of those killed and survivors of the shooting a chance to see inside before the structure is torn down. The building has been closed and surrounded by a temporary memorial to the victims for years. Relatives of 24 of the 49 people killed plan to go inside starting late Wednesday as do about 70 survivors, city officials said, though they know some may decide once they arrive that they cannot go through the doors. The building has been cleaned and sanitized since the massacre nine years ago,but bullet holes still dot the inside walls. Portions of the walls have large holes where people tried to escape. There is no furniture inside, however, so the visitors will see only barren rooms. FBI agents trained with helping victims and survivors will accompany the tours. They will offer support and be able to show where the dance floor, the stage, the bar, the bathrooms — where some people were held hostage for hours — and the dressing rooms were located, said Donna Wyche, a mental health specialist for the city, who is helping to coordinate the tours. The agents also will be able to show visitors, if they ask, the exact spots where many of the victims fell. 'They may want to stand or be in the place where their loved one died,' Wyche said. The city is holding the tours — which are not open to the public — at the request ofvictims' families and survivors. 'It's not closure. But it is part of the journey of grief,' Wyche said Wednesday while standing outside of the Pulse building. 'We've heard them. We've listened to them. And they've said it very clearly: 'We want to see it one last time. We want to be in that sacred place, one more time.'' Christine Leinonen's son Christopher 'Drew' Leinonen, 32, and his boyfriend Juan Guerrero were both killed in the shooting. She is traveling from Polk County to Orlando for a late Wednesday afternoon visit. She has never been inside the club before and doesn't know what she expects to see or feel — but said she is determined go inside no matter what. 'I just want to see where my son took his last breath, where he bled to death,' Leinonen said. 'I owe it to him.' Leinonen said her son was shot nine times. Sometimes, she tries to imagine the pain he felt from the bullets, and the shock and terror as he lay helpless on the dance floor, waiting for aid that never came. She wants to see the last things he saw, she said, and breathe the air he breathed. 'I'm never going to actually know what he felt…but I have to get closer,' she said. 'I have to get close to my son's reality. I'm never going to get closure. I'm not trying to get closure.' About 250 people are expected to tour, many of them relatives but also friends or clergy members who victims and survivors have asked to accompany them. The city will have mental health counselors on site, too, to speak with any visitors who want that help. Delgado, 38, who lives in Clermont, has a friend going with her. She expects she'll hold her hand tightly during their tour Friday morning. Despite what she's faced, including hospital stays and countless therapy sessions, Pulse still sometimes also means 'great memories' when she thinks about about all the time she and friends danced and listened to music at the club on south Orange Avenue. Pulse was billed by its founders as 'the hottest gay bar in Orlando' but it was popular with a large crowd — gay and straight. The club's theme on the night of the shooting was Latin night, when Pulse became a crossroads of the Latino and gay communities. 'It had such a great vibe,' Delgado said. 'I remember how great everyone was.' Not all the survivors of the Pulse shooting want to go back inside. Leonel Melendez Jr. — who was shot multiple times and whose parents were told he might not survive his first days in the hospital — said he's not interested. Every year, he dreads mid-June, when he is reminded again of the worst night of his life. 'The whole thing just brings bad memories,' he said of the Pulse nightclub building. 'But I try not to feel sad. Pulse to me is like a cut, or a wound. I know that it happened. But with time, it heals.' he said. 'But the scar will always be there.' During the shooting, bullets tore through the back of his head and ripped apart his left leg. His good friend Javier Jorge-Reyes was killed. For two weeks, Melendez — 38 at the time — was in intensive care in critical condition. He was on a respirator for 10 days and endured several surgeries. His parents, Nicaraguan immigrants, still call it a milagro, a miracle, that he is alive. Today, Melendez can no longer hear out of one of his ears. And he struggles with physical pain and the emotional toll of the shooting. 'It's just very hard,' he said. 'It's a lot of mixed feelings, mixed emotions. Emotionally, it's very sad that my friend is no longer here.' Orlando Mayor Buddy Dyer toured the building nine years ago, after the FBI, which investigated the shooting, turned the building back to the city. He visited again more recently. 'It's a very emotional thing. Each person is going to experience it, I suspect, very much differently,' he said. 'Nothing can bring those 49 back. Nothing can cure the mental anguish that so many people have gone through,' Dyer said. 'There are different phases of grief, and everybody experiences it somewhat differently. I would hope that a site visit would be helpful to some, but I would also hope that the completion of the memorial would help everybody,' he said, speaking to reporters outside the club Wednesday. Building a Pulse memorial has been a drawn-out, controversial affair. Orlando took over the effort in late 2023 after the collapse of the onePulse Foundation. A demolition date has not been set, but city officials said the entire building will be razed, though the iconic Pulse sign will likely be saved. The new memorial — now estimated to cost $12 million — should be built by the end of 2027. Early plans show a reflection pool where the club's dance floor stood. An 18-member citizens' advisory group that includes victims' families, survivors and others helped choose the design. Though there was eventual agreement, some members initially wanted to save the building. Joshua Hernandez, who survived the shooting, will travel to Orlando from his home in Puerto Rico this week but is still not sure if he is ready to step inside the Pulse building. Hernandez had just left the dance floor to go to the bathroom when the shooting started. He was shot in his left arm and in the stomach and lay on the floor for nearly three hours until police killed the gunman and rescued him. He was in the hospital for two weeks. 'Probably yes,' he said about taking the tour. 'It probably will help me heal. … But every day I have this on my mind. It's still like yesterday.' Hernandez is frustrated there is still no permanent memorial 'It's been nine years. I don't want it to be 20 years and still no memorial,' he said. 'I'm ready to finish this facet of my life.' Skyler Swisher of the Sentinel staff contributed to this story.

Hong Kong outlaws video game, saying it promotes ‘armed revolution'
Hong Kong outlaws video game, saying it promotes ‘armed revolution'

Boston Globe

time15 minutes ago

  • Boston Globe

Hong Kong outlaws video game, saying it promotes ‘armed revolution'

The game was removed from Apple's app store in Hong Kong on Wednesday, but remains available elsewhere. Advertisement But it had already been out of reach for many gamers. It was never available in mainland China, and earlier this month Google removed Reversed Front from its app store, citing hateful language, according to the developers. ESC Taiwan is a group of anonymous volunteers who are outspoken against China's Communist Party. Their products, which include a board game released in 2020, are supported by crowdfunded donations. The developers said that the removal of the game demonstrated how mobile apps in Hong Kong are subject to the type of political censorship seen in mainland China. 'Our game is precisely accusing and revealing such intentions,' the group's representatives said in an email. In social media posts, they also thanked authorities for the free publicity and posted screenshots of the game's name surging in Google searches. They said the comments and pseudonyms selected by players in the game would not be censored, whether they were in support or in opposition of the Communist Party. Advertisement In its statement, Hong Kong police said the game promoted 'secessionist agendas' and was intended to provoke hatred of the government. They said that publishing, recommending, and downloading the game, or supporting the online campaigns that funded it, could amount to sedition and incitement to secession under the national security law in Hong Kong, offenses that can lead to jail sentences. This is not the first time a video game has been used as an avenue for political protest that has incurred the wrath of Chinese authorities. Animal Crossing, an online game in which players could build elaborate designs of their own island, was removed from mainland China after players began importing Hong Kong protest slogans into the game. Even though virtually all forms of dissent in Hong Kong have been quashed, the national security dragnet in the city continues to widen. Authorities have made widespread arrests under the law, which was imposed five years ago in the wake of massive pro-democracy protests. Last week, Hong Kong authorities laid new national security charges against Joshua Wong, one of the city's most prominent young activists. Wong is serving the prison sentence of another national security charge that ends in January 2027. Authorities last month charged the father of Anna Kwok, an outspoken activist living in Washington, D.C., accusing him of helping handle her financial assets. Kwok is on a list of people overseas wanted by the Hong Kong police, which has placed bounties on their heads by offering rewards for information that would lead to their arrest. Advertisement This article originally appeared in

Wall Street's rally stalls as US stocks dip for their 1st loss in 4 days
Wall Street's rally stalls as US stocks dip for their 1st loss in 4 days

Los Angeles Times

time26 minutes ago

  • Los Angeles Times

Wall Street's rally stalls as US stocks dip for their 1st loss in 4 days

NEW YORK — Wall Street's rally stalled on Wednesday after U.S. stocks climbed back within 2% of their all-time high. The Standard & Poor's 500 fell 0.3% for its first loss in four days. The Dow Jones Industrial Average was virtually unchanged after edging down by 1 point, and the Nasdaq composite slipped 0.5%. Several Big Tech stocks led the way lower, and a 1.9% drop for Apple was the heaviest weight on the market. It's been listless this week after unveiling several modest upcoming changes to the software that runs its devices. The action was stronger in the bond market, where Treasury yields eased after a report suggested President Trump's tariffs are not pushing inflation much higher, at least not yet. U.S. consumers had to pay prices for food, gasoline and other costs of living that were 2.4% higher overall in May than a year earlier. That was up from April's 2.3% inflation rate, but it wasn't as bad as the 2.5% that Wall Street was expecting. A fear has been that Trump's wide-ranging tariffs could ignite an acceleration in inflation, just when it had seemed to get nearly all the way back to the Federal Reserve's 2% target from more than 9% three summers ago. It hasn't happened, though economists warn it may take months more to feel the full effect of Trump's tariffs. 'Another month goes by with little evidence of tariffs, but the longer-term inflation challenge they pose remain,' according to Ellen Zentner, chief economic strategist for Morgan Stanley Wealth Management. Financial markets also had only modest reactions to the conclusion of two days of trade talks between the United States and China in London. Trump said Wednesday that China will supply rare-earth minerals and magnets to the United States, while his government will allow Chinese students into U.S. universities in a deal that still needs an agreement by him and by China's leader. Trump also said that 'President XI and I are going to work closely together to open up China to American Trade. This would be a great WIN for both countries!!!' Investors are still hoping for a more sweeping trade deal that would ease tensions between the world's two largest economies. Hopes for such deals between the United States and countries around the world have been one of the main reasons the S&P 500 has charged nearly all the way back to its all-time high after dropping roughly 20% below a couple months ago. Without them, the fear is that Trump's high tariffs could drive the economy into a recession while pushing inflation higher. The S&P 500 is now sitting 2% below its record. On Wall Street, Chewy dropped 11% after the seller of pet supplies reported a weaker profit for the latest quarter than analysts had forecast. Expectations were high after its stock had already rallied nearly 37% coming into the day for the year so far. Tesla swung between gains and losses before finishing with a rise of 0.1% to continue its shaky run. It's been recovering much of its big losses taken last week after Elon Musk's relationship with Trump imploded, which in turn raised fears about a loss of business for the electric-vehicle company. Musk on Wednesday backed away from some of his earlier comments and said they went 'too far.' All told, the S&P 500 fell 16.57 points to 6,022.24. The Dow Jones Industrial Average slipped 1.10 to 42,865.77, and the Nasdaq composite sank 99.11 to 19,615.88. In the bond market, the yield on the 10-year Treasury eased to 4.41% from 4.47% late Tuesday. Shorter-term yields, which more closely track expectations for what the Fed will do with overnight interest rates, fell more. Wednesday's better-than-expected reading on inflation raised expectations along Wall Street that the Fed could cut its main interest rate at least twice by the end of the year. The Fed has been keeping interest rates steady so far this year, going on pause after cutting rates at the end of last year. It has been waiting to see how much Trump's tariffs raise inflation because cutting interest rates could push inflation up even more, in addition to giving the economy a boost. 'The Fed could be justified in doing some preemptive rate cuts,' said Brian Jacobsen, chief economist at Annex Wealth Management. 'They were afraid that inflation would rise before growth would slow, but the script has been flipped and they will likely change their tune.' In stock markets abroad, indexes fell across much of Europe after rising in Asia. South Korea's Kospi was one of the best performers and jumped 1.2%. Choe writes for the Associated Press. AP Business Writer Yuri Kageyama contributed.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store