Waikato woman stole $7k from employer Early Education Waikato
'The only reason it's $7400 is because police could not get retailers, and places that Lisa had purchased from, to follow through and verify that had happened,' Frame told the judge.
'But from our end, it is very definite that those [258] were transactions made by her. In fact, two of those transactions were made after she was no longer working for us.'
McKenzie had been the administrator at EEW's two centres in the suburbs of Fairfield and Claudelands and after the thefts were discovered, blame was initially cast on locals in the area.
'Both of the centres are in low socio-economic areas, so it did actually impact quite widely where there were questions around how budgets were being spent.'
Judge Tan acknowledged Frame's comments that more money had gone but she could only sentence McKenzie based on the $7000 figure.
'I know that the reality from your perspective might be different to what I'm dealing with today.'
McKenzie was arrested and charged with one charge of theft by a person in a special relationship.
She first appeared in court in November last year and pleaded guilty the following month.
The 43-year-old was back in court last week for sentencing by Judge Tan.
'Accounting discrepencies'
McKenzie worked at Early Education Waikato between 2005 and 2023, moving into an administrator role in 2018.
That role meant she was authorised to use the company credit card to make business-related purchases.
However, in January 2021, she began using the credit card for her own purchases and intentionally omitted recording them, along with the receipts, into the finance logbook.
She left her job there in October 2023.
It was only when a newly hired administrator took over that she spied 'accounting discrepancies' and the company carried out an audit.
In total, they found the card was used 258 times in that 33-month period, totalling $31,444.52.
However, police were only able to prove McKenzie was responsible for 54 of the purchases, which amounted to $7378.40.
When questioned by police, the mother-of-three didn't offer an explanation or deny her offending but said she could pay it back.
'She can pay the money back now'
McKenzie's counsel, Russell Boot, said she had managed to borrow money from family to pay the stolen money back straight away.
Boot said that was a 'significant feature' and meant the EEW would not be drip-fed their owed monies.
As McKenzie had attended a restorative justice conference, pleaded guilty early, didn't have any other criminal convictions, Boot pushed for a sentence of community work.
'The reality is, the conviction is also a significant penalty for a person.
'There was some discussion for a Section 106 [discharge without conviction] but that's not being pursued,' Boot said.
McKenzie was employed at the moment and it was hoped her offending wouldn't impact that, he said.
'But that's a matter for her employer.'
Boot also added his client was only being sentenced on the $7000 amount and, if that was to increase, they would have to head to a disputed facts hearing.
'Cynical, calculated and persistent'
Police prosecutor Brendan Mills labelled McKenzie's offending as a gross breach of trust.
Advertisement Advertise with NZME.
'It was deeply cynical and calculated and persistent.
'There was also a large ripple effect on staff and students. McKenzie's offending undermines the funding integrity of those ECE centres and, as I understand it, the charitable trust which ... it puts the Government tax-payer funding at risk.
'There's high public interest in the education sector, in particular, being protected from fraudsters.'
'It's not just an entity that's been affected'
Judge Tan told McKenzie the impact of her offending 'makes for sad reading'.
'In terms of things that were going on for you, but also the impact of your offending and behaviour on the centre which expands widely in terms of the wider early childhood education community.
'So it's not simply an entity that has been impacted, but it is the children and their families and your then co-workers and those left to clean matters up.'
There was also an air of suspicion around the community in general at the time with people asking 'where has the money gone'.
While it wasn't clear why she had offended, but Judge Tan said there were 'things going on' for her wider family at the time 'that impacted on your poor decision making'.
Judge Tan accepted community work would be appropriate and sentenced her to 120 hours' and ordered she pay the reparation in full immediately.
Belinda Feek is an Open Justice reporter based in Waikato. She has worked at NZME for 10 years and has been a journalist for 21.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
19-05-2025
- NZ Herald
Erin Patterson allegedly visited death cap site before fatal lunch
On Monday, retired pharmacist and former Victorian Poisons Information Centre specialist Christine McKenzie gave evidence that she located death cap mushrooms near the township of Loch, about 28km northwest of Leongatha, on April 18, 2023. Prosecutors allege Patterson's phone records indicate she 'travelled to and remained in the Loch area at around 10am' on April 28, before returning to Leongatha. Also on May 22, it's alleged her records indicate she again visited Loch and Outtrim, where the jury was told a sighting of death caps was posted on iNaturalist a day earlier. McKenzie told the jury she was visiting her daughter and posted the sighting on iNaturalist, a citizen science website used to record species, under the name 'Chrismck'. 'We'd been for a walk … my husband and I took our grandson for a walk with the dog,' she said. She told the court that she observed death cap mushrooms under oak trees at the Loch Recreation Reserve and removed the sporing bodies. 'Initially, the ones I saw first were under a single oak tree,' McKenzie said. 'We had a dog poo bag with us, so I removed all the death cap mushrooms I could find.' Asked by prosecutor Jane Warren if there was a 'risk' the mushrooms could regrow, McKenzie replied 'absolutely'. 'More could come up over the subsequent days, weeks,' she said. Quizzed on if she saw any regrowth, she said she was only visiting Loch for the day. Under cross-examination by Patterson's barrister Sophie Stafford, McKenzie agreed she regularly looked out for death cap mushrooms when walking at the reserve. 'I often suspected there would be death cap mushrooms under the oak tree,' she said. 'I'd never seen them previous to that day.' McKenzie told the jury that she worked for the Victorian Poisons Information Centre for 17 years and developed an algorithm to decide what calls about mushrooms should be escalated to a mycologist to be identified. 'We couldn't ask every single call about fungi to be identified, there could be hundreds,' she said. She told the court that she developed a special interest in fungi and undertook further study. 'I became fascinated about how few fungi had been identified in Australia and I find them just personally beautiful,' she said. Telecommunications expert takes the stand Advertise with NZME. Digital Forensic Sciences Australia's Dr Matthew Sorrell, an expert in telecommunications systems, told the jury he'd given evidence in more than 400 criminal cases. Sorrell began giving the jury an overview of how telco company records can track mobile phones through their mobile data usage and connection to cell towers. 'In country areas, there are typically 1-2 base stations that cover a local town,' he said. 'There will also be base stations designed to provide wide area coverage.' He said mobile phone service will operate through 'greediness', with a phone flicking to different cell towers depending on which provides a better service. Jurors in the trial were shown a map that depicts cell towers in the Gippsland area at Korumburra, Loch South, Arawata, Kardella and Holmes Hill. Sorrell will continue giving evidence when the trial resumes. Prosecutors allege Patterson intended to kill the lunch guests attending her home after inviting them with the 'false claim' of discussing a cancer diagnosis. 'It is the prosecution case that the accused deliberately poisoned, with murderous intent, each … after inviting them for lunch on the pretence that she'd been diagnosed with cancer and needed advice about how to break it to the children,' Crown prosecutor Nanette Rogers, SC, said at the start of the trial. Her husband Simon Patterson's parents, Don and Gail Patterson, both 70, and Gail's sister Heather Wilkinson, 66, died in hospital in the weeks after the gathering. Wilkinson's husband, Korumburra Baptist Church pastor Ian Wilkinson, fell gravely ill but recovered. Defence barrister Colin Mandy, SC, told the jury that Patterson did not dispute that the four lunch guests consumed deadly death cap mushrooms at her Leongatha home. 'The defence case is that Erin Patterson did not deliberately serve poisoned food to her guests at that lunch,' he said. 'The defence case is that what happened was a tragedy, a terrible accident.'
National Business Review
15-05-2025
- National Business Review
Quick Takes of the Week to May 16
Monday May 12 Summerset launches $100m bond offer Retirement village provider Summerset is launching a $100m bond offer for retail and institutional investors to roll over existing debt. The bonds will mature in May 2031 and the interest rate will be the sum of the issue margin plus the base rate but, in any case, would be no less than 5.35%. Both the issue margin and the interest rate would be completed via bookbuild process and the bonds would be quoted on the debt market on May 26. Summerset has the ability to accept a further $50m in over-subscriptions. Today's announcement comes after Summerset said last week it was considering a six-year, fixed-rate bond offer to repay a portion of existing drawn bank debt. The company would then use bank debt to fund the repayment of Summerset's $125m bonds that mature in September. Summerset has four retail bonds totalling $575m on issue. The joint leader managers for the offer are ANZ Bank, CBA Bank, Craigs Investment Partners, and Forsyth Barr. Te Matatini outgrows Nelson; 2027 event scrapped for larger host Te Matatini, New Zealand's premier kapa haka festival, will no longer be hosted by Te Tauihu (Nelson-Marlborough) in 2027, as organisers say the event has become too large for smaller regions. Despite significant preparation, the festival's rapid growth in scale and attendance raised serious concerns about Te Tauihu's capacity in terms of accommodation, transport, and logistics. Te Matatini will now seek expressions of interest from larger regions better equipped to handle its expanding audience and infrastructure needs. Te Tauihu leaders expressed disappointment but acknowledged the logistical realities. It's estimated the cultural festival injected $22 million into the Auckland economy in 2023, and more than $25m into New Plymouth for this year's event. Tuesday May 13 Graham McKenzie to re-stand for MCK board Millennium Copthorne Queenstown. Graham McKenzie – a long-serving director of NZX-listed Millennium & Copthorne – will stand for re-election to its board. McKenzie, a former partner to law firm Bell Gully, was part of the independent directors' committee leading the response to the hotel group's recent takeover offer by major shareholder CDL Hotels Holdings. He'd indicated he wouldn't be standing for re-election but, on the strength of a request by a minority shareholder, McKenzie's re-election has been included in the notice of meeting. A former director of CDL, he has been a fixture of the MCK board since 2006. The company's annual meeting is scheduled to take place in Auckland on May 30. Wednesday May 14 Vector mulls sale of fibre business Electricity distributor Vector has signalled the possible sale of its fibre network business, with Australian investment bank Barrenjoey hired to help with a strategic review. In a brief statement to the NZX, Vector said the fibre business 'builds and manages data network solutions for businesses predominantly in Auckland, including major businesses, government entities and some leading channel partners'. There was no certainty a transaction would eventuate, it said. Vector has had a telecommunications operation since acquiring UnitedNetworks in 2002 and was a bidder for the Government's ultrafast broadband rollout in 2011 but lost out to the deal creating Telecom spin-off Chorus. The financial performance of Vector's fibre business is included in its accounts as part of 'other' revenue, which was $66.2 million in the year to June 2024, out of total revenue of $1.14 billion. David Smol. Government sets date for replacement of Crown Research Institutes Three new Public Research Organisations (PROs) being created under a major reform of the science sector will become operational on July 1. Barry Harris will chair the Bioeconomy Science Institute, while David Smol will chair the New Zealand Institute for Earth Science. The Institute of Environmental Science and Research will retain its existing governance as it transitions to the New Zealand Institute for Public Health and Forensic Science. Former Director-General of Health Dr Ashley Bloomfield has been appointed CEO of ESR until the end of 2026. All three organisations will remain Crown Research Institutes until legislation enables their transition to PROs in mid-2026. No date has yet been set for starting the new Advanced Technology PRO, although last week's $71m allocation from existing funding for a new science platform hosted by the Robinson Research Institute was hailed as the first step towards it. Foley Wines harvest up 35% NZX-listed Wine and liquor business, Foley Wine, has reported a 35% lift in its grape harvest. The company behind brands such as Mt Difficulty, Roaring Meg, Clifford Bay reported more than 8,600 tonnes of grapes were harvested across vineyards in Marlborough, Martinborough, and Central Otago. That was up from 6,404 tonnes of grapes picked in 2024. In Marlborough, Foley Wines reported its largest harvest on record, totalling more than 6,800 tonnes. However, disruptive weather and frost negatively impacted yields in Otago. Foley Wines chief executive Mark Turnbull stepped down at the end of April after 13 years in the role. He was replaced by Mike Higgins on an interim basis. Consumers reluctant to splurge in current economic environment Consumer spending using electronic cards was flat in April, according to data from Statistics NZ today. Retail spending using credit, debit, and charge cards was unchanged last month, compared with March. Spending in 'core' retail industries increased just 0.2%. Westpac senior economist Satish Ranchhod said some of the softness in spending was because of falls in petrol prices. Spending on groceries continued to rise, while spending on durables, such as household furnishings, along with the hospitality sector, had been flat in recent months. 'Today's soft result reinforces the picture of subdued domestic demand in the early part of the year,' Ranchhod said. 'We expect this picture will start to turn around over the coming months.' He said further interest rate cuts would help, but there were 'powerful headwinds', such as the cost of living and a soft labour market. 'Putting that all together, retail spending is likely to remain slow in the near term." Auckland Airport immigration area. Annual net migration gain continues to trail previous years New Zealand's annual net migration continues to dwarf previous years, according to Statistics NZ data released today. Overall, there was an annual net migration gain of 26,400 in the year ended March, well down from a gain of 100,400 the previous year. International migration statistics spokesperson Sarah Drake said the fall was mainly driven by fewer migrant arrivals, although departures rose to a provisional annual record. On a monthly basis, there was a net gain of 2300 in March, compared with a net gain of 3500 in March last year. From a travel perspective, Stats NZ said New Zealand residents arrived back from more than three million short-term overseas trips of less than 12 months. Drake said the increase was mainly driven by more trips to Australia, as well as Indonesia, China, and Japan. Meanwhile, overseas visitor arrivals to New Zealand were 3.32 million over the year, up 137,000 from the previous year. Thursday May 15 TradeWindow revenue up 30%, gives FY26 forecast despite trade war Trade Window Holdings is set to declare annual trading revenue of $8 million when it reports its FY25 results on May 29, and has given guidance for the following FY26 year of between $10m to $11m. The NZX-listed trade software company noted the unaudited FY25 revenue figure would be a 30% rise on the $6.2m it reported in FY24. It had guided it would reach revenue of between $7.3m and $8.3m in FY25. It said drivers of growth included its expansion in Australia, a 38% rise in annual recurring revenue – having reached earnings break-even in March this year – and its ability to cross-sell to existing customers. The company said it expected ongoing global trade disruptions would "accelerate the adoption of digital solutions among shippers and freight forwarders, as these businesses seek to reduce backend costs and navigate increasingly complex compliance requirements". Michael Fielding. AUT spin-out Dot Ingredients raises funding for novel surfactant Auckland-based Dot Ingredients has raised $350,000 in a round led by Motion Capital and including AUT Innovation Fund and Climate Venture Capital Fund. The AUT spin-out is based on research by AUT Associate Professor Dr Jack Chen and Dr Andres Tiban into Celluspheres technology – an innovative surfactant derived sustainably from wood pulp cellulose. Surfactants are a component of thousands of everyday products such as cosmetics and pharmaceuticals with a global market valued at $85m annually, but more than 95% come from petrochemicals and palm oil. Dot Ingredients CEO Dr Michael Fielding said the investment allows the startup to protect its IP and strengthen industry partnerships ahead of a seed round later this year. Dot Ingredients has already had substantial backing from various sources. Motion Capital partner Ralph Chang said the economics were compelling, with the technology having the potential to scale across multiple industries. "We see a strong pathway to global impact." SFO unveils foreign bribery reporting platform and ad campaign The Serious Fraud Office (SFO) has launched a national campaign targeting foreign bribery, to raise awareness and to encourage reporting. It includes a new online platform to support safe, anonymous reporting of suspected foreign bribery. The practice benefited corrupt people over honest businesses, the SFO said, noting it could take many forms, including a New Zealand company paying a foreign official for market access, a bribe from an overseas company to a public official here, or kickbacks to a private sector employee by a foreign company. The new platform will provide an encrypted channel for whistleblowers to report foreign bribery to SFO investigators. It uses the WhistleB platform provided by Navex, and was configured to "meet the highest possible settings for privacy and data security", the SFO said. All reports would be received by trained staff, and all interactions with case handlers remained encrypted, with data being stored in EU-based data centres.
Otago Daily Times
02-05-2025
- Otago Daily Times
Tourist dies after house bus wood burner left open
File photo A Coroner has found a fatal house bus fire might have been avoided if there had been clear instructions on how to use the wood burner. Chinese national Jirong Wang, 46, died while staying in the holiday rental near Hokitika in February last year. In her in-chambers findings, Coroner Heather McKenzie found the woman died from inhaling smoke and other fire fumes. The house bus had a door-closed wood burner, but there were no instructions on how to use it, so she and her husband left the fire's door open and stacked firewood in front of it, McKenzie said. "[Her husband] awoke in pain and soon realised there was a fire. He escaped but could not get Ms Wang. Others soon came to help but the fire was too involved to be put out with domestic fire extinguishers," she said. A forensic pathologist found there was no specific reason for her not to be able to leave the house bus, but the flames moved fast and she might have been overcome by smoke, and disorientation might have played a role, the report found. A Fire and Emergency New Zealand investigation found the fire had been used incorrectly, with the door left open overnight and the fire burning while they slept. "I recommend that accommodation providers whose accommodation includes heating by way of a wood burner have clear instructions on use, including not to leave the door open when unattended," McKenzie said. "Had Mr An and Ms Wang known not to leave the door open, they might not have done so and the fire might not have started in the bus."
