Will European agriculture convert to new genomic techniques?
ADVERTISEMENT
In the late 20th century, genes from different species were introduced into seeds, creating Genetically Modified Organisms, known as GMOs. The aim of the technology is to develop more resilient plant lines and increase productivity.
About two decades ago, the European Union implemented strict rules to cover authorisation, labelling and risk assessment; but now it has proposed deregulation of New Genomic Techniques, which modify the plants' own genes.
"The European Commission has decided to create two categories: one for products from these new techniques and one for the old ones, which will continue to be subject to the existing rules. However, some people think that these new types of GMOs carry the same risks as the old ones, with unpredictable impacts on the environment," explains Robert Hodgson, who covers the issue for Euronews.
The controversy is likely to flare up again because this month the governments of the 27 member states reached an agreement on the proposal, and ministers will now have to reach a consensus with the European Parliament, which has a different position on thorny issues such as patents and labelling.
©
Euronews
On a short tour of several cities, Euronews collected some European opinions. "I'm not totally against it. It would be important to do thorough research to determine if it has any side effects," said a Berlin resident.
"In recent decades there has been a huge development of this technology and we still do not have full control over it," said another from Warsaw (Poland).
"They need to be labelled, it's absolutely necessary so that the consumer can have a choice. Personally, I wouldn't buy them," was the opinion of a passer-by in Lyon (France).
Biotechnology experts argue that these plant varieties will be more resistant to drought, pests and require less fertilizer. Health issues such as allergies are also being targeted, through low-gluten grains for example.
Detractors point to the risks: disruption of pollinating insects, contamination of organic agricultural products, reduced access to seeds for small farmers and unforeseen effects on human health.
Will patents lead to small farmers exclusion?
©
Euronews
The European Council was divided on whether to allow patents, weighing arguments that this could restrict the choices available to farmers and create monopolies. It took almost a year for them to decide to allow patents, as long as their specific reporting requirements were met.
The European Parliament's position is to completely ban patents, explained one of the shadow rapporteurs for the legislative review.
"If a few big international agrichemical groups have a monopoly on seeds, farmers will pay more, they won't be able to choose and, above all, we will no longer be able to openly innovate on varieties," said Christophe Clergeau, a French centre-left MEP.
Few member states have actually shown much interest in GM crops, Spain being the exception. In many countries, these techniques have even been banned, with governments exercising their right to opt-out, but this option may no longer exist for all categories.
"It was about ten years ago when this issue really became a political hot potato and there was a lot of public opposition in Europe. Governments demanded an opt-out and they granted it," explains Hodgson, adding: "As plants in the new category will be largely equivalent to common natural plants, governments will no longer have the option of banning their cultivation."
Parliamentarian Clergeau stresses that "we are at the beginning of this new technology", arguing that the EU must be very careful because "when we intervene in nature, we trigger cascades of changes that can pose dangers to biodiversity".
ADVERTISEMENT
A new world of possibilities is rapidly opening up for food production, with researchers already exploring how generative artificial intelligence can be applied to the technology. Not without controversy!
Watch the video here!
Journalist: Isabel Marques da Silva
Content production: Pilar Montero López
ADVERTISEMENT
Video production: Zacharia Vigneron
Graphism: Loredana Dumitru
Editorial coordination: Ana Lázaro Bosch and Jeremy Fleming-Jones
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
LeMonde
an hour ago
- LeMonde
Shaken by US and Chinese tariffs, the cognac industry questions its future
The countdown has started, with pressure mounting in the Cognac region in southwestern France. China has set a July 5 deadline on making permanent customs duties of between 35% and 39% on imports of the prized eau de vie(brandy) from Charente − duties that have been in place on a provisional basis since October 2024. This marks a major blow for the industry. These duties would come on top of the US tariffs on the French spirit, which have stood at 10% since April – a level that could rise further if trade negotiations between Washington and Brussels, with a deadline set by President Donald Trump for July 9, fail or prove unfavorable to the sector. Caught in this double bind, the cognac industry has entered a deep crisis and is questioning its future. "I feel that in France, people are not fully aware of the problem: 80% of global cognac sales are made in China and the United States," said Bernard Arnault during his hearing before the Senate on May 21, describing a "major risk." The head of the LVMH luxury conglomerate, which owns the cognac house Hennessy, added that in a worst-case scenario, "with a 40% increase in Chinese customs duties and no agreement with the United States, there would be dramatic repercussions for Charente viticulture, which employs around 80,000 people."
LeMonde
4 hours ago
- LeMonde
Macron calls Gaza humanitarian blockade a 'scandal'
French President Emmanuel Macron said on Monday, June 9, that the humanitarian blockade of Gaza was a "scandal" and "shameful," calling for the reopening of humanitarian supply routes. Macron also called for a truce in the besieged Palestinian territory as tens of thousands of people staged rallies across France after Israel stopped a boat, carrying a dozen activists, including Greta Thunberg, from reaching Gaza. The rallies in Paris and at least five other cities were called by left wing parties. Jean-Luc Melenchon, head of the France Unbowed (LFI) party, called the seizure of the Gaza boat by the Israeli military "piracy." Macron meanwhile urged the immediate liberation of French nationals among the 12 activists on the vessel. He "requested that the six French nationals be allowed to return to France as soon as possible," his office said. France was "vigilant" and "stands by all its nationals when they are in danger," he added. The French government called on Israel to ensure the "protection" of the activists, and also called the humanitarian blockade of Gaza "a scandal" and a "disgrace."
LeMonde
5 hours ago
- LeMonde
Macron says imposing a moratorium on seabed mining is 'an international necessity'
French President Emmanuel Macron and other world leaders on Monday, June 9, called for global rules to govern the seabed and warned against racing to exploit the ocean floor in a thinly-veiled rebuke of US President Donald Trump. Growing anxiety over Trump's unilateral push to fast-track deep-sea mining in international waters shot to the surface at the opening of the UN Ocean Conference in France. "I think it's madness to launch predatory economic action that will disrupt the deep seabed, disrupt biodiversity, destroy it and release irrecoverable carbon sinks – when we know nothing about it," said Macron. Imposing a moratorium on seabed mining was "an international necessity," he added. The number of countries opposed to seabed mining rose to 36 on Monday, according to a tally kept by the Deep Sea Conservation Coalition, an umbrella group of non-governmental organiations. Trump was not among the roughly 60 heads of state and government in Nice, but his spectre loomed large as leaders defended the global multilateralism he has spurned. Of particular concern, his move to sidestep the International Seabed Authority (ISA) and issue permits directly to companies wanting to extract nickel and other metals from waters beyond US jurisdiction. Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva called for "clear action" from the seabed authority to end a "predatory race" to exploit the ocean floor. "We now see the threat of unilateralism looming over the ocean. We cannot allow what happened to international trade to happen to the sea." The deep sea, Greenland and Antarctica were "not for sale," Macron said in further remarks directed clearly at Trump's expansionist claims. The ISA, which has jurisdiction over the ocean floor outside national waters, is meeting in July to discuss a global mining code to regulate mining in the ocean depths. UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres said he supported these negotiations and urged caution as countries navigate these "new waters on seabed mining." "The deep sea cannot become the wild west," he said, to applause from the plenary floor. 'Wave of hope' Island nations also spoke out against seabed mining, which scientists warn could result in untold damage to ecosystems largely unexplored by humanity. "Here in Nice, we can feel that the looming threat of deep sea mining, and the recent reckless behaviour of the industry is seen by many states as unacceptable," said Megan Randles from Greenpeace. Macron said a global pact to protect marine life in international waters beyond national jurisdictions had received enough support to become law and was "a done deal." The high seas treaty struck in 2023 requires ratifications from 60 signatory countries to enter into force, something France hoped to achieve before Nice. Macron said the treaty "would be implemented" after roughly 50 nations ratified and 15 others formally committed to joining them. His office said this would happen by the end of the year, but did not name the countries. "Today's surge of ratifications for the High Seas Treaty is a tidal wave of hope and a huge cause for celebration," Rebecca Hubbard, director of the High Seas Alliance, told AFP. 'Prove you're serious' On Monday, the United Kingdom announced plans to extend a partial ban on bottom trawling in some of its protected marine areas. Macron said on Saturday that France would also restrict the destructive fishing method in some of its marine protected areas but was criticised for not going far enough. Greece and French Polynesia announced Monday the creation of new protected marine parks, following similar action from Samoa this week. Just 8% of global oceans are designated for marine conservation, despite a globally agreed target to achieve 30% coverage by 2030. But even fewer are considered truly protected, as some countries impose next to no rules on what is forbidden in marine zones or lack the finance to enforce any regulations. The summit will not produce a legally binding agreement at its close, but wealthy nations faced calls to cough up the missing finance to make ocean protection a reality. Small island states turned out in numbers to demand money and political support to combat rising seas, marine trash and the plunder of fish stocks that hurt their economies. "We say to you, if you are serious about protecting the ocean, prove it," said President Surangel Whipps Jr of Palau, a low-lying Pacific nation.
