Numbers prosecuted for not having TV licence down despite wave of evasion set off by RTÉ scandal
The number of people being taken to court for not holding a TV licence has dropped sharply, despite the wave of evasion set off by the
RTÉ
payments controversy
.
Raising fresh questions over the effectiveness of the TV funding regime, new figures show enforcement reduced after licence sales collapsed in the wake of the affair.
An Post
, the collector of the annual €160 charge, changed procedures at the height of the controversy because licence inspectors were being subjected to 'abuse and harassment'. The process has since returned to normal.
The revelation of undeclared payments to host
Ryan Tubridy
two years ago this week triggered a full-blown crisis for RTÉ over lavish corporate hospitality, a failed musical and large exit payments for departing executives.
READ MORE
This led to more than 100,000 people refusing to renew their TV licence, prompting a cash crunch at RTÉ that necessitated a government bailout for the broadcaster to avoid insolvency.
There were 947,924 licence sales in 2022, the year before controversy. But renewals collapsed once the disclosures started, with only 824,278 sales in 2023. There was another drop last year, to 792,243 sales.
Under the system set up to increase enforcement and deter non-compliance, An Post can bring people to court for licence fee evasion. The latest figures show a decline in enforcement in the year of the scandal and the following year.
In 2022, the company made 13,709 summons applications for non-payment and pursued 7,263 court cases. There were 13,198 summons applications and 6,555 court cases in 2023. This fell to 12,229 summons applications and 5,392 court cases last year.
'It was the case that inspectors on the doors were taking quite an amount of abuse and harassment,' An Post said.
'Certainly we had to amend inspection activity during the period of the RTÉ issue – and there was a cohort of the customer base that was unwilling to take out or renew TV licences for that same reason.
'But we have seen that change and many of those customers have returned to being fully complaint and the inspection campaign has returned to normal.'
Asked whether Minister for Communications
Patrick O'Donovan
believed the licence and enforcement system was working, his department said it was 'critically important' that households pay the fee.
'It is not only required by law. It underpins availability of public service content which is of great importance to our democracy and society,' a department spokesperson said.
The then government last year resolved to retain the licence fee but asked officials to examine 'potential enhancements'.
The drop in licence sales continues this year, with 329,956 sold as of the week ending June 6th, down from 335,400 in the comparable a year earlier period.
An Post did not provide enforcement data for this year, but it said the drop in prosecutions 'from 2023, through 2024 to 2025' followed procedural changes allowing inspectors to leave cards rather than calling into addresses.
Prosecution was always a last resort, the company said.
'The emphasis is on encouraging and reminding householders and business people to pay their fair share and of their legal and civic duty to do so. Only when a long series of postal reminders and house calls fail to result in a purchase or renewal does a case move to prosecution.'
More than 43 per cent of the An Post database comprises 'addresses entitled to free TV licences and addresses listed as having 'No TV'.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
20 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Peter McVerry Trust tells PAC it will not attend hearing
The Peter McVerry Trust has again rejected a request to appear before a powerful Dáil committee for a public hearing on its €15 million State bailout. The Committee of Public Accounts (PAC) had asked the charity to attend Leinster House on Thursday to discuss a report on its financial troubles by the Comptroller and Auditor General (C&AG), the spending watchdog. The meeting comes after serious governance failings by the trust came to light in investigations by two State regulators. This is the trust's second such refusal. It declined to attend the PAC in early 2024 because investigations were ongoing. READ MORE The charity established by Jesuit priest Fr Peter McVerry received just over €140 million from State sources between 2019 and 2022, the last year for which figures are available. [ Dublin hotel bought for €6.24m by McVerry Trust vacant since 2022 Opens in new window ] Responding to questions, the trust said it was not 'at this time' in a position to attend the PAC and still awaited completion of financial accounts for 2023. The C&AG report found the trust wanted the State to fully fund its services in the future. The previous financial model assumed 70 per cent State income and 30 per cent from fundraising. The report also said the Department of Housing had incurred €1.56 million in costs for 'professional fees' in relation to the McVerry trust. Such spending was in addition to the €15 million rescue package. In a letter to the PAC, the McVerry charity said the comptroller's document was 'accurate and the committee can be assured that the trust has nothing to add to it at this stage'. The charity was 'deeply appreciative' of financial support from the department and other funders, it said. Fine Gael TD James Geoghegan , a PAC member, said the refusal to attend was not acceptable, adding that the trust should reconsider. 'The reasons previously given for not attending the PAC committee was because of outstanding investigations which are now complete,' he said. 'Now the explanation is that they have nothing further to add, but this could have been an opportunity to help rebuild trust.' Asked about its refusal to attend, the trust held out the prospect of a PAC appearance when the 2023 accounts are released. 'Once these audited accounts are available, they will be published and we will share relevant information with our stakeholders and the public as appropriate, including making representatives available for the appropriate Oireachtas committee in due course,' it said. 'We remain fully committed to the ongoing reform and restructuring within our organisation. We continue to work intensively with our funders and regulators to ensure full regulatory compliance and to secure long-term financial sustainability.'
Irish Times
35 minutes ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on tourism protests: unwelcome visitors
Widespread weekend protests in Italy, Portugal and Spain, have seen local activists use water pistols and 'noisy strolls' of suitcases to draw attention to soaring housing costs and the environmental toll of 'overtourism'. In Barcelona, the centre of such recent protests, demonstrators carrying signs reading 'Tourists go home' and 'Tourism is stealing from us' marched down the city's Golden Mile, a street flanked by luxury boutiques and high-end hotels, spraying visitors with water. The main target of anger has been the soaring number of short-term lettings and its effect on availability and affordability in the local rental market. Airbnb insists that it is being scapegoated by protesters who should turn their attention to the hotel industry. The majority of overnight visitors in Europe, it points out, opt to stay in hotels – 63 per cent in 2024 according to EU. Last year travellers stayed in short lets for 715 million nights, an increase of 57 million on 2023. Figures for hotels were up 73 million to 1.9 billion in the same period. Since lockdowns ended, tourism to European locations such as Barcelona and Athens has rocketed. The golden goose of tourism accounts for more than 12 per cent of Spain's gross domestic product – protests also took place on its resort islands of Majorca, Minorca and Ibiza. READ MORE In response, the Greek island of Santorini, Venice, and Bruges in Belgium, have imposed new regulations and taxes on their tourism industries. Barcelona plans to ban Airbnb rentals by late 2028 and the Spanish government last month ordered Airbnb to remove nearly 66,000 listings from its platform. Pompeii said it would limit the number of daily visitors to its archaeological site to 20,000 a day. Ibiza and other places are limiting cruise ships. In the long run, however, the business model of cheap modern mass tourism must begin to accommodate paying staff decently. As part of this, the cost of tourism is likely to rise.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Former Cork hurler Anthony Nash has drink-driving case dismissed
The former Cork hurler Anthony Nash, who was charged with driving under the influence of alcohol, had the case against him dismissed on Monday after his barrister cited a lack of evidence as to the time of driving. Cork District Court heard how the two-time All Star goalkeeper asked a garda 'Do you know who I am?' when he was arrested on suspicion of drink-driving after his car was found in a ditch with the back of the vehicle protruding on to the road. Mr Nash (40), of Barterswood in Tower, Blarney, Co Cork, also told the garda 'I'm drunk' when she approached him on August 9th, 2023, the court heard. Garda Catherine Byrne told the court a Skoda Kodiaq crashed in to a ditch on the side of the road at Cloghroe, Blarney, Co Cork. READ MORE She arrived at the scene at 9.22pm, having received a report from radio control minutes earlier. Garda Byrne said a male came from the driver side of the vehicle. She stated he was 'dishevelled and appeared distressed'. She said he identified himself as the driver and he stated 'I'm drunk.' She asked him if he was driving the vehicle at the time of the accident and he replied he was. 'He then said, 'Do you know who I am?'. I replied 'No'. I asked if he had alcohol and he said, 'Yes, a bottle of wine'. He said, 'I'm Anthony Nash',' Gda Byrne said. Mr Nash was arrested on suspicion of drink-driving at 9.35pm. She said at that point he became visibly upset and stated: 'My life is ruined.' Mr Nash was taken to Gurranabraher Garda station in the patrol car. He was asked if he wanted to give a sample of blood or urine. He opted to provide urine, but was unable to do so. He then complied to a direction to give a blood sample. The allegation in the summons was that Mr Nash had 236 milligrams of alcohol per 100 millilitres of blood. That exceeds the limit of 50 milligrams of alcohol per 100 millilitres of blood. Paula McCarthy, defending, said her client had fully complied with gardaí and had been unable to provide a urine sample 'through no fault of his own'. She told Judge Philip O'Leary that while Gda Byrne received a call about the incident at 9.15pm there was no evidence as to the time of driving. Ms McCarthy applied for the case to be dismissed on the grounds that there was absence of evidence on the time of the driving or the fact of the driving. For a case of this type to succeed there must be evidence the driving occurred within three hours of a test for alcohol being carried out. The judge said as there was no evidence of the time of driving he had no option but to dismiss the case.
