Europe rights court condemns France over racial profiling
STRASBOURG: A top European court on Thursday condemned France for failing to protect the rights of a Frenchman who had accused his country's police of racial profiling.
The European Court of Human Rights was unable to determine discrimination in the case of five other French plaintiffs.
But it found that the government had provided no 'objective and reasonable justification' for police stopping Karim Touil three times in 10 days in the eastern city of Besancon in 2011.
The court said it was 'very aware of the difficulties for police officers to decide, very quickly and without necessarily having clear internal instructions, whether they are facing a threat to public order or security.'
But in the case of Touil, it presumed 'discriminatory treatment' that the French government was not able to refute.
It ordered the French state to pay him 3,000 euros ($3,500).
Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International last year said racial profiling was 'widespread throughout the country and deeply rooted in police practices.'
HRW said young men and boys perceived as black or Arab, some as young as 10, were often subjected to 'abusive and illegal identity checks.'
The rights groups said they had lodged a complaint with the UN Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination.
France's rights ombudsman in 2017 found that a young person 'perceived as black or Arab' was 20 times more likely to face an identity check than the rest of the population.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Arab News
4 hours ago
- Arab News
Ukraine, Russia exchange another group of POWs
CHERNIGIV REGION, Ukraine: Ukraine and Russia exchanged a new group of captured soldiers on Thursday, the latest in a series of prisoner swaps agreed at peace talks in Istanbul earlier this month. Neither side said how many prisoners were released in the latest exchange. The two countries pledged to swap at least 1,000 soldiers each during their direct meeting in Istanbul on June 2 but no follow-up talks have been scheduled. The return of prisoners of war and the repatriation of war dead have been among the few areas of cooperation between the warring sides since Moscow invaded Ukraine in 2022. 'Today, warriors of the Armed Forces, the National Guard, and the State Border Guard Service are returning home,' Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky said on social media. He shared images of Ukrainian soldiers draped in blue-and-yellow national flags, smiling and tearfully embracing. AFP reporters in Ukraine's northern Chernigiv region saw relatives awaiting the prisoner release. Some family members waved posters of missing or captured soldiers in the hope someone would recognize their loved ones and bring them news. Svitlana Nosal learned her husband Viktor had been freed. 'It's such a joy, I don't know how to describe it, how to put it into words,' she said, laughing and crying in the late afternoon sun. The majority of those released on Thursday were held captive for more than three years, according to Ukraine's Coordination Headquarters for the Treatment of Prisoners of War. Many of them were taken prisoner in Mariupol, a Ukrainian port city that fell to Russian forces in 2022 following a nearly three-month siege, it said. Russia said its soldiers had been transferred to Belarus and were receiving 'psychological and medical care.' 'Another group of Russian servicemen has been returned from territory controlled by the Kyiv regime,' the defense ministry said in a statement. It posted a video showing freed Russian soldiers draped in their national flag, chanting 'Russia, Russia, Russia!'
Arab News
6 hours ago
- Arab News
Members of UK Jewish group to appeal punishments for Gaza war criticisms
LONDON: Dozens of representatives of the main organization representing Jews in the UK are appealing against disciplinary action taken against them after they criticized Israel's war on Gaza. The Board of Deputies of British Jews this week sanctioned 36 of its representatives after they signed a letter in April in which they said they could 'no longer remain silent' over the loss of life in Gaza. The board suspended five of the deputies for two years and reprimanded the remaining 31 for breaching its code of conduct. The reprimanded members said on Thursday they would appeal against the decision, and continued to voice concerns about the conflict, The Guardian newspaper reported. In a group statement, they said they 'remain deeply concerned about the remaining hostages, the appalling humanitarian crisis and ongoing war in Gaza and the further deteriorating situation in the West Bank.' They added that they stand in solidarity with the majority of Israelis who want an immediate end to the war in Gaza, and there was 'no justification for the continuing misery and destruction being wrought on Gazan civilians.' When it announced the punishments on Tuesday, the Board of Deputies said the letter was 'neither authorized by the board nor did the signatories share it with the organization before sending to the Financial Times.' It had received various complaints about the letter and the media coverage that followed, it added. The five signatories suspended for two years were removed from any elected positions they held. They were handed more severe punishments than the others because they had 'contributed to the misleading press release,' the board said, and made public statements relating to the letter. The remaining 31 deputies who signed the letter but did not promote it received a 'notice of criticism' and were warned they would face suspension if they were involved in any similar incidents. One of the five suspended members, Harriett Goldenberg, was vice chair of the board's international division. She told The Guardian: 'So many Jews in the UK agreed with our sadly groundbreaking letter. We were inundated with thanks from those who said we represented them, and that we were their voice. It is tragic that voice is still needed.' The Board of Deputies is the largest representative body for Jews in the UK, with 300 deputies who are elected by synagogues and communal organizations.
Arab News
10 hours ago
- Arab News
Germany scraps funding for sea rescues of migrants
'I don't think it's the foreign office's job to finance this kind of sea rescue,' Wadephul said'We need to be active where the need is greatest'BERLIN: Germany is cutting financial support for charities that rescue migrants at risk of drowning in the Mediterranean, saying it will redirect resources to addressing conditions in source countries that spur people to decades, migrants driven by war and poverty have made perilous crossings to reach Europe's southern borders, with thousands estimated to die every year in their bid to reach a continent grown increasingly hostile to migration.'Germany is committed to being humane and will help where people suffer but I don't think it's the foreign office's job to finance this kind of sea rescue,' Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul told a news conference.'We need to be active where the need is greatest,' he added, mentioning the humanitarian emergency in war-shattered the previous left-leaning government, Germany began paying around 2 million euros ($2.34 million) annually to non-governmental organizations carrying out rescues of migrant-laden boats in trouble at them, it has been a key source of funds: Germany's Sea-Eye, which said rescue charities have saved 175,000 lives since 2015, received around 10 percent of its total income of around 3.2 million euros from the German Friedrich Merz's conservatives won February's national election after a campaign promising to curb irregular migration, which some voters in Europe's largest economy see as being out of though the overall numbers have been falling for several years, many Germans blame migration-related fears for the rise of the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD), now the second largest party in experts say that migration levels are mainly driven by economic and humanitarian emergencies in the source countries, with the official cold shoulder in destination countries having had little impact in deterring this, German officials suggest that sea rescues only incentivise people to risk the sometimes deadly crossings.'The (government) support made possible extra missions and very concretely saved lives,' said Gorden Isler, Sea-Eye's chairperson. 'We might now have to stay in harbor despite emergencies.'The opposition Greens, who controlled the foreign office when the subsidies were introduced, criticized the move.'This will exacerbate the humanitarian crisis and deepen human suffering,' said joint floor leader Britta Hasselmann.
