Trump again questions NATO's collective defense guarantee ahead of summit
THE HAGUE, Netherlands (AP) — President Donald Trump on Wednesday once again raised questions about America's commitment to defend its allies should they come under attack as he prepared to join a NATO summit in the Netherlands.
Just as he did during his first term in office, Trump suggested that his backing would depend on whether U.S. allies are spending enough on defense. He's demanded that European allies and Canada dedicate 5% of GDP to their security.
On the eve of the meeting in The Hague, Trump told reporters aboard Air Force One that his commitment to Article 5 of NATO's founding treaty – the organization's collective security guarantee – 'depends on your definition.'
'There's numerous definitions of Article 5. You know that, right?' Trump said. 'But I'm committed to being their friends.' He signaled that he would give a more precise definition of what Article 5 means to him once he is at the summit.
As a candidate in 2016, Trump suggested that he as president would not necessarily heed the alliance's mutual defense guarantee. In March this year, he expressed uncertainty that NATO would come to the United States' defense if needed.
Article 5 is the foundation stone on which the 32-member North Atlantic Treaty Organization is built. It states that an armed attack against one or more of the members shall be considered an attack against all members.
It also states that if such an armed attack occurs, each member would take, individually and in concert with others, 'such action as it deems necessary, including the use of armed force, to restore and maintain the security of the North Atlantic area.''
That security guarantee is the reason previously neutral Finland and Sweden sought to join NATO after Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022 and why Ukraine itself and other countries in Europe also want in.
Article 5 was only invoked once, in the wake of the September 11, 2001, terror attacks on the United States, paving the way for NATO's biggest ever operation in Afghanistan.
But NATO allies have also taken collective defense measures, including joining the U.S. to fight the Islamic State group in Syria, Iraq and Afghanistan, as well as help keep the peace in the Balkans.
The Three Musketeers-like pledge of all for one, one for all, is at the heart of NATO's deterrent effect. To question it too loudly might invite an adversary to test it. European officials have said that Russia is planning to do just that.
NATO's credibility hinges on Article 5 and its commitment to offer membership to any European country that can contribute to security in Europe and North America.
But Ukraine, currently in the middle of war with Russia, might oblige all 32 member countries to spring to its defense militarily, potentially igniting a wider war with a nuclear-armed country. Trump is vetoing its membership for the foreseeable future.
Article 5 becomes problematic when the territory of a member is unclear. For instance, Russian forces entered Georgia in August 2008, a few months after NATO leaders first promised the country it would join, along with Ukraine.
Georgia's NATO application is still pending but seems unlikely for many years. Russia continues to occupy large swaths of Ukraine and other parts are contested, meaning that its borders cannot be easily defined.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
36 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Trump Policies Will Cut Deficits Up to $11 Trillion, White House Economist Says
(Bloomberg) -- President Donald Trump's policies will reduce US fiscal deficits by up to $11 trillion over the coming decade, according to the White House's chief economist — a projection that defies analysts who say government debt is poised to climb to record highs in coming years. Bezos Wedding Draws Protests, Soul-Searching Over Tourism in Venice US Renters Face Storm of Rising Costs US State Budget Wounds Intensify From Trump, DOGE Policy Shifts Commuters Are Caught in Johannesburg's Taxi Feuds as Transit Lags 'We calculate that, overall, the reduction in deficits as a result of the total suite of the president's policies is going to be roughly $8.5 to $11 trillion over the 10-year budget window,' Stephen Miran, chair of the Council of Economic Advisers, told reporters on a call Wednesday. 'Those are very big numbers.' About half the savings, or $3 trillion to $5 trillion, would come from faster economic growth — thanks to the pending Republican tax cut bill, along with deregulation efforts — Miran argued. He also cited a $3 trillion bump in revenues from Trump's tariff hikes, referring reporters to the Congressional Budget Office's recent calculation — which came in at $2.8 trillion. Reduced debt loads thanks in part to those savings will help to bring down the US Treasury's interest costs by approximately $1 trillion to $1.5 trillion, he said. Miran was speaking on a call touting the benefits of the GOP's 'One Big Beautiful Bill' of tax and spending cuts that Trump has called on his party to pass in Congress by July 4. The House passed one draft last month, and the Senate is now aiming to approve its version this week. The House-passed version of the package was most recently estimated by the CBO to boost the deficit, not cut it, by some $2.8 trillion. The CBO analysis on tariffs also assumed that the tariff rates in effect as of mid-May would be in place for a decade — even though trade talks are under way that may reduce those levies, and Trump won't be in office throughout that period. Trade Agreements A preliminary analysis from the Tax Foundation found the Senate bill would cost $3.9 trillion over a decade, after accounting for economic impacts. Miran also said that he's optimistic there will be a flurry of framework agreements with US trading partners getting announced by July 9, the expiration date for Trump's pause on reciprocal tariffs. Agreements will depend on the willingness of other countries to engage, Miran said, adding that he expects there to be 'some stubborn holdouts.' Any agreements notwithstanding, Miran said there's no downside risk to the CBO's $2.8 trillion estimate for increased revenue from tariffs. The CEA offered a breakdown of its analysis showing the impact of Trump's policies, which included the following estimates: Faster growth thanks to the tax cuts will shrink fiscal deficits by $2.1 trillion to $2.3 trillion over a decade. Stronger growth due to deregulation and Trump's energy policies will narrow the deficit by another $1.3 trillion to $3.7 trillion. The US debt-to-gross domestic product ratio will fall to 94% by 2034, instead of rising to 117% if Trump's 2017 tax cuts were allowed to expire at year-end. Analysis by the non-partisan CBO in January that incorporated an expectation for the expiration of the 2017 tax reductions showed the US on course for a 107% debt-to-GDP ratio by 2029 — exceeding the all-time high reached in 1946, just after the end of World War II. For his part, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent earlier this month said there's 'varying scoring' of the tax bill, telling lawmakers, 'It is my view that over the 10-year window, it will decrease.' Federal budget deficits have exceeded 6% of GDP the past two years, despite strong economic growth and job gains. Bessent said this month that the 2025 gap would come in between 6.5% and 6.7%. When it downgraded the US sovereign rating last month, Moody's Ratings said it expected deficits to widen, reaching nearly 9% of GDP by 2035, 'driven mainly by increased interest payments on debt, rising entitlement spending, and relatively low revenue generation.' (Updates with additional estimates starting in third paragraph after 'Trade Agreements' subheadline.) Inside Gap's Last-Ditch, Tariff-Addled Turnaround Push Luxury Counterfeiters Keep Outsmarting the Makers of $10,000 Handbags How to Steal a House Ken Griffin on Trump, Harvard and Why Novice Investors Won't Beat the Pros Is Mark Cuban the Loudmouth Billionaire that Democrats Need for 2028? ©2025 Bloomberg L.P. Sign in to access your portfolio
37 minutes ago
What to know about 'Alligator Alcatraz,' Florida's immigration detention site in the Everglades
TALLAHASSEE, Fla. -- An immigration detention facility located at an isolated Everglades airfield surrounded by mosquito-, python- and alligator-filled swamplands is just days away from being operational, federal officials said Tuesday. Florida officials are racing ahead with the construction of what they've dubbed 'Alligator Alcatraz' to help carry out President Donald Trump's mass deportation agenda, working to build a compound of heavy-duty tents, trailers and temporary buildings similar to sites used during natural disasters. The construction of the facility in the remote and ecologically sensitive wetland about 45 miles (72 kilometers) west of downtown Miami is alarming environmentalists, as well as human rights advocates who have slammed the plan as cruel and inhumane. State officials say the installation is critical to support the federal government's immigration crackdown, which has resulted in a record-high number of detentions, totaling more than 56,000 immigrants in June, the most since 2019. Here's what to know. Construction of the site in the dog days of summer is part of the state's plan to operationalize 5,000 immigration detention beds by early July, according to Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier, a former chief of staff for Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis and a key architect of the state's aggressive immigration enforcement campaign. Uthmeier helped coordinate the state-funded flights of about 50 Venezuelans to Martha's Vineyard, Massachusetts, in 2022. In the eyes of Florida officials, the harsh conditions surrounding the far-flung Everglades airstrip and its nearly 10,500-foot (3,200-meter) runway make it an ideal location to house and transport migrants. "We don't need to build a lot of brick and mortar," Uthmeier said in an interview with conservative media commentator Benny Johnson. 'And thankfully, Mother Nature does a lot on the perimeter.' 'There's really nowhere to go. If you're housed there, if you're detained there, there's no way in, no way out," Uthmeier added. The Trump administration wants to more than double its existing 41,000 beds for detaining migrants to at least 100,000 beds. A tax-cutting and budget reconciliation bill approved last month by the U.S. House of Representatives includes $45 billion over four years for immigrant detention, a threefold spending increase. The Senate is now considering that legislation. More than 50 years ago, environmental advocates, including the famed Marjory Stoneman Douglas, rallied to stop the same stretch of land from being turned into what was to be the largest airport in the world. Now, activists are rallying to halt what some critics have described as a state-backed 'heist.' 'Surrounded by Everglades National Park and Big Cypress National Preserve, this land is part of one of the most fragile ecosystems in the country,' reads a statement from the advocacy group Friends of the Everglades. 'Let's not repeat the mistakes of the past. This land deserves lasting protection.' Florida Democratic U.S. Rep. Maxwell Frost condemned the detention center, calling its apparent use of alligators as a security measure a 'cruel spectacle.' 'Donald Trump, his Administration, and his enablers have made one thing brutally clear: they intend to use the power of government to kidnap, brutalize, starve, and harm every single immigrant they can — because they have a deep disdain for immigrants and are using them to scapegoat the serious issues facing working people,' Frost said in a statement. Maria Asuncion Bilbao, Florida campaign coordinator at American Friends Service Committee, an immigration advocacy group, warned that the health and safety of detainees is being put at risk. 'What's happening is very concerning, the level of dehumanization,' Bilbao said. 'It's like a theatricalization of cruelty.' Bilbao, who leads a group of immigration advocates who help immigrants at one of the ICE offices in South Florida, said she's concerned about the health risks of the heat and mosquitoes, and the challenges the remoteness of the site presents to community members hoping to protest or monitor activities there. Officials with the U.S. Department of Homeland Security have applauded the effort and the agency's 'partnership with Florida.' DHS Secretary Kristi Noem said the new facility will be funded in large part by the Shelter and Services Program within the Federal Emergency Management Agency, or FEMA, which is best known for responding to hurricanes and other natural disasters. 'We are working at turbo speed on cost-effective and innovative ways to deliver on the American people's mandate for mass deportations of criminal aliens,' said Noem in a written statement provided to the AP. 'We will expand facilities and bed space in just days." Managing the facility 'via a team of vendors' will cost $245 a bed per day or approximately $450 million a year, a U.S. official said. The expenses will be incurred by Florida and reimbursed by FEMA, which has a $625 million shelter and service program fund. Immigrants arrested by Florida law enforcement officers under the federal 287 (g) program will be held at the facility, as well as immigrants in the custody of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, or ICE. Under the revived 287 (g) program, local and state law enforcement officers can interrogate immigrants in their custody and detain them for potential deportation. Agencies across all 67 Florida counties have signed more than 280 such agreements, more than a third of the 720 agreements ICE have reached nationwide. State officials are commandeering the land using state emergency powers, under an executive order issued by DeSantis during the administration of then-President Joe Biden to respond to what the governor deemed a crisis caused by illegal immigration. Florida is moving forward with the construction on county-owned land over the concerns of Miami-Dade County Mayor Daniella Levine Cava, local activists and Native American tribal leaders who consider the area sacred. By relying on executive orders, the state is able to sidestep purchasing laws and fast-track the project, which Fried said amounts to an abuse of power. The orders grant sweeping authority to the state's head of emergency management, Kevin Guthrie, including the power to suspend 'any statute, rule, or order' seen as slowing the response to the emergency, and the ability to place select law enforcement personnel from across the state under his 'direct command and coordination.' 'Governor DeSantis has insisted that the state of Florida, under his leadership, will facilitate the federal government in enforcing immigration law,' a DeSantis spokesperson said in a statement. 'Florida will continue to lead on immigration enforcement.'
Fox News
38 minutes ago
- Fox News
CNN host touts 'friendliness' of Iranians who shouted 'Death to America,' calls it jarring juxtaposition
CNN host Erin Burnett took time during her report on Tuesday to remark on the "friendliness" of the Iranians who chanted "Death to America" when she visited the country years ago. The "OutFront" host reported live from the United Arab Emirates on "Inside Politics with Dana Bash" to discuss the sentiment in the Middle East after the fragile ceasefire between Iran and Israel. Burnett said that despite news of both Israel and Iran reportedly violating the agreement, most people on the ground felt optimistic that the ceasefire would ultimately hold. Burnett then described her own experience with "whiplash" from Iran, recounting how she once spoke with Iranians after they chanted "Death to America." "I remember at one point being in Tehran years ago, and they're chanting 'Death to America' all around me, even as I say, 'Oh, I'm an American, reporting for CNN.' And they were happy to speak to me. So those two sort of jarring realities of the chant and yet, the friendliness, have existed together," Burnett said. "Death to America" has been a slogan used by Iranian leaders for years and was referenced by President Donald Trump as a motivator behind his decision to launch airstrikes against the nation's nuclear facilities on Saturday. "For 40 years, Iran has been saying, 'Death to America. Death to Israel.' They have been killing our people, blowing off their arms, blowing off their legs with roadside bombs," Trump said on Saturday evening from the White House. "That was their specialty. We lost over a thousand people, and hundreds of thousands throughout the Middle East and around the world have died as a direct result of their hate in particular." Trump called out CNN reporters as "gutless losers" and "scum" early Tuesday morning for downplaying the success of the U.S. strikes. "But when I see CNN, all night long, they're trying to say, 'Well, maybe it wasn't really as demolished as we thought.' It was demolished. You take a look at the pinpricks, and you see that place is gone. And I will say, I think CNN ought to apologize to the pilots of the B-2s," Trump said.
