Less than 2% of Labor's promised $1bn mental health funding would be spent next financial year
Just $16.5m of Labor's promised $1bn mental health package – or 1.65% – is due to be spent in the next financial year, according to official policy costings that reveal some new care centres might not open until 2029.
Anthony Albanese this month unveiled a major suite of policies to make it easier for the public – in particular young Australians – to access free mental health treatment.
In an announcement hailed as 'visionary' by leading psychiatrist and former Australian of the Year Patrick McGorry, the prime minister promised:
$225m for 31 new and upgraded Medicare mental health centres
More than $200m for 58 new, upgraded or expanded headspace services
$500m for 20 specialist care centres for young people with complex needs
$90m for more than 1,200 training places for mental health professionals and peer workers
Peak mental health groups praised the $1bn pledge as a significant and much-needed investment to fill gaps in the provision of care for the one in five Australians who experience a mental health disorder.
The 8 April announcement did not include several key details, including a proposed timeline for the new and upgraded clinics.
But those details have now been revealed in a costing request for the policy submitted to Treasury and Finance on 17 April, and published over the weekend.
The request, submitted under Albanese's name, showed just $16.5m of the total $1bn commitment was expected to be spent in 2025-26.
The bulk of the funding – roughly $878m – is not allocated until the 2027-28 and 2028-29 financial years, as the services are progressively built and upgraded.
Under Labor's plan, the first five new Medicare mental health centres would be opened in 2025-26, with 19 due to be operational in 2027-2028.
However, the final three aren't scheduled to be up and running until 2028-2029.
The clinics would be in addition to the 61 centres that the Albanese government has been progressively opening over recent years.
The new, upgraded or expanded headspace services would be rolled out from 2026-27 to 2028-29.
The costing request also revealed the proposed timeline for the specialist youth mental health centres, a new model designed to provide intensive care to patients with personality disorders, eating disorders and early psychosis.
The government plans to establish 12 centres in 2027-28, the document showed.
The remaining eight would be upgraded and rebadged existing headspace early psychosis youth services.
Guardian Australia put questions to Labor about the costings, including why only $16.5m was set aside for next financial year.
'Our focus is on growing the mental health workforce as we expand the network of free mental health services across the country to build genuine, sustainable improvements in access to mental health supports when and where people need them,' the spokesperson said.
Peter Dutton has promised a total of $900m for mental health, which includes $500m to restore the 20 Medicare-subsidised mental health sessions offered during the pandemic and $400m for youth-specific services.
Sign up for the Afternoon Update: Election 2025 email newsletter
The government spokesperson claimed the Coalition's plan would add to demand for private psychologists without growing the workforce, which would drive up gap fees and lengthen waitlists.
The Coalition declined to provide Guardian Australia with costings for its mental health policies but insisted they would be published ahead of the 3 May election.
A spokesperson said a Dutton government would restore mental health and suicide prevention as a 'national priority', guaranteeing that under its plan 'people won't be waiting years before any real action on mental health'.
'Labor announced it would copy the Coalition's youth mental health measures at the 11th hour after three years of completely neglecting mental health, and now it's clear that this announcement was a shameful con,' the spokesperson said.
Giancarlo de Vera, the chief executive of New South Wales-based mental health consumer group Being, was concerned Labor's promised funding would roll out too slowly and was not targeted at the services patients needed.
'Consumers are looking for community-based, peer-led services, and the fact that the budget is only really funding 500 peer workers is not what consumers want,' de Vera said.
'Consumers want services that support their ability to stay in the community, and services that support a greater choice in the support they do access.'
In Australia, the crisis support service Lifeline is 13 11 14. In the UK and Ireland, Samaritans can be contacted on freephone 116 123, or email jo@samaritans.org or jo@samaritans.ie. In the US, you can call or text the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline on 988, chat on 988lifeline.org, or text HOME to 741741 to connect with a crisis counselor. Other international helplines can be found at befrienders.org
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
2 hours ago
- Reuters
Humana to back curbs to Medicare Advantage billing practices, WSJ reports
June 5 (Reuters) - Humana (HUM.N), opens new tab has told congressional staffers that it will support moves that would curtail billing practices worth billions in extra payments to the industry, the Wall Street Journal reported, citing staffers and a document viewed by it. The company is willing to back new limits on lucrative payments insurers can gain from diagnoses recorded by nurse practitioners who visit millions of enrollees in their homes, according to a one-page policy overview shared with the staffers, the WSJ reported on Thursday. Humana did not immediately respond to a Reuters request for comment. Nearly half of the 65 million people covered by Medicare, the U.S. program for people aged 65 and older or with disabilities, are enrolled in Medicare Advantage plans run by private insurers. Insurers are paid a set rate for each patient, but can be paid more for patients with multiple health conditions. Last fall, staff working for Senators Mike Crapo and Ron Wyden, the leaders of the Senate Finance Committee, contacted Medicare Advantage insurers for suggestions on legislative steps that would address the potential misuse of home visits described in Journal articles, the newspaper reported citing people familiar with the matter. The Journal reported in February that the U.S. Department of Justice was examining UnitedHealth's (UNH.N), opens new tab practices for recording diagnoses that trigger extra payments to its Medicare Advantage plans. The healthcare conglomerate had then said it was unaware of any new probe. The WSJ has run a series of stories over the last several months detailing how UnitedHealth profited from using Medicare billing rules to its favor.
The Guardian
21 hours ago
- The Guardian
More Australians can't afford specialist fees. Experts say it's ‘not in the spirit of Medicare'
The cost of an initial dermatology appointment is now up to nearly $300 on average, new data shows. It reflects a broader problem: that Medicare rebates are not keeping up with the pace specialist fees are rising. Online healthcare directory Cleanbill, which has tracked bulk billing rates among GPs, is expanding to provide data on out-of-pocket costs to see other health professionals, starting with dermatology. The report, released on Thursday, found the Medicare rebate in March 2017 for an initial appointment with a dermatologist was $72.75, while the out-of-pocket cost was $148.73. By March 2025, the rebate had risen by $11.40, to $84.15, while the average out-of-pocket costs, at $210.18, were $61.45 more expensive. Over eight years, average out-of-pocket costs for an initial consultation had increased by over 40%, and average follow-up consultation costs had increased by over 55%. The rebate rose by less than 16%. Cleanbill compared the 2017 data collected by predecessor MindTheGap for 165 dermatology clinics still currently operating, with its own data collected in October. Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email Based on all 280 dermatology clinics Cleanbill identified currently operating, the average upfront cost of an appointment was $296.71 – more than 3.5 times the Medicare rebate. Cleanbill's report highlighted that as private health insurance does not cover out-of-hospital consultations, these out-of-pockets costs are being borne entirely by patients. Private health insurance mainly covers the cost of private hospital treatment, and may also cover non-Medicare subsidised services such as physiotherapy, psychology and dental services – but not GP or specialist consultations. 'These out-of-pocket costs far exceed the increases that we've seen to the Medicare rebate,' Cleanbill's chief executive, James Gillespie, said. 'In these circumstances, it's easy to see why the number of Australians putting off specialist care due to cost has risen from 176,000 in 2016-17 to 900,000 in 2023-24,' he wrote in the report, citing Australian Bureau of Statistics data. Many specialist services are available to patients for free in public outpatient clinics, but patients need a referral from their GP to qualify, and each hospital or specialist clinic has its own process for assessing urgency, accepting referral letters and making appointments. A GP referral is needed to claim the Medicare rebate at a specialist appointment, meaning a second round of out-of-pocket costs that 'stacks one on top of the other', Gillespie said. Gillespie said it was reasonable to extrapolate similar price increases across other medical specialists than dermatologists. The latest government data on medical specialist consultations showed patient out-of-pocket costs in non-hospital settings increased in real terms (adjusting for inflation) from $1.1bn in 2012-13 to $1.9bn in 2022-23 – or 'from $213 per patient to $294 (38%)'. In the same period, Medicare benefits paid by the government increased in real terms from $2.5bn to $2.9bn – or 16%. The government this year promised $7m to expand the much-derided Medical Costs Finder website, which the former Coalition government spent $24m setting up to see only 70 specialists – out of 11,000 registered to practice – choose to voluntarily display their fee information as of March 2025. Prof Yuting Zhang, an expert in health economics at the University of Melbourne, said providing cost information was only a first step – and the government had not outlined a policy to lower fees. Zhang and her colleagues at the Health Analytics, Leadership and Economics Hub mapped specialist fees in 2023 across different areas, finding on average that rheumatology had the highest fees, followed by neurology and immunology. Specialist fees have gone up 'a lot' but the Medicare schedule fee hasn't been properly indexed, Zhang said, remaining 'quite flat' for about the last 20 years, leaving patients to absorb the increasing gap. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion Some fees were 'super high' at about $1,200 but cost varied widely even within the same specialty for exactly the same services, she said. 'Some people might be willing to pay a lot more to see a specialist and thinking the price might be an indicator for quality – which I can assure you, it's never the case,' Zhang said. 'More expensive doesn't really mean better.' A third of people living with chronic diseases say they are not able to attend specialist appointments due to the cost, a study published in May in the journal Health Policy found, with both the upfront cost and out-of-pocket costs being a major barrier to care. Australian National University researchers analysed the experiences of more than 1,800 Australians living with a range of chronic conditions within 37 studies. Assoc prof Jane Desborough, the lead author of the study, said while GPs face 'consistent pressure' to bulk-bill, backed by policy initiatives, there is 'no similar conversation about non-GP specialists who are also trained in the public system, who are also remunerated through Medicare … yet from the evidence, it seems quite uncommon for them to bulk-bill'. Many Australians with multiple chronic conditions often need to see several different specialists; even a person with a single chronic condition such as psoriatic arthritis needs both a dermatologist and rheumatologist. Those who struggled to afford specialist appointments reported often choosing who they saw based on 'what's hurting most at the time', Desborough said. Chronic illness often impacts people's capacity to work. The frustration of not being able to afford specialist visits is compounded by the long wait list for public specialist clinics, she said, as well as an increased trend by specialists towards exclusive private practice. Those who had full access to the specialist clinics in the public system were 'very grateful for what Medicare does,' Desborough said. But as for others, having to forego important aspects of their life – like food choices, social activities, family holidays, children's sport, school excursions – to access healthcare: 'That's not in the spirit of Medicare,' she said. The health minister, Mark Butler, said the private health sector, including insurers and specialists, 'need[s] to do more to protect patients for exorbitant bills'. Zhang said specialist medical colleges could play a role, by developing codes of conduct around fee practices and scrutinising members who consistently charge high fees. The government could also open more public clinics offering free specialist care for those who cannot afford the gap fees in private clinics, Zhang said.
Daily Mail
a day ago
- Daily Mail
Anthony Albanese joins calls to axe ultra-violent Aussie fighting event featuring 181kg man mountain who was jailed for robbing a drug dealer
Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has weighed in on a debate surrounding plans to host a bare-knuckle fight night at the RAC Arena in Perth. The Bare Knuckle Fight Championship, which is co-owned by Conor McGregor, is due to land in Western Australia on July 19. Organisers announced the first two fights for its main card on Wednesday night which will see Ben Rothwell, a 274lbs former UFC fighter who has a 4-0-0 record, come up against man mountain and strongman Alex Simon - who broke multiple Australian records for powerlifting. Tassie fighter Bec Rawlings, the competition's first-ever female champion, is due to go head-to-head with Canadian Jade Masson-Wong. Mr Albanese, though, is one who has expressed concerns over the event, after the Australian Medical Association appeared to criticise the event while WA opposition also blasted the event. Prime Minister Albanese also appeared to express his concerns on Wednesday morning. 'A bit of common sense you've got to look after people's health a bit and maybe save people from themselves,' the Prime Minister said to Triple M's breakfast show. Albanese also referenced the issue of concussion when pressed on his thoughts on the sport, noting that he had a meeting with legendary footballer Mark Carroll last week over how the issue has been impacting himself and his friends. 'It's a bit crazy,' Albanese said in reference to the event. 'And concussion is such a big issue - AFL and rugby league. He added: 'I just think we've got to be much more conscious about health issues.' Meanwhile, The Australian Medical Association has also been critical of the event. 'We have a domestic violence crisis; we have people sorting out their problems with their fists in Northbridge on Saturday night; this is not the type of example our community needs,' Michael Page, the Australian Medical Association's WA president, said to Channel Nine News Perth. 'We have so many fantastic other sports, so many opportunities for tourism and entertainment in our community, we don't need this type of race to the bottom with bloody violence.' The rules of the competition state that fighters are required to have their knuckles bare of any gloves or protective equipment during the fight, which will last five two-minute rounds. Meanwhile, the WA opposition has called on Premier Roger Cook to 'show some leadership and prevent this morally repugnant event'. Cook responded: 'I can appreciate that, to the layperson, this sounds like people just getting in a ring and having a go. It is not. 'It is not my cup of tea, but the Combat Sports Commission has provided preliminary advice that anything of this nature requires at least two medical practitioners and requires the participants to be experienced and knowledgeable of the particular discipline.' The Combat Sports Commission are currently assessing permits for the event, with a final deadline on a decision to be due by the end of this week. Sports Minister Rita Saffioti explained she would not intervene to cancel the event. 'The advice to me is that with very strict protocols and criteria that the event, if the organiser were to meet that, that it could be conducted in WA,' she said. However, organisers are beginning to announce the main cards for the July 19 fight night, which suggests there may be some confidence that the event will go ahead. Australian, Simon, a champion powerlifter and mixed martial arts fighter, is now due to meet current heavyweight champion Rothwell in the event in what will be an inaugural super heavyweight title match for competitors over 120kg. The weightlifter has previously opened up on how he had also previously spent some time in prison. 'Pretty much we robbed a drug dealer, but it was like a home invasion and it was armed,' the weightlifter told The Secrets of The Underworld Podcast last month. A former Bikie gang member, Matthew Floyd, is understood to have sought a permit from the WA Combat Sports Commission, according to The West Australian.
