Joshlin Smith case: A landmark trial in South Africa's fight against human trafficking
In powerful closing arguments on Tuesday, Senior State Advocate Zelda Swanepoel described the Joshlin Smith case as unlike any South Africa has seen before, a heartbreaking story where the victim's voice has not been heard.
The six-year-old girl went missing from her Middelpos home in Saldanha Bay on February 19, 2024.
Her mother, Racquel 'Kelly' Smith, her boyfriend, Jacquen 'Boeta' Appollis, and their friend, Steveno 'Steffie' van Rhyn, were charged with kidnapping and human trafficking.
They have pleaded not guilty.
Former accused Lourentia 'Renz' Lombaard testified that Kelly sold her daughter to a sangoma for R20 000.
Addressing the Western Cape High Court, Swanepoel explained that in most human trafficking cases, the child is recovered and can testify about what happened. But Joshlin remains missing. Her absence, Swanepoel said, makes this case unprecedented.
'Usually, in a TIP (Trafficking in Persons) case, the most important source of information is the victim,' she told the court. 'In this case, we don't have that.'
Drawing on extensive research and a recent article that she submitted as an authority, Swanepoel said that although South Africa has dealt with child trafficking before, those cases were very different.
In the past, in three matters, undercover police operations intervened before any actual harm occurred. The children were never fully handed over to criminals.
But Joshlin's situation is different.
'This is the first time we are dealing with a case where the child is truly gone,' Swanepoel emphasised. 'That is why this case is so important, not only for justice for Joshlin but also for the development of our law.'
According to the State, the evidence shows that Joshlin was sold in a planned agreement between the accused parties.
Swanepoel described this as 'modern-day slavery', the commodification of a human being for exploitation.
'A person is never supposed to be a commodity,' she argued. 'It sounds bizarre to the reasonable person that a child could be sold. But sadly, that is the reality we are facing.'
Because South African law historically had no crime specifically criminalising the selling of a person, Swanepoel explained that legislation was introduced to close this gap, following international obligations like the Palermo Protocol.
Swanepoel broke down the elements of trafficking as set out in South African law under Section 4(1) of the Prevention and Combating of Trafficking in Persons Act (PACOTIP). She explained that trafficking requires three elements:
The act - what was done,
The means - how it was done, and
The purpose - exploitation.
However, when the victim is a child, as in Joshlin's case, only two elements are required: the act and the purpose. The 'means' such as force or coercion is not necessary to prove, because children are inherently vulnerable.
'Section 11 of our legislation removes the need to prove the means when a child is trafficked,' Swanepoel said, referring the court to previous cases she had prosecuted where this principle was upheld.
Swanepoel urged the court to recognise the gravity of the allegations.
'This is a very important case, not only because of Joshlin, but because it shapes how South Africa protects its most vulnerable.'
The trial continues.
mandilakhe.tshwete@inl.co.za
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The South African
an hour ago
- The South African
Newspaper headlines from around the world - Tuesday, 10 June 2025
A bundle of newspapers on the table. Image: The South African/CANVA Here are the stories that made headlines on the front pages of newspapers worldwide on Tuesday, 10 June 2025. The New York Times front page reported that vintage guns are being used against drones. The Wall Street Journal front page reported that Marines were sent into Los Angeles as blame was traded over the clashes. The Hindustan Times' front page reports: Murder in Meghalaya, wife and lover hatched plot, say police. China Daily's front page reported thattech-driven manufacturing is key for growth. Daily Mail's front page reported that Labour is at war over spending plans, as Number 10 tries to stem the threat from Farage. If you wish to stay up-to-date – for FREE – on the latest international and South African news, then bookmark The South African website for all that plus the latest in the world of finance, sport, lifestyle – and more. Did we mention it was 100% free to read …?


The Citizen
3 hours ago
- The Citizen
12-year-old in court after killing 14-year-old in Brakpan collision
For children aged between 12 and 14 years, the law introduces a presumption that they lack criminal capacity, unless proven otherwise by the state. A 12-year-old child has appeared before the Brakpan Magistrates Court on charges of culpable homicide and driving without a license after allegedly causing the death of a 14-year-old boy. According to reports, the younger child was driving his parents' vehicle when the fatal collision took place in Brakpan, Gauteng, on Saturday. Details of the fatal collision According to the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA), the 12-year-old was behind the wheel when he ran a stop sign and struck the teenage victim. 'It is alleged that on 7 June 2025, the minor was driving his parents' vehicle at the corner of Madeley and Northdeene Street when he drove over a 14-year-old boy and bumped into a wall. 'The 14-year-old boy sustained injuries and was declared dead on the scene,' said NPA Regional spokesperson Lumka Mahanjana. Following the collision, the younger child was arrested. 'The 12-year-old was then taken to the Brakpan charge office and later released into the care of his parents by police,' Mahanjana added. He was only released into his parents' custody on Sunday, 8 June 2025. ALSO READ: Four taken to hospital after collision on R328 Court proceedings and legal considerations During Monday's court appearance, the minor was accompanied by his guardian, as required by law. The matter has been postponed until 28 August 2025 to allow for a comprehensive assessment of the child's criminal capacity. The law introduces a presumption that children aged between 12 and 14 lack criminal capacity unless the state proves otherwise. 'A child falling in this age group can only be arrested as a last resort,' LegalWise stated. Current legislation directs that 14-year-olds and above can typically stand trial in South African courts. The Constitutional Court firmly established the principle that child offenders must be treated differently from adults, a view that was solidified when the Child Justice Act 75 of 2008 came into effect on 1 April 2010. This Act introduced a separate criminal justice system tailored specifically for children, aiming to address their unique needs and circumstances within the legal framework. LegalWise explains that 'under the Child Justice Act, a child under the age of 12 years has no criminal capacity and cannot be prosecuted or arrested for an offence. It does not mean that there will be no consequences if the child is found guilty.' The Act instead 'offers alternatives for rehabilitation by diverting a child offender from a prison sentence to community service, counselling and therapy.' This reflects a significant shift in focus—from punishment to rehabilitation, acknowledging that children are still developing and should be given the opportunity to reform. NOW READ: Trio convicted for brutal farm attack in Eastern Cape


The South African
14 hours ago
- The South African
Happy ending! SPCA rescues starving dog seen in TikTok
The national SPCA rescued an emaciated dog – nicknamed 'Bobby' – that was featured in a TikTok video last week. The animal was removed from its owners following a national outcry on social media. Content creator Sasha Tshiamo was the woman seen in the viral video – however, she insisted that the animal did not belong to her nor was it her 'responsibility'. Last week, a TikTok video featuring Sasha Tshiamo dancing was posted on the X platform. The video quickly went viral because of an emaciated dog in the background. The animal's ribcage was clearly visible, and it appeared lethargic. After scores of South Africans shared their concerns, the SPCA confirmed that it would be investigating the incident. It later updated the public that the starving dog – or 'Bobby' – had been rescued and removed from its home. It posted on X: 'Our Special Projects Unit jumped into action, and Bobby was taken in. She is now safe'. The SPCA has rescued an emaciated dog spotted in a viral video. the dog – nicknamed 'Bobby' was forced to eat plastic to survive. Images via X: @nspca_sa SPCA shared pics of the female dog, who appeared to have given birth to young puppies. They said of 'Bobby': 'She is the most lovable dog, handing out kisses to everyone since the moment she arrived! Forced to eat plastic to survive, Bobby was found severely malnourished, suffering from fly strike, and covered in ticks and fleas'. It continued: 'She's on a long road to recovery, but once healthy, she'll be sterilised and available to the loving and caring home she deserves'. View this post on Instagram A post shared by NSPCA (@ The SPCA has yet to reveal if Bobby's owners will face criminal charges for animal abuse. Under the Animals Protection Act 71 of 1962, offenders can face a fine or imprisonment. They could also face a denial of ownership – preventing them from owning animals – as well as a criminal conviction. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 . Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp , Facebook , X, and Bluesky for the latest news.