Chaska kindergarten teacher charged with malicious punishment of 5-year-old girl
The Brief
A woman is charged with malicious punishment of a 5-year-old girl while she worked as a kindergarten teacher in Chaska.
Security camera footage shows the teacher holding the girl "on the ground for an extended period of time," according to court documents.
The school principal reported the incident in October 2024.
CHASKA, Minn. (FOX 9) - A woman who worked as a kindergarten teacher in Chaska is charged with malicious punishment of a child after security camera footage showed a 5-year-old girl being restrained and held on the ground.
What we know
A criminal complaint filed in Carver County Court states Chaska police responded to a local school on Oct. 24, 2024 for a report of a teacher physically restraining and picking up a 5-year-old student.
That teacher, Miriam Deborah Swirski-Lubin, 53, is now charged with one count of malicious punishment of a child.
The school principal told officers she learned the restraint had happened the day before, and that although she did not witness it, another staff member did, and the incident was captured on security cameras.
The complaint states that the principal spoke to the teacher regarding the incident, and Swirski-Lubin said, "What was I supposed to do?" during the conversation. The principal reportedly explained that carrying a student is a form of restraint and it is not permitted, even by those who are trained in Crisis Prevention Intervention (CPI).
Swirski-Lubin then "left the school appearing to be distraught and frustrated" according to the criminal complaint.
The principal also explained that any restraint was inappropriate as the footage showed the student was not doing anything that would harm herself or others.
Footage viewed by police shows Swirski-Lubin grabbing the victim's shoulder before sitting on the ground and holding the student down with both arms around the student's upper body across her chest. The footage also shows the student "turning and moving their legs in an attempt to get away," according to the complaint.
This reportedly took place in the school gym while other teachers were clearing the students out. The complaint states that when the gym was empty, Swirski-Lubin crossed her legs across the student's body to prevent her from moving and continued to hold her down "for an extended period of time."
Swirski-Lubin then picked the student up and carried the student to another classroom. Surveillance footage reportedly shows Swirski-Lubin struggling to hold onto the student, causing her to toss the student up to regain control of her body when her head slipped close to the ground. Swirski-Lubin then slammed the classroom door shut and appeared to be angry, according to the complaint.
Court documents show Swirski-Lubin retained an attorney and refused to give a statement.
Public records with the Minnesota Professional Educator Licensing and Standards Board show Swirski-Lubin still has a teaching license, which is set to expire on June 30, 2025.
What we don't know
Court documents did not share details on any injuries to the student.
The Source
This story used information from a criminal complaint filed in Carver County.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
16 hours ago
- Yahoo
Minneapolis PD memo tells officers not to assist with immigration enforcement
The Brief A memo from Minneapolis police reminds officers not to assist with ICE raids. Officers are prohibited from assisting with immigration enforcement under a city ordinance. The memo follows a protest in Minneapolis last week over ICE agents who were assisting with what turned out to be a criminal investigation. MINNEAPOLIS (FOX 9) - The Minneapolis Police Department issued a new memo over the weekend, reminding officers of a separation order that restricts police from aiding in immigration removal actions by federal authorities, like ICE. The memo comes days after a protest over ICE agents involvement in what turned out to be a criminal investigation in Minneapolis. The backstory The memo comes days after a protest escalated in Minneapolis as ICE agents took part in what authorities later said was a criminal investigation into human and drug trafficking – not an immigration enforcement action. Officials said federal authorities were executing a search warrant at a Mexican restaurant at Lake Street and Bloomington Avenue last Tuesday. However, rumors spread online that ICE agents were taking part in a raid, sparking a protest in the street. What they're saying On Wednesday, the day after the protest, officials including Sheriff Dawanna Witt and Mayor Jacob Frey criticized other public leaders for contributing to the heightening of tensions. The next day, at the Minneapolis City Council meeting, city leaders unamiously approved an after-action review by an auditor of the city's role with assisting ICE during the investigation and protest. The city of Minneapolis has a 'separation ordinance" that restricts officers from assisting with immigration enforcement actions. The review approved by the city council will look into that. Separately, the department is scheduled to present to a council committee later this month the steps it's taking to abide by the ordinance. What we know A memo sent out by Minneapolis Assistant Chief Katie Blackwell reminds officers they aren't allowed to assist in any immigration enforcement activity. The memo also tells officers they can't even assist with ancillary activities related to ICE raids, like crowd control. "Any assistance for federal enforcement action must be routed through the chain of command for evaluation and authorization by the Chief of Police or Chief's designer," the memo states. "Members of the MPD shall not self-deploy to any related immigration enforcement activity. We remain committed to supporting public safety and maintaining trust within our communities." The memo was first reported on by conservative Twin Cities news outlet Alpha News. FOX 9 was able to obtain a copy of the memo from Minneapolis police. Dig deeper In a statement, Minneapolis police say the memo was issued in light of the confusion surrounding last week's criminal investigation. "Assistant Chief Blackwell's memo serves as a clear reminder of the Minneapolis Police Department's longstanding policy and the City's ordinance prohibiting involvement in federal civil immigration enforcement activities. "The email was issued to help ensure officers understand how to appropriately respond to any requests for assistance related to immigration enforcement. This clarification was especially important in light of recent public confusion and misinformation following the federal operation earlier this week. "Our role remains focused on addressing criminal activity and maintaining public safety, while respecting the boundaries set by city ordinance and department policy." The backstory The memo also comes as protests over ICE in Los Angeles have spiraled out of control. Over the weekend, President Trump sent in the National Guard to help quell the protests which turned to rioting Sunday night.
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
St. Paul fire inspector kidnapped, attempted to sexually assault teen: Charges
The Brief A 73-year-old man is charged with attempted criminal sexual conduct after allegedly trying to sexually assault a 13-year-old. Investigators say the girl missed her school bus, and thought the 73-year-old was a security officer. Court documents show that instead of giving her a ride to school, he took her to his apartment. ST. PAUL, Minn. (FOX 9) - It was a terrifying morning for a 13-year-old girl who was just trying to make it to school. Last month, after missing the bus, the girl ended up in a car with a man who is now charged with allegedly trying to sexually assault her. The City of St. Paul says that the man is a 73-year-old DSI Fire Inspector with The City. What we know Court documents say on May 21, a 13-year-old girl missed her school bus, and walked blocks to try to get to school. It was raining, and the girl stopped on Phalen Boulevard in St. Paul to go to a medical clinic to ask for help getting to school. That's where she encountered 73-year-old James Allen Thomas sitting in a gray SUV, near the entrance of the clinic. Thomas asked if the 13-year-old needed help. Court documents say she was shivering when she said yes, and through her iPad, she communicated that she needed a ride to middle school. Because of his uniform, she thought he was a security officer. Documents show Thomas turned off both his cell phones after leaving the clinic. Investigators say instead of taking the 13-year-old to school, Thomas drove her to his apartment on the 1100 block of Agate Street. Court documents say the girl noticed a foul smell and saw beer cans. He motioned for her to go to the bedroom, where Thomas attempted to sexually assault the girl. He then allegedly offered the girl $50 twice to do sexual acts with him, and she said no both times. Investigators say, afterward, Thomas grabbed the 13-year-old's iPad and asked if it had the location finder on. She said she didn't know and needed to get to school. Thomas then took the girl back to his car and started driving, court documents say. While driving, Thomas asked the girl several questions, including what her address was, to which she gave her school address. Thomas then took the girl to her middle school. Court documents say when the girl got out of Thomas' SUV she approached a school staff member and hugged them tightly and was shaking, visibly upset, that staff member told investigators. Thomas got out of the vehicle and told the staff member he was a "Sergeant with the St. Paul Fire Department." What they're saying The St. Paul Fire Department tells FOX 9 they don't have the ranking of sergeant or an employee named James Allen Thomas. The City of St. Paul says Thomas is a DSI Fire Safety Inspector II with the city. Documents show Thomas was arrested Thursday, admitting to seeing the 13-year-old in the clinic parking lot off Phalen Boulevard and giving her a ride to school. But he denied it took him 45 minutes to travel 6.5 miles to the girl's school. What's next The documents also say Thomas also denies trying to have sexual contact with the 13-year-old. He added that the girl looked about 10-years-old and seemed scared while she was with him. Thomas posted bail, and he is charged with kidnapping, second-degree attempted criminal sexual conduct and soliciting a child to engage in sexual conduct.
Business Upturn
4 days ago
- Business Upturn
NIA files chargesheet in Chhattisgarh Army personnel targeted killing case
By News Desk Published on June 7, 2025, 10:32 IST The National Investigation Agency (NIA) has chargesheeted an accused arrested in connection with the targeted killing of an Indian Army personnel in Chhattisgarh in February 2024. According to an official statement released on Friday, the agency has filed the chargesheet against Ashu Korsa, a resident of Bijapur district, under various sections of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) and the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act. The chargesheet has been submitted before the NIA Special Court in Jagdalpur. Korsa has been charged under Section 302 read with 120B of IPC, 1860, and Sections 16, 18, 20, 38, and 39 of the UA (P) Act, the agency said. NIA investigations have revealed that the accused was part of a criminal conspiracy orchestrated by the proscribed terrorist organisation CPI (Maoist) to assassinate Army jawan Motiram Achala. Achala was shot dead by armed cadres of the CPI (Maoist) on 25th February 2024 during a visit to the Useli village fair in the Amabeda area of Kanker district, where he was accompanied by his family members. The NIA added that it continues to probe the wider conspiracy and network behind the targeted killing as part of its ongoing efforts to dismantle terrorist activities in the region. News desk at
