Scotland avoided PPE ‘VIP lane' due to devolution, UK Covid-19 Inquiry told
Former Scottish health secretary Jeane Freeman has told the UK Covid-19 Inquiry she believed Scotland avoided a 'VIP lane' for procuring personal protective equipment (PPE) due to devolution.
Ms Freeman was 'politically responsible for making sure the health workforce had access to PPE', the inquiry heard, during evidence around procurement of PPE.
Giving evidence, Ms Freeman praised NHS National Services Scotland (NSS) and said it was 'minimising the cost of procurement because you're doing it at such scale', although she acknowledged the country 'often came close' to running out of key items.
She rejected claims from former prime minister Boris Johnson that the UK 'should have one single route', the inquiry heard.
Counsel for the inquiry Tom Stoate said: 'The inquiry has heard about the evidence of a high priority or VIP lane for procurement of PPE. You've talked about how NSS worked. Did that mean Scotland needed a fast-track system?'
Ms Freeman said: 'Absolutely not. We had offers of help, all of which were passed to NSS. A proper triage process would apply.'
She said that 'due diligence' would be applied 'to help decide whether new offers were appropriate to award new contracts'.
Ms Freeman added: 'Audit Scotland said in 2021 there was no evidence of bias. We did not have a VIP lane and did not need one.
'My view is there are many questions to be asked about the VIP lane and application of due diligence and probity to any offer of supply when you are using public money, and when quality and appropriateness of PPE is critical to safety of your staff and patients they are treating.'
Mr Stoate asked: 'Did Scotland run out of key items of PPE?'
Ms Freeman said: 'No. We are saying we did not run out at any point; we often came close.'
Asked about a statement from Mr Johnson that 'we should try to proceed as one UK' regarding procurement, Ms Freeman said: 'If what the former PM means is we should have single procurement route, I don't agree.
'I think it removes the democratic accountability of devolution of the Scottish Government, secondly the route UK Government took with the VIP lane is not one I would wish Scotland to take.
'Having a single system could lead to a system where Scottish ministers are responsible for actions in which they have no say.'
Caroline Lamb, chief executive of NHS Scotland and director general of Health and Social Care, told the inquiry that around 75,000 NHS staff have now been 'fit-tested' for FFP3 masks in the wake of the pandemic, compared to around 7,000 prior to it.
Giving evidence, she said that in May 2020 Scotland provided two million FFP3 masks to England and another two million to Wales.
Ms Lamb said: 'May was in the period when everyone was working really hard to provide PPE needed. As soon as we had that comfort we could provide what was needed in Scotland, we were very keen to provide mutual aid to other nations.
'The relationships at an official level were never bad, but what improved was that recognition that collaboration is great but you need to be equal partners in that collaboration and accept everybody's skills and expertise.'
She added: 'Scotland's share of the UK stockpile was not big enough to cope with the scale of pandemic we experienced. We have worked hard now to put in place surge capacity. 'Just in time' may work when demand is fairly predictable, but we need to have in place ability to surge up stock to meet demand.'
Under cross-examination from Leslie Thomas KC, representing the Federation of Ethnic Minority Health Organisations, she said efforts had been stepped up to 'fit-test' PPE for NHS staff.
Ms Lamb said: 'What became clear in pandemic is one size doesn't necessarily fit all and there was an issue for minority ethnic groups and women; there is a different range of fits available, we also worked closely with a supplier in Scotland to understand the demographics – not just understanding supply but that the people who need that supply have been fit-tested.
'The numbers have gone from 7,000 fit-tested pre-pandemic to around 75,000 in 2023.
'It's not just about having the confidence you've got supply to meet people's needs, it's that they're comfortable they can meet people's needs.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
STV News
37 minutes ago
- STV News
Swinney tried to ‘push people into arms of Reform', claims Sarwar
Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar has accused First Minister John Swinney of 'attempting to push people into the arms of Reform', following the Hamilton by-election. During a heated exchange with journalist Martin Geissler on BBC Scotland's Sunday Show, Sarwar branded questions put to him as 'embarrassing' and suggested Geissler was asking about a 'fantasy world'. Sarwar repeatedly described the SNP campaign – which urged voters they could only stop Reform by voting SNP – in the run-up to last week's poll as 'dishonest and disgraceful'. Labour's Davy Russell gained the seat from the SNP with 8,559 votes, while SNP candidate Katy Loudon came second on 7,957, ahead of Reform's Ross Lambie on 7,088. Before the vote, Swinney had claimed 'Labour are not at the races' and he described it as a 'two-horse race' between the SNP and Reform. Speaking on Sunday, Sarwar said: 'The best John Swinney had to offer after 18 years was 'vote SNP to stop Farage' – a dishonest, shameful campaign.' He said it showed a 'lack of ambition' from a Government 'running down the clock', and he claimed commentators had been 'embarrassed' by the result. Sarwar added: 'Frankly, your questions are embarrassing too, Martin.' The broadcaster responded: 'I think you should be slightly embarrassed.' PA Media Prior to the vote, John Swinney had claimed only SNP candidate Katy Loudon could stop Reform (PA). Sarwar said he had spoken to Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer on Friday following the victory, and the Scottish leader said he wants to see the two-child benefit cap removed 'as fast as possible'. He told the BBC that Labour aims to 'improve growth' and bring mortgage rates and energy bills down to alleviate the cost-of-living crisis. He added: 'Maybe you don't have a mortgage Martin, but people do have mortgages across the country. 'There have been four interest rates cuts because of economic stability and those four interest rates cuts have meant that the average mortgage is down by over £1,000. 'We've started to see energy bills come down, but those need to come down much quicker, because people feel a real pressure in the cost-of-living crisis.' He said voters had 'utterly rejected the SNP and Reform and sent a message to John Swinney that he ran a dishonest and disgraceful campaign that attempted to push people into the arms of Reform rather than confront the issues he has caused in people's communities'. He added: 'That's why, ultimately, people want them removed from office.' Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
The National
an hour ago
- The National
SNP candidate calls out Tory rival for being in 'lockstep with failed ideology'
John Redpath, the party's candidate for the Ettrick, Roxburgh & Berwickshire constituency hit out at incumbent MSP Rachael Hamilton for failing to deliver for the local community as he officially launched his campaign for Holyrood 2026 over the weekend. A founding member of Yes Berwickshire, Redpath launched his campaign with an event at Gordon Village Hall, the village where he grew up. We told how he was confirmed as the SNP candidate in April. SNP members, supporters and local residents took part in the event, where Redpath pledged to fight for more investment in rural infrastructure. READ MORE: Scottish independence 'already begun as UK political culture diverges' Redpath will contest the seat against the Tory deputy leader, who he accused of taking part in 'plenty of photo ops' without delivering for local residents. Speaking at the launch, Redpath said: "I believe this constituency deserves more than just timid and inactive representation. It deserves ambition. It deserves action. 'It deserves a voice in Parliament that will fight for your interests. 'For too long, rural communities like ours have been ignored or taken for granted by politicians who stoke division in Parliament but say little of substance here at home. 'Farmers have been hit hard by the fallout from Brexit - a decision Scotland overwhelmingly opposed. (Image: SNP) 'Fishing communities, local businesses, and our NHS have all faced the ripple effects of decisions made in London, not in Holyrood - and certainly not in the Borders. 'And what has Rachael Hamilton done about it? Plenty of photo ops. Plenty of party line speeches. 'But when it comes to delivering real change - she's marched in lockstep with a failed right-wing ideology that has delivered nothing for the Borders. I'm standing for a different kind of politics - one that is rooted in Scottish values, Scottish democracy, and Scottish priorities.' Hamilton was appointed deputy leader of the Scottish Tories by Russell Findlay in September 2024, after he won the contest to replace Douglas Ross. The Scottish Borders MSP has been in a number of rows during her time in the Scottish Parliament. In 2022, Hamilton prompted a furious response after she suggested that families who are forced to turn to food banks are 'less well-educated' when it comes to cooking and preparing meals. In January 2023, she raised eyebrows after she suggested Scotland's parliament only had the right to pass legislation if it was 'good law' during a discussion on the UK Government blocking Scotland's gender reforms from becoming law. We also told how she repeatedly failed to declare an interest in blood sports while attempting to water down hunting legislation. In response to Redpath's comments, Hamilton said: 'As MSP for Ettrick, Roxburgh & Berwickshire, my priority has always been to champion the issues close to the hearts of my constituents. 'I know how important to Scotland rural communities are, unlike the out of touch SNP who have neglected the genuine concerns of rural Scotland over the last 18 years. READ MORE: Furious Anas Sarwar clashes with BBC journalist over Labour policies 'I'm focused on the issues that really matter to people living in this constituency rather than the fringe obsessions of the cosy left-wing consensus at Holyrood.' Redpath also warned of the 'clear and present threat' of Nigel Farage's Reform UK, who came third in the recent Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election, won by Labour, where the SNP came second. He argued that Westminster failings had opened the door to Farage's 'dangerous' ideology. At the event, Redpath was surprised by a £500 kickstarter donation from Scottish Borders SNP Councillors, announced by SNP group leader Councillor Elaine Thornton-Nicol.
Daily Record
an hour ago
- Daily Record
Youth violence campaigner begs third Swinney summit 'cannot be another talking shop'
Vicky Donald, whose teenage daughter was attacked on a school bus, pleaded: "Let's hope another child doesn't die in between this summit and the next." The mum of a schoolgirl who was brutally battered on a school bus has begged "this cannot be another talking shop" after John Swinney announced a third summit on youth violence. Vicky Donald's 15-year-old daughter, Kaylynn, was attacked during the journey on her way home from class in Ladybank, Fife, two years ago. Since then she has called for urgent action as a youth violence epidemic grips Scotland. The latest summit, and her renewed plea, comes in the wake of three blade tragedies in the last 12 months, including the deaths of 16-year-old Kory McCrimmon on May 31, 2024, Amen Teklay, 15, on March 5 this year and Kayden Moy, 16, on May 17 just last month. All three deaths have taken place amid the Record's youth violence campaign, Our Kids ... Our Future, which launched two years ago after we highlighted a concerning series of attacks on teens. As part of the campaign, we have demanded the Scottish Government to invest in young people and in initiatives to prevent violence. stop more kids from dying. "If not, then let's hope another child doesn't die in between this summit and the next." The emergency event will hear from the Justice and Education Secretaries, Ministers for Children and for Victims and Community Safety, as well as cross-party MSPs, youth workers and partners delivering violence reduction and other community programmes for young people. The gathering is expected to focus on actions through education and community engagement with young people at risk of violence and prevent them from turning to antisocial behaviour or crime - including carrying a weapon. It is the third event of its kind after similar summits were held in September 2023 and in January. During the most recent event, Vicky, Kaylynn, other victims and their families met with Swinney at St Andrew's House in Edinburgh to tell them how their attacks had impacted their lives. The sit-down was secured after Kaylynn - who was left requiring mental health support following her beating in October 2022 - demanded the First Minister to act urgently to prevent further tragedies. The family wrote to Swinney again after Kayden's death last month and slammed his government's "inaction" to combat youth violence. Vicky said: "My daughter and others already gave their time, their pain, and their voices at the last summit. They told the truth. "And what happened? More promises, more headlines—and no real change. It's become clear that this government hides behind words, summits, and staged concern. "While young people continue to suffer and communities live in fear, the First Minister offers talk instead of action. We don't need more polished statements—we need bold, immediate steps to make our streets safer. "After this, the Scottish Government simply cannot hold any more summits. "They've now heard from teachers, experts, victims and their families so by now, they should have a good picture of how bad the issue of youth violence is. "Until action is taken, all this is just theatre." Three teenage boys aged 14, 15, and 16 have been arrested and charged in connection with the death of Amen, an Eritrean refugee, in Glasgow's Maryhill. In recent weeks, three teenage boys – a pair aged 17 and a 14-year-old – have appeared in court charged with the murder of Kayden, who was allegedly attacked on Irvine Beach in North Ayrshire, and died in hospital. And just last month, a 14-year-old boy was sentenced to five years detention after admitting culpable homicide following the death of Kory at Glasgow's Greenfield Park last year. Ahead of Thursday's summit, the Cabinet Secretary for Justice Angela Constance said: 'It's important to be clear that Scotland remains a safe place to live. "But more needs to be done to change the attitudes and behaviours of some who are at risk of violence, or those young people who are considering carrying a weapon. There is no place for violence in Scotland and anyone who commits a crime, will face the consequences. 'Our work remains focused on ensuring our prevention and punishment measures respond to the changing behaviours of young people. This includes ensuring good school and community engagement with young people, appropriate police powers and tackling the root causes of violence. 'At this meeting we want to hear the views of the youth work and third sector representatives on what more, or different, can be done, within the current financial climate, to help address this issue. The role of youth work and grassroot community intervention is key. We all must work together to help young people feel safe and realise that carrying a knife is never the answer.' Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'.
