Public consultation on the cards for Western Springs stadium plans
The TAU board has already evaluated the two plans and said the Auckland Arena with a new 12,500-seat sports stadium is its preferred option.
A report and attachments of nearly 300 pages for councillors contain new details of the two plans, which have been presented to councillors behind closed doors and limited details shared with the public.
Proposals
12,500-seat sports stadium
25,000-capacity concert venue
8 indoor basketball courts
6 padel courts
4 outdoor training fields
5 hospitality establishments
High-performance facilities
Cost: $200 million-$300m privately funded
Western Springs Bowl
Backers: Ponsonby Rugby Club, CRS Records, Eccles Entertainment
Multi-sport hub for Ponsonby Rugby Club and other clubs
50,000-seat concert venue with permanent stage
Boutique 5000-seat stadium
Cost: $30m, including ratepayer funding of $18m-$20m
Despite TAU saying it did not want proposals that rely on ratepayer funding, the Western Springs Bowl requires ratepayer funding of $18m to $20m, and the Auckland Arena proposal would involve ratepayers forking out $13m to move or upgrade Stadium Rd, which runs into Western Springs.
The Auckland Arena will have up to 500 car parks for the public to access the gym/health centre, courts and hospitality between 5am and 10pm daily. The park and ride station at Constellation Drive on the North Shore has 370 car parks.
In the report to the governing body, officers outline the benefits and downsides of the two proposals.
It said the Auckland Arena would likely lead to a huge increase in the use of Western Springs, private investors would bring a strong history of running similar venues, and fund the ongoing running and maintenance costs. Other benefits include addressing shortages for indoor sports and a gap in high-performance facilities for football.
The downsides include the potential impact on other stadiums, and the development of the outer fields displacing music venues, which could move to Go Media (Mt Smart) Stadium.
The Western Springs Bowl would improve the venue for concerts and festivals, and attract more international acts; the 5000-seat stadium meets a need within the city's stadium network, particularly for rugby, said the report.
The downsides would likely mean ongoing running costs for the council, particularly for Ponsonby Rugby Club; and fewer visitors than the Auckland Arena. Large events would also require new investment in public transport.
The Auckland Arena team has released a video of its proposal, featuring a campaign to generate public support.
All Black Ali Williams said: 'Western Springs is just crying out for it to happen.'
The backers of the Western Springs Bowl have said they did not wish to comment beyond what TAU has released until the process is concluded.
The report touches on a judicial review brought by the Western Springs Speedway Association (WSSA) over the lawfulness of the council decision last October to move the motorsport to Waikaraka Park in Onehunga.
Officers said 'litigation gives rise to uncertainty in the decision-making process and may have financial and reputational implications' for the council and TAU.
WSSA spokesman Jason Jones said the judicial review aimed to overturn the council's decision, go back to square one, and hold a fair process.
Public consultation on the three options will run from May 19 to June 15.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
1News
29-05-2025
- 1News
Auckland millionaires absent from controversial helipad hearing
Multi-millionaire couple Anna Mowbray and Ali Williams have not taken up the chance to personally convince a hearing that they should be granted a suburban helipad. Thursday was the final day for the applicants to satisfy the panel of independent commissioners that their application meets the demands and conditions of a helicopter pad at their Rawene Ave property in Westmere, Auckland. The resource consent application hearing was adjourned on Thursday, with the couple absent from the hearing. Anna Mowbray of Zuru Toys and the job platform Zeil, and former All-Black Ali Williams' contentious application hearing has gone ahead this month at the Auckland Town Hall, without their physical presence throughout. During the hearing, a panel of independent commissioners heard expert evidence and submissions from those opposing and supporting the application. ADVERTISEMENT The hearing was not yet officially closed, RNZ understood this could take another week with the panel now deliberating whether they required further information. The independent panel would then have a 15 working day window to announce a decision, meaning the couple would have to wait until later next month to hear an outcome. The applicants' lawyer, Chris Simmons, asked the panel not to let their absence influence their decision making. "I'll take a moment just to encourage the panel not to read anything into the applicants' physical absence from the hearing," he said. "They are absolutely invested in this application, they've been involved and, in fact, I think that they've observed online, every minute of proceedings. "The applicants have adopted a comprehensive approach to consultation and undertaken a thorough examination of potential adverse effects that been identified," the lawyer said. According to Auckland Council, out of 1397 written submissions made on the application, a majority — 1227, or 87% — opposed the helipad. One hundred and eight were supportive, and 12 were neutral. ADVERTISEMENT
RNZ News
29-05-2025
- RNZ News
Auckland millionaires fail to attend controversial helipad hearing in person
The Rawene Avenue property where the helipad might be built. Photo: RNZ/Maia Ingoe Multi-millionaire couple Anna Mowbray and Ali Williams have not taken up the chance to personally convince a hearing that they should be granted a suburban helipad. Thursday was the final day for the applicants to satisfy the panel of independent commissioners that their application meets the demands and conditions of a helicopter pad at their Rawene Avenue property in Westmere, Auckland. The resource consent application hearing was adjourned on Thursday, with the couple absent from the hearing. Anna Mowbray of Zuru Toys and the job platform Zeil, and former All-Black Ali Williams' contentious application hearing has gone ahead this month at the Auckland Town Hall, without their physical presence throughout. During the hearing, a panel of independent commissioners have heard expert evidence and submissions from those opposing and supporting the application. The hearing is not yet officially closed, RNZ understands this could take another week with the panel now deliberating whether they require further information. The independent panel will then have a 15 working day window to announce a decision, meaning the couple will have to wait until later next month to hear an outcome. The applicants' lawyer, Chris Simmons, asked the panel not to let their absence influence their decision making. "I'll take a moment just to encourage the panel not to read anything into the applicants' physical absence from the hearing," he said. "They are absolutely invested in this application, they've been involved and in fact, I think that they've observed online, every minute of proceedings. "The applicants have adopted a comprehensive approach to consultation and undertaken a thorough examination of potential adverse effects that been identified," the lawyer said. According to Auckland Council, out of 1397 written submissions made on the application, a majority - 1227, or 87 percent - opposed the helipad . One hundred and eight were supportive, and 12 were neutral. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Scoop
22-05-2025
- Scoop
All Blacks Great Joins Battle To Keep Western Springs Stadium In Public Hands
Tuifa'asisina Sir Bryan Williams is calling on Aucklanders to keep Western Springs stadium in public hands. Auckland Council and Tātaki Auckland Unlimited (TAU) have launched a public consultation on the future of Western Springs Stadium. Tuifa'asisina, former All Black and Ponsonby Rugby Club stalwart, is backing a community-led proposal to transform the stadium into a multi-use venue, as he fears a commercial redevelopment would erase a vital community space. 'This is not just about rugby - it's about preserving public access to one of Auckland's most iconic community spaces,' Tuifa'asisina says. 'We're not looking to build walls or gates. We're building access - access to top-class facilities at community rates.' The council consultation document outlines three options for the site's future: redeveloping it into a new Auckland Arena, transforming it into the Western Springs Bowl, or keeping the current setup with flexibility for alternative ideas. Tuifa'asisina supports the Bowl option, which is backed by Ponsonby Rugby Club and music promoters CRS Records and Eccles Entertainment. It proposes: -A 5000-8000 seat stadium for school finals, club sport, and community tournaments -A permanent stage for concerts and cultural events -Shared clubrooms and changing rooms for local sports and fitness groups -Affordable spaces for holiday programmes, fundraisers, and community events 'Let's be honest, private management means restricted access, high hireage fees, and limited availability. "That's not the Auckland we want to live in,' he says. Mike Lee, Waitematā and Gulf Ward councillor, says the public consultation process is already flawed, and claims Auckland Council sidelined community voices early on. 'It's all very well and good that the Council is asking the public, but they should have asked the public before they evicted Speedway from Western Springs Stadium,' he says. Auckland Council voted last year to evict the speedway and relocate the club south to Waikaraka Speedway. Lee says this has removed "the most popular" candidate from the choices. Rich lister Anna Mowbray and her husband, former All Black Ali Williams, are backing a privately funded venue focused on football. [ It would replace the natural amphitheatre with a new 12,500-seat stadium, including new facilities for Auckland FC, community sports, and commercial amenities such as restaurants and gyms. Mowbray, co-founder of ZURU and one of the private investors, told RNZ's Morning Report they want to create a world-class facility that serves both professional sports and the wider community. However, Tuifa'asisina has concerns the commercial option could limit access to large-scale community events 'We've seen festivals like Laneway and Pasifika fill the park with joy. Will they happen in a private, locked facility?' Tuifa'asisina asks. Lee says he is opposed to the privatisation of a public, open space. 'I firmly believe that soccer, rugby, concerts and speedway can all fit into Western Springs Stadium with a bit of intelligent planning and with goodwill.' He says he strongly support the retention of Ponsonby Rugby at Western Springs. "Essentially, it's the only place available that's suitable.' Council officials say the public now has a chance to help shape the venue's long-term use. Max Hardy, Auckland Council's Director of Group Strategy, says Western Springs has a rich and layered history – from the time when eels were fished in the springs, to its use as a water reservoir, and later a stadium for speedway, sport, and iconic concerts. TAU's chief executive Nick Hill says the site has untapped potential. 'Western Springs Stadium is a special place with huge potential to evolve and meet the needs of our vibrant city and region." Renowned architect Pete Bossley, who is supporting the Bowl proposal, says the natural contours of the stadium are irreplaceable. 'The amphitheatre is iconic and historic. To destroy that would be criminal.' Ponsonby Rugby Club chair Greg Edmonds warns that once the stadium is privatised, the public is unlikely to get it back in this lifetime. 'We're offering a balanced, public-private model that meets council goals and gives the public real value. We're not in this to line our pockets – we're doing this because community engagement is the fabric of a strong city. And this is our shot to keep that fabric intact.' 'It's a common-sense solution. And it's one that keeps this beautiful ground open to the people who love it,' Tuifa'asisina says. Public feedback is open until 15 June 2025 on the Auckland Council 'Have Your Say' website. No final decisions will be made until the consultation period ends and all submissions have been reviewed.
