US judge to hear closing arguments before deciding penalty in Google antitrust case
A federal judge is set to hear closing arguments on Friday before determining how he will punish Google for illegally maintaining a search engine monopoly.
The case, brought by the US government, could throw Google's expansion plans into turmoil just as it looks to strengthen its artificial intelligence offerings.
District Judge Amit Mehta last year sided with the US Justice Department and ruled that Alphabet-owned Google had been illegally exploiting its dominance in the search sector to stifle competition, ultimately harming consumers with less choice.
Last month, the trial moved into a second phase, with Mr Mehta listening to technology executives, economists and regulatory experts as he considers what penalty he will levy against Google.
His decision could be one of the most consequential in technology regulation since 1982, when the Department of Justice broke up AT&T's monopoly through its Bell telephone system. Another landmark case came in 2000 when a judge found that Microsoft breached antitrust laws by engaging in predatory practices.
The Justice Department wants Mr Mehta to enact far-reaching penalties that would be a warning to other companies.
Prosecutors want Google to divest its popular Chrome browser from its portfolio, and it wants the tech giant to share coveted search data with competitors.
The department also wants to end the lucrative deals arranged by Google where it pays companies such as Samsung and Apple to make Google's search tool the default option on devices.
Mark MacCarthy, a senior fellow at the Institute for Technology Law and Policy at Georgetown University in Washington, has studied antitrust policy for several decades. He said Google's ubiquitous presence presents the judge with a unique challenge.
Mr MacCarthy voiced concerns that a court-ordered requirement for Google to share users' search data could see companies exploit that information without people's consent.
Forcing Google to share data "would require unprecedented co-operation among the courts involved", he said. 'My view is that this would be better done by a new digital regulatory agency.'
Google has been pushing its own proposed remedies. These are far lighter than those proposed by the department, including a solution that would give users the ability to change their default search provider at least every 12 months.
'Our proposal allows browsers to continue to offer Google Search to their users and earn revenue from that partnership … but it also provides them with additional flexibility,' Google said, adding that it would give options to hardware sellers to make deals with other search engines.
'Browser companies like Apple and Mozilla should continue to have the freedom to do deals with whatever search engine they think is best for their users.'
Google has also proposed what it described as a 'robust mechanism' to ensure that it would comply with the proposed remedy.
The case playing out in Washington is not the only legal battle Google is fighting. The tech giant is appealing against part of a recent ruling that found it unfairly used its internet advertising dominance and crushed competitors.
In that case, both Google and the government are trying to shape what remedy will ultimately be decided.
The worst-case scenario for Google in that case could be that it is forced to spin off its advertising technology division, which would mean the loss of a significant amount of revenue for the search engine.
Perhaps more importantly, whatever ensues could have ripple effects across the technology ecosystem revolving around Google.
Eric Mulheim, chief financial officer of Mozilla, maker of the Firefox web browser, spoke about that shortly after testifying in the antitrust remedy trial.
'We believe the court should ensure that small and independent browsers are not harmed in any final remedies,' Mr Mulheim said, referring to Mozilla's paid partnership with Google that could be threatened by what the judge decides.
'Without this, we risk trading one monopoly for another, and the vibrant, people-first web we've spent decades fighting for could begin to fade."
In a separate court filing, Mozilla pushed for a 'more tailored' approach to whatever remedies are decided on, that will not affect independent web browsers.
Even with so much legal scrutiny, in terms of influence, market share and revenue, Google is still a force to be reckoned with. To regulators, that is the whole point, and the legal walls seem to be closing in.
On Friday, however, both Google and the department have one more chance to influence the final decision as Mr Mehta considers closing arguments.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Zawya
an hour ago
- Zawya
Wheat and corn higher, soybeans stuck near 3-week low
PARIS/SINGAPORE - Chicago wheat and corn edged higher on Friday as the cereal markets consolidated after losses this week linked to favourable U.S. and global harvest prospects. Soybeans ticked lower to hold near Thursday's three-week low, curbed by expectations of ample supplies along with uncertainty over biofuel demand as the U.S. government considers waivers for oil refiners. A firmer dollar kept grain prices in check as grain markets awaited an update on demand from weekly U.S. export sales figures later on Friday. The most-active wheat contract on the Chicago Board of Trade (CBOT) rose 0.7% to $5.37-3/4 a bushel by 1015 GMT. Corn added 0.5% to $4.49-1/4 a bushel to steady after a one-week low on Thursday. CBOT soybeans inched down 0.1% at $10.50-1/2 a bushel to consolidate above Thursday's low of $10.40. Agricultural consultancy Sovecon on Thursday raised its forecast for Russia's wheat exports for the 2025-2026 season by 1.1 million metric tons to 40.8 million tons, citing improved weather conditions for the harvest. India is likely to produce a record 117.5 million metric tons of wheat in the year ending June 2025, the farm ministry said, above its March forecast of 115.4 million tons. In the U.S., winter wheat conditions are at a five-year high despite an unexpected decline last week, while regular showers have helped most corn and soybean crops get off to a good start to their growing season. With expectations rising for Brazil's upcoming second corn crop, the corn market found little support in large export sales reported on Thursday by the U.S. Department of Agriculture. "Despite exceptional export sales reported by the USDA —amounting to 205,096 tons for the 2024/25 campaign — market support remains absent," Argus Media analysts said in a note. The soybean market was assessing a Reuters report that the White House is considering a plan to clear a record backlog of requests from small refineries for exemptions from U.S. biofuel laws. Prices at 1015 GMT Last Change Pct Move CBOT wheat 537.75 3.75 0.70 CBOT corn 449.25 2.25 0.50 CBOT soy 1050.50 -1.25 -0.12 Paris wheat 202.00 0.00 0.00 Paris maize 193.00 2.25 1.18 Paris rapeseed 474.50 2.00 0.42 WTI crude oil 61.35 0.41 0.67 Euro/dlr 1.13 0.00 -0.34 Most active contracts - Wheat, corn and soy US cents/bushel, Paris futures in euros per metric ton
Zawya
an hour ago
- Zawya
Tax bill contains 'sledgehammer' for Trump to retaliate against foreign digital taxes
U.S. President Donald Trump would have the power to retaliate against countries that impose special digital service taxes on large U.S. technology companies like Amazon and Alphabet, under a provision in the sweeping tax bill that Congress is considering. "If foreign countries want to come in the United States and tax US businesses, then those foreign-based businesses ought to be taxed as well," said Representative Ron Estes, a Kansas Republican who helped craft the provision. Some 17 countries in Europe and others around the world impose or have announced such taxes on U.S. tech products like Meta's Instagram. Germany announced on Thursday it was considering a 10% tax on platforms like Google. The levies have drawn bipartisan ire in Washington. Democrats who oppose much of the tax bill have not spoken out against the retaliatory tax provision, found in Section 899 of the 1,100-page bill. Trump has been pressing foreign countries to lower barriers to U.S. commerce. Under the bill, Congress would empower his administration to impose tax hikes on foreign residents and companies that do business in the U.S. The U.S. Constitution gives Congress, not the president, the power to decide on taxes and spending. The provision could raise $116 billion over the next decade, according to the Joint Committee on Taxation. But some experts warned that an unintended consequence of retaliatory taxes could be less foreign investment in the U.S. "This new Section 899 provision brings a sledgehammer to the idea that the United States will allow itself to be characterized as a tax haven by anyone," said Peter Roskam, former Republican congressman and head of law firm Baker Hostetler's federal policy team. The House of Representatives narrowly passed the bill on May 22, and it now heads to the Senate. Democrats broadly oppose the Republicans' tax and spending bill, which advances many of Trump's top priorities such as an immigration crackdown, extending Trump's 2017 tax cuts and ending some green energy incentives. Section 899 would allow the Treasury Department to label the foreign tech taxes "unfair" and place the country in question on a list of "discriminatory foreign countries." Some other foreign taxes also would be subject to scrutiny. Once on the list, a country's individuals and its companies that operate in the U.S. could face stiffer tax rates that could increase each year, up to 20 percentage points. Joseph Wang, chief investment officer at Monetary Macro, said Section 899 could help Trump reduce trade imbalances because if foreign investment decreases it could depreciate the U.S. dollar. This in turn could spur exports of U.S. products by making them cheaper overseas. Portfolio interest would remain exempt from any tax Trump imposes, but some experts cautioned that taxing foreigners could quell foreign investment in the U.S. "Foreign investors may change their behavior to avoid the taxes in various ways, including potentially by simply investing elsewhere," said Duncan Hardell, an advisor at New York University's Tax Law Center. PUSH BACK TO GLOBAL MINIMUM TAX The new approach follows the 15% minimum global corporate tax deal negotiated by the administration of Democratic former President Joe Biden. Republicans, led by Representative Jason Smith of Missouri, chairman of the House tax committee, opposed that approach, arguing it unfairly benefits Chinese companies. Foreign countries have invoked that global minimum to slap higher taxes on U.S. tech firms, if they concluded that generous U.S. tax credits for research and development pushed their tax burden below that 15% threshold. Trump in February directed his administration to combat foreign digital taxes, but they were not addressed in the trade deal announced in May between the U.S. and the United Kingdom, which imposes a 2% levy on foreign digital services. It was unclear if the Treasury Department would actually use the new authority if it becomes law, or if the mere threat of action would convince other countries to change course. The department did not share its intended strategy when asked.
Zawya
an hour ago
- Zawya
Stocks head for best month since 2023 ahead of inflation data
LONDON - World stocks were heading for their best month since late 2023 on Friday and the dollar was flirting with its first monthly rise of the year, while traders waited for key inflation data and assessed the latest in Washington's to and fro on tariffs. Markets have been see-sawing all week as investors try to ride out a rollercoaster news flow after a U.S. court blocked most of President Donald Trump's tariffs and a federal appeals court temporarily reinstated them. An initial fall by European stocks on Friday turned into 0.3%-1% gains despite an unexpected dip in German retail sales and as Wall Street futures beginning to sag again ahead of U.S. PCE inflation data due later. MSCI's main world index is up over 5% this month while the dollar, which was up 0.3% on Friday, is tantalizingly close to its first positive month of 2025. It was helped by benchmark 10-year U.S. Treasury yields - which are a proxy for U.S. borrowing costs - rising 0.5 basis points in European trade. They had dipped on Thursday on soft economic data and a solid 7-year bond auction. Investors have also been rattled by a little-publicized provision in Trump's budget bill that would allow the government to impose taxes of up to 20% on foreign investment. "A foreign tax provision in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act is alarming," Brown Brothers Harriman strategist Elias Haddad said, adding that all the uncertainty raised the risk of the U.S. entering "a period of stagflation". Oil prices were on track for a second consecutive weekly drop on expectations of another OPEC+ output hike, although they were up on the day and still up for the month as a whole. Japan's Nikkei saw profit taking overnight after its near 2% rally the previous day, with investors also concerned about Japanese debt levels and the impact of tariffs. The yen appreciated as much as 2% from its low on Thursday and was changing hands at roughly 144 per dollar in London. The euro and pound were down 0.3% and 0.1% at $1.13 and $1.34 respectively. In Asia, Hong Kong's Hang Seng had dropped 1.2%, with Apple suppliers hit by the U.S. tariff reversal. Mainland Chinese blue chips dipped 0.5% too although both scored solid monthly gains. Korean stocks have fared even better, notching up their best month since November 2023 in line with the main world index. An index tracking emerging market currencies meanwhile has also gained about 2% for the month. That is also its best since November 2023. Soaring gold prices have helped Ghana's cedi rocket nearly 40% this month. "Trump's trade agenda remains alive and kicking, with the legal battle adding yet another layer of uncertainty," said Rodrigo Catril, senior FX strategist at National Australia Bank. "The only thing that looks more certain is more uncertainty," he said. Despite the courtroom drama, the Trump administration said negotiations with top trading partners were continuing unabated. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said during an interview with Fox News that he was scheduled to have talks with a high-level Japanese delegation later on Friday in Washington, although he said talks with China were "a bit stalled".
