logo
Mathematician Adam Kucharski: ‘Our concepts of what we can prove are shifting'

Mathematician Adam Kucharski: ‘Our concepts of what we can prove are shifting'

The Guardian29-03-2025

Adam Kucharski is a professor at the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine. As a mathematician and epidemiologist, he has advised multiple governments on outbreaks such as Ebola and Covid. In his new book Proof: The Uncertain Science of Certainty, he examines how we can appraise evidence in our search for the truth.
What inspired you to investigate the concept of proof?Alice Stewart, an influential epidemiologist, used this nice phrase that 'truth is the daughter of time'. But in many situations, whether you're accused of a crime or thinking about a climate crisis, you don't want to wait; there's an urgency to accumulate evidence and set a bar for action. We're entering an era where questions around information – what we trust and how we act – are increasingly important, and our concepts of what we can prove are shifting as well.
You examined the ways that mathematical proofs have changed throughout history. What did you learn?I was so fascinated by the cultural differences in what people have assumed to be obvious. In Europe, for example, negative numbers were shunned for a very long time. That's because a lot of our maths was built around ancient Greek geometry, where something like a 'negative triangle' doesn't make sense. In contrast, a lot of the early mathematical theories in Asia were driven by finance and the concepts of debt, where negative numbers make a lot more sense, so they were much more comfortable handling those concepts.
I found that ideas like calculus were also based on physical intuitions about the world: an apple falls, and we can write down the equations that drive its motion. But when you started getting down into it, you could find exceptions where the intuitions weren't true. As a result, you had this tension with an entire community who wanted to ignore these nuisances – these 'monsters', as they called them – while other characters were pushing for an evolution of the field. Einstein's work on relativity, for example, relied on these controversial ideas.
In the book, you draw some parallels between these mathematical debates and the politics of the time.A lot of democratic ideas in the foundation of countries like the US attempted a kind of mathematical precision. The statement 'we hold these truths to be self-evident' in the US constitution was originally 'we hold these truths to be sacred', for example. But Benjamin Franklin crossed it out because he wanted more mathematical certainty behind these ideas, as if they were axioms. And in parallel with mathematics crumbling in its foundations, you saw the US descending into civil war, because the idea that all people are created equal wasn't self-evident to some people. You had the same tension manifesting in two different ways in two very different fields.
Tell me a bit about Abraham Lincoln. How was he influenced by mathematics in his rhetoric?Lincoln was renowned for his speeches and the precise nature of his arguments, and that didn't come about by coincidence. He made a conscious decision as a lawyer to get a better understanding of what it means to demonstrate something and construct an argument that is logically robust. So he went and taught himself the fundamentals of ancient Greek mathematics, Euclid's Elements, and he would deploy those principles in his debates. He took advantage of this notion that if you can find a flaw or contradiction, you can cause someone's entire argument to collapse.
You describe how some core concepts arose from casual conversations. How did the perfect cup of tea inspire the design of clinical trials?There was a tearoom in Rothamsted agricultural station in Hertfordshire, and in the early 1920s, three statisticians were having a conversation when one of them, Muriel Bristol, observed that tea always tastes better if the milk is put in before the hot water. The other people around the table disagreed, but they thought it was a nice challenge to see how you could work out whether she could tell the difference or not. In the end, they calculated that you need to lay out eight cups, in which half have the milk added before the hot water, and half after, ordered randomly. This produces around 70 possible combinations, meaning there is only a 1.4% chance that Bristol would get that out of all the possibilities correct – which she did.
One of the mathematicians was Ronald Fisher, who would end up writing a landmark book called The Design of Experiments that examined how you can separate an effect from chance or human biases – and this included the principle of randomisation and using probabilities to test the strength of a hypothesis.
How is AI changing our understanding of proof?A few years ago, I was at a dinner with a lot of AI specialists, and there was a lot of talk about the fact that AI is often more efficient if you don't worry about it providing an explanation for what it's doing or the decisions it makes. I found it interesting that this was a concern, because in medicine, we have a lot of things that work without us understanding why. One example is anaesthesia: we know the combination of drugs that makes a patient unconscious, but it's not clear why they do.
We've struggled with similar questions for a long time, right?In the 1970s, we had the first ever computer-aided proof of the four-colour theorem, which says that if you want to colour a map so that no two bordering countries have the same colour, you'll only need four colours to do this. Even if you simplify it down and you look for symmetries, there are still just too many combinations to go through by hand. But a pair of mathematicians used a computer to punch those combinations and get over the line. There was a lot of scepticism, because it was the first time that you had this major theorem that mathematicians couldn't verify by hand. But then, among the younger generation of mathematicians, there is scepticism about some of the old methods. Why would hundreds of pages of handwritten maths be more trustworthy than a computer?
I think that's going to be an important debate in the future, as algorithms become increasingly useful for the predictions they can make, even if we don't have an easy understanding of the way they work.
With the spread of misinformation, it may feel that many people have simply stopped caring about evidence. What do you think of this?There has been some interesting research looking at what people say they value online, versus what they actually do. If you ask people whether accuracy is important in what they share, they'll say they don't want to share things that are false. In the moment, however, they often get distracted: something triggers an emotional response, or aligns with political beliefs, and they share the information on those grounds, without checking the facts.
But there are lots of layers to this. In some cases, there can be an incentive to go against what authority says, if you want to suggest that you're not constrained by the thinking of the crowd. Henri Poincaré, a mathematician who did a lot of work in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, described something like this: 'To doubt everything or to believe everything are two equally convenient solutions; both dispense with the necessity of reflection.' And I think that's the danger, at the moment – that there's this almost excessive doubt. People are just disengaging with truth altogether.
Proof: The Uncertain Science of Certainty by Adam Kucharski is published by Profile (£22). To support the Guardian and Observer order your copy at guardianbookshop.com. Delivery charges may apply

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Do you have a summer cold or is it the new strain of Covid?
Do you have a summer cold or is it the new strain of Covid?

Telegraph

time8 hours ago

  • Telegraph

Do you have a summer cold or is it the new strain of Covid?

We associate colds and viruses with the winter, and for good reason. Illness spikes in the colder months because it's a time when we huddle indoors, creating the perfect environment for viruses to spread. Then there's the cold air, which dries out our airways and leaves us more vulnerable to catching bugs. Why then are we still getting colds in the summer? The culprits: there are still bugs that can make you sniffily at this time of year, and there's also a new Covid strain beginning to spread in Britain. So, which could be making you unwell and, most importantly, what can you do to avoid it? What's happening with the new strain of Covid? The NB.1.8.1 Covid strain is the latest that health officials are keeping their eyes on. It first emerged in China in January and the World Health Organization (WHO) began tracking it a fortnight ago because of some potentially worrying mutations that the variant carries. 'There is some early indication that it may be slightly better at evading immune responses and antibodies, but this is very early data,' explains Dr Lindsay Broadbent, assistant professor in virology at the University of Surrey. However, the risk posed by NB.1.8.1 remains low, and there is no evidence that it causes a more severe illness or is drastically different to previous strains of the virus, she notes. 'People don't need to be overly concerned,' Dr Broadbent adds. Latest weekly data from the UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA) suggests there's been a slight uptick in Covid infections in recent weeks. Of patients tested by their GP, 5.2 per cent tested positive for Covid, up from 4.5 per cent the week before. Since first being detected in the UK in January there have been 13 confirmed cases of NB.1.8.1, though 12 of these were recorded in April and May. For context, around 50 positive tests are currently being sequenced per week. This is when a throat or nose sample that tested positive for Covid is genetically sequenced to determine the variant behind the infection. 'NB.1.8.1 has been detected in small numbers in the UK to date, but international data suggests that it is growing as a proportion of all Covid cases,' notes Dr Gayatri Amirthalingam, deputy director of the UKHSA. 'Based on the available information so far, however, there is no evidence to suggest that this variant causes more severe disease than previous variants, or that the vaccines in current use will be less effective against it.' Why are people still getting summer colds? While there is typically a cyclical spike in colds in the winter, that doesn't mean they disappear in the warmer months. In fact, some cold-causing viruses, such as parainfluenza virus Type 3 and enteroviruses (especially coxsackieviruses and echoviruses) are much more common in the summer, says Prof Fidelma Fitzpatrick, head of clinical microbiology at the Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, and consultant microbiologist in Beaumont Hospital in Dublin. Summer colds can also be caused by adenoviruses, which spread year-round but can have peaks in the summer, and rhinoviruses, which is the classic winter cold but is still around in the summer, she says. 'The risk of being exposed to a virus and getting sick depends on lots of factors including our behaviour, the environment and how common those viruses are at any given time,' Dr Broadbent explains. As we enter the summer, people's social calendars tend to fill up with weddings, parties, festivals and holidays, meaning lots of mixing between different groups and generations that wouldn't be together otherwise, says Prof Fitzpatrick. 'There is often more socialising and travel during the summer months, this may mean we are in contact with a lot more people than usual,' Dr Broadbent confirms. Adding to that is that activities that often come with summer festivities – alcohol, a lack of sleep and eating more processed foods – are known to weaken our immune system, making us less equipped to fight off these cold-causing bugs, Prof Fitzpatrick says. Additionally, air conditioning can dry out our nasal passages, which makes it easier for viruses to infect, she notes. It's unclear whether summer colds are on the rise, as the specific viruses that cause them are not tracked. Latest UKHSA data suggests that parainfluenza cases decreased slightly in the week to June 1, though this reflects the trend for all four types of parainfluenza and only Type 3 is specifically linked with summer colds. What are the symptoms to watch out for? Covid continues to cause cold-like symptoms for most people. 'Most infected people have mild to moderate symptoms,' says Prof Fitzpatrick. These include a runny nose, sore throat, congestion, a mild cough, tiredness and headaches. However, people with underlying health conditions face a higher risk of developing more serious symptoms, such as difficulty breathing, and the illness lasting for longer. It's impossible to know from the symptoms alone whether you have Covid or a summer cold, as the latter also causes a runny nose, low energy, muscle aches, a cough, headache and sore throat, Prof Fitzpatrick says. However, Covid tests are available from pharmacies with prices starting around £2, which can indicate if that virus is to blame. While there are no Covid restrictions in place, official advice recommends trying to stay at home if you catch the virus.

Should we be worried about new Covid strain Nimbus as UK cases rise?
Should we be worried about new Covid strain Nimbus as UK cases rise?

Daily Record

time10 hours ago

  • Daily Record

Should we be worried about new Covid strain Nimbus as UK cases rise?

The new variant of Covid NB.1.8.1 is more easily spread than past strains of the virus. A new strain of Covid that causes some new and unusual symptoms has been found in the UK and 21 other countries so far, including Australia, China and India. The variant has been named NB.1.8.1, or "Nimbus", and is similar to the Omicron strain of the virus. This new version of the disease is making up a "growing proportion" of Covid cases worldwide, according to the UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA). Scientists have discovered that this new variant can spread far more easily than previous strains of Covid, and the World Health Organisation have deemed it a "variant under monitoring". ‌ New and unusual symptoms have been associated with Nimbus, including heartburn, along with some other gastrointestinal signs like nausea, diarrhoea, and a severe sore throat that causes a "razor-blade sensation". Nimbus is rising worldwide, and 13 cases had been found in the UK as of yesterday, June 10. ‌ But is this new variant of Covid something we should be worrying about? Dr Gayatri Amirthalingam, UKHSA Deputy Director, said: "NB.1.8.1 has been detected in small numbers in the UK to date, but international data suggests that it is growing as a proportion of all COVID-19 cases. "Based on the available information so far however, there is no evidence to suggest that this variant causes more severe disease than previous variants, or that the vaccines in current use will be less effective against it." Dr Chun Tang, GP at UK private healthcare centre Pall Mall Medical, said: 'NB.1.8.1 isn't too different from the Omicron variant, but it does have some tweaks to its spike protein, which might make it spread a bit more easily or slip past some of our existing immunity. 'That said, early signs suggest it doesn't seem to cause more serious illness, but of course, we're still learning more about it.' ‌ WHO have announced that the risks posed by Nimbus to the public are low, and that existing Covid vaccinations are thought to be effective against the new variant, which was first discovered in January of this year. However, those suffering from symptoms of the NB.1.8.1 Covid variant are being advised by UKHSA to stay home to prevent further spreading of the highly-transmissible virus. ‌ The full list of symptoms are; a high temperature or shivering (chills) – a high temperature means you feel hot to touch on your chest or back (you do not need to measure your temperature) a new, continuous cough – this means coughing a lot for more than an hour, or 3 or more coughing episodes in 24 hours a loss or change to your sense of smell or taste shortness of breath feeling tired or exhausted an aching body a headache a sore throat a blocked or runny nose loss of appetite diarrhoea feeling sick or being sick Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store