The secret to faster hip and knee surgeries? Fixing referrals, study says
About one in three Canadians needing a new hip or knee are waiting longer than they should, but instead of turning to private clinics, researchers say a more centralized referral system could help fix the backlog.
A study published Tuesday in the Canadian Medical Association Journal (CMAJ) found that organizing referrals and surgeries through a coordinated, team-based approach could help with long wait times for hip and knee replacements.
'Canada performs poorly for access to scheduled surgery … access to care is a weakness in the Canadian health system, this has really been the Achilles heel of the Canadian health system,' said Dr. David Urbich, study author and head of the department of surgery at Women's College Hospital in Toronto.
'But the good news is, there are very good solutions. They're not difficult. They are not expensive.'
Story continues below advertisement
2:24
Health Matters: Long wait times for surgery, treatment costing Canadians
Reducing wait times for hip and knee replacement surgeries could be as simple as reorganizing how patients are referred to surgeons — no need for extra operating rooms, more surgeons or additional funding, the study argued.
In Canada, the benchmark wait time for hip and knee replacement surgery is 182 days — six months.
According to the latest data from the Canadian Institute for Health Information, around 66 per cent of patients get their surgery within that window. But that still leaves a third waiting longer.
The numbers are even lower for knee replacements, with just 59 per cent getting the procedure within six months.
Get weekly health news
Receive the latest medical news and health information delivered to you every Sunday. Sign up for weekly health newsletter Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
To address this issue, some Canadian provinces have been experimenting with private for-profit delivery of some surgeries to help ease wait times.
Story continues below advertisement
However, this study proposes creating a central list, saying it could impact wait times more effectively.
How to cut down on wait times
For many Canadians, the process of getting a knee or hip surgery starts with a 'direct physician-to-physician referral,' Urbich explained.
That means a family doctor refers the patient to a specialist — but they might not know if it's the right one or even the next available one.
Most surgeons work as independent practitioners, managing their own waitlists for consultations and surgeries. Once a surgeon takes on a patient for a procedure, they typically don't share care with other surgeons, according to the study.
To see if there's a better way to tackle long wait times, the researchers looked into a few different intake models aimed at helping patients get seen faster.
Story continues below advertisement
Using data from Ontario, they broke things down into three models of care.
1:48
Albertan seeks surgery outside province amid long wait times
The study focused on patients referred by a family doctor or general practitioner in 2017 for non-urgent hip or knee replacements. In total, the simulations were based on 17,465 surgeries performed on 17,132 patients, involving 7,783 referring doctors, 274 surgeons and 71 hospitals across five regions in Ontario.
The models included:
Single-entry referral model . This is when all patients' referrals in a region are pooled together and then directed to the next available surgeon for consultation, rather than being sent to specific surgeons individually.
. This is when all patients' referrals in a region are pooled together and then directed to the next available surgeon for consultation, rather than being sent to specific surgeons individually. Team-based care model . After consultation, patients who need surgery enter a shared regional queue and are scheduled for surgery on the next available date with any surgeon in that region, instead of waiting for a specific surgeon.
. After consultation, patients who need surgery enter a shared regional queue and are scheduled for surgery on the next available date with any surgeon in that region, instead of waiting for a specific surgeon. Fully integrated model. This combines both the single-entry referral and team-based care models. Patients are pooled into a single queue both for consultations and surgeries, and they see the next available surgeon for each step.
Both team-based and fully integrated models had much larger effects on reducing wait times than the single-entry referral model, the study found.
Story continues below advertisement
'The best model is when surgeons work together in teams and share the care of patients together and patients are referred to a team,' Urbich said.
'So they're seen by the next available surgeon for consultation. And then when it comes time to have surgery, they also have surgery by the next available surgeon.'
1:34
Surgery wait times in New Brunswick have increased, health council says
That is what it takes to prevent anybody from waiting too long for a joint replacement surgery, he added.
He also stressed that in these models, all surgeons are qualified and experts in the operations they do.
'Adoption of these models will require strong leadership among health-system leaders and the active participation of surgeons,' the study concluded. 'It will also require some investment in system infrastructure, instead of one-time investments to increase surgical volumes during times of crisis.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Vancouver Sun
a day ago
- Vancouver Sun
Can these YouTube videos create a flood of medical professionals to B.C.?
The provincial government is hoping to turn a trickle northward into a torrent. A new targeted advertising campaign has been launched in three Western U.S. states — Washington, Oregon and California — aimed at luring more doctors and nurses to B.C., to help combat the shortage of medical personnel in the province. There had been a steady stream of doctors and nurses moving north since the U.S. election in November. In April, the province streamlined its credential recognition process with American professionals, resulting a 127 per cent leap in applications from U.S. trained nurses. It cut the time nurses can be registered from an average of four months to just a few days. The new marketing campaign urges the health professionals to 'follow their hearts' and move to B.C., and is operating under a highly-targeted strategy. The advertisements will hit 14,000 digital screen locations within a 16-kilometre radius of health care facilities in those states, across video, social, audio and print platforms. The target areas in select cities also include restaurants, grocery stores, ride-share screens and outdoor placements, such as digital billboards, transit shelters and urban panels. Start your day with a roundup of B.C.-focused news and opinion. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder. The next issue of Sunrise will soon be in your inbox. Please try again Interested in more newsletters? Browse here. The six-week long campaign is projected to reach nearly 80 per cent of health care professionals in those target areas. 'Our message to U.S. doctors, nurses and allied health workers is strong and clear — there has never been a better time to come to British Columbia, and for Canadian health professionals currently living and working in the U.S., now is the time to come home,' Minister of Health Josie Osborne. 'With the chaos and uncertainty happening in the U.S., we are seizing the opportunity to attract the talent we need to join and strengthen our public, universal health care system in British Columbia.' Since the change in the U.S. administration, one report from the Medical Council of American had reported a 750 per cent spike in a seven-month period of American doctors registering for a Canadian licence. In B.C. specifically, since the launch of its recruitment campaign, the province has reported nearly 1,600 medical professionals who have inquired about the move, including 704 doctors and 525 nurses. A budget that passed through the U.S. Congress included cuts that would eviscerate medical services in the states, including a near-20 per cent cut of almost US$6M to the National Institutes of Health. Science and medicine have been under incredible ideological and financial pressure since the change in presidential administrations. In B.C., the provincial government is highlighting its pro-medicine and science stance . The new campaign also helps tailor support and guidance for those who start the process in moving north, and highlight the areas where help is most urgently needed, such as cancer care, emergency departments and rural communities facing severe health care worker shortages. 'American health care professionals are increasingly drawn to B.C. as a place that supports science, protects reproductive rights and takes care of people no matter how much money they have in their bank account,' said Premier David Eby. 'That's why I'm delighted to see that our new, fast-tracked credential recognition has cut registration time from months to just days and is bringing in new U.S. nurses to strengthen our public health system and deliver better care for British Columbians, faster.'
Toronto Star
2 days ago
- Toronto Star
Teva birth control pills recalled across Canada over extra placebos
Birth control medication is being pulled from Canadian shelves over extra placebo tablets, Health Canada says. The recall concerns Teva Canada's Seasonale tablet with lot numbers 100059661 and 100069150, according to the agency's recall notice. Health Canada is urging patients not to skip doses or stop taking their birth control. But if your package contains white placebo pills in the first or second blister card tray, don't take them, and return the pills to your pharmacy for a replacement. ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW If you can't get to a pharmacy right away, take the next pink active pill in the proper order, as laid out in the instructions, until you can get a replacement. If you took a white placebo pill instead of an active pink pill from one of the first two trays, or if you are unsure, you should also use another method of non-hormonal contraception and consult with your health care professional.
Toronto Star
2 days ago
- Toronto Star
3 Canadian national team players among the Whitecaps stricken by illness
Three Canadian national team players were among those who fell ill following the Vancouver Whitecaps' appearance in the CONCACAF Champions Cup final last weekend in Mexico City. The Whitecaps said a 'significant number' of players and staff had a gastrointestinal illness. Three of them — Ali Ahmed, Sam Adekugbe and Jayden Nelson — were ill when they arrived at Canada's training camp in Halifax ahead of Saturday's Canadian Shield match against Ukraine, coach Jesse Marsch said Friday.
