Repeated failings by the nursing regulator demand a new approach
Yet another official review has confirmed what The Independent has reported: that the body in charge of making sure that nurses are qualified to work safely in the NHS and the private sector has been guilty of serious failings.
The Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC) has allowed 350 underqualified or fraudulently qualified nurses to work in the UK, a damning new report from the Professional Standards Authority has found.
The NMC is also failing to spot workers who could pose a risk to patient safety and to prioritise investigating them, as we report today.
These are only the latest of a series of damning findings by inquiries that might not have taken place if it were not for journalists acting on the concerns of whistleblowers to investigate problems.
Rebecca Thomas, The Independent 's award-winning health correspondent, has been tenacious in reporting the problems of poor NHS services that are so often compounded by cultures of covering up, usually backed by bullying or threats.
This latest inquiry was prompted by her reporting, based on the testimony of whistleblowers.
What is most discouraging is that The Independent and other media organisations have been reporting on failures of the NMC for at least 17 years. We reported two years ago that Sir Ben Bradshaw, who was a health minister in the last Labour government, said that he was 'extremely concerned' to see many of the same issues that led him to commission an inquiry in 2008 'are still being raised today'.
In a health service beset by problems, a regulator that is fundamentally unable to root out problems is instead going to make them worse. The Independent has led the way in reporting the systemic problems in maternity care and mental health care – and in both cases, the failure of the regulator to ensure nursing standards makes matters worse.
After the Lucy Letby case, we ought to be more aware of the need to pick up concerns about nurses at an early stage. This is a job that the NMC has simply failed to do in far too many cases.
Since The Independent 's reporting, the NMC's chief executive and chair have stood down, and Paul Rees, the interim chief executive of the NMC, said the report reflected a 'dark period' in the NMC's history. But it is a dark period that has lasted for far too long.
We hope that Mr Rees is capable of the 'radical change' that he has promised. Bringing about a change in the culture of organisations is a huge challenge, and one that seems to plague the health service and many of the regulatory bodies linked to it.
This requires leadership from the top. The running of a regulator such as the Nursing and Midwifery Council may not be the direct responsibility of the secretary of state, but ministers have to take a close and intrusive interest in it. Rooting out rogue nurses ought to be part of a wider safety culture in the NHS.
Jeremy Hunt, who was the longest-serving health secretary, made the making of a safety culture a personal mission towards the end of his time in office. Wes Streeting should take up his crusade. The current health secretary should even consider drafting in his predecessor, in a safety overlord role, to assist in trying to change the culture of the NHS at a fundamental level.
Mr Streeting owes it to all patients to try a new approach. Patient safety is too important to allow any more years of repeating the same failures.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Glasgow Times
6 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
Lorraine Kelly 'should have realised' daughter was pregnant
The broadcaster, originally from the Gorbals in Glasgow, became a granny in September 2024 when her daughter Rosie welcomed a baby girl named Billie. However, Rosie admitted she had been 'so nervous' about telling her mum the news, and chose to keep her pregnancy a secret until she reached the 12-week mark. However, the timing proved difficult, as Rosie and Lorraine were due to travel to Scotland together for Lorraine's book tour. READ MORE: Major change revealed for Lorraine Kelly's much-loved ITV show Speaking on the Bedside Manners podcast with Dr Oscar Duke, Rosie said: "I was so scared to tell mum. "Steve and I were very much like, we want to wait the 12 weeks before we tell people. "I was very much like, I need to tell my mum. I knew that I wanted to tell you before that because we were going on your book tour." Rosie shared her concerns: "I was going to go up with you to Scotland, and I was terrified about going up still having the secret and not being able to help mum with her luggage and carrying all the books. "It was like, she's going to know something's up and I can't keep it a secret, but I remember we went on a spa day and you were like, let's go in the hot tub. I was like, oh." Lorraine responded: "I should've realised then. It was early on, and I was ever so slightly chuffed. I was crying and everything. It was just lovely." The NHS advises pregnant women to avoid hot tubs, particularly in the first 12 weeks of pregnancy, due to the risks of overheating, dehydration, and fainting. READ MORE: Lorraine Kelly 'glad to be back' on her TV show and explains reason for surgery Lorraine, who has been married to Steve Smith since 1992, said she was 'so excited' to become a grandmother. She shared: 'To be honest, I'll answer to anything, but 'Granny' I'm delighted with — I think it's the best title ever.' She jokingly added that she is available for babysitting '24/7.' Speaking to Yours magazine, Lorraine described baby Billie as 'just adorable.' "I was working when Rosie was little, and I missed out on quite a lot, so it's nice to get that time again. "The most important thing is your family, and sometimes it takes a wee baby coming into the world to make you realise that. "You know, for all the interesting things I do, the best thing that I've been doing this year is just taking her for a walk in the pram." Lorraine says she has "adopted him as my son". She praised Steve for "loving" and "taking care" of Rosie.
BBC News
10 minutes ago
- BBC News
Swanley couple meet paramedics who saved newborn son's life
A couple from Kent have introduced their four-month-old son to the "superhero" paramedics who saved his life when he suffered a cardiac arrest after his Webb, 33, and Matt Woolhouse, 35, from Swanley, took baby George to Dartford Ambulance Station to meet some of the team who helped him after he was starved of oxygen during the Wheeler, one of the ambulance crew who helped save George, said she was "over the moon" to be reunited with the Woolhouse said: "Thank you really doesn't feel enough." He added: "It's hard to put into words how we feel as without you, we wouldn't be here with George today."Ms Webb said: "It was overwhelming to be able to meet everyone again and talk it all through, as it was a total whirlwind that afternoon."I can't thank them enough for everything they did for our family. They really are superheroes." 'Special reminder' Paramedics became involved after Ms Webb, who gave birth to George at home on 25 January, suffered complications when his shoulder became later went into cardiac arrest after being "starved of oxygen" for seven minutes, South East Coast Ambulance Service said.A team of paramedics were able to restart his heart and after a 10 day stay in neonatal intensive care at Medway Maritime Hospital, George has gone on to make a good recovery. Ms Wheeler said: "I was over the moon to be able to reunite with baby George, Charlotte and Matt."It made my week, and it was a really special reminder of the difference that we can make to our patients."George will now be monitored for two years to ensure there are no long-lasting complications.A spokesperson for South East Coast Ambulance Service said that just 12% of newborns survive cardiac arrest when born out of hospital.
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Why over-60s should have four coffees a day
It's no great surprise to any of us that with ageing comes the unavoidable deterioration of our bodies. As the years notch up, we tend to lose muscle mass, vital organs decline, we become slower, weaker and less mentally focused. So it's inevitable that the stairs seem steeper, the shopping feels heavier, our breath is more sluggish, and a favourite glass and the top shelf of the cupboard becomes frustratingly out of reach. Then there's the thing we fear more than anything: becoming 'frail'. Professor Tahir Masud, clinical advisor to the Royal Osteoporosis Society (ROS) and a consultant physician at Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust, adds: 'Health care professionals often refer to frailty as a 'lack of physiological reserve'. It can lead to older people being at a higher risk of falls, reduced mobility, and being unable to look after themselves without help. In people suffering from osteoporosis and fragility fractures, frailty can increase the risk of broken bones by increasing the risk of falls. It can also escalate the possibility of hospitalisation and the need for residential or nursing homes, as well as an earlier death.' But there is some good news: drinking coffee could be the key to staying strong as you age. A recent study published in the European Journal of Nutrition claims that regularly drinking four to six cups of coffee a day has been linked with a reduced risk of frailty. And because, for many of us, coffee is craved and revered, it could now mean we can enjoy those daily cups of Costa Rica's finest, while feeling reassured it is supporting our health… What did the report reveal? This research, which carried out an analysis over seven years, surveyed 1,161 adults aged 55 plus through the Longitudinal Ageing Study Amsterdam (LASA). It's the first of its kind to look at the relationship between coffee consumption and effect on frailty. The physical health of each of the participants was evaluated using a model called Fried's five-component frailty phenotype (developed by Dr Linda Fried in 2001), which focusses on certain frailty traits: unintentional weight loss, weakness, exhaustion, slow walking speed and low physical activity. 'The results from the research support the idea that moderate to high habitual coffee consumption leads to improvement in these areas and so may reduce the risk of frailty in older adults,' says Bini Suresh, British Dietetic Association (BDA) spokesperson and lead dietitian at Cleveland Clinic London, who has some reservations: 'While a seven-year study lends credibility, there are a few important limitations and caveats to consider. The study is observational, so we can't confirm cause and effect – the people who drink more coffee might engage in other health-promoting behaviours. But it does add weight to the growing evidence base linking certain dietary patterns and specific foods with functional health outcomes, particularly in the ageing.' How does coffee make us stronger? There is growing research which advocates the benefits of moderate coffee drinking. Its unique components each play a role in making it a positive addition to your diet as you age. The caffeine content acts as an 'adenosine receptor antagonist', which in laymen's terms, means it helps reduce fatigue and enhance alertness. Plus, caffeine can improve muscle movement, thus supporting mobility and reducing weakness. The polyphenols (natural plant compounds) have anti-inflammatory and antioxidant properties which ward off age-related muscle loss, swelling, and support overall function. While a lesser-known compound, trigonelline, may sustain cognitive health and improve memory. Despite the latest study citing six cups, experts are keen to make sure we don't go overboard. Dell Stanford, senior dietitian at the British Heart Foundation, says: 'Consuming two or three cups of coffee a day may be linked to lower risk of cardiovascular disease (CVD) compared to drinking no coffee. However, drinking more than four or five cups of coffee per day, will probably raise your caffeine intake to above the recommended daily maximum of 400mg (four to five cups). Generally, the effects of too much caffeine may include temporarily increased blood pressure and heart rate, palpitations, anxiety, agitation, nausea, headache and sleep disturbance.' Can coffee substitute regular exercise? Bini Suresh thinks not. 'Coffee complements, it shouldn't replace exercise,' he says. 'Regular physical activity will directly improve strength, endurance and the body's ability to function well. While the caffeine in coffee might give you a performance boost and delay fatigue, it's there as a support tool. I'd always advise regular movement and a healthy balanced diet that includes antioxidant-rich foods, like coffee.' What other foods might help with frailty? Antioxidants, like polyphenols (naturally occurring in plants), help to protect cells, including muscle and brain cells, from damage. Nichola Ludlam-Raine, dietitian and author of How Not to Eat Ultra-Processed, says: ' Yes, coffee is a major source of polyphenols, but similar compounds are found in berries, dark chocolate, olive oil, green tea, and many vegetables. Once consumed, they're absorbed in the gut (though bioavailability varies), metabolised mainly in the liver, and act throughout the body. Protein-rich foods (like eggs, dairy, legumes, tofu, fish and lean meat) are important for muscle preservation, in addition to foods rich in omega-3 fatty acids (like oily fish, flaxseed and walnuts), and those containing vitamin D and calcium are also key (think eggs and dairy) for bone strength. Fermented foods are also important for gut health (which supports immunity), and colourful fruits and veg for their antioxidant content, which all contribute to preventing frailty.' Are there downsides to drinking four plus cups of coffee daily? Not everyone's tolerance to coffee is the same, but, generally, an overload of caffeine can have health repercussions. 'Caffeine can interfere with calcium absorption – so older adults should balance intake with good sources of calcium and vitamin D elsewhere in their daily diet,' says Ludlam-Raine. 'There could be potential issues, including disturbed sleep, especially if consumed after midday (caffeine blocks adenosine, the chemical that promotes sleepiness). You could also experience increased heart rate, anxiety and raised blood pressure. Anyone who struggles with acid reflux or IBS might find too much coffee causes digestive problems.' What type of coffee is best? In the UK, around 95 million cups of coffee are consumed per day. And although they come in a smorgasbord of flavours, add-ons and sizes, the general thinking is that a straight, black, filtered coffee (ones that have been through a paper or metal filter like a Aeropress or filter coffee machine) is the healthiest. Adding a splash of milk to your brew will provide certain essential vitamins, protein and calcium, but if you get into the cappuccino and latte territory you will also be totting up the calories. Choosing a high-quality bean will mean it's rich in cell-protecting polyphenols, while an organic product won't have been subjected to pesticides and other contaminants. Medium roast coffee provides a balance of antioxidants (dark roast can pose potential acrylamide risk – a chemical which forms when foods are cooked at high temperature and is carcinogenic). And, although processed, decaf coffee isn't necessarily bad – it still contains all the benefits, just perhaps at slightly lower levels. If instant is your go-to, it might be worth swapping one for a 'proper' coffee. 'Instant coffee tends to contain less caffeine, [and is] therefore unlikely to have an impact on bone health,' explains Bini Suresh.
