‘I need our mum's £420k home for my emotional support dogs'
A woman has told her younger sister she can't have her inheritance as she needs their mother's £420,000 house for her and her emotional support dogs.
Agnes Duggan died in August 2018, aged 78, and left her house in Crawley, Sussex, to be split equally between her three daughters, Sharon, Ann and Brenda Duggan.
But now, Sharon Duggan, 49, who moved to the house in 2014 to care for her mum, is suing her sisters on the basis that her medical ailments outweigh the rights of her sisters to get their inheritance.
She claimed she needs to stay in the house for life with her rescue dogs – which she told Central London County Court 'help with her mental and emotional well-being' – as she is too 'noise sensitive' to live in a flat.
She added that her sisters, Brenda Duggan, 55, and Ann Duggan, 60 should get a 'small lump sum each', which she could raise with a mortgage.
Brenda, an alternative therapist, insisted her sister and her pets will be fine in a one-bed flat.
Representing herself in court, Sharon, a former NHS medical secretary, told Judge Alan Johns KC that she should have the right to stay put in the family home in Lyndhurst Close, Southgate, Crawley.
She told the court she is 'dyslexic and suffers from a variety of health issues, including chronic fatigue syndrome, migraine, fibromyalgia, depression, anxiety, insomnia, PTSD, and adjustment disorder (and) also has long Covid.'
Brenda suggested she could relocate to a flat using her inheritance. But Sharon rejected this due to intrusive noise, her history of fragile mental health and the effect on her two dogs.
Alex Findley, barrister for Brenda, challenged this claim as he said there is no medical evidence to show she cannot live in a flat.
Sharon replied: 'I have two dogs to consider and I am hyper-vigilant and sound sensitive. A flat would not be suitable due to the noise levels.
'I would be better off living in a car. I couldn't cope with it.'
Mr Findlay insisted that Agnes had always been clear that her estate should be equally split and said Sharon's case that she is unfit for future work is 'an extremely pessimistic claim which is not adequately supported by medical evidence'.
He added: 'Likewise, there is no evidence from a suitably qualified expert in mental health to support her assertion that her cognitive and mental difficulties are such that she cannot work.'
'Significant' credit card spending
The barrister said there was evidence that Sharon, who lives on benefits, had received nearly £160,000 from various sources over the past ten years, although she now claims to be penniless, despite living rent-free.
He said: 'Sharon claims to have an income of £1559.44 per month, no other savings or assets, and outgoings of around £1,500 per month.
'Evidence of credit card spending does not support Sharon's case to be in deep financial need. She has regular expenditure on going out to restaurants and cafes, online shopping, through Paypal and Amazon Marketplace, dog grooming, and there is significant monthly expenditure on online courses relating to spiritualism and alternative medicine over the last few years.'
He highlighted that Brenda has multiple sclerosis, and is currently unemployed, and said: 'The claimant appears to believe that Brenda is hiding significant wealth and makes a number of other allegations, but there is no evidence to support the claims Sharon makes about Brenda.
'While she does own her own home, it is not valuable, and she is not wealthy.'
'Ann is also near retirement age and has dependent children. While her financial disclosure has been limited, there is no reason to believe she is sufficiently wealthy that she can forego her inheritance from her mother without some hardship.'
Brenda, who is an executor and beneficiary under Agnes' will, is opposing her sister's legal claim, while her fellow executor and beneficiary, Ann, has adopted a 'neutral position' in the case.
Judge Alan Johns KC is expected to reserve his ruling in the case.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
37 minutes ago
- The Independent
Awkward moment new Reform UK chair David Bull is shown his tweet calling Nigel Farage an idiot
New Reform UK chairman David Bull was shown a previous tweet he posted calling Nigel Farage an 'idiot' during a live breakfast TV interview. Dr Bull appeared on Good Morning Britain on Wednesday morning (11 June), where host Susanna Reid showed him a tweet he made from 2014, calling Mr Farage an 'idiot', stating comments made by him were 'dangerous'. The tweet was over comments Mr Farage made about migrants with HIV. Dr Bull replaces Zia Yusuf, who resigned as Reform's chairman last week.
Telegraph
38 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Britain's vital green spaces are in grave danger unless we act now
This week, as the Chancellor announces the Government's latest spending review, we are bracing for cuts across the board. In tough times, difficult choices must be made. At such a moment it is important to remember that the numbers in the spreadsheets are not simply economic abstractions, and that some cuts can cost more than they save. World Environment Day is an excellent moment to remember that green spaces are a case in point. They are one of the most powerful and under-appreciated tools for improving public health and fostering social cohesion while sustaining wildlife. The truth is that local parks are delivering huge value and can contribute so much more. Green spaces, parks and playing fields are frontline services for the wellbeing of our communities. They are where we exercise, connect with others, improve our mental health and, crucially, where connect with Nature. At a time of rising isolation and disconnection with the natural world, these places matter more than ever. But they are vanishing. In the last ten years, more than 800 parks and playgrounds have closed across the UK. In many communities, especially those already suffering the effects of inequality, access to safe, high-quality outdoor spaces has become a postcode lottery. Seventy per cent of children in low-income areas don't meet the recommended daily exercise levels. One in five young people now face an actual or probable mental health disorder. We're seeing the consequences in our health service. Lack of physical activity and limited access to nature are directly linked to long-term conditions, ranging from obesity and Type 2 diabetes to anxiety and depression. We are spending a fortune in fixing problems which could in part be prevented at much lower cost. Regular use of parks and green spaces generates over £34 billion in health and wellbeing benefits each year. At a time when the Health Service is under extraordinary pressure, investing in green spaces is not a 'nice to have.' It is a preventive public health policy. But the benefits of green space are not just physical or economic; they are emotional and deeply formative. As someone who has spent my life seeking ways to sustain Nature, I know how critical early experiences are in shaping our relationship with the natural world. My own love of Nature wasn't sparked in some distant wilderness, but in the green areas close to home: wonderful patches of wild 'brownfield' scrub, local fields, and neighbourhood parks. These everyday encounters with Nature weren't spectacular, but they were profound. You can't foster a love of the natural world through screens or textbooks alone. It must be felt, seen, heard. That spark happens outdoors. Every child deserves that spark. Yet today, far too many children grow up without ever hearing birdsong or walking beneath a canopy of trees. Girls, ethnic minorities, and families in deprived communities face the greatest barriers to experiencing the simple, profound benefits of nature. That is not just a social failing. It is a moral one. Green spaces are where future conservationists are born. When children climb trees, build dens, or simply lie on the grass and look up at the sky, they're doing more than playing. They're forming bonds with Nature that can last a lifetime. That sense of care and wonder is what leads people to protect and preserve the wild as they grow up. Our future depends on it. This year marks the centenary of Fields in Trust, a charity that has spent 100 years quietly protecting more than 3,000 green spaces across the UK. It is a remarkable achievement, but there is still so much more to do. Fields in Trust believes that everyone should live close to a protected park. As we face the overlapping challenges of poor public health, rapid urbanisation, and the climate and Nature emergencies, that vision has never been more important. Yet green spaces continue to be at risk, and once lost they are rarely replaced. Parks are places of healing. Places where children run, families connect, and communities thrive. They are one of the few remaining spaces where people of all ages and backgrounds naturally mix. We must reframe access to quality green spaces, including wilder ones, as a right, not a privilege. We stand at a crossroads. If we want to create a future where our world's living systems are restored and thriving, we must begin by protecting Nature on our doorsteps. The next generation of conservationists and environmental stewards won't appear by magic. They will emerge from the children and families who had the chance to explore, love and connect with nature today.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Shoppers say these peroxide-free whitening strips made their teeth up to EIGHT shades whiter in just one week - now 23% off
Looking to brighten your smile for summer? Shoppers are getting teeth up to eight shades whiter in just one week with these peroxide-free whitening strips - and they're now 23 per cent off at Amazon. As little as 30 minutes of wear of the DrDent Premium Teeth Whitening Strips leaves teeth significantly brighter and whiter, helping to remove stains from common teeth-staining activities such as smoking and drinking coffee. They're now back on sale -and with over 10,000 sold in the past month, it's clear people are loving the results. DrDent Premium Teeth Whitening Strips (21 Treatments) Formulated with non-toxic ingredients such as coconut and mint oil, these powerful strips can whiten teeth by as much as one shade in just one week. An affordable alternative to in-salon whitening sessions, the non-slip design makes DIY whitening a breeze, while the formula quickly gets to work to reduce stains left behind from caffeine and smoking. You can save an additional five per cent by applying coupon before heading to checkout. £19.95 (save £6.04) Shop With over 2,500 four and five-star reviews, shoppers have praised the purse-friendly whitening strips as a 'great alternative to in-salon whitening' claiming 'these really do whiten your teeth' - and for a fraction of the cost. Smokers and coffee drinkers have been blown away by the results of the DIY strips, with one customer writing: 'Wow! I am so impressed. I have only used it once but the difference is incredible. I could see the stains coming off as it was on.' Using a unique PAP (phthalimide peroxy caproic acid) formula, the DrDent Premium Teeth Whitening Strips have been specifically formulated to be gentle on teeth, for a pain-free whitening experience every time. Made with natural ingredients and infused with the likes of coconut and mint oil, the peroxide-free strips offer a safer at-home whitening experience compared to others at a similar price point on the market. The non-slip design ensures the whitening strips are easy to use - simply dry teeth, pop the bottom strip on first, followed by the top one, and leave to work their magic for up to 60 minutes. Afterwards, rinse any remaining gel and enjoy your new, brighter smile. Ideal for those who may be trying to achieve their best smile yet in time for summer, DrDent promises a visibly brighter smile in as little as seven days following 30 to 60 minutes of wear per day. Several customers, however, have noticed the benefits with as little as one treatment, with one customer even stating: 'They are super easy to apply, especially with the mouth opening tool, and leave lasting results very quickly. I noticed a difference even after one use!'. The DrDent Professional Teeth Whitening Strips have gained over 9,900 five-star reviews from Amazon shoppers, while customer before and after's speak for themselves. One impressed user raved: 'From the first time I've used it, my teeth were whiter, and more importantly, the strips didn't make my teeth feel sensitive. I've been using them once a week to help keep my teeth whiter as I do drink a lot of coffee - I would definitely recommend them!'. Another agreed, adding: 'My teeth were terribly discoloured after a long stint in hospital, so I thought I would give this a go. I'm so glad I did because they work!! And they work really well. Each kit contains 42 whitening strips per box, as well as a mouth opener, instructions, and a guide to check your whitening progress 'Don't just take my word for it, read the reviews from other people who have used them. It's really easier to use them and if you get stuck there is a few videos. What are you waiting for, go order them.' A third penned: 'OMG, I can't recommend these more. This is my first time using them and they have turned my teeth from yellow to white after one use - will definitely be buying again if needs be. They really have brought back my self confidence!'. Each kit contains 42 whitening strips per box, as well as a mouth opener, instructions, and a guide to check your whitening progress. Plus, if you're not 100 per cent satisfied with the results, you can get a full refund. here - but be quick, as these savings won't be around for long.
