Under Trump, book bans have gone federal. Some readers are fighting back.
Write to us at
. To subscribe,
.
TODAY'S STARTING POINT
An MIT professor's study of lyric poetry in Elizabethan England, a children's book about a freckled 7-year-old girl, and Vice President JD Vance's best-selling memoir about his working-class roots would seem to have little in common. Yet they all appear to have gotten swept up in the Trump administration's efforts to restrict Americans' access to certain books.
Book bans in the US predate the founding of the country. The first known instance was in 1637 in what is now Quincy, Mass. Most efforts to remove books from libraries and school curriculums are usually at the state and local level, hashed out in legislatures, town council meetings, and school board elections.
But the Trump administration's various efforts to make them a priority of the federal government is novel.
Advertisement
'It's a definite escalation,' Sabrina Baêta, who researches book bans and censorship at PEN America, a free-expression nonprofit. Today's newsletter explains the administration's efforts and how some are resisting them.
Flying off the shelves
Most directly, the Trump administration
The administration says the culling reflects
Advertisement
The Defense Department has also allegedly removed or placed under review hundreds of books from the PreK-12 schools it runs for the children of service members in the US and abroad. According to
'1984,' George Orwell's classic about a government that censors information and polices language.
Why officials would have pulled some of those books for review, including Vance's, isn't clear. A spokeswoman for the Department of Defense Education Activity, which oversees Pentagon-run schools, said she couldn't comment 'as this matter is currently the subject of active litigation.'
But for Baêta, of PEN America, the notion that a Trump order could end up removing a book by his own vice president 'speaks to the pernicious nature of censorship.' Trying to stifle certain topics, she said, inevitably sucks in ideas that even proponents might not find objectionable. Arguments in the ACLU's case are scheduled for early next month.
The administration's actions could also make it harder for other Americans to access books.
In March, President Trump signed an executive order that aimed to gut the Institute of Museum and Library Services, which provides federal grants to libraries around the country. A judge has
Advertisement
Trump
The next chapter
But the administration's efforts, and ongoing attempts in many states and localities to limit access to certain books, have triggered a response from free-speech advocates.
Most Americans
Advertisement
Book bans can also turn reading itself into an act of resistance. Last fall, the ACLU's Massachusetts branch started
Of course, some books do contain information that every kid may not be ready to read. 'The Kite Runner' depicts horrible violence and child abuse and those under 18 needed a parent's permission join the ACLU of Massachusetts' book club to read it. But Baêta argues that engaging with challenging subjects in a classroom, in a book club, or with a parent is better than encountering them for the first time in the real world.
'We don't want students to be coming across uncomfortable topics in their lives for the first time in real life,' she said. 'We want that to be in a book. What softer introduction is there?'
🧩 4 Down:
POINTS OF INTEREST
The MBTA has said it needs at least $25 billion for repairs, far more than it's budgeting.
Lane Turner/Globe Staff
Boston and Massachusetts
Harvard connection:
House Republicans accused the university of having 'hosted and trained' members of a Chinese paramilitary organization and demanded the school turn over information
Scathing:
The state auditor accused Governor Maura Healey's administration
Nuts and bolts:
The MBTA's board of directors approved a $9.8 billion budget for construction projects that
Karen Read:
Her defense attorney continued to cross-examine a digital forensics analyst over his credentials and
School's in:
The state education board voted to require trade schools to
Trump administration
Deportations:
The administration appears to have begun deporting migrants to South Sudan, a war-torn African country, despite a court order. (
Another one?
Shortly after ending a probe into New York City Mayor Eric Adams, the administration is investigating former NY governor Andrew Cuomo, the front-runner to replace Adams, over testimony Cuomo gave to Congress. (
Local resistance:
Massachusetts residents
RFK Jr.:
Trump's health secretary
Not quite:
A Democratic senator asked Kristi Noem, Trump's homeland security secretary, to define habeas corpus, which protects against wrongful detention. Noem said it lets the president remove people from the US. (
No tax on tips:
The Senate unexpectedly passed a bill that would create a tax deduction for workers who earn tips, a Trump campaign promise. It now goes to the House. (
The Nation and the World
SCOTUS vs. Maine:
The US Supreme Court ordered the Maine House to restore a conservative lawmaker's right to speak and vote on the floor. The House had censured her for posting a transgender minor's name and photo online. (
George Wendt:
The actor who earned six consecutive Emmy nominations for his performance as Norm Peterson on the NBC comedy 'Cheers' died at age 76. (
Diddy trial:
The mother of Cassie Ventura, Sean Combs's former girlfriend, testified that she photographed bruises Combs allegedly left on her daughter. (
BESIDE THE POINT
🎓
Valedictory:
Across New England, graduating high school athletes
💬
Talker:
Nobody's spoken the Proto-Indo-European language in 4,000 years, but billions speak one descended from it. A new book explains how it spread around the world. (
Advertisement
☀️
Fun in the sun:
From parades to the ice cream trail, consider these nine
ways to
📱
Hear that?
If Siri eavesdropped on you sometime over the last decade, Apple might owe you money. (
⛳
Second wind:
Burnt out, he decided to play every golf course in Massachusetts.
📸 Authorial dispute:
Who really took the famous 'napalm girl' photograph during the Vietnam War? A new documentary upends the official story. (
🎵
Fan guide:
Here's what's new at this year's
Thanks for reading Starting Point.
This newsletter was edited by
❓ Have a question for the team? Email us at
✍🏼 If someone sent you this newsletter, you can
📬 Delivered Monday through Friday.
Ian Prasad Philbrick can be reached at
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Fox News
8 minutes ago
- Fox News
Patel's immigration push at FBI yields 10,000 arrests since January
EXCLUSIVE: FBI Director Kash Patel's efforts to help carry out the Trump administration's immigration agenda have led to the bureau making 10,553 arrests since January. That figure, included in FBI data reviewed exclusively by Fox News Digital, reflects the total number of immigration-related arrests the bureau has assisted the Department of Homeland Security with making since Jan. 20, 2025. Recent arrests involving the FBI have included, for instance, an operation at the end of May on Nantucket and Martha's Vineyard. The FBI aided ICE in arresting about 32 people on the two islands, including an alleged member of the MS-13 gang and a man named Luciano Pereira Deoliveira, who had pending child rape and pornography charges, according to the data. Patel has also periodically highlighted these arrests on social media, including the FBI's capture of Harpreet Singh in April. The FBI's Sacramento field office investigated Singh, who was wanted in India for alleged ties to terrorism and whom authorities say entered the U.S. illegally in 2022. The data comes as Patel has faced media scrutiny for the dramatic shakeup at the bureau during the past four months, which has involved ousting senior officials and other employees or attempting to relocate them to new field offices. Some reports say many agents and employees have been reassigned at times to help the DHS with immigration enforcement. Patel adviser Erica Knight said the bureau's priorities have changed to arresting allegedly criminal immigrants in part because of the surge in illegal migration during the Biden administration. "With over 10,000 immigration-related arrests, the Bureau under the direction of Director Patel is making it clear, it's not turning a blind eye to the border crisis, it's targeting the violent cartels and criminal networks that are exploiting it," Knight said. "This is the direction Americans have been demanding, and the Bureau is delivering on the promise to put safety and sovereignty first." Of the roughly 38,000 employees at the FBI, 13,192 have been tasked at some point since January with working on immigration enforcement, according to the data. Employees include both agents and support staff. The most recent week of data showed the highest number of employees working on immigration tasks were concentrated in the Los Angeles field office, followed by the Philadelphia, Houston, and San Antonio field offices. Although a statistic-rich agency, the FBI has no prior recent data of agents and employees aiding DHS with arrests through any formal effort. Under Patel, the FBI has launched interagency operations, such as one he and Attorney General Pam Bondi showcased in Virginia in March when announcing the arrest of an alleged top member of MS-13 in the state. The Virginia Homeland Security Task Force brought together state and federal law enforcement agencies to address transnational organized crime and immigration enforcement. U.S. Attorney Erik Siebert of Virginia said during a press conference at the time of the arrest that the task force had made 342 arrests, "many of them with illegal status" and 81 with "gang or transnational crime affiliation." The DOJ charged the MS-13 leader with a gun charge but later moved to dismiss the charge and instead deport him. A retired FBI agent who worked in the bureau for two decades told Fox News Digital that his understanding from interacting with a handful of agents is that some are likely to "grumble about" the new immigration enforcement work, while others view it as necessary to address the recent years' influx of migrants into the country. "The fact that the bureau is helping out on this stuff now is just because it's unusual times," the retired agent said. "We've never had a presidential administration … import 9 million potential threats into its country, or whatever that number is, so the FBI having to get involved in this stuff is unusual, but it's also necessary." "I think it was inevitable the FBI does get involved, but the trick is they've got to juggle helping out DHS and also tending the farm," he said. The retired agent also said the bureau "brings a lot to the table that these other agencies just don't have," such as new sources, databases, and skill sets. He also said the work can be beneficial for the FBI because of the intelligence-gathering opportunity it presents. "I would hope they're exploiting every single one of these guys, clearly debriefing them and finding out what they know and who they know," he said.
CBS News
8 minutes ago
- CBS News
Trump administration pauses garnishment of Social Security checks for defaulted student loans
Student loan borrower shares her story as collections resume for those in default The Trump administration says it's pausing the garnishment of Social Security benefits for student loan borrowers who have defaulted. That means a temporary pause on a decision announced in April to restart collections on student loans in default. On May 5, the restart policy was put into action when the Education Department began involuntary collections through the Treasury Department's offset program, which claws back overdue debts by garnishing federal payments such as tax refunds and Social Security checks. The halt comes after the Trump administration last month retreated from another type of Social Security benefit clawback, when it announced it would only take 50% of a person's monthly check to recover overpayments, down from a previously announced 100%. In that case, advocates for senior citizens had expressed concern that the policy would lead to hardship, given that one-third of Social Security recipients rely on their monthly benefit check for at least 75% of their income. In a statement emailed to CBS MoneyWatch, the Education Department said it hasn't offset any Social Security payments because of student debt since it resumed collections on May 5. The department "has put a pause on any future Social Security offsets," spokeswoman Ellen Keast said in the email. She added, "The Trump Administration is committed to protecting Social Security recipients who oftentimes rely on a fixed income. In the coming weeks, the Department will begin proactive outreach to recipients about affordable loan repayment options and help them back into good standing." While most people may think of student borrowers as recent grads who are juggling loan repayments with other living expenses, there are about 3.6 million people over 60 who carry student loan debt, according to Bankrate. About 452,000 people over 62 — the earliest age when one can collect Social Security benefits — have defaulted on their student loans, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau said earlier this year.
Fox News
9 minutes ago
- Fox News
Bryson DeChambeau hits golf balls on White House South Lawn during visit with Trump
As a two-time U.S. Open champion who has earned north of $80 million on the golf course alone, Bryson DeChambeau has seen and done some pretty cool things. His recent trip to the White House to visit President Donald Trump was about as unique it gets. As the undisputed golf content king these days, DeChambeau managed to do something not many people throughout history have done: He hit golf balls off the South Lawn at the White House. White House Special Assistant Margo Martin shared a video of DeChambeau hitting a wedge onto the green of the South Lawn practice green, and he wasn't hitting short chip shots, he turned the property into a makeshift Par 3 course. DeChambeau, who has finished T-6 or better in five of the last six major championships, didn't only hit golf balls on the South Lawn during his stop in Washington D.C. He and President Trump made a stop at Trump National in Lowes Island, Virginia to hit some shots together as well, which is where Trump shared a quick joke about how long of a hitter he is. "We play golf a lot together, it's not a very pleasant experience for me because I always consider myself a reasonably long hitter," President Trump said. "My wife says, 'Are you as long as Bryson?' I say, 'Yeah sorta, pretty close - it's not close.'" DeChambeau is a long-time supporter of Trump, and he was even called on stage by the President during his victory speech back in November after he ran away with the presidential election. As the President noted, he and DeChambeau have played many rounds of golf together over the years. The President made an appearance on the LIV golfer's YouTube channel, where the duo teamed up to shoot 50. Following his U.S. Open win at Pinehurst in 2024, DeChambeau paid a visit to Trump National Golf Club in New York, hit some long drives, and drank some red wine
