Makgoba community pleads for help from G20 countries
At the centre of the dispute are allegations that fruit is exported while communities who own the land, live from hand to mouth.
Farm workers in Tzaneen, Limpopo, package fresh avocados to be exported to Europe and Asia. Picture: Supplied.
A war of words is brewing between the Westfalia Fruit Company and residents of Makgoba, who own a series of agricultural plantations in Limpopo.
The fallout could affect the export of important citrus fruits to countries attending the G20 Presidency Summit in SA later this year.
At the centre of the dispute are allegations that Westfalia is exporting fresh avocados while communities, who own the land, live from hand to mouth.
The company exports avocados to international countries, including the UK, Netherlands, France, Spain, Germany, Canada, Costa Rica, Argentina, Japan, UAE, Saudi Arabia and South Korea.
Now, the Makgoba community, which won back the land from the Limpopo Land Claims Commission in 2009, is pleading with G20 countries to help them.
'About 90% of our community remains unemployed while the company is making so much profit from our fertile land,' said Frans Kubjana, spokesperson for Makgoba Concerned Group on Friday.
Kubjana said jobs in the company were given to foreigners, allegedly some undocumented.
'This is because Westfalia prefers cheap labour over South Africans.
'Despite having a mutual understanding to train our children, school them and develop our communities, Westfalia continues to snub us and collect good profits in an endeavour to line their pockets. Unfortunately, they do this at the expense of our fertile ancestral land.
'We want presidents of countries doing business with Westfalia in the G20 to intervene. If not, we will close the business and show them the door.'
Westfalia Fruit denies the claims
Westfalia Fruit called the allegations baseless and devoid of truth.
'Makgoba Community members are making unfounded allegations against Westfalia Fruit,' said Bomikazi Molapo, head of communications at Westfalia Fruit Africa.
Molapo said Westfalia has a zero-tolerance policy towards abusive or disruptive behaviour and takes the well-being of all its staff and stakeholders seriously.
'Westfalia has always been committed to supporting the local communities, amongst them, the Makgoba community. We are proud to provide resources, training and reliable market access to all eligible smallholder farmers and community traders.
'While our community supply programme continues as normal, it is important to clarify that we recently notified a fruit trader that their access to Westfalia Fruit's operations and facilities has been revoked.
'This is the result of a sustained pattern of disruptive and aggressive conduct towards staff and community members, including persistent disregard for agreed codes of conduct, which has been repeatedly addressed with the individual both in person and in writing.
'We remain open to constructive dialogue through appropriate channels and we are committed to transparency and positive development in all our operations,' she said.
ALSO READ: Steel producers slam ArcelorMittal's call to end scrap export tax
Land claims
The Limpopo Regional Land Claims Commission has successfully settled and finalised a significant number of land claims in the province.
The commission has 5 916 settled land claims, with 1 305 outstanding.
Additionally, the Commission on Restitution of Land Rights (CRLR) has finalised 641 claims and settled 362 claims against its targets to date.
NOW READ: Fat cats criticised as Limpopo government agency tries to cut 100 jobs
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
4 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
The Finance Ghost: The retail lowdown on Lewis, Spar, Pick n Pay and Dis-Chem
There was a flurry of corporate activity in the past week as companies with February and March year-ends looked to get results out before the end of the month. Many companies manage to get results out within two months of the end of the reporting period, with others using the full three months that they are allowed by the JSE. Amongst all the noise, there were several retailers that released important results. As a major source of employment in South Africa and with businesses that everyone can relate to as you can easily visit the stores yourself, this sector is always deserving of attention. Lewis: the pick of the litter The narrative around furniture group Lewis is nothing like it used to be. For years, this was a story of tepid growth and a focus on cost control, with a capital allocation strategy that took full advantage of the benefits of share buybacks. Now, Lewis is behaving like a growth stock with double-digit revenue growth and a colossal jump in Heps of 60.3% for the year ended March 2025. Such has been the extent of share price growth that they didn't do any share buybacks at all in the second half of the financial year! advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads Can they keep it up? This is the question on everyone's lips. Somehow, they've managed to boost credit sales (up 12.1% versus cash sales up 3.4%) without sacrificing the quality of the debtors' book. This is a holy grail outcome, as retailers that sell on credit must always consider the benefit of additional sales against the risk of credit losses. So far, so good at Lewis. The market is still wary of how sustainable this growth path is, so investors will be paying a great deal of focus to the next interim period. Spar retreats from Europe – well, mostly With Spar having been through such a terrible time in recent years, it was always unlikely that the pain would end with the disposal of the business in Poland. Things got so bad there that Spar essentially paid someone to take that asset away, with the group incurring debt to recapitalise the business in Poland before selling it for next to nothing. It's the equivalent of begging someone to arrive with a trailer to drag your broken old car off your lawn. advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads To add to the headaches, the business in Switzerland had been showing some worrying signs for a while, as food is so expensive in that country that Swiss residents literally cross the border to buy their groceries instead of going to their local retailers like Spar. Risks like these are extremely hard for South Africans to foresee, which is why it's advisable to stick to familiar markets rather than doing business somewhere completely different. Unlike in the case of Poland where they waited until the very end to remove that tumour from the group, Spar has decided to sell the Swiss business. They are also letting go of AWG in southwest England, which came as a surprise as there weren't any obvious concerns around that business. This leaves them with only the businesses in Southern Africa and Ireland going forwards. Of course, there's a difference between simply deciding to sell something and actually getting it sold, so it will be a while until the group is so clean and simple. In the meantime, investors have to suffer through diluted Heps from total operations dropping by between -24% and -34% for the 26 weeks to 28 March 2025. If you look at only the continuing operations, it should be between 0% and -15% lower for the period – still a poor outcome. They have a lot of fixing to do at Spar. Pick n Pay is a reminder that turnarounds are hard Speaking of fixing, there's still a long way to go at Pick n Pay. In fact, with the results for the 53 weeks to 2 March 2025 now out in the wild, the group has noted that they only expect their core Pick n Pay segment to break even by 2028. CEO Sean Summers has agreed to extend his contract until then to help drive that outcome. advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads This leaves the group in a situation where the controlling stake in Boxer is doing the heavy lifting, with the plan being to stem the bleeding in Pick n Pay as quickly as they can. There are at last some encouraging signs, like an uptick in like-for-like sales, but Pick n Pay will have to fight every step of the way in a market that is a bloodbath of competition. advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads If you dig into the underlying earnings or read the company announcements, just be cautious of getting excited about the trading profit line. Due to silly accounting rules, lease costs (which are obviously substantial for retailers) are actually recognised in net finance costs, which come in below trading profit. In other words, trading profit ignores lease costs, so it's a very flattering view of profitability. This is why Pick n Pay clarifies that their breakeven goal for 2028 is based on trading profit net of lease costs, which is the correct way to look at things. Dis-Chem keeps delivering – but did the market want more? With Dis-Chem's share price closing 6.3% lower on Friday after the release of results for the year ended 28 February 2025, you would be forgiven for thinking that the numbers were weak. Instead, we find Heps growth of 20% and a similar increase in the total dividend for the year. Sure, Dis-Chem is now on a demanding Price:Earnings (P:E) ratio of 24.4x based on latest numbers, but could the market really have been expecting so much more than 20% growth in earnings? In such a case where the share price move isn't easily explained by the earnings, it's best to skip to the outlook section of the announcement to see if there are any clues there. Dis-Chem notes a constrained consumer environment, but we are hearing that story everywhere and it's not exactly anything new. Helpfully, they've also given a sales update for 1 March to 27 May (i.e. about the first quarter of the new financial year) that reflects 8.6% growth in group revenue. This is even better than the 8% full-year growth that they just reported! Comparable pharmacy store revenue has accelerated from 4.1% for FY25 to 4.6% for these past few months. Perhaps the worry was around growth in wholesale revenue to external customers, which slowed down significantly from 22.1% to 13.6%. Still, that really shouldn't be enough to drive a 6.3% drop in the share price. advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads advertisement Don't want to see this? Remove ads This share price dip comes after a strong 30-day performance in the market, so it may be due to profit-taking by punters in response to earnings. Regardless, the underlying business is strong and Dis-Chem has continued to deliver for investors despite the pressure on consumer spending. As local retail businesses go, this is one of the best. DM
eNCA
5 hours ago
- eNCA
Service providers urged to follow proper channels
JOHANNESBURG - ICASA chairperson, Mothibi Ramusi, has urged telecommunication service providers to use the correct channels when applying for certification. This comes on the back of reports that some South Africans are illegally using Starlink services. The authority has also sent out its teams to conduct physical verifications in the affected areas. Starlink, an American service provider is not authorised or licensed to operate in the country. The satellite internet provider is owned by South African born billionaire, Elon Musk. The tech mogul wants to bring Starlink to SA but faces a major hurdle because of ownership. By law, every national network infrastructure and communications service provider must be 30% owned by historically disadvantaged groups.
IOL News
9 hours ago
- IOL News
Reserve Bank's interest rate cut: response to low inflation and economic challenges
The South African Reserve Bank has lowered interest rates in response to a low inflation rate, but experts warn that rising taxes could still burden households. This article explores the implications of the rate cut and the ongoing economic challenges facing South Africa." Image: File The low inflation rate was the driver behind the South African Reserve Bank (Sarb) Governor Lesetja Kganyago lowering interest rates this past week. Kganyago announced that the central bank's Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) voted to decrease the repo rate from 7.50% to 7.25%. This means that the prime lending rate in South Africa has been lowered from 11% to 10.75%. Frank Blackmore, Lead Economist at KPMG told Business Report that the reason for this was the low inflation rate. Blackmore said, "The Reserve Bank remains data dependent in that respect, as well as the easing of some of the risks such as the exchange rate. Appreciation from the highs over R19, back down to around R18 to the dollar level and as well as the oil prices, which have remained low at this point. They have also taken into consideration that the Value Added Tax (VAT) hike will not take place, also eases future inflation in that respect." "An interesting analysis was also done by the MPC regarding an upside risk scenario if things worked in the other direction and South Africa would face a kind of stagflation scenario including weak economic growth and tight monetary policy reacting to higher levels of inflation, all caused by perhaps, the trade wars that are currently ongoing globally. Probably more interestingly another scenario where they're reducing the target rate from a current 4 1/2% objective, so the midpoint of the three to 6% range to the 3% objective so the bottom of their three to 6% range. This puts us closer in line with many of our trade partners as well as being closer to the median emerging market rate of around 3%," the economist said. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad Loading "In this situation, the benefits would also fall to all South Africans meaning that lower inflation would preserve the value of the earnings and wealth in future periods. Given the low inflation that we are currently experiencing this would be the right time to institute such a change," Blackmore further added. Neil Roets, CEO of Debt Rescue, told Business Report that the announcement of a BPS cut to the repo rate may be good news for economists, but will not shield South Africans from the burden of the fuel and sin tax levies that have been introduced by Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana within his Budget 3.0 projection. Roets warned that increased taxing of the workforce is not the answer, referring to the fuel-tax levy and raising sin taxes even higher, and will put further financial strain on households, driving them to new depths of despair. "This, at a time when they are buckling under the weight of multiple unsustainable inflation-related living costs. The reality is that the Finance minister's decision to impose new tax measures will hurt lower-income families most, as they will bear a proportionally higher burden, thus forcing them to make impossible lifestyle choices with the little disposable income they have left,' Roets said. Roets said that Kganyago is a longstanding advocate of shifting to a lower inflation target, arguing this would make the nation better placed to compete with its trading partners. 'A single-point target of 3% would be in line with South Africa's peers and lead to lower interest rates in the long term,' he has previously said. "His critics worry that reaching a lower inflation target would require tighter monetary policy however, that would cost growth and employment in a country with one of the highest jobless and poverty rates on earth. The Governor reiterated his view saying that the MPC is of the view that the 3% scenario is more attractive than the 4.5% baseline, and they would like to see inflation expectations move lower, towards the bottom end of their target range. He also said the MPC will consider scenarios with a 3% objective at future meetings," Roets said. A lower inflation target risks scuppering further interest rate cuts this year too, Investec Chief Economist, Annabel Bishop warned Bishop said, 'With a change to the inflation target reportedly occurring soon this year, the Sarb has chosen to cut interest rates this month to avoid the limitation of doing so in the future, but then could easily be at risk of needing to reverse the cut.' 'The reality is that the slow pace of the country's repo rate reductions is perpetuating the debt trap that millions of ordinary South Africans find themselves in, leaving millions with no option but to survive on credit,' Roets further said.
