logo
Why is No 10 tight-lipped about welcoming reparation campaigner?

Why is No 10 tight-lipped about welcoming reparation campaigner?

Yahoo16-04-2025

It was back in February when the Telegraph, citing Caribbean sources, reported that the Foreign Office was to open talks on slavery reparations with Caribbean officials, who were demanding trillions of pounds from the UK in compensation for its role in the slave trade.
In his piece, my colleague Craig Simpson reported that members of the Reparations Commission of the Caribbean Community (Caricom), a political grouping of 15 states who have led on calls for compensation from former colonial powers, were planning a visit to London in April with a specific aim to restate demands for payments.
We were even told that the 'trip has been overseen by Mia Mottley, Barbados's prime minister,' who famously pushed for reparations to be on the agenda at the Commonwealth Heads of Government summit in Samoa last year.
To say the demands are ambitious would be an understatement. In no conceivable way could the nation's taxpayers and its finances afford the bill.
'Ms Mottley has stated that Britain owes her country £3.9 trillion,' this paper had reported, 'while a 2023 report put the figure owed to former Caribbean colonies overall at £18 trillion.'
A Foreign Office spokesman at that time had denied that there were any plans for a ministerial meeting, claiming no date had been set for a UK-Caricom meeting.
Imagine my surprise then to come across a press release on 4th April - issued not by the Foreign Office but by No 10 - that Sir Keir had welcomed Prime Minister Mia Mottley of Barbados to Downing Street that morning.
When was this meeting scheduled, I asked the Downing Street Press Office. Were any payments to Barbados discussed at the meeting? My questions were refused, with the spokesman instead directing me back to the rather bare-boned press release, which would only provide the following information:'The leaders reflected on the strength of the relationship between the UK and Barbados, and the shared challenges faced by the two countries, including growth, climate change and global instability.'The Prime Minister also thanked Prime Minister Mottley for the action taken by Barbados against the Russian shadow fleet.'A standard news agency report on the meeting offered some interesting details.'We've known each other many, many years as good colleagues and now as leaders who work together, think alike', Sir Keir said of his guest, a fellow King's Counsel who was educated at the London School of Economics.In her response, Ms Mottley said, '[w]e've had the opportunity to meet a number of times since you've assumed office.' We know that at least one of those times - at the Commonwealth Head of Governments summit - the matter of reparations has certainly been discussed. How many other discussions have there been on the subject, given Ms Mottley's focused, high profile and long-running campaign for compensation?
There are other reasons to be wary of a ruinous bill being presented to Parliament as a fait accompli, much in the same way as the Mauritius payment, not the least because it is the same international judge from Jamaica who ruled against the UK on the Chagos Islands who has called for Britain to pay more than £18 trillion in reparations for slavery, declaring even that amount to be an 'underestimation' of the damage caused.
While calls for reparations are longstanding, in recent years they have been reportedly gaining momentum worldwide, 'particularly among Caricom [of which Ms Mottley is the current Chair] and the African Union', whose joint theme for 2025 is 'Justice for Africans and the People of African Descent through reparations.'
These organisations enjoy the support of both the European Union and the United Nations leadership - indeed, Ms Mottley is widely viewed as a potential candidate to succeed Antonio Guterres as the next UN secretary-general - who appear to be increasingly willing to entertain compensation claims.
Speakers at a session of the United Nations Permanent Forum on African Descent in New York declared only yesterday that 'the calls for reparatory justice can no longer be ignored'. These calls at the Forum are being led by Ms Mottley's Caricom colleague, Dr Hilary Brown.
International campaigners are also encouraged by what they view as a British government sympathetic to their cause after 14 years of Conservative-led refusal to discuss compensation claims. Foreign Secretary David Lammy and Attorney General Lord Hermer have both previously voiced their support for reparations, hitherto a political position only championed by edgier backbenchers such as Bell Ribeiro-Addy and Dawn Butler.
While the Government has steadfastly refused to allow the word reparations to enter its formal communiqué, it has been more comfortable using expressions such as addressing 'wrongs of the past' when discussing payments to former colonies, as we've seen in the case of the Mauritius deal.
In the case of Barbados and other Caribbean nations, if Ms Mottley is successful in her campaign, the bill presented to the taxpayer would likely be framed as payments towards the climate crisis, rather than reparations.
But of course, reparation by any other name is still reparation. As, of course, is bankruptcy.
Please share share examples of public spending in your personal and professional lives which you consider to be a waste of taxpayers' money. You can email us your stories – either in writing or as voice notes – at wastewatch@telegraph.co.uk
Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Russia launches ‘largest ever' drone strike against Ukraine
Russia launches ‘largest ever' drone strike against Ukraine

Washington Post

time26 minutes ago

  • Washington Post

Russia launches ‘largest ever' drone strike against Ukraine

KYIV — Russia unleashed its largest overnight drone attack in the war on Monday, launching cruise and ballistic missiles as well in a barrage that lasted through the night and struck locations across Ukraine, even as Kyiv and Moscow began a days-long prisoner exchange involving hundreds of soldiers. Russian forces launched 479 self-detonating drones, of which 460 were shot down or deflected through electronic interference, Ukraine's air force said in a statement on social media. Ukraine's western Rivne region went through 'a very difficult night' and 'suffered a powerful enemy airstrike,' Oleksandr Koval, head of the regional military administration, wrote on Telegram. One person was injured, he said. He did not provide further details. Monday's attack appeared to have caused less damage than one on Friday, which Kremlin officials said was in response to an audacious Ukrainian assault on air bases inside Russia earlier in the week. In Friday's bombardment, Russian drones and missiles hammered Kyiv and cities in western Ukraine, causing extensive damage and injuring dozens. Monday's strike took place as Moscow's forces claimed to be advancing toward Ukraine's southeastern Dnipropetrovsk region — an area of the country that has been heavily bombarded but so far has avoided ground fighting. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said the offensive was in part an attempt to create a 'buffer zone.' However, Andriy Kovalenko, head of the Ukrainian military's Center for Countering Disinformation, posted on Telegram that 'all information from the Russians, including Peskov's statements, about their offensive on the Dnipropetrovsk region is NOT true.' The Russian advance could represent a further intensification of Moscow's military pressure across the front line, which has now spread to Ukraine's northeastern Sumy region. In his regular evening address, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky said Sunday that in 'some areas' along the front line, 'the situation is very difficult.' Fighting is underway in the Donetsk, Sumy and Kharkiv regions, he added. On Monday, Zelensky announced on Telegram the beginning of a prisoner exchange that would 'continue in several stages in the coming days.' Zelensky said he could not divulge all details but that the first group included those who were seriously wounded and under the age of 25. 'The process is quite complicated, there are many sensitive details, negotiations continue virtually every day,' Zelensky wrote.

Musk's father says Trump dispute triggered by intense stress, has to end
Musk's father says Trump dispute triggered by intense stress, has to end

Yahoo

time42 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Musk's father says Trump dispute triggered by intense stress, has to end

By Guy Faulconbridge MOSCOW (Reuters) -The dispute between Donald Trump and Elon Musk was triggered by months of intense stress on both sides, and the public battle between the U.S. president and the billionaire donor needs to stop, Musk's father told Reuters on Monday. Trump and Musk began exchanging insults last week on social media, with the Tesla and SpaceX CEO describing the president's sweeping tax and spending bill as a "disgusting abomination". Asked whether he thought his son had made a mistake by engaging in a public clash with the president, Errol Musk said people were sometimes unable to think as clearly as they should "in the heat of the moment." "They've had five months of intense stress," Musk told Reuters at a conference in Moscow organised by conservative Russian tycoons. "With all the opposition cleared and two people left in the arena, all they have ever done is get rid of everything and now they are trying to get rid of each other - well that has to stop." Asked how it would end, he said: "Oh, it will end on a good note - very soon." Neither the White House nor Musk could be reached for comment outside normal U.S. business hours. Trump said on Saturday his relationship with Musk was over and that there would be "serious consequences" if the world's richest man decided to fund U.S. Democrats running against Republicans who vote for the tax and spending bill. Musk bankrolled a large part of Trump's 2024 presidential campaign. Trump named Musk to head an effort to downsize the federal workforce and slash spending. Musk's father told reporters he was standing by his son. "Elon is sticking to his principles but you cannot always stick to your principles in the real world," Musk's father said. "Sometimes you have to give and take." Speaking beside sanctioned Russian businessman Konstantin Malofeyev, Musk's father praised President Vladimir Putin as a "very stable and pleasant man." He accused "fake media" in the West of projecting "complete nonsense" about Russia and for casting it as an enemy.

Russia launches biggest drone barrage of the Ukraine war, Kyiv says
Russia launches biggest drone barrage of the Ukraine war, Kyiv says

Yahoo

time42 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Russia launches biggest drone barrage of the Ukraine war, Kyiv says

Nearly 500 drones and 20 missiles of various types were launched by Russia at Ukraine overnight, marking the biggest barrage of the war, Kyiv said. On Monday, Ukraine's air force said its air defenses were able to destroy 277 of the 479 drones launched in the darkness and 19 missiles mid-flight. Kyiv claims only 10 drones of missiles hit their target and just one person was injured. The bombardment targeted mainly central and western areas of Ukraine, they said. Russia's aerial attacks usually start late in the evening and end in the morning, as drones are harder to spot in the dark. Four Killed In Russian Attacks On Ukraine As Moscow Continues To Retaliate For Kyiv's Drone Strike Russia has targeted civilian areas of Ukraine with Shahed drones during the war. The attacks have killed more than 12,000 Ukrainian civilians, according to the United Nations. Russia says it targets only military targets. Read On The Fox News App Despite the attack, the Kremlin said on Monday that Russia was still ready to honor agreements with Ukraine on a new prisoner of war exchange and on the repatriation of dead soldiers, despite what it said was Kyiv's failure to so far honor its side of the bargain. Russia Launches Largest Aerial Attack Of Ukraine War, Killing At Least 12 "We have seen and heard a hundred different excuses, justifications and so on, but it is difficult to view them as credible," Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov told reporters, according to Reuters. "The Russian side remains ready to implement the agreements reached in Istanbul." The exchanges were agreed to during a second round of direct peace talks in Istanbul on June 2 and are meant to see a new prisoner of war swap of at least 1,200 people – focusing on the youngest and most severely wounded – as well as the repatriation of thousands of bodies of those killed in the war. The return of prisoners of war and the return of the bodies of the dead is one of the few things the two sides have been able to agree on, even as their broader negotiations have failed to get close to ending the war, now in its fourth year. The Associated Press and Reuters contributed to this report. Original article source: Russia launches biggest drone barrage of the Ukraine war, Kyiv says

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store