Thames Water must be held to account
So creditors wishing to take over Thames Water want the company and its senior management to be granted clemency from rules on sewage spills and environmental protection (Bidders demand Thames Water granted immunity over environmental crimes, 7 June). The rights of investors, it would seem, should prevail over the rights of communities to a clean environment.
It is the failure of rigorously enforced regulation that led to the mismanagement of Thames Water, with loans being used to increase shareholder dividends and bloated bonuses for incompetent managers. In many countries the law can now be used to confiscate private assets gained from immoral activities, such as drug-running and prostitution. There is no reason why those who accrue wealth through the degradation of the natural environment should be treated any differently.
Far from granting immunity from prosecution, the government should tighten the law to enable the criminal prosecution of the managers responsible and the repayment of shareholder dividends awarded by an underperforming business. Such a move would enable financial markets to promote good corporate governance and environmental sustainability. After all, financial investors and shareholders want profitable businesses that provide them with financial returns. If investors knew that they could lose their investment and dividends by investing in a company such as Thames Water, they would soon look to invest in more ethically run businesses.
The government should now initiate legal proceedings to seize the assets of those managers who enriched themselves by creating a debt-laden, high-polluting water company. The proceeds should be invested in water infrastructure and environmental clean-ups. And Thames Water should be taken into public ownership and its assets auctioned off. Only socially responsible investors need apply.David HumphreysEmeritus professor of environmental policy, Open University
Have an opinion on anything you've read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sky News
34 minutes ago
- Sky News
Farming: Cost of rural crime in Wales at its highest in more than a decade
The cost of rural crime in Wales is at its highest in more than a decade, a new report has revealed. Last year, rural crime cost an estimated £2.8m in Wales, according to insurance provider NFU Mutual. That's an 18% increase on the previous year, with Wales the only UK nation to have seen a rise. For farmers like Caryl Davies, that makes their work harder. The 21-year-old farms on a beef and sheep farm in Pembrokeshire. She told Sky News that having the quad bike stolen from her family farm last August had made them feel "really unsafe at home". The fact it happened in such a rural area was a "really big shock" for Ms Davies and her family. "We'd rely on the bike day in day out, to look after our cows and sheep, and it's had a really negative impact on us," she said. The cost of replacing a bike exactly like theirs would be "close to £10,000". "They're a really expensive piece of kit, but you can't be without them, especially in these rural areas where we've got the mountain and maybe places that aren't very accessible," she added. "The bike is totally crucial for our day-to-day running of the farm." The incident was caught on camera in the calving shed, but the Davies family have since invested in an enhanced CCTV system. That comes at an additional cost. "For some farmers, this is spare money that we haven't really got," Ms Davies added. "Farming is hard enough as it is, without people stealing your things and having to spend this extra money on making your home farm safe." The total cost of rural crime across the UK has fallen since 2023 - down from £52.8m to £44.1m. Quad bike and All Terrain Vehicles (ATVs) remained the top target for thieves during the past year, NFU Mutual's figures show. James Bourne farms in Pontypool, Torfaen, and claims to have had over 200 sheep stolen from common land adjoining his farm over a four-year period. The 32-year-old told Sky News that losing sheep from his herd was a "big hit" on his business as well as the young family he is trying to support. "The way agriculture is at the moment anyway, we're struggling to make ends meet, and any profit that is in it is obviously being taken from me," he said. "So I really need to try and find out and get to the bottom of where they're going because obviously it's an ongoing issue." Andrew Chalk, from NFU Mutual, told Sky News that while there had been a "significant drop" across the UK, there were "worrying signs". "In Wales, especially, rural crime's gone up which just shows that organised criminals are looking for ways to target the countryside again and again," he said. "What we've found increasingly is that organised criminals are targeting certain areas of the countryside, so they're hitting multiple farms in one night. "They're raiding them, they're moving away to another area and then hitting multiple farms there. So it is hugely concerning." Mr Chalk said NFU Mutual had also heard reports of criminals using drones and other equipment to "look at the lay of the land". "What it does show is that organised criminals are always going to find new ways to target rural crime and that's why we need to be on top of it and to work together to actually disrupt them," he added. Police forces in Wales say they are aware of the "significant impact" that rural crimes have on those affected. A Dyfed-Powys Police spokesperson said the force had acquired new technology to help combat rural crime, including "advanced DNA asset-marking kits" and hopes to "empower farmers with effective tools and advice". The spokesperson acknowledged the difficulty of patrolling the entire police force area, "given the huge area" it has to cover, and thanked rural communities for their "continuing vigilance and for reporting any suspicious activity". Temporary Chief Superintendent Jason White, from Gwent Police, said the force would be "increasing resources" within the rural crime team throughout this financial year and urged anyone in a rural area who believes they have been a victim of crime to get in touch.
Times
37 minutes ago
- Times
How UK businesses disappeared from world's biggest trade fairs
B efore the pandemic, British businesses used to be the second-largest exhibitors at Drinktec, with about 100 companies attending the largest trade fair in the world for the drinks industry. This year, only a quarter of that number will attend the event in Munich. Similarly dramatic falls have been seen at trade shows in other industries. About 1,400 British fashion and textile businesses visited the industry's major trade fairs each year before Covid-19; now the figure is closer to 300. The trade association for Britain's baby products industry used to organise three UK pavilions at big events in Germany, China and the United States but hasn't organised one since 2019, due to a lack of appetite from British companies. While the shrinking presence of UK businesses abroad has coincided with the pandemic, it appears to be more the product of a little-noticed change in government policy.
Times
37 minutes ago
- Times
BT job cuts may deepen as AI advances, says Allison Kirkby
Advances in artificial intelligence could deepen significant job cuts under way at BT, the telecoms company's chief executive has said. In the latest pronouncement by a leading chief executive on the impact of AI on the labour market, Allison Kirkby said BT's plans to cull more than 40,000 jobs and reduce costs by £3 billion by the end of the decade did not reflect the full potential of the technology. 'Depending on what we learn from AI … there may be an opportunity for BT to be even smaller by the end of the decade,' she said in an interview with the Financial Times. In May 2023, BT said that it would replace 10,000 jobs with artificial intelligence by the end of the decade, which would include call handling and network diagnostics.
