'Depraved paedophile' identified 40 years after sexual abusing two girls under 8
This is retired member of the Defence Forces, Eddie Lillis, unmasked today as a 'depraved paedophile' who preyed upon and sexually assaulted two little girls 40 years ago.
Lillis was jailed for three and half years at Limerick Circuit Criminal Court after he admitted sexually abusing the two girls, who were aged between three and eight when he groomed and abused them in the 1980s.
Judge Colin Daly lifted a court order restricting the media from identifying Lillis, 63, of Shannonvale, Old Cratloe Road, Limerick.
Shortly after Lillis sexually assaulted his first victim, Girl A, she told her mother what happened and gave a formal statement to Gardaí, however, the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), at the time, directed there was not enough evidence to prosecute Lillis. Lillis went on to abuse Girl B, the court heard.
However, four decades later, in 2020, after Girl A made another complaint and Gardaí received a separate complaint from Lillis' second victim, Girl B, Gardaí re-investigated the case and the DPP ordered Lillis to face trial.
Lillis pleaded not guilty to all of the charges. Following his trial at Limerick Circuit Criminal Court, he was convicted on four of the five charges, and the jury could not reach a decision on the fifth count.
In her victim impact statement which she read in court, Girl A stated: 'If Eddie Lillis had been held accountable when I made my original complaint, (Girl B) may have avoided his depraved actions.
'My hope is that by making his crimes known to the public, Eddie Lillis will never have the opportunity to harm another child.'
Both women said they came forward to Gardaí to 'protect other little girls' from Lillis, or indeed, any other 'paedophile'.
They said they wanted to show 'other victims of historic sexual abuse that it is never too late to pursue justice'.
Lillis, who was supported in court by some of his family, said, through his barrister, that, despite him having contested the trial, he accepted the jury's decision.
Girl A stated that the 'heinous' sex acts carried out on her by Lillis changed her from being 'a carefree, innocent six-year old little girl, to feeling confused and terrified'.
'The person who hurt me was someone who was supposed to protect and serve our community - Instead, he took advantage of my innocence and vulnerability.
'I had never seen a man's penis before, and the thought and disgusting smell of his penis has stayed with me into adulthood and still makes me feel sick to my stomach.'
Girl A, who was sexually assaulted by Lillis a few days prior to her First Holy Communion, praised her parents 'who instantly believed me and brought me to make a statement to Gardaí'.
She said she continued to struggle afterwards with anxiety knowing 'that there are many more Eddie Lillis's out there'.
'It has affected my family who felt helpless in bringing this pedophile to justice, I watched it have a devastating impact on my parents and siblings,' she said.
'The only reason I have put myself and my family through this is to keep other children safe from this man.'
'He is now a convicted paedophile, I am relieved that my allegations were finally taken seriously by the DPP and that (the defendant) is being held to account,' Girl A concluded.
Girl B told the court that Lillis's sexual assaults on her had 'warped' her childhood and that 'despite extensive and ongoing therapy, the psychological scars never go away'.
Girl B said the abuse made her fearful for her own daughter and 'all little girls because of men like Edward Lillis', and that her fear for other children convinced her 'to come forward once and for all'.
'He (Lillis) maintained his innocence and put my family and I through the further trauma of a trial, he has never shown a midget of remorse.'
Neither victim wished to be identified but they said they supported the court lifting reporting restrictions on identifying Lillis.
Lillis' barrister, senior counsel, Anthony Salmon, asked Judge Colin Daly to take into account Lillis's 'service to the State, and his previous good character until his convictions caught up with him'.
Jailing Lillis, Judge Daly said the married father of three 'took advantage' of his position of trust in the community 'to abuse the two children'.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
2 hours ago
- Sunday World
Judge tells man whose partner died after festival drug use it is ‘one of the saddest cases'
The court heard that Mr Carroll and his girlfriend had attended the Forbidden Fruit festival on June 2, 2024, where they both consumed drugs A 24-year-old man whose partner died after they both took drugs following a music festival has avoided a conviction for simple possession, in what a judge described as "one of the saddest cases" to come before his court. The District Court was told that the defendant Brian Carroll has now made a commitment to living a "drug-free life". Mr Carroll, of Cedarmount Road, Mount Merrion, Co Dublin pleaded guilty to possession of MDMA and cannabis and appeared before Judge Conor Fottrell at Dún Laoghaire District Court on Wednesday. Stock image News in 90 Seconds - 7th June The court heard that Mr Carroll and his girlfriend had attended the Forbidden Fruit festival on June 2, 2024, where they both consumed drugs, while further substances were taken later at a house in south Dublin. The woman was found unresponsive later that night and died as a result. Mr Carroll had been in a relationship with the deceased for two and a half years. Gardaí who carried out a search of the house recovered cannabis worth €44, €16 of MDMA and a small quantity of cocaine. Garda Harry Poole told the court that the drugs were for personal use and were at the lower end of the scale. The court heard that Mr Carroll later voluntarily attended a garda station, gave a full account of what occurred and has not come to garda attention since. Judge Fottrell initially questioned whether the District Court had jurisdiction to hear the case, given the serious background circumstances. 'I appreciate the plea before the court today, but this is a serious matter,' he said. 'I'm not sure it's a District Court matter.' Defence solicitor Mark O'Sullivan said it was a tragic accident and argued that the case before the court concerned a minor possession matter. 'That's all the court is being asked to hear today,' he said. After considering the details, Judge Fottrell accepted jurisdiction. 'On the basis of what's before me, the circumstances are tragic. I'll accept jurisdiction.' Mr O'Sullivan told the court that Mr Carroll and the deceased had bought the drugs together, but the woman had taken more than his client. He said his client was fully cooperative, had no previous convictions, and had voluntarily presented himself to Gardaí. Letters were handed into court from Kilmacud Medical Centre and the Community Addiction Response Programme. The court heard Mr Carroll had engaged in trauma counselling following the incident, tested negative for drugs in recent months and remained in full-time employment. He had also volunteered with Little Flower Penny Dinners during the Covid-19 pandemic. The woman's father and sister were present in court. 'On behalf of my client, I extend our sympathies to the family,' Mr O'Sullivan said. 'Relations remain good between them. This was an absolute tragedy.' In a personal letter to the court, the man expressed remorse and a commitment to living a drug-free life. Judge Fottrell acknowledged the man's remorse, the steps he had taken since and the tragic nature of the case. 'This is a tragic case,' he said. 'The consequences were anything but minor. However, the value of the drugs involved is low, and there are no previous convictions". 'You've pleaded guilty, made full admissions, and taken meaningful steps since. I don't propose to impose a conviction. "This is one of the most unusual and saddest cases to come before the court. I hope you continue your recovery," the judge said, addressing the defendant. Judge Fottrell concluded the matter without a conviction, following a €1,000 charitable donation. Funded by the Courts Reporting Scheme.
RTÉ News
6 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Family of Elizabeth Plunkett call for cold case review
The family of Elizabeth Plunkett has written to the DPP, the Garda Commissioner and the Minister for Justice requesting a cold case review into her death and a renewed public appeal for evidence. John Shaw and Geoffrey Evans confessed to abducting, raping and murdering both Ms Plunkett in Brittas Bay Co Wicklow, and Mary Duffy in Conamara, Co Galway, in 1976. Originally both men were charged with murder, rape and false imprisonment of Ms Plunkett and Ms Duffy. However, when Shaw began a parole application nearly two years ago, it was revealed he had never been convicted for Ms Plunkett's murder despite previous reports. It was also revealed to the Plunkett family that the State never held an inquest into the death of Ms Plunkett nor ever issued a death certificate in her name. The Plunkett family are collaborating with the team at RTÉ Documentary On One on Stolen Sister, a six-part podcast series currently publishing to raise awareness around Ms Plunkett's case. This collaboration led to an inquest being held into Ms Plunkett's death earlier this year. In January, a verdict of unlawful killing was returned at the inquest at Gorey courthouse. Coroner Dr Seán Nixon sitting gave the cause of death as asphyxia due to strangulation. While Shaw was never convicted of crimes against Ms Plunkett, Evans was convicted of her rape and false imprisonment, but not murder. As Shaw was never convicted of any charges relating to Ms Plunkett, her family said they are no longer considered victims of a crime under the 2019 Parole Act and are not entitled to take part in the parole process. Evans died in 2012. In the Plunketts' letter, written on their behalf by solicitor James MacGuill SC, the family seeks to justify a cold case review. They outline a series of developments since the decision of the statutory Parole Board to no longer view them as victims of a crime. These include the findings of the recent inquest, as well as the post-mortem report issued following Ms Plunkett's death that contained samples of potentially significant evidentiary value that the family believe should be submitted for modern forensic examination. The letter also states that publicity was given to the case by RTÉ because it identified a significant public interest in establishing why Shaw was not prosecuted for such a serious crime. In addition, the correspondence outlines that renewed interest in the case has already led to a new witness coming forward with information about the night Ms Plunkett was abducted. A further incident that was reported to the authorities at the time is also mentioned in the letter. A young woman in Fethard, Co Tipperary, was allegedly chased by two men, who she later identified as Shaw and Evans, after watching a television report of their arrest. The Plunkett family claim these matters warrant immediate investigation as they provide strong corroborative evidence of similar facts to Ms Plunkett's murder and Shaw's statement of confession. The decision to only prosecute Shaw for the murder of Ms Duffy has not yet been made clear to the Plunkett family. P arole application Shaw is serving a life sentence in Arbour Hill Prison for the murder of Ms Duffy in September 1976. According to information given to the Plunkett family by the Victim Liaison Office of the Irish Prison Service, Shaw's most recent parole application has been refused. He will be eligible to apply for parole again in February of next year. The Minister for Justice's office told RTÉ: "The Parole Board, as provided for under the Parole Act 2019, was established on 31 July 2021. The 2019 Act placed the parole process on a statutory footing and established an independent, statutory Parole Board to decide on parole applications. "The Parole Board makes its decisions to grant or refuse parole independently from the Minister for Justice." RTÉ contacted the Parole Board and the Irish Prison Service for comment; both said they do not comment on individual cases. In 2016, the Parole Board recommended that Shaw be given two days of temporary release a year under a prison escort. While the Minister for Justice at the time rejected this suggestion, that decision was later reversed in 2020. Shaw's most recent escorted visit out of prison was granted just two weeks ago, in late May, when he was brought to Dún Laoghaire, Co Dublin, in the company of prison staff and later returned to custody. Kathleen Nolan and Bernie Plunkett, sisters of Elizabeth Plunkett told RTÉ News: "We're relieved that this individual, who confessed to abducting, raping and murdering our beloved Elizabeth has once again been refused parole. "However, he has still not faced justice for what he did to our sister. This is why we're telling Elizabeth's story in the podcast series Stolen Sister, to bring wider public attention to our plight - and to seek for any new witnesses that might be able to help our case. "We're calling on the DPP to tell us why this man never faced the courts for what he did to our Elizabeth. And we're asking gardaí to now re-examine his case so Elizabeth can finally get some justice." If anyone has any information on John Shaw and Geoffrey Evans, the Plunkett family have asked that you contact the podcast makers through documentaries@
Sunday World
7 hours ago
- Sunday World
Man with 145 convictions held knife to woman's throat during cocaine-fuelled burglary
Defendant with 145 previous convictions stated drugs 'blew the socks off me' This was after the man crashed a stolen car close to where she lived in Gyles Quay, a popular North Louth beach which was packed with cars on a sunny Sunday afternoon last year. James McDonagh (38), Dominic Street, Newry, Co. Down, appeared before Dundalk Circuit Court via video link for a sentence hearing. He has been in custody since the offending occurred. He pleaded guilty to aggravated burglary, unlawfully using a car without consent, dangerous driving and driving without insurance, at Gyles Quay on June 23, 2024. Other charges including false imprisonment of a female are being taken into consideration. He told Gardaí who arrested him at the scene that he had taken too much cocaine. 'It blew the socks off me'. The defendant, one of 13 children, moved to Newry from Dundalk, and has 145 previous convictions on both sides of the border. Judge Dara Hayes adjourned the matter to June 19 and said that there will be a 'significant sentence'. Gardaí had been alerted by the PSNI about a stolen BMW which had crossed the border. A car was spotted acting suspiciously around Bellurgan, north of Dundalk, but despite extensive searches throughout the early hours of the morning it could not to be located. Around 2pm this car was seen on the main Carlingford Road. It turned for Gyles Quay and went into a car park. Gyles Quay basking in glorious sunshine on a day similar to the incident. Photo: Ken Finegan/ News in 90 Seconds - 7th June Det Gda Eimear Gallagher in plain clothes and a colleague wearing full uniform approached the BMW. Its driver's door was open. A man was in the front seat. He didn't engage with the officers and reached down. Det Gda Gallagher testified that she feared he had a weapon. The driver turned on the ignition. She asked him to get out. By this stage the other guard was standing in front of the car. The engine was being revved and Det Gda Gallagher told her colleague to move. At that point Mr McDonagh took off at such speed that the car was 'bouncing' across the potholed surface as he left the car park. The two Gardaí raced to their vehicle and once on the move activated the blue lights and siren to try to get the BMW to stop and to warn pedestrians. One man had to lift a buggy containing a child out of the way to avoid being hit by the defendant as he sped past. Read more The car struck a parked van and as it continued back towards the main road it mounted a footpath on which there were a lot of pedestrians before colliding with a wall and coming to a stop. The driver got out and ran. He had a large silver knife in his right hand and a hammer in the other. He scaled a fence and ran along the beach towards Ferguson's caravan park. Meanwhile, a woman living in a bungalow at the park was sitting on a sofa. It was so warm she had the back doors open. Suddenly, around 3pm, a man came through the door with what she described as a butcher's knife. He had something else in his other hand but she was only focused on the knife. He had blood on his face. He screamed for her car keys and demanded money. The woman's young son came out of his room and was screaming. The woman was in such fear that she was willing to co-operate to protect her son. She couldn't find the keys. McDonagh held the knife to her throat until she found them. While this was going on armed Gardaí had arrived outside. The victim saw them. The man ran and was chased through the house by the guards and out the back door. Det Gda Gallagher told the mother and child to stay inside and not come out until Gardaí returned. Outside, one of the other officers pulled his gun and the man lay down on grass. He was arrested there by Det Gda Gallagher at 3.04pm, some 500m from the house. The man said: 'I think I took too much cocaine. It blew the socks off me. I took the car. I didn't know it was wanted. I was driving nice and slow. I was washing up 'Coke' to do 'Crack'. 'I didn't know they were guards. I put the boot down and drove off. I panicked and I crashed.' Later, he added: 'Jesus, I didn't do a burglary, did I? Only slagging.' McDonagh said that he wasn't going to use the knife. "I was only scaring her. I saw youse outside and I ran. You got me.' He denied putting a knife to the woman's throat. "She walked to me. She must have wanted a claim or something.' "I could get big time. I'm sorry for what I said and what I did.' He signed the memos of interview. The court heard of 145 previous convictions – 85 in the Republic of Ireland and sixty in the North. These included unauthorised taking of vehicles, theft, possession of a knife, robbery, trespass, assault, burglary, assaulting police and drugs possession. Gda Laura O'Connor read out out a harrowing Victim Impact Statement which detailed how the woman and her family had moved to Ireland hoping for a safe and better quality of life. Her husband lost his life tragically here. She spoke of her son screaming for his life and the ongoing consequences of the attack. She felt completely unsafe in her own home. There were flashbacks of the knife against her throat. Her son's terrifying screams haunted her. She thanked the Gardaí. It was stated in a probation report that James McDonagh accepted full responsibility. He had taken a combination of drugs with whiskey when he stole the vehicle in Northern Ireland to sell across the border to buy cocaine. He identified as a member of the Travelling community, the second youngest of 13 children. His parents moved to Newry and he intends to live with his brother in Dundalk. Single, and the father of two adult children, he had never worked and was reliant on social welfare. The defendant was on methadone and continued to use drugs in custody. He was assessed at high risk of reoffending. Judge Hayes said that he was grateful to the victim for coming to court. It was of much assistance to him. 'It was a horrifying experience for you and your son. I'm dreadfully sorry. It's unimaginable how awful it must have been for you and your son.' The judge said these were extremely serious offences. He allowed time for a drugs counsellor's report to be prepared. Funded by the Courts Reporting Scheme
