Princess Alexandra hospital staff 'failed' newborn, parents say
A couple whose newborn baby was starved of oxygen during labour have told a coroner's court she was "failed by those looking after her".An inquest is being held into the death of Emmy Russo, who was born at Princess Alexandra Hospital in Harlow, Essex, in January 2024 and died at Addenbrooke's Hospital in Cambridge three days later.Daniel and Bryony Russo told the inquest there had been "so many warning signs" about their daughter's condition and her death had been "so avoidable and so preventable".One of the midwives involved in their care said she thought about Emmy "every single day" and passed her condolences to the couple before giving evidence.
In a statement read out to Essex Coroner's Court, Mr Russo said the couple were "laughed off" when they asked for a C-section during labour on 9 January 2024."We were repeatedly dismissed with a tone that said 'it's all ok, just relax'," he said.Mrs Russo had been classified as low-risk during pregnancy and had not experienced any serious complications before labour.Mrs Russo told the inquest she felt her baby "wasn't going to come out" during labour and she knew something was wrong, which she had repeatedly told staff.Mr and Mrs Russo said they had also raised concerns about the presence of meconium in Mrs Russo's waters, and could not understand why staff members seemed "quite relaxed" after a sudden drop in the baby's heart rate.The 32-year-old eventually ended up having an emergency caesarean after foetal monitoring results were reviewed again around 21:00 GMT.After Emmy was born, no heart beat could be detected and she had to be resuscitated before being transferred to Addenbrooke's.An MRI scan there revealed she had severe brain damage and she died on 12 January.A post-mortem examination found she died from acute hypoxic ischemic encephalopathy, a brain injury caused by lack of oxygen and blood flow, and placental disfunction.Mrs Russo told the inquest she felt an earlier induction or C-section would have resulted in Emmy surviving as a "happy, healthy baby".
Emily Day, a midwife at Princess Alexandra Hospital who was involved with the couple's care for about four hours, told the inquest how an abdominal CTG (cardiotocography) belt was placed on Mrs Russo's stomach to constantly monitor the baby's heart rate and movements.She said she had tried to reassure Mr and Mrs Russo and said the hospital had "the right team", while ensuring Mrs Russo could have the epidural she had requested multiple times. When asked by Thea Wilson, assistant coroner for Essex, whether anything had changed for her as a result of Emmy's death, Ms Day replied: "I've taken quite a few things from this case, I'd say I think about it every single day."She added that she had become "more confident about escalating my concerns" as a result of what happened, and had become more aware of potential signs of infection.A number of other midwives, consultants and other clinicians are due to give evidence at the inquest.
Follow Essex news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Girl, 12, dies after doctors mistook fatal tumour for 'tummy bug'
Jackie Dunlop has urged parents to "trust their gut" after losing her daughter Ava Nelson from a condition which GPs initially dismissed as something minor A mum is urging parents to trust their instincts after her daughter's tummy bug turned out to be an inoperable brain tumour. Jackie Dunlop from North Ayrshire became concerned when her daughter Ava Nelson, then aged 10, suffered with severe headaches and sickness for three weeks. Following visits to the GP and her local hospital, the young girl was a viral infection or a gastric bug. However, after the fourth week of Ava feeling unwell, Jackie pushed for more testing and what followed shocked the 38-year-old to the core. An MRI revealed a pressure of Ava's brain, caused by a large mass, and she was rushed up to the Royal Hospital for Children in Glasgow. She had to have an emergency operation to relieve the pressure and a biopsy a week later revealed Ava had a high-grade glioblastoma. The family were told she had just six to 12 months to live, but Ava outlived that prediction and passed away nearly two years later in April 2024, aged 12. Now Jackie, from Kilwinning, who previously worked as a carer, is telling parents not to ignore their own suspicions regarding their child's health. She said: "We thought it was a sickness bug. But going into week three I started to worry. Everyone put it down to a viral sickness bug. Four weeks I had been fighting with doctors. The surgeon told us if we didn't fight she'd have been dead within a week because the pressure was that bad." She continued: "I always say to any mother go with your gut instinct if you feel that something is wrong with your child. If you feel something is wrong then go get them checked. If you aren't getting anywhere stand your ground and make sure you get the help and support you need until you have the right answers. Mothers know their child best." Ava began experiencing headaches, dizziness, and balance issues in May 2022. Despite numerous GP appointments and hospital visits, her symptoms were dismissed as just a viral illness, reports Glasgow Live. Growing concerned about her daughter's health, Jackie refused to accept this and persevered for further medical attention at Crosshouse Hospital's children's ward. Jackie recounted: "To look at her you wouldn't know anything was wrong. They agreed to do blood tests – Ava then started vomiting. She started declining but the blood tests came back fine. I pushed for a scan." The persistence paid off when an MRI scan showed a brain tumour. Ava was rushed to the Royal Hospital for Children in Glasgow on May 31, 2022. Jackie said: "They told us Ava has severe pressure on her brain. They found a tumour. The pressure was caused by the tumour." Ava underwent emergency surgery the following day; however, doctors couldn't fully remove the tumour due to its location. The biopsy results returned on June 8, 2022, confirming Ava's diagnosis with cancer. Jackie revealed: "The hardest part for me was that wasn't going to survive. They gave us six to 12 months." Ava bravely endured 12 weeks of simultaneous radiotherapy and chemotherapy, which resulted in her needing a feeding tube after the treatment caused a rupture in her stomach. Her parents, Jackie and Roland, made the heart-wrenching decision not to disclose Ava's terminal prognosis, choosing instead to create cherished memories. Jackie shared: "We were trying to normalise life." The family dedicated themselves to ensuring their beloved "wee warrior" had as many joyous moments as possible, despite their own sorrow. Jackie said: "As a family we did everything in our willpower to make sure that the time we had left with our wee warrior was full of fun filled memories as much as it was killing us inside." In spring 2023, Ava was admitted to Robin House Children's Hospice, where she fought for another year before passing away on April 16, 2024, with her loving parents and sisters, aged nine and 17, by her side. Jackie recalled: "They moved her into the rainbow room. It was the most peaceful room." Jackie now aims to inspire other parents to trust their instincts about their children's health. She added: "Ava was quiet as a mouse. She was quite shy and timid. But she was sweet and loving. She was the best."
Daily Record
6 hours ago
- Daily Record
Mum's warning as daughter dies from brain tumour thought to be tummy bug
The family were told she had just six to 12 months to live - but Ava outlived this and passed away nearly two years later - aged 12. A mum is urging parents to trust their instincts after her daughter's tummy bug turned out to be an inoperable brain tumour. Jackie Dunlop, 38, became concerned when her daughter, Ava Nelson, then 10, suffered with severe headaches and sickness for three weeks. She took her to see the GP and went to her local hospital but was told it was a viral infection or a gastric bug. But after the fourth week of Ava feeling unwell, Jackie pushed for more testing. An MRI revealed a pressure of Ava's brain - caused by a large mass - and she was rushed up to the Royal Hospital for Children in Glasgow. She had to have an emergency operation to relieve the pressure and a biopsy a week later revealed Ava had a high grade glioblastoma. The family were told she had just six to 12 months to live - but Ava outlived this and passed away nearly two years later in April 2024 - aged 12. Now her mum wants others to trust their gut. Jackie, who previously worked as a carer, from Kilwinning, Ayrshire, said: "We thought it was a sickness bug. "But going into week three I started to worry. Everyone put it down to a viral sickness bug. Four weeks I had been fighting with doctors. "The surgeon told us if we didn't fight she'd have been dead withing a week because the pressure was that bad. "I always say to any mother go with your gut instinct if you feel that something is wrong with your child. If you feel something is wrong then go get them checked. "If you aren't getting anywhere stand your ground and make sure you get the help and support you need until you have the right answers. "Mothers know their child best." Ava started getting headaches, dizzy spells and balance issues in early May 2022. She went to her GP and to her local hospital but it was brushed off as a viral infection. Jackie wasn't happy and pushed to get her to the children's ward at Crosshouse Hospital. She said: "To look at her you wouldn't know anything was wrong. "They agreed to do blood tests - Ava then started vomiting. She started declining but the blood tests came back fine. I pushed for a scan." Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. Ava had an MRI which revealed a mass on her brain. She had to be blue-lighted to Royal Hospital for Children in Glasgow on May 31, 2022. Jackie said: "They told us Ava has severe pressure on her brain. They found a tumour. The pressure was caused by the tumour." Ava had to have an emergency operation the next day but doctors were unable to remove all of the tumour due to its position. The biopsy results came back a week later on June 8, 2022 and Ava was diagnosed with cancer.
Daily Mirror
2 days ago
- Daily Mirror
'I was in a shopping centre - then a man left me paralysed'
Medical student Grace Spence Green's life was changed in a moment when a man falling from a third floor balcony landed on her, breaking her spine. Now with a rich, rewarding life she's determined to change the image of disability Grace Spence Green doesn't remember the moment of her accident, when a man l eapt from a third-floor balcony in Westfield shopping centre, in east London, and landed on top of her. She was a medical student and just 22, and only recalls walking along the shopping centre atrium towards the train station. The next thing she knew was waking up on the floor and not being able to feel her legs. 'I remember crying, maybe screaming.' The collision had broken her spine, leaving her paralysed from the chest down. Shockingly, abruptly, the trainee doctor had become a patient. In her powerful new book To Exist As I Am, Grace, now 29, tells the story of her traumatic experience, and her physical and mental recovery. A woman of extraordinary resilience, determination and positivity, she says she wouldn't change what happened to her. "As the years went by, what I gained through my disability, how it's changed me, the relationships that have changed – I can now say I wouldn't change it because of all I've gained from it,' she says. She spent two weeks in hospital where titanium was bolted into her spine to hold her shattered vertebrae in place. She spent much of that first week 'floating on a cloud' of morphine, while her parents and her partner of three years, Nathan, spent every possible moment by her bedside. But Grace, who had enjoyed a happy, loving and comfortable upbringing in London, 'felt as though I just slipped out of my life'. Five days after sustaining her injury, she began to write daily, finding it therapeutic. But she says that as she wrote her book, it was painful to revisit those earlier entries. 'I felt really sorry for this girl,' says Grace. 'I didn't quite recognise her because lots of it was really angry or muddled. It just seems like someone that was really lost, which I was. But she had to go through all of that to come out the other side.' After a couple of weeks, Grace was transferred to the Royal National Orthopaedic hospital in Stanmore, Middlesex. Initially, she experienced 'a sense of denial' because she no longer felt unwell, and 'I looked down and I looked the same'. But her desperate hopes of recovery were shattered when she saw an MRI scan of her spine, which showed it was almost severed. Slowly but surely, Grace began to accept her circumstances, considering how to make the best of them. She counted her blessings. She has been profoundly grateful for Nathan's devoted support. 'He's been such a constant and that has really, really helped. It always felt like we were dealing with this together. It wasn't just my burden to bear. "He's had comments like, 'Are you going to stay with Grace?' But that was never a question for him. So I was able to maintain some self worth, especially through the really low points in the first year.' Happily, Grace and Nathan are getting married in July. Grace returned to medical school 10 months after she was injured and, in 2021, she graduated and started work in a London hospital. But everyday life brought 'a barrage of comments or micro-aggressions or people making me feel less than'. On an 'almost daily' basis, complete strangers ask why she is in a wheelchair. 'How would you feel if I asked you to recount the most traumatic events of your life, every time you meet someone new? It can feel like my life is being reduced to this single moment… I am so tired of talking about that day.' People tend to address her able-bodied friend or partner instead of speaking to her directly. ''Can she walk?'' When she is boarding a train or plane, strangers will start pushing her wheelchair without consulting her. 'I appreciate an open 'Can I help you?' or 'Let me know if you need help with that'. And I would like people to be honest, I much prefer when someone says, 'I don't know the best way to help you'.' Grace says her recovery would have been much less traumatic if disability wasn't so stigmatised in our society. 'When I was injured, I felt like my life suddenly became very small and the things I would be able to do fitted into a very small box. I always wonder how catastrophic it would have felt if there were more disabled voices out there, if I knew that you could live a good life.' A significant turning point came a few months after her discharge when she took part in the Stoke Mandeville Games for the newly injured, and met people going through similar experiences. She even launched a podcast with five of them, with the inspired title of This Is Spinal Crap. 'It felt really great having a space to talk to these five people. They all have this shared experience. I can breathe out with them because they understand, I can relax and be more myself. It came at a time when I was really lost. I had recently been discharged, I didn't really know what I could do any more and what I would enjoy. So it felt really special.' During the pandemic, Grace interviewed disabled people around the world for the podcast. Their shared experiences allowed her to feel part of a community, their rich, rewarding lives providing the hope and inspiration she needed. These days, she enjoys outdoor swimming, seated water skiing, and she travels often. 'The first time I got on a train on my own was really huge for me. It was the realisation that I could navigate the world and be independent.' Grace has no desire to endlessly replay the day of her injury, nor does she want to dwell on the man who injured her. CCTV showed him smoking weed in a stairwell before running up to the third-floor balcony. He has since been deported. But Grace has never harboured anger or bitterness towards him. 'Very early on, I came to the realisation that if I wasn't there, the man likely would have died because he would have jumped head first. And that made it much easier to start navigating all of the emotions I felt because what I was going through was really difficult. But I wouldn't have changed it.' Instead of dwelling on the past, Grace is far more interested in focusing on the future, and in advocating for disabled people. She describes her book as a form of activism. 'I wouldn't want to change the person I am now. But, by sharing my own experience and showing my vulnerability, I hope people will be more open to listening and learning. It feels to me like the way I can make a change. Disabled people deserve more than this.'
