RM818mil bid for Batu Kawan land too costly with added conditions, says Chow
Chief minister Chow Kon Yeow said among the reasons the IJM-led consortium's proposal was nixed was the extra expenditure by PDC to fulfil the requests made. (Facebook pic)
GEORGE TOWN : A consortium's RM818 million bid for state land in Batu Kawan dropped in value to just over RM500 million when several conditions requested were considered, Penang chief minister Chow Kon Yeow told the state assembly today.
He was explaining why state agency Penang Development Corporation (PDC), which owns the Batu Kawan Industrial Park 2 land, had rejected a proposal by a consortium formed by IJP Properties and Aspen Vision.
PDC previously claimed the consortium's proposal was rejected due to multiple reasons, but Chow today said that while the consortium had offered the highest price, it would have placed a financial burden on the state.
'They made an offer with a higher price, but if you were to minus the extra (conditions requested), it comes down to about RM500 million. About the same as the Umech offer,' he said, referring to Umech Construction Sdn Bhd.
The below-market price land deal with Umech was dropped as it had bypassed an open tender process.
The IJM-led consortium offered RM818 million for the land last December, but claimed its proposal was rejected without any opportunity for further negotiations.
Chow said among the reasons the IJM-led consortium's proposal was nixed was the extra expenditure by PDC to fulfil the conditions requested, including RM150 million in infrastructure costs to ensure connectivity for the proposed project on the land.
The consortium also suggested converting the land from leasehold to freehold, which would require state approval and involve a premium of RM144 million.
Another request was to use nearby PDC land in Batu Kawan as a quarry, which Chow said carried an opportunity cost of RM25 million.
The consortium also sought a first right of refusal for 500 acres of adjacent land, potentially limiting PDC's ability to develop it freely.
Finally, it wanted the freedom to change company shareholding and transfer land without PDC's consent, Chow said.
Lim Guan Eng (PH-Air Putih) argued that PDC should have kept the door open for negotiations, claiming that the consortium was robbed of a chance to clarify or revise its offer.
'This is a request for proposal (RFP) by open tender, not a closed tender. After the best offer is picked for the RFP by open tender, there will be discussions and negotiations, all part of the process,' Lim said.
He cited the consortium's Dec 2, 2024 statement, which said that it had 'earnestly requested the opportunity to present and explain its submission, but this was not granted'.
Lim also said the consortium had made it clear that the request for freehold status and other enhancements were optional and should not have been treated as conditions.
PDC board has final say
Chow, who is PDC chairman, replied that any major decisions must be approved by the corporation's board, and that all proposals must comply with good governance standards.
'If the terms go against that, we cannot accept it,' he said. However, he did not explain why PDC had refused further negotiations with the consortium.
PDC is currently reviewing bids under a fresh tender exercise for the same plots of land.
Chow said if no acceptable bids emerge, the agency may consider developing the land itself.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Malay Mail
an hour ago
- Malay Mail
DPM Fadillah: Petronas job cuts unrelated to Petros appointment as sole gas aggregator
KUCHING, June 7 — Petroliam Nasional Berhad's (Petronas) decision to cut over 5,000 jobs, along with a freeze on all promotions and recruitment until December 2026, is unrelated to the recent recognition of Petroleum Sarawak Berhad (Petros) as Sarawak's sole gas aggregator. Deputy Prime Minister Datuk Seri Fadillah Yusof clarified this when met by reporters at the Majlis Ibadah Korban held at Masjid Darul Husni Warrahmah here today. 'No, it has nothing to do with that. It is actually due to the global situation, particularly the decline and fluctuation in oil prices,' he said. Petronas had earlier stated that its internal budgeting was based on Brent crude prices averaging between US$75 and US$80 per barrel. However, the global benchmark has since fallen and is currently hovering around US$65 per barrel. 'Even for Petronas to remain sustainable, oil prices must be above US$60 per barrel. That is why they have to re-evaluate their position,' Fadillah added. — The Borneo Post
Malay Mail
an hour ago
- Malay Mail
Japan says progress made but no deal yet in tariff talks with US
TOKYO, June 7 — Japan said today it was making 'progress' in talks aimed at easing US President Donald Trump's tariffs but cautioned that the two sides have not found 'a point of agreement yet'. Japan, a key US ally and its biggest investor, is subject to the same 10 percent baseline tariffs imposed on most nations plus steeper levies on cars, steel and aluminium. Trump also announced an additional 24 percent 'reciprocal' tariff on Japan in early April, but later paused it along with similar measures on other countries until early July. Japan wants all levies announced by Trump lifted. During a fifth round of talks, 'we further made progress towards an agreement', Ryosei Akazawa, Tokyo's trade envoy, told Japanese reporters in Washington. But, he added: 'We've not been able to find a point of agreement yet'. Akazawa said Tokyo was hoping to seal a deal 'as soon as possible', however, talks may still be ongoing when a summit of the Group of Seven wealthy nations starts on June 15. Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba and Trump are reportedly planning to hold bilateral talks around the time of the G7 summit in Canada. Washington's 25-percent auto tariffs are particularly painful for Tokyo, with roughly eight percent of all Japanese jobs tied to the sector. Japan's economy, the world's fourth largest, contracted 0.2 percent in the first quarter of 2025, adding to pressure on the unpopular Ishiba ahead of upper house elections expected in July. — AFP
Malay Mail
an hour ago
- Malay Mail
Penang defends 5pc housing discount for Indian Muslims, says Bumiputera quota untouched
GEORGE TOWN, June 7 — The offer of a five per cent discount for first-time homebuyers from the Indian Muslim community in Penang does not involve units under the Bumiputera quota and does not affect any existing home ownership policies, said state executive councillor Datuk Seri S. Sundarajoo. Sundarajoo, who is in charge of housing and environment, said the initiative is part of efforts to expand home ownership opportunities in the open market, particularly for groups with low participation rates, without affecting the rights of other communities. 'This discount is being offered as a form of corporate social responsibility by developers and does not involve any financial support or subsidy from the state government. 'The state government would like to emphasise that all existing housing policies, including the Bumiputera quota and various incentives for first-time homebuyers, remain intact and will continue to be enforced,' he said in a statement today in response to criticism from several quarters regarding the discount. Last Thursday, Sundarajoo announced a five per cent discount incentive for the Indian Muslim community for the purchase of residential and commercial units under the MADANI Home Ownership Campaign (MOC), which is effective from June 1, 2025 to May 31, 2026. Other initiatives include the introduction of a special housing category, Rumah MutiaraKu Type D (RMKu D), with a maximum price of RM400,000, and a reduction in contribution rates for developers who do not physically build RMKu Type A or B units — from RM120,000 to RM100,000 in areas under the Penang Island City Council, and from RM120,000 to RM72,500 under the Seberang Perai City Council. Sundarajoo said the five per cent discount is an additional measure complementing various existing programmes already in place to meet housing needs in the state. He explained that it is an intervention to help reinvigorate the property sector following discussions and consensus among housing industry stakeholders, taking into account the growing concern over the oversupply of non-affordable units in Penang. 'According to the Q4 2024 Penang State Property Market Report issued by the National Property Information Centre, 2,796 residential units were identified as overhang, involving various types of properties across the state,' he said. In addition to improving housing accessibility, he said the initiative also aims to revitalise the property sector affected by rising construction and labour costs, in line with the state government's aspiration to achieve more balanced, sustainable and inclusive development in Penang. — Bernama
