Safety Commissioner highlights ‘injustice' over lack of redress for mesh scandal
Ministers have been urged to give financial compensation to women affected by the mesh scandal as the Patient Safety Commissioner expressing her disappointment over a lack of action to date.
Last year, Dr Henrietta Hughes highlighted that thousands of women's lives were 'destroyed' because of pelvic mesh and said that there was a 'clear case for redress' for thousands of women and children affected by vaginal mesh implants and sodium valproate.
She said the Government should create a two-stage financial redress scheme – an interim scheme and a main scheme.
But campaigners said they have 'faced silence' in the year since the report was published.
Dr Hughes said: 'It is very disappointing that women who have suffered so much harm are still waiting for redress.
'This is an injustice as it augments the original harm they suffered. They need redress now and the Government must act immediately.'
Kath Sansom, founder of the Sling the Mesh campaign group, called on the Government to urgently act on the report's findings.
Ms Sansom told the PA news agency that women's lives have been 'irreparably damaged' by mesh, with many unable to work or reduce their hours due to chronic pain and disability.
But despite this, no compensation scheme has been put in place to help those affected, Ms Sansom said.
She said: 'For a year, we have waited for action, but all we've received is silence.
'The Hughes Report made it clear that financial redress is essential.
'It is unacceptable that the Government continues to turn a blind eye to women who have lost their health, their jobs, and their quality of life through no fault of their own.
'The time for excuses is over – we need action now.'
Transvaginal mesh implants were used to treat pelvic organ prolapse and incontinence after childbirth.
However, in some cases they have caused debilitating harm to some women.
This morning's launch in Parliament of my report into redress options for those harmed by pelvic mesh and valproate heard how women were deceived, kept in the dark, and fobbed off and let down by the health system – read the report at https://t.co/o02LyUM9RM pic.twitter.com/ZQXEPmt8Fu
— Patient Safety Commissioner (@PSCommissioner) February 7, 2024
Side effects have included infection, pelvic pain, difficulty urinating, pain during sex and incontinence.
MP Sharon Hodgson, chairwoman of the All-Party Parliamentary Group for First Do Harm, said: 'A year on from the publication of the Hughes Report which calls for a redress scheme for women impacted by the mesh and valproate scandals – the Government are yet to issue a response.
'I will not rest until these thousands of women and families get the justice they deserve.
'They have been let down by a system supposed to protect them and as a result will suffer lifelong physical and mental barriers – they will never be the same again.
'While financial compensation cannot reverse this damage, it would at least provide confirmation to them that – contrary to the gaslighting and dismissal they have received – they were right to raise concerns, that they were wronged, that it wasn't their fault, and that they deserve better.'
Alison Fuller, from the charity Epilepsy Action, said: 'It's been a year since Hughes report led by the Patient Safety Commissioner on redress options for people harmed by sodium valproate and pelvic mesh.
'For the first time, the report sets out the options to provide redress for people harmed by sodium valproate, when risks weren't communicated effectively.
'These families are struggling immensely, not just from an emotional standpoint, but from a financial one, too. They have been for decades. They simply can't wait any longer.
'Yet a year on we still have no clear timeline for a response to the recommendations. We're aware the Government has acknowledged it and committed to considering it. But the people affected deserve more than that.'
A Department of Health and Social Care spokesperson said: 'The harm caused by sodium valproate and pelvic mesh continues to be felt today. Our sympathies are with those affected and we are fully focused on how best to support patients and prevent future harm.
'This is a complex area of work and Health Minister Baroness Gillian Merron met with some of those affected before Christmas, and has committed to providing an update to the Patient Safety Commissioner at the earliest opportunity.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Bloomberg
5 hours ago
- Bloomberg
RFK Jr. Removes All Members of CDC Panel Advising on Vaccines
The Department of Health and Human Services is retiring the 17 members of a committee of government vaccine advisers, Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. said Monday. 'A clean sweep is needed to reestablish public confidence in vaccine science,' Kennedy said in an opinion piece published in the Wall Street Journal.
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Children in most deprived areas more likely to visit A&E and be obese
Children living in England's most deprived areas are more likely to visit A&E, be overweight or obese and suffer from tooth decay, a new report by aid agency Unicef UK has found. The organisation has called on the Government to lift its two-child benefit cap after its findings showed that where children grow up until the age of five has 'a significant impact' on their early outcomes and future potential. In the report published on Monday, every local authority in England was analysed against its level of deprivation and a range of early childhood health and educational outcomes. It found that, when considering early years development, the most deprived authorities were more than twice as far away from achieving the Government's 'good level' target of 75% than the most affluent areas. Only four of the 151 upper tier local authorities in England are currently meeting that target. Nearly twice as many children suffer from late-stage, untreated tooth decay in the most deprived areas (29%) compared to the least deprived (15%), while five-year-old children living in the poorest communities are three times more likely to have had teeth removed due to decay, the report found. Almost a quarter of reception-age children in the most deprived areas (24%) are overweight or obese, while general obesity levels in those areas are more than double those of children in the most affluent areas (12.9%, compared to 6%). There is also an average of 1,020 A&E visits per 1,000 babies and young children in the most deprived areas, an increase of 55% on rates in the most affluent areas, the report found. The five local authorities with the highest levels of deprivation – Blackpool, Knowsley, Liverpool, Kingston upon Hull, and Middlesbrough – were each in the lowest 20% for five of the six child wellbeing measures used in the analysis. Some 1.2 million babies and children under the age of five – 35% of the age group's total population – now live in poverty across England, the report said. It added that child poverty has increased more in the UK then in any of the 38 OECD and EU countries. Among the report's recommendations are long-term, sustainable funding and expanding provision for Family Hubs, recruiting an additional 1,000 health visitors a year and making access to Government-funded childcare hours equal for all children aged two or older, regardless of their location or parental employment. Unicef UK, joined by BBC presenter Dr Chris Van Tulleken, will present a petition calling for investments in early childhood, which has more than 105,000 signatures, to the Prime Minister at 10 Downing Street on Tuesday. Chief executive Dr Philip Goodwin warned the consequences of growing up in poverty can be lifelong and said the report's findings were 'not acceptable'. He said: 'There must be immediate, decisive, and ambitious action by the government. Any further delays will entrench inequality and condemn hundreds of thousands of children to poverty and its effects, as child poverty rates continue to rise. 'The Government must act urgently to lift the two-child limit and the benefit cap and commit to investing in the vital health and education services that support children during their crucial early years.' Introduced in 2015 by then-Conservative chancellor George Osborne, the cap restricts child welfare payments to the first two children born to most families. Sir Keir Starmer said he was 'absolutely determined' to 'drive down' child poverty when he was pressed on the two-child benefit cap in Parliament last week, ahead of the publication of the Government's strategy on the issue.
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Stormont minister calls for terminally ill to be allowed state pension early
A Stormont minister has urged the UK Government to allow the terminally ill early access to their state pension. Communities Minister Gordon Lyons said it is imperative that Government does more to ensure financial security and dignity for people in their final months of life. The measure – proposed by the end-of-life charity Marie Curie – would allow terminally ill individuals to claim their state pension based on national insurance contributions, topped up to at least pension credit-level. Figures from the charity's Dying In Poverty campaign show that around 111,000 people die in poverty each year in the UK, with more than one-in-four working-age individuals facing financial hardship in their final year. Mr Lyons has written to pensions minister Torsten Bell to press for action. 'It is imperative that we do more to ensure financial security and dignity for people in their final months of life and I am urging Minister Bell to take decisive action on this issue,' he said. 'A terminal diagnosis should not be accompanied by the added burden of financial hardship but unfortunately this is the stark – and unacceptable – reality for too many. 'Marie Curie's compassionate and practical solution would allow terminally ill individuals to access the state pension early, providing much-needed financial stability and some peace of mind during the most difficult of times.' On March 31, the Northern Ireland Assembly unanimously backed a private member's motion urging the UK to implement legislative changes that would enable those with a terminal diagnosis to access their state pension early. It is understood that these issues may be tackled in the UK Government's new Pension Schemes Bill. Mr Lyons said he has committed to engaging with the Department for Work and Pensions on behalf of those diagnosed with a terminal illness and to advocating for greater support. He added: 'I am urging the UK Government to act swiftly and compassionately to deliver meaningful change on early access to state pensions. 'No-one should be facing their final months with the added burden of financial distress and I will continue to press for a fair and compassionate system that meets the needs of those who are most vulnerable.' A government spokesperson said: 'No-one should suffer financial hardship because of a health condition, especially people nearing the end of life. 'And our special rules unlock early access to certain benefits and support systems for those nearing the end of their lives. 'Our Pension Schemes Bill will increase the life expectancy threshold for support from six to 12 months, giving more people the help they need at the hardest time of life.'
