Judge dismisses gender bias suit by woman who lost bid to be top pastor of famed Black church
A federal judge has dismissed a gender discrimination lawsuit filed by a professor and minister who lost her bid to become the first woman to serve as senior pastor of New York City's prominent Abyssinian Baptist Church.
The Rev. Eboni Marshall Turman, a Yale Divinity School professor and former assistant pastor at Abyssinian, was among the candidates interviewed in the search for a successor to longtime senior pastor Calvin O. Butts III, who died in 2022.
After not being named a finalist, Marshall Turman sued the church and the search committee for gender discrimination in December 2023. No woman has ever been senior pastor of Abyssinian, which was founded in 1808
In a ruling Monday to dismiss Marshall Turman's lawsuit, U.S. District Judge Dale Ho referred to the legal concept of 'ministerial exception,' which grants religious organizations some protection against employment discrimination claims related to the hiring and firing of clergy.
Ho also said Marshall Turman did not make a sufficiently persuasive case that she was more qualified than the five men who were named as finalists.
Marshall Turman, in an email to The Associated Press on Wednesday, said she was considering an appeal and depicted Abyssinian as 'mired in hypocrisy.'
'The case was not dismissed on its merits but on a technicality — religious exception — which contends that the church has a right to discriminate, even though the Bible says, 'in Christ there is neither male nor female,'' Marshall Turman wrote.
'My moral claim still stands: gender discrimination against me or anyone else has no place in God's house.'
Abyssinian defended its selection process and welcomed Ho's ruling.
'While the church celebrates this legal victory, it reaffirms its commitment to gender equity in religious leadership and remains committed to its long history of championing social justice and equality for all,' it said in a statement Wednesday.
Among the five finalists for the senior pastor position, the selection committee's eventual choice was Kevin R. Johnson, who founded Dare to Imagine Church in Philadelphia after a contentious resignation and split with historic Bright Hope Baptist Church in 2014.
Abyssinian congregants elected Johnson as senior pastor in June 2024.
However, some longtime members were displeased by the selection process, and the election itself. Four filed a lawsuit in October in a New York State court, alleging that several aspects of the process violated the church's bylaws.
That lawsuit remains pending, though Abyssinian filed a motion in December seeking its dismissal.
The lawsuit 'is nothing more than a scheme developed by Petitioners to remove the duly-elected pastor of a historic Baptist Church in Harlem, simply so they can propose a candidate whom they believe is more spiritually qualified for the position," the motion said. 'They have not made sufficient allegations to demonstrate fraud or wrongdoing in the election process.'
Based in Harlem, Abyssinian became a famous megachurch with the political rise of the Rev. Adam Clayton Powell Jr., perhaps the most influential of the many men who have led the congregation. Powell, pastor from 1937 to 1972, served in Congress for 26 years. Over the years, Abyssinian has been the spiritual home of many influential New Yorkers.
___
Associated Press religion coverage receives support through the AP's collaboration with The Conversation US, with funding from Lilly Endowment Inc. The AP is solely responsible for this content.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
20-05-2025
- The Herald Scotland
We need a government that has the courage to increase council tax
And perhaps when owner-occupiers are exposed to how quickly rents are increasing in their area, they will be more supportive of planning permission for local house building, increasing government revenue, and allowing income taxes to be cut further. Of course, the last attempt to increase council tax rates for the largest 28% of houses was bitterly opposed by the Conservatives, eventually bouncing Humza Yousaf into announcing the council tax freeze that led to his downfall. Deep down, do any of the Conservative, Reform or Labour parties actually want Scotland to be more like Singapore? Alan Ritchie, Glasgow. Read more letters Rail capacity is a scandal Alan Simpson ('The new electric rail line that hasn't got enough trains to run', The Herald, May 19) makes some highly pertinent points and raises valid questions on the upgrade to the East Kilbride rail line. One point that he does not mention is that the original plan to upgrade the line from Busby to East Kilbride from single to double track was dropped as being unaffordable. The result is that, even when there are new electric trains to run on the line, the frequency of services will be constrained because of the single-track bottleneck at East Kilbride. A large part of the justification for investment in the line was founded on the need to increase capacity for commuters from the vast new housing developments being built around East Kilbride. The housing developments are being built but the capacity of the rail network is not being and cannot be increased sufficiently to match. This ought to be a major scandal but, alas, we have become so accustomed to wasteful public spending and ill-considered projects that it has gone almost unremarked. Alistair Stewart, Kirkcaldy. Selective with Scripture Doug Clark, writing about the opening of the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland (Letters, May 17), takes the opportunity to also criticise Christianity and indeed Christ. Of course, it is easy to criticise an organisation especially from outside it, although it is at least helpful when the organisation in question reports its own failings. Beyond that he uses a peculiar if not naïve hermeneutic to support his wider arguments. It reminds one of the person who thought he might find guidance in the Bible by opening it at random and putting his finger on the page. At the first attempt he read 'Judas went out and hanged himself'. Not being satisfied with that he thought he would try again only to find, 'go and do likewise'. Lifting texts without regard for context is not to be recommended ether for guidance or argument. The Bible is an altogether more sophisticated document than that. Now Christianity is indeed exclusive in one sense but inclusive in a much wider sense, witness John 3: 16 "God so loved the world that he gave his one and only son, (Christ) that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life", a better-known and easier-understood verse than those that were quoted. J Spence, Airdrie. Look, listen and learn Anent recent correspondence about political buzzwords, my older daughter pointed out that politicians frequently begin their non-answers with "Look". Sure enough, my daily e-newspaper includes an interview with the Prime Minister, whose response to a question begins with "Look". The practice spreads. The Rangers manager's answer to the first question in his post-match interview on Saturday (May 17) began with "Look". "Listen" is another instruction often directed at interviewers by, in particular, football managers. My impulsive response in my imaginary role of interviewer would be: " How dare you tell me to look or listen?" Then again... David Miller, Milngavie. Give TV ads a miss I agree wholeheartedly with the comments of Denis Bruce (Letters, May 19) regarding the utter crassness of many of today's TV commercials. There is however a simple solution. Use a TV recording device. Whether purchased outright or as part of a subscription package, this device allows the viewer to record all TV programmes that they might wish to watch. Once recorded you can fast forward through those dreadful ads. Another benefit is that you can watch your favourite programmes whenever it suits and you can pause whenever you fancy that wee cuppa (or a wee hauf). David Clark, Tarbolton. • I completely agree with Denis Bruce about the abysmal state of TV advertising, regardless of the products being sold. A quick look at any of the 1960s and 70s advertising compilations on YouTube will show how far TV advertising has fallen, from works of art by directors like Ridley Scott, which also essentially sold the product, to the artless, stupid and witless rubbish that fills the commercial breaks now, a great reason for recording and fast-forwarding. Stuart Neville, Clydebank. Britain's 2025 Eurovision representatives, Remember Monday (Image: PA) What the hell was that? Is it any wonder that What the Hell Happened?, the UK entry for the Eurovision Song Contest flopped ("Remember Monday say Eurovision gave 'lifelong memories'", The Herald, May 19)? It was so bad it wouldn't make the playlist in my local Co-op, and that's saying something. The whole show is so bad Keith Richards sitting on stage smoking a Benson and Hedges would probably have won it. Allan Sutherland, Stonehaven.
NBC News
17-05-2025
- NBC News
New standards for Oklahoma high school students promote misinformation about the 2020 election
OKLAHOMA CITY — Oklahoma high school students studying U.S. history learn about the Industrial Revolution, women's suffrage and America's expanding role in international affairs. Beginning next school year, they will add conspiracy theories about the 2020 presidential election. Oklahoma's new social studies standards for K-12 public school students, already infused with references to the Bible and national pride, were revised at the direction of state School Superintendent Ryan Walters. The Republican official has spent much of his first term in office lauding President Donald Trump, feuding with teachers unions and local school superintendents, and trying to end what he describes as 'wokeness' in public schools. 'The left has been pushing left-wing indoctrination in the classroom,' Walters said. 'We're moving it back to actually understanding history ... and I'm unapologetic about that.' The previous standard for studying the 2020 election merely said, 'Examine issues related to the election of 2020 and its outcome.' The new version is more expansive: 'Identify discrepancies in 2020 elections results by looking at graphs and other information, including the sudden halting of ballot-counting in select cities in key battleground states, the security risks of mail-in balloting, sudden batch dumps, an unforeseen record number of voters, and the unprecedented contradiction of 'bellwether county' trends.' The new standard raised red flags even among Walters' fellow Republicans, including the governor and legislative leaders. They were concerned that several last-minute changes, including the language about the 2020 election and a provision stating the source of the Covid virus was a Chinese lab, were added just hours before the state school board voted on them. A group of parents and educators have filed a lawsuit asking a judge to reject the standards, arguing they were not reviewed properly and that they 'represent a distorted view of social studies that intentionally favors an outdated and blatantly biased perspective.' GOP lawmakers can't muster enough support to reject the new standards While many Oklahoma teachers have expressed outrage at the change in the standards, others say they leave plenty of room for an effective teacher to instruct students about the results of the 2020 election without misinforming them. Aaron Baker, who has taught U.S. government in high schools in Oklahoma City for more than a decade, said he's most concerned about teachers in rural, conservative parts of the state who might feel encouraged to impose their own beliefs on students. 'If someone is welcoming the influence of these far-right organizations in our standards and is interested in inserting more of Christianity into our practices as teachers, then they've become emboldened,' Baker said. 'For me, that is the major concern.' Leaders in the Republican-led Oklahoma Legislature introduced a resolution to reject the standards, but there wasn't enough GOP support to pass it. Part of that hesitation likely stemmed from a flurry of last-minute opposition organized by pro-Trump conservative groups such as Moms for Liberty, which has a large presence in Oklahoma and threatened lawmakers who reject the standards with a primary opponent. 'In the last few election cycles, grassroots conservative organizations have flipped seats across Oklahoma by holding weak Republicans accountable,' the group wrote in a letter signed by several other conservative groups and GOP activists. 'If you choose to side with the liberal media and make backroom deals with Democrats to block conservative reform, you will be next.' Superintendent says his new standards 'encourage critical thinking' After a group of parents, educators and other Oklahoma school officials worked to develop the new social studies standards, Walters assembled an executive committee consisting mostly of out-of-state pundits from conservative think-tanks to revise them. He said he wanted to focus more on American exceptionalism and incorporate the Bible as an instructional resource. Among those Walters appointed to the review committee are Kevin Roberts, the president of The Heritage Foundation and a key figure in its Project 2025 blueprint for a conservative administration, and Dennis Prager, a radio talk show host who founded Prager U, a conservative nonprofit that offers 'pro-American' educational materials for children that some critics say are not accurate or objective. In a statement to The Associated Press, Walters defended teaching students about 'unprecedented and historically significant' elements of the 2020 presidential election. 'The standards do not instruct students on what to believe; rather, they encourage critical thinking by inviting students to examine real events, review publicly available information, and come to their own conclusions,' he said. Recounts, reviews and audits in the battleground states where Trump contested his loss all confirmed Democrat Joe Biden's victory, and Trump lost dozens of court cases challenging the results. Critics say Walters' new standard is filled with misleading phrasing that seeks to steer the discussion in particular direction. Democrats characterized it as another political ploy by Walters, widely viewed as a potential candidate for governor in 2026, at the expense of school children. 'It's harmful posturing and political theater that our kids do not need to be subjected to,' said Sen. Mark Mann, a Democrat from Oklahoma City who previously served on the school board for one of the state's largest districts. Concerns about politicizing school standards National experts on education standards also expressed alarm, noting that Oklahoma has historically ranked highly among the states for its standards. Brendan Gillis, the director of teaching and learning at the American Historical Association who oversaw a research project that analyzed standards in all 50 states, said Oklahoma's social studies standards had been 'quite good' until the latest version. In addition to concerns about election misinformation, Gillis added: 'There was also a lot of biblical content that was sort of shoehorned in throughout the existing standards.' He said a lot of the references to Christianity and the Bible misinterpreted the history of the country's founding and lacked historical nuance. David Griffith, a research director at the Thomas B. Fordham Institute, a conservative-leaning education think-tank, said he was not aware of any other states that have tried to promote election misinformation in their curriculum standards. He called the new standards an 'unfortunate' departure from Oklahoma's traditionally strong social studies standards. 'It is just inappropriate to promote conspiracy theories about the election in standards,' he said.
Economist
15-05-2025
- Economist
Europe's attempts to police speech test its liberal credentials
Should the Finnish Lutheran church sponsor the Pride parade, a festival of rainbow flags and sexual inclusivity? Many might argue that a staid institution would do well to show prospective parishioners that it has kept up with the times. Paivi Rasanen is not among them. A staunch conservative, mother of five and member of parliament since 1995, she questioned on social media whether the church endorsing Pride was compatible with the Bible's teachings on sin and shame. An accompanying picture of some of the book's less tolerant passages made clear her own conclusions. That was in 2019. The temerity of her questioning has resulted in six years of police investigations, prosecution, trials and the threat of a hefty fine.
