Another foreign judge quits Hong Kong's highest court amid national security crackdown
HONG KONG, April 11 (Reuters) - An Australian judge became the latest foreigner to resign from Hong Kong's highest court before the end of his term on Friday as a security crackdown fans international criticism of a perceived erosion of the rule of law in the financial hub.
Robert French, a former Chief Justice of Australia's High Court, said he respected Hong Kong and the "integrity and independence" of the remaining foreign judges but that the "role of the non permanent justices on the Court of Final Appeal has become increasingly anachronistic and arguably cosmetic."
Britain and China agreed to have non-permanent foreign judges on the court when London handed its former colony over to Chinese rule in 1997 under a "one country, two systems" formula.
Their presence was widely seen by lawyers, businesses and politicians as burnishing the city's rule-of-law credentials after it lost access to Britain's Privy Council for appeals.
Noting that the Hong Kong court was the only one in greater China to have foreign judges serving, French said there "may be a substantive role for international judges in Hong Kong in the future as part of an international commercial court."
The government confirmed the resignation in a statement, saying it was grateful to French for his valuable contributions and his "support for the rule of law in Hong Kong."
Last year, another non-permanent judge, Britain's Jonathan Sumption, quit the court shortly after a landmark verdict in which 14 prominent democratic activists were convicted for subversion, part of a national security crackdown on dissent.
Sumption said Hong Kong's rule of law had been " profoundly compromised" and the city was "slowly becoming a totalitarian state."
The number of foreign judges on Hong Kong's Court of Final Appeal (CFA) has fallen from around 13 to five in recent years, with some raising concerns at the imposition of a sweeping national security law.
In his statement to Reuters, French said he rejected any suggestion that foreign judges serving on the CFA were "somehow complicit in the application ... of national security laws or somehow confer on them a spurious legitimacy."
Hong Kong's chief justice is allowed to select one foreign judge - typically retired top jurists from Britain, Australia and Canada - to serve on the five-person Court of Final Appeal at any one time.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
South African assets sink on risk aversion after Israel's strike on Iran
JOHANNESBURG, June 13 (Reuters) - South Africa's rand and government bonds fell steeply in early trade on Friday, after Israeli military strikes on Iran drove investors toward safe havens. At 0657 GMT, the risk-sensitive rand traded at 18.04 against the dollar , 1.6% weaker than Thursday's close. The rand had been on a strong run for weeks, helped by local coalition partners resolving a budget dispute, talk of a lower inflation target and strong precious metal prices. The escalation in hostilities in the Middle East - a major oil-producing region - adds a fresh layer of uncertainty for financial markets at a time of pressure on the global economy from U.S. President Donald Trump's erratic trade policies. No major domestic data releases are due on Friday, but next week local consumer inflation (ZACPIY=ECI), opens new tab and retail sales (ZARET=ECI), opens new tab figures will be published. The yield on South Africa's benchmark 2035 government bond was up 16.5 basis points to 10.25%.
Scottish Sun
3 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Israel v Iran LIVE: Middle East braced for all-out war as Tehran's nuke sites hit by missiles & top generals killed
FIRE & FURY Israel v Iran LIVE: Middle East braced for all-out war as Tehran's nuke sites hit by missiles & top generals killed THE Middle East stands on the brink of all-out war after Israel unleashed a massive wave of missile strikes on Iranian soil. Israeli forces targeted Tehran's nuclear facilities and killed top military and scientific figures in a lightning offensive dubbed Operation Rising Lion. 3 Smoke rises up after an explosion in Tehran, Iran on Friday Credit: AP 3 Smoke rises from a damaged building in the aftermath of Israeli strikes Credit: Reuters 3 A building in Tehran hit in an Israeli strike on the Iranian capital early in the morning Credit: AFP In a ferocious show of force, around 200 Israeli fighter jets roared across Iranian skies early Friday, dropping 330 munitions on 100 high-value targets, including uranium enrichment plants and key command centres. The Israeli military called the blitz a 'pre-emptive, precise, combined offensive based on high-quality intelligence' and confirmed it had struck nuclear and missile sites across the country. The IDF said in a statement: 'Dozens of IAF jets completed the first stage that included strikes on dozens of military targets, including nuclear targets in different areas of Iran.' Iran has vowed "severe punishment", calling the strikes a 'cowardly' act of aggression as fears mount of a devastating counterstrike. In a fiery statement, Tehran said the assault 'shows why Iran insists on enrichment, nuclear technology, and missile power,' framing the attack as proof of its need for deterrence. A 'special state of emergency' is now in effect in Israel. Air raid sirens blared across the country in the early hours, with residents jolted awake by alerts warning of an imminent missile and drone attack. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called the assault vital to "roll back the Iranian threat to Israel's very survival", vowing the campaign would last 'as many days as it takes to remove the threat.' He accused Tehran of advancing toward a nuclear weapon, claiming Iran had enriched enough uranium for 'nine atom bombs.' 'In recent months, Iran has taken steps that it has never taken before – steps to weaponize this enriched uranium,' Netanyahu said. 'This is a clear and present danger to Israel's very survival.' Explosions rocked military sites northeast of Tehran, including the Mahalati complex. Revolutionary Guard commander Hossein Salami, top nuclear scientist Fereydoun Abbasi, theoretical physicist Dr Mohammed Mehdi Tehranchi, and Major General Gholam Ali Rashid were among those killed. Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei accused Israel of targeting residential areas, saying: 'In the enemy's attacks, a number of commanders and scientists were martyred. 'Their successors and colleagues will immediately continue their duties.' The International Atomic Energy Agency confirmed the Natanz nuclear facility was struck and said it was in contact with Iranian officials regarding radiation concerns. U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio insisted Washington was not involved, though he said 'necessary steps' were being taken to protect American personnel in the region. 'Let me be clear: Iran should not target US interests or personnel,' Rubio warned. He backed Israel's right to self-defence, saying it 'believes the strikes are necessary.' Stay up to date with the latest on Israel vs Iran with The Sun's live blog
Daily Mirror
6 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Everything we know as explosions boom across large city and conflict escalates
The potential for an all-out war between Israel and Iran has increased today after Benjamin Netanyahu's country this morning attacked Tehran, which is Iran's capital Israel has today attacked Iran's capital Tehran - targeting the country's nuclear programme. General Hossein Salami, the commander-in-chief of Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), was killed during Israel's overnight strikes. Air-raid sirens rang out as Israel declared a state of emergency, following the violent attacks on several nuclear and military sites across Tehran and surrounding areas. The potential for an all-out war between two bitter Middle East adversaries has increased as tensions were already high over Tehran's rapidly advancing nuclear programme. "This is not a one-day attack," an Israeli military source told CNN, describing the attacks as "preemptive, precise, combined offensive". Fatalities and injuries are likely, though exact figures for each have yet to be confirmed by authorities. Iran has temporarily closed its airspace over Tehran, and all departures and arrivals have been suspended at Israel's Ben Gurion Airport, which is near Tel Aviv. Black smoke seen over Iran's main nuclear enrichment facility Black smoke rose today over Iran's main nuclear enrichment facility at Natanz, though it wasn't clear how bad the damage was. Iranian state television briefly showed the live picture with a reporter. Natanz is partially above ground, partially below ground, with multiple halls of centrifuges spinning uranium gas for its nuclear program. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had said Israel targeted the site in Friday's attack. Natanz previously has been targeted by the Stuxnet cyberattack and multiple sabotage campaigns likely carried out by Israel. Australia and New Zealand condemn strikes Australia and New Zealand's governments have condemned the Israeli strikes. Australian Foreign Minister Penny Wong said she was 'alarmed by the escalation' between Israel and Iran, which she said risked further destabilizing an already volatile region. New Zealand's Prime Minister Christopher Luxon said the strikes were 'a huge concern' for his government and 'potentially catastrophic' for the Middle East. 'The risk of miscalculation is high,' he said. The two countries were among five that enacted travel and financial sanctions on two far-right Israeli government ministers Wednesday, accusing them of 'inciting extremist violence' against Palestinians in the Israeli-occupied West Bank. Iranian state TV says head of Revolutionary Guard is feared dead Iranian state television says the head of Iran's paramilitary Revolutionary Guard, General Hossein Salami, is feared dead after an Israeli attack. It added that one other top Guard official, as well as two nuclear scientists, were also feared dead. The report offered few other details. Iran's Revolutionary Guard, created after its 1979 Islamic Revolution, is one of the main power centres within the country's theocracy. It also controls Iran's arsenal of ballistic missiles, which it has used to attack Israel twice during the ongoing Israel-Hamas war in the Gaza Strip. Headquarters of Iran's paramilitary Revolutionary Guard is ablaze An Israeli attack on Iran has set the headquarters of Iran's paramilitary Revolutionary Guard ablaze, state television reported Friday. A reporter on air said he was unable to get closer due to the intensity of the fire in Iran's capital, Tehran. Multiple sites in the capital had been hit in the attack, which Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said targeted both sites of and officials leading Iran's nuclear program and its ballistic missile arsenal.
