Vatican pays millions in legal costs to British banker caught up in ‘trial of the century'
It was the first time the Vatican had faced trial in the English courts in its 2,000-year history.
The Holy See had claimed Mr Mincione committed fraud by inflating the price when his companies sold the former Harrods property to the Vatican in 2018 to convert into luxury apartments.
The financier and his legal team claimed he was the victim of a 'witch hunt' where the legal goalposts were moved to secure his conviction in a trial in Italy.
After ruling in his favour, the UK court has now ordered the Vatican to make an immediate payment to Mr Mincione of £1.5m 'within weeks', with further payments to be made following detailed assessment.
Mr Mincione said: 'I am proud as a British citizen that these matters have finally been examined by a truly independent judicial system which has exonerated me of dishonesty, fraud or conspiracy.
'I am grateful that the English judge has awarded us millions of pounds in legal costs, reflecting the true winners and losers of this sorry case.
'For the first time, I am also pleased to share the opinion of the Vatican City State's chief prosecutor Alessandro Diddi when he previously said he was satisfied by the findings in this case.
'The Vatican trial was originally an attempt to deflect attention from its own incompetence, but it quickly became a witch-hunt. I am still a Catholic and I believe that my Church should be and can be better than this.'
In his judgment on the case, Mr Justice Robin Knowles granted 29 of the 31 declarations sought by Mr Mincione in his legal action against the Vatican.
It accepted independent expert evidence that the value of £275 million for the Harrods warehouse was a supportable market value for the property before the transaction in 2018.
However, the judge criticised Mr Mincione for failing to act in good faith in their communications with the Vatican, saying he had not been frank about the £275 million valuation and 'was misleading by reference to the sources available to him and in context'.
The Vatican, a Catholic enclave in the centre of Rome, often avoids legal action in foreign jurisdictions by claiming sovereign immunity.
The defence of sovereign immunity was not, however, available to the Vatican in the case of 60 Sloane Avenue, the central London property at the centre of the dispute, because the dispute relates to a commercial transaction.
During the trial in the Vatican, it emerged the late Pope Francis had authorised secret wiretaps, including of a cardinal, during the investigation. The extraordinary powers allowed investigators to bug phones, intercept emails and arrest anyone they wanted without seeking prior approval from a judge.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
2 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Man and woman mauled by ‘Bully-type dog' in horror attack at home as cops seize three pets
DOG ATTACK Man and woman mauled by 'Bully-type dog' in horror attack at home as cops seize three pets Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A MAN and a woman were mauled by a "Bully-type dog" in a horror attack at a home — with police confirming they have seized three dogs from the scene. The man, in his 30s, and the woman, in her 20s, suffered serious injuries after a horrific dog attack in Blackpool on Havelock Street, at 2.38am on June 15. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up Both individuals were rushed to hospital, where they are currently receiving treatment. Police have seized the bully-type dog involved in the vicious attack, along with two other dogs that were at the scene. It comes after a "monster" seven-and-a-half stone XL Bully mauled three young girls, dragging one across the floor and biting her down to the bone. Mum Victoria Hewitt was at home with her two children, aged eight and four, as well as an 11-year-old friend of the kids when family pet Karma suddenly flipped. A knock at the door resulted in the dog acting in a "very aggressive and violent way" and she "went" for the eight-year-old, a court heard. During the incident in Costessey, Norfolk, Hewitt, 42, tried to distract the animal with some ham but it didn't work, prosecutor Chris Youell said. Instead, Karma began attacking the child as the other two screamed, before it targeted them too, reports Eastern Daily Press. The girls ran for the door and were all bitten before Hewitt managed to wrestle the dog away. The eight-year-old managed to flee upstairs with her toddler brother, aged two, who was in his cot during the attack on March 7 last year. A neighbour helped Hewitt restrain Karma and held her on the floor, telling everyone to get out. When cops arrived on the scene, the mum screamed at them to "shoot the dog". The three girls suffered bite and puncture wounds which needed medical treatment. The eight-year-old had "significant" injuries, including a deep wound down to the bone on her arm, the court heard. The dog had previously belonged to an ex partner of Hewitt's who had left it with her. Which dog breeds are banned in the UK? THERE are specific regulations in place that prohibit certain dog breeds from being owned or bred in the UK. THERE are specific regulations in place that prohibit certain dog breeds from being owned or bred in the UK. So what are the illegal dogs in the UK and why are they illegal? Here's what we know. Which dog breeds are illegal in the UK? People tend to think of large, vicious dogs when they imagine being bitten by one. But the truth is that many types of dogs are known to bite humans, whether provoked or not. However, it's important to remember that just because a breed tends to bite humans, that doesn't mean that they all do. British law determines five breeds of dog are illegal to own, breed, sell or give away. These are an XL Bully, Pit Bull Terrier, Japanese Tosa, Dogo Argentino and Fila Brasileiro. 1 The horrific dog attack took place on Havelock Street, Blackpool, at 2.38am on June 15 More to follow... For the latest news on this story keep checking back at The Sun Online is your go-to destination for the best celebrity news, real-life stories, jaw-dropping pictures and must-see video. Like us on Facebook at and follow us from our main Twitter account at @TheSun.
Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
The £2 coin worth an incredible £1,000 if it has an error
An expert shared exactly how to spot this valuable error coin An expert has urged people to keep an eye out for a rare £2 coin that could be worth £1,000. This piece, from 2014, is highly sought after by collectors due to a specific error. The coin was created to commemorate the start of the First World War. On its reverse (the tail side) it features the image of Lord Kitchener, the former British Secretary of State for War. While this may be 'easy to spot' in your change, it is only particularly valuable if it has the error. An expert, known online as the Coin Collecting Wizard, explained: 'The Lord Kitchener £2 coin from 2014 is easy to spot with its bold 'your country needs you' design. 'And most of them are only worth £2 but there's a rare error version that collectors go crazy for.' This error can be found on the obverse of the coin (the head side). He continued: 'On the Queen's side the words 'two pounds' are supposed to be there but on some they're completely missing. 'his little mistake turns an ordinary coin into something worth over £1,000. 'So next time you're checking your change take a proper look, you might just be holding a small fortune without even knowing it. Just remember it's only the rare mule error that's worth serious money - that means the coin must be completely missing the 'two pounds' wording on the Queen's side. 'If your coin has the full design with £2 clearly shown then it's just the standard version and worth exactly that, £2.' He issued a warning: 'Don't get caught out by listings online trying to sell the regular ones for silly prices, it's the error that makes the difference.' In February last year a misprinted Lord Kitchener £2 coin sold for a staggering £1,000 at auction. Prior to being sold it was authenticated by the Royal Mint, according to This Money. There have only been two reports of these error coins being found in circulation. Lockdales Auctioneers officiated the sale of one back in March 2020 to the value of £500.
Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Sir Mo Farah's real name and family after Team GB ace's 30-year secret was outed
Sir Mo Farah will always be known for his incredible performances at the London 2012 Olympic Games, but he shocked the world in 2022 for a completely different reason Sir Mo Farah's name will always be mentioned as one of Team GB's all-time legends at the Olympic Games. He won two gold medals in London in 2012 and two more at the Rio De Janeiro games four years later, captivating the sporting world on his way to a knighthood in 2017, where Queen Elizabeth II made him a Sir. He will be wearing an England shirt with 'Farah' emblazoned on the back when he steps onto the Old Trafford pitch for Soccer Aid this weekend. Yet, the name on the Three Lions shirt, the name that was pinned onto his running vest and the name next to his many records is not really his. In 2022, as part of the eye-opening BBC documentary 'The Real Mo Farah', the athlete revealed his name was not 'Mo Farah' and that he had been living under somebody else's identity. Farah, 42, revealed his real name was Hussein Abdi Kahin. When he was only four years old, Farah, who was originally from Somaliland, lost his father, who was killed while tending to his cattle by a piece of shrapnel from a bazooka blast during Somalia's civil war. After being sent to neighbouring Djibouti for his safety, Farah would eventually be illegally trafficked into the United Kingdom. A woman, whose identity is still unknown, pretended to be his mother and brought him to the UK under the premise that he would be staying with family. He was instructed to come into the country under the name Mo Farah - who was a different child - and was handed illegal documents. This dangerous process went through while he was only nine years old. He realised he had taken someone else's place at the airport when he saw a man wondering why his child had not arrived. When he got to the woman's flat, she tore up a piece of paper with his family's contact details on it and ordered him to look after the children of another family. He told the BBC: "If I wanted food in my mouth, my job was to look after those kids, shower them, cook for them, clean for them. She said, 'If you ever wanna see your family again, don't say anything.' Often I would just lock myself in the bathroom and cry." At the age of 11, Farah enrolled into Feltham Community College. Teachers and other staff at the school were told he was a refugee from Somalia. His form tutor Sarah Rennie said Farah was, "unkempt and uncared for" and "emotionally and culturally alienated," largely due to the lack of English he spoke. It was during PE lessons when the teachers realised he was an athletics prodigy. Alan Watkinson, Farah's PE teacher, said: "The only language he seemed to understand was the language of PE and sport." Watkinson would go on to contact social services who managed to find another family from Somalia to foster him. Mr Watkinson helped him gain British citizenship under the name Mohamed Farah, which was granted in 2000. From that point onwards, Farah developed as a person and an athlete, going on to become a four-time Olympic gold medallist and a six-time world champion. When Farah was sent away, he had to leave his mother Aisha and two brothers, who all live on a farm in Somaliland. Farah met his now-wife Tania Nell while at university in West London. Together they have four children, Rhianna, Hussein Mo, Amani and Aisha Farah. Incredibly, in the documentary, Farah also met the real Mohamed Farah over a video call. However, The Sun claimed the athlete had to break contact with him and change his phone number, after he was allegedly hounded for money by the man and around ten others who had got hold of his number.
