ICMSA claims commission's Dublin briefing on Mercosur was ‘worse than useless'
The Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers' Association (ICMSA) has strong criticised the outcome of a briefing to Irish farmers by the European Commission, held in Dublin, on the Mercosur trade deal describing it as 'worse than useless'.
The president of ICMSA, Denis Drennan, said that 'whether deliberately or inadvertently' commission officials had not allowed adequate time to deal with the questions posed by ICMSA and others.
He said farmer representatives had travelled to Dublin 'without the opportunity to even ask the vital questions- much less receive a detailed answer'.
Drennan said: 'Farmers are the most sector within the EU that will be most impacted by Mercosur and because farming and agri generally play such a disproportionate role in Irish life there's a good argument for saying that Irish farmers would be the single most affected sector in the EU by the disaster that will be Mercosur.
'That being the case, we would have thought that the very least we are entitled to is sufficient time to ask and have answered the serious questions that the importance of the meeting absolutely merited'.
European Commission representatives have not commented on the ICMSA's criticism.
ICMSA
According to the ICMSA president farmers received an 'unsatisfactory presentation that was over with without any opportunity to ask even the most basic questions that Irish farmers demand are answered' in relation to the briefing from European Commission representatives.
The ICMSA has compiled a list of questions which it believes remained to be answered in relation to the Mercosur deal. Drennan said these include:
How can the EU Commission guarantee that an animal did not get growth promoters?
What are the sanctions for a country if growth promoters found?
Does the EU Commission accept that the 'cattle traceability system in Mercosur countries is inferior' and how will it ensure that beef from only approved cattle will enter the EU food chain?
How many staff will the EU Commission have at meat plants/on the ground to ensure the agreement is implemented correctly?
In the EUDR, the EU Commission have implemented a complex system for EU farmers to comply with, will the same rules apply to Mercusor farmers and how will the EU Commission verify their data?
If a steak arrives in the EU, how will the EU Commission know that it did not come from deforested areas?
What are the labelling requirements for Mercosur beef and how will a consumer know if they are consuming it?
The proposed €1 billion compensation fund – what is the funding source, is it from CAP or is it additional funding and how will it be triggered and how will the funding be distributed?
The ICMSA president also said that European Commission officials should be in a position to answer questions on these issues and said that it believes the outcome of the Dublin briefing 'only serve to compound and increase farmer anxieties'.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Daily Mirror
24 minutes ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Ireland goalscorer Saoirse Noonan on 'surreal' Páirc Uí Chaoimh homecoming
Saoirse Noonan described her Páirc Uí Chaoimh goals as 'surreal' - as the former Cork Gaelic footballer marked her return to her hometown venue in spectacular style. It wasn't enough to earn Ireland the margin of victory needed to secure automatic promotion to League A, as the Girls in Green needed to beat Slovenia by four to leapfrog them into top spot. But with a promotion/relegation play-off still to come in October against one of Austria, Iceland, Belgium or Denmark, Ireland will have a second bite of the cherry. And if they can follow Noonan's lead, and make it second time lucky, then Carla Ward's side can look forward to top-tier football next year in the World Cup qualifiers. The Celtic striker didn't score when she represented Cork at the iconic Leeside stadium in 2020, in a league match against Westmeath, but she found the net on Tuesday evening. 'It was a bit surreal,' she said of her goal. 'Obviously my first competitive start so I was just trying to find my feet, ease my way into the game and not get caught up in the moment. 'It's unbelievable, I'm absolutely delighted.' She added: 'Obviously the first thing was to go out and win the game but the bigger picture, we obviously wanted to get the goals. 'We started off well, that's something that we've spoken about the last few days, I think we did that. We had a lot of chances, possession, we played really well. 'They're a good team, at least we got the win and it's something we can build on going forward.' Ireland had plenty of chances to add to that lead before half-time, while they continued to create openings after the break. However, they couldn't break down Slovenia's stubborn resistance. 'I think we thought, a 1-0 lead, can we get another one before half time? That was the focus,' said Noonan. 'We were pushing, we were unlucky, one or two decisions we could have made better. 'Look, it's about building. This team is good, we're working hard every day, we're growing - you can see the growth. 'From the first time Carla came in to now, even for myself, I feel like each camp and each day, you feel like you're getting better.' As for playing again in Páirc Uí Chaoimh, she said: 'To come back wearing a different shirt, it's the same feeling, you're representing something you're really proud of. It's phenomenal.' Meanwhile, Ireland coach Ward confirmed that centre-half Anna Patton would have to sit out the first-leg of the play-off through suspension. She added that the performance last night, although lacking in the goals needed to top the group, offered much to build on ahead of the play-offs. Next up for Ireland is a friendly double-header away to the USA at the end of the month. 'We are still building,' said Ward. 'Through this entire campaign we have had five training sessions with the entire squad, so to build the way we are and to finish the way we did, I could not ask for more. 'A couple of more goals? Yes. But we got to be proud of that performance. That was an Irish performance.' Describing the performance against Slovenia, the former Aston Villa boss added: 'Probably the way I'd put it would be a Carla Ward team on the ball and an Irish mentality off the ball. 'That's what we need to build on. We have to build on. 'If we want to play in an exciting way going forward, and that's the way I like my teams to play, we have to be better off the ball. And that was the start of it tonight. 'Now we go to the US and play the best in the world and try to continue that work, but there is still a lot of work to do. 'What it does do is put us in a position to build. And I said to the group; that's something, firstly, you can be proud of, secondly, that you can build upon and, thirdly, if we can combine the two, the future is bright.'
The 42
40 minutes ago
- The 42
Ireland beat Slovenia at Páirc Uí Chaoimh but fall short of four-goal win needed for top spot
Republic of Ireland 1 Slovenia 0 AT THE FINAL whistle, Slovenia celebrated wildly. Ireland won the game, but not the war. A frst-half goal from Cork history-maker Saoirse Noonan wasn't enough at Páirc Uí Chaoimh as the hosts fell short of the four-goal win needed to steal top spot and secure Nations League promotion. Carla Ward's side went for it, but instead navigate the play-offs in October as they chase promotion to League A. They'll learn their fate in Friday's draw, a third-place League A team lying in wait. As Saša Kolman and his players revelled in their incredible achievement — thanks to a 4-0 win in Koper in February — the Irish squad huddled quietly and paid tribute to the retiring Louise Quinn. Much of the 9,433 fans stayed around on a windy night on Leeside to do so too. They hailed their home heroes Noonan, Denise O'Sullivan and Megan Connolly as they circled the pitch, the GAA markings still visible, and points covered on the scoreboard. Ward said Ireland would go gung-ho, and that they did. She made four changes from Friday's 2-1 comeback win over Türkiye, three of them attacking, and gave Katie McCabe full licence to go forward. One addition, Cork's own Noonan broke the deadlock in the 19th minute. The first sportsperson to play a competitive inter-county Gaelic football match and soccer international in the Páirc, Noonan headed home her second international goal after a superb delivery from Jessie Stapleton, moved out to right-back on the night. Ireland had been piling on the pressure through an encouraging start against a stiff breeze; Noonan's first chance cleared off the line amidst a raft of early corners. Anna Patten was among the others to go close, but Slovenia still held a threat on the counter. Abbie Larkin and Emily Murphy danced out wide, the former and Megan Connolly testing Zala Meršnik and finding their range from distance, while McCabe sent in some delicious deliveries, before Ireland hit the front. Slovenia looked rattled as the one-way traffic continued, and did their utmost to frustrate. Maja Sternad was booked for a cynical foul on the clearly-targetted McCabe, while manager Saša Kolman also saw yellow on the line. Advertisement Kyra Carusa, Murphy and Patten probably should have done better with chances from corners — Connolly and McCabe on song from the set-piece — and the returning centre-forward saw a penalty shout waved away for a clear push from Meršnik. But the Slovenian transitional threat remained; Courtney Brosnan stepping up with a huge save to deny Lara Prasnikar on the cusp of half time. The Eintracht Frankfurt star really should have done better one-on-one, having exposed the Irish defence, not for the first time. Caitlin Hayes, making her first start under Ward, did bring further solidity, however. Ireland would have liked to have been more than one goal to the better at the break, but they will have been encouraged by their efforts through the chaos. Hometown hero Denise O'Sullivan grew into the game more and more on the restart, but Ireland struggled to string together as many chances. That wasn't helped by the stop-start nature of the contest, Slovenia doing their utmost to slow matters down with cynical challenges and unnecessary bookings. Just after the hour-mark, the Megan Campbell siren sounded. The long-throw specialist was introduced alongside Amber Barrett, and both looked to impact quickly. Hayes headed a Campbell slingshot over the bar, and the lively Murphy skied a golden chance after being played through by Barrett. The Newcastle United forward later drew a good save after cutting in from the left. Slovenia were living off scraps, but fired warning shots here and there. Brosnan dealt with all sent her way. With 10 minutes to play, the retiring Louise Quinn was thrown into the action alongside Marissa Sheva. It was anticipated the towering centurion would be sent up top as Ireland chased more goals, but she went centre-back. They kept knocking — and kept Meršnik on her toes — but couldn't add to Noonan's early effort. And amidst handbags down the stretch, Patten picked up her second yellow of the campaign, meaning she is suspended for the first leg of the play-offs. IRELAND: Courtney Brosnan; Jessie Stapleton (Megan Campbell 62), Anna Patten, Caitlin Hayes, Katie McCabe; Emily Murphy, Megan Connolly, Denise O'Sullivan, Abbie Larkin (Louise Quinn 80); Saoirse Noonan (Amber Barrett 62), Kyra Carusa (Marissa Sheva 80). SLOVENIA: Zala Meršnik; Lana Golob, Sara Agrež; Kaja Korošec, Dominika Čonč; Lara Prašnikar; Špela Kolbl, Sara Makovec, Kaja Eržen; Zara Kramžar, Maja Sternad (Nina Kajzba, 68) Referee: Miriama Bockova (Slovakia).
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
‘Livelihoods are at stake': High Court to decide this week on lifting of Skellig Michael boats suspension
A High Court judge has said he will decide this week whether or not to lift a suspension on boating permits needed to ferry people to and from Skellig Michael, saying 'people's livelihoods are at stake'. The permits have not been issued while legal proceedings are before the courts in the form of a judicial review of the tendering process. At the High Court on Tuesday, Mr Justice Garrett Simons said he was 'staggered' by the assertion by lawyers for the Office of Public Works (OPW) that it would need six months to prepare the case. He ordered the case would be heard next month and would get 'top priority'. READ MORE The granting of permits to successful applicants is on hold pending a judicial review taken against the OPW by two companies who were unsuccessful in their applications to the government body for the 2025 season, which runs from May to the end of September. The OPW had run a competition in late 2024 to award 15 boating permits for summer 2025 to serve the Co Kerry island, which was chosen as a film location for the Star Wars movies The Force Awakens and The Last Jedi. The OPW has said that under Irish and EU law it was precluded from issuing permits for the 2025 summer season until legal proceedings were resolved. Skellig Michael Boat Trips and Atlantic Endeavour Limited both dispute the process underpinning the granting of the licences, alleging it to be 'deficient' and 'without transparency'. They have been granted permission for the challenge. David Dodd, for the plaintiffs, told Mr Justice Simons nobody wanted the boats not to visit the island. He said permits could be granted by the court in an interim fashion and the issuing of a one-season permit was not a 'contract' as contended by the OPW. Mr Dodd said he was resisting a suggested 'five-year framework' on the OPW's granting of the permits as part of a contract, but the plaintiffs also wanted to see the boats out. He said the OPW in applying to the court to have the suspension lifted had referred to a 'contract' having to be in place for the boats to take to sea. There should be no such 'contract' and permits issued were akin to planning permission or a gun permit being granted, neither or which, he said, were 'contracts' nor necessitated frameworks. A permit is a statutory one without an offer or an acceptance as found in a contract, he said. Whether or not this granting amounted to a 'contract' was a matter for the full hearing of the main case, Mr Dodd said. 'We are happy, however, for the suspension to be lifted,' he said. Mr Justice Simons asked Andrew Beck SC, for the OPW, how it was looking for six months to prepare for this 'most straightforward case of competition for licences'. Mr Beck said there was discovery of documents needed, amendments to make and a possible issue around cross-examination. The judge said he was 'staggered' the case would take up to six months to get on. Mr Justice Simons said he would rule on Thursday whether or not he would lift the suspension of the permits. He adjourned the main hearing to July 21st.
