Councillor told to resign after heated backlash to 'First Nations snub' - but he says there's more to the story
A South Australian council has turned on one of its own after a councillor was accused of walking out of Acknowledgement of Country speeches and a smoking ceremony.
Barossa Council last Tuesday voted in favour of a motion that councillor Bruce Preece resign without delay following four separate complaints about his politically incorrect behaviour.
The council brought in law firm Kelledy Jones to investigate the complaints at a cost to ratepayers of $47,000, the ABC reported.
The Kelledy Jones report found Mr Preece had walked out of Acknowledgement of Country speeches on five occasions and also during a smoking ceremony on Australia Day last year.
Another complaint involved him using the homophobic slur 'poofter' in a conversation about AFL player Jeremy Finlayson's suspension.
Barossa Council also ordered Mr Preece to publicly apologise and attend behavioural training, as per the report's recommendations.
Mr Preece said the investigation had been unfair and that he would appeal the matter to the state ombudsman.
'I believe one of the great pillars of Australian society and the way our country is run is that we have the rule of law, we have the principle that people are innocent until proven guilty and that those accused of wrongdoing are given procedural fairness in the ensuing investigations,' he said.
The report found Mr Preece walking out during five Acknowledgment of Country services in 2023 was deliberate and calculated.
A complainant said his actions were 'disruptive and contemptuous as well as disrespectful and discriminatory, on the basis that the Acknowledgement of Country is a public demonstration of respect to the First Nations of Australia and is a longstanding element of council's meeting procedure'.
The report also said he allegedly turned his back on a smoking ceremony at a 2024 Australia Day event being performed by Uncle Quentin Agius.
'For an extended period of time Cr Preece stood 'with his back facing the stage,' the complaint alleged.
The councillor was also alleged to have been heard by some attendees saying 'they shouldn't be allowed to have that smoke, they shouldn't be allowed to do that ... it's so wrong', 'it smells disgusting' and 'people can't breathe because of all that smoke'.
Another complaint alleged Mr Preece had blindsided the council by announcing to the local paper in December 2023 that he would be bringing in a motion to discontinue the Acknowledgements of Country at council events and meetings.
In response to the allegations, Mr Preece's lawyer said he had walked out of the Acknowledgements of Country to either get his reading glasses from his car or go to the bathroom, having recently had a battle with bowel cancer.
He said his client had turned his back on the smoking ceremony to assist an elderly woman who was coughing, and that, regarding the newspaper article, he was not required to 'foreshadow' raising a motion with other councillors.
Regarding the the homophobic slur, Mr Preece's lawyer said he was pursuing a 'stick and stones' type argument, but accepted the pursuit of the debate 'may not have been appropriate to the context and apologies for any offence caused'.
He made the comment ahead of a Gawler River Floodplain Management Authority meeting regarding Port Adelaide AFL player Jeremy Finlayson being suspended for saying the word 'poofter' on the field.
According to the complaint, Mr Preece was 'outraged' the word had caused the suspension and claimed he had been a victim of the same slur on the footy field, adding he was 'sick' of society telling him what was ok to say.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
One year after Hollywood producer said Sydney Sweeney is 'not pretty' and 'can't act', the actress appears to take subtle swipe at detractors
Sydney Sweeney, who was last year derided by a prominent female Hollywood producer for both her looks and her acting abilities, appears to have taken a subtle swipe at her detractor. The Anyone But You actress, 27, was publicly mocked by Carol Baum, whose films include Father of the Bride and Dead Ringers, on a New York stage in April 2024. Baum was in conversation with New York Times film critic Janet Maslin when she said the Euphoria star was 'not pretty' and 'can't act', while also labelling Sweeney's 2023 romcom 'unwatchable'. She later made a dramatic U-turn, however, saying that is isn't her style to be 'c**ping on an actor like that in public'. A spokesperson for Sweeney responded swiftly at the time, branding Baum 'shameful' for choosing to 'attack another woman', while the star's fans said it was an example of 'internal misogyny'. And, in an interview with The Times yesterday - published just over a year on from the debacle - Sweeney said: 'It's the women who give me the hardest time.' Sweeney neither named Baum nor referred directly to the shocking episode - but the comment nevertheless returned attention to Baum's very personal attack. The actress, who founded the production company Fifty-Fifty Films in 2020, suggested that people tend to assume she's less involved than she is. Sweeney told The Times: 'I have to be like, I want to be in the room, I want to sit in every single meeting and want to be involved in every decision, I want to be taken seriously as a producer.' She explained that she had learnt to be 'very direct' and 'very blunt' before adding: 'To be honest, actually, I always find that it's the women who give me the hardest time.' Last April, in the aftermath of Baum's criticisms, a representative for Sweeney told MailOnline: 'How sad that a woman in the position to share her expertise and experience chooses instead to attack another woman. 'If that's what she's learned in her decades in the industry and feels is appropriate to teach to her students, that's shameful. 'To unjustly disparage a fellow female producer speaks volumes about Ms Baum's character.' Baum was speaking with Maslin before an audience of fans when she made the comments following a screening of her 1988 film Dead Ringers starring Jeremy Irons. 'She's not pretty, she can't act,' said Baum, who later admitted that she had been inundated with hate mail from Sweeney's fans. 'There's an actress who everybody loves now – Sydney Sweeney. I don't get Sydney Sweeney.' Addressing her romcom Anything But You, in which she stars alongside Glen Powell, Baum continued: 'I was watching on the plane Sydney Sweeney's movie because I wanted to watch it. 'I wanted to know who she is and why everybody's talking about her. I watched this unwatchable movie – sorry to people who love this movie – [this] romantic comedy where they hate each other.' Referencing the producing class she teaches at the USC School of Cinematic Arts, Baum added: 'I said to my class, 'Explain this girl to me. She's not pretty, she can't act. Why is she so hot?'' 'Nobody had an answer but then the question was asked, 'Well if you could get your movie made because she was in it, would you do it?' 'I said, "well that's a really good a very hard question to answer because we all want to get the movie made and who walks away from a green light? Nobody I know. Your job is to get the movie made.' In yesterday's wide-ranging interview with The Times, Sweeney belatedly clarified the status of her relationship with fellow producer Jonathan Davino. The actress, who was seen without her engagement ring in February, came clean about the breakup when asked if she was planning a wedding. 'No,' was the answer. She answered 'yes,' when asked if she was single, adding: 'I'm learning a lot about myself, spending more time with my friends. And I'm loving it.' She and Davino, 41, had been together since 2018 and got engaged in 2022. He was a producer on her successful romcom, Anyone But You, co-starring Glen Powell. She and the 36-year-old Texan had such chemistry in the film that many wondered if they were a couple at the time - especially since they decided to lean into the spark while promoting the movie. 'Glenn and I adore each other, so I think we were so happy for the reception of the film,' she said, seeming to shut down any idea of a love connection. 'When you spend so much time with someone, you become close and you talk to each other about anything. 'So work, life, family, friends, he's just there for me. I'm there for him.' For now, Sweeney is happy to share snuggles and go on outdoor activities with her dogs Sully Bear and Tank, work on restoring vintage cars, and create a real estate empire. She already owns multi-million dollar homes in Los Angeles, South Florida and the Pacific Northwest. 'I'm obsessed with [property website] Zillow,' she explained. 'I'm learning a lot about myself, spending more time with my friends. And I'm loving it,' she told the outlet; Pictured with stylist Gigi Vittoria 'Right now I'm looking at New York, looking at Montana. Maine. Rhode Island. Texas, Italy, London — everywhere.' As she promotes Echo Valley, a mother-daughter drama co-starring Oscar winner Julianne Moore, the actress recognized a need to step away from working so much. 'I have to prove myself as a young woman, as an actor, as a businessperson — all of it,' she told the outlet. Regarding slowing down, The Handmaid's Tale actress said, 'I hear it more from my family than myself [they say] "Sydney, you're going to burn out. Sydney, you need to slow down. Sydney, you need to take a break".' Echo Valley debuts on Apple TV+ on June 13.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE The Logies invite list that's tearing the MAFS cast apart: Who will walk the red carpet and who has been snubbed REVEALED
This year's Married At First Sight cast are in a frenzy of panic ahead of the 2025 Logie Awards, after learning that only a small handful of them will be invited to attend the glittering ceremony. Set to take place on August 4 in Sydney, the event will once again be hosted by Channel Seven, leaving some Channel Nine stars sweating over their invite status. Daily Mail Australia can reveal that only a few of this year's breakout stars have made the cut, despite MAFS 2025 scoring strong ratings and widespread attention. Those tipped to attend include Jamie Marinos, Awhina Rutene, Rhi Disljenkovic, Jeff Gobbels, Tony Mojanovski, Ryan Donnelly, Carina Mirabile, Eliot Donovan, Beth Kelly and Teejay Halkias. All ten stars have remained in good standing with Nine and have been spotted at recent promotional events, making them the obvious choices to represent the show and network. From A-list scandals and red carpet mishaps to exclusive pictures and viral moments, subscribe to the DailyMail's new showbiz newsletter to stay in the loop. Should Channel Nine be feeling generous Katie Johnston and Ashleigh Ackerman will also be considered. Meanwhile, relationship experts John Aiken and Alessandra Rampolla will once again attend the awards to officially represent the series, while Mel Schilling has been invited but is yet to confirm her appearance. Insiders say the decision to limit the guest list has caused serious tension within the cast. 'Everyone's panicking and desperate to go,' one source told Daily Mail Australia. 'Some of them acted like saints during filming thinking it would secure them a Logies invite – now they're hearing they didn't make the cut and they're furious.' Those who've been left off the invite list include Morena Farina, Lauren Hall and Sierah Swepstone. Despite still being together, Jacqui Burfoot and Clint Rice won't be receiving an invite following their controversial stint on the show. Perth groom Paul Antoine, Tim Gromie, Adrian Araouzou and Veronica Cloherty also didn't make the list. 'There's already drama bubbling behind the scenes,' the insider continued. 'People are reaching out to stylists, PRs and brands trying to bluff their way in - but it's not happening.' The snubbing of certain cast members is a sharp reminder of last year's backlash, when only past participants Evelyn Ellis, Jules Robinson and Cameron Merchant were invited to the 2024 ceremony - with the rest of the MAFS cast allegedly being blacklisted by producers for proving 'too difficult' post-show. This year, it's clear that behaviour and ongoing cooperation with the network have played a major role in who made the cut. 'It's a reward system. If you've stayed on good terms with Nine, played ball, and showed up to events – you're in. If you've caused headaches or gone rogue, you're out.' With the Logies just weeks away, the cast are still anxiously waiting for final confirmations – but insiders say the current list is unlikely to change. It comes as comedian Sam Pang was confirmed to be returning as host for the third time in three years. Sam's cheeky and irreverent comedy as host last year and in 2023 proved to be a big hit with audiences and TV's A-list as well as a major ratings winner for Seven.
The Guardian
2 hours ago
- The Guardian
Is the cost-of-living crisis over? Victoria's new treasurer is optimistic, but housing remains a battleground
Victoria's new treasurer, Jaclyn Symes, is confident cost-of-living pressures will ease by the next election – and that voters will be less concerned about the state's soaring debt once they see the completed projects it has helped fund. In an exclusive interview with Guardian Australia after handing down her first budget in May, Symes also signalled openness to reforming stamp duty. But she hit back at industry groups like the Property Council, calling on them to move beyond criticising current policies and offer solutions: 'Saying, 'Don't do this,' that doesn't particularly help me. I have a policy brain, I like to find problems and fix them.' The upper house leader made history in becoming Victoria's first female treasurer after she was handpicked by the premier, Jacinta Allan, to take over from retiring Tim Pallas in December. Symes inherited a mountain of debt, and the recent budget forecasts it to climb even higher, to $194bn in 2028-29. That's up from just $21.8bn before Labor took office in 2014, after years of rapid public sector growth, major infrastructure spending, the pandemic and subsequent credit rating downgrades. Symes's first budget was sold as a turning point, delivering a $600m operating surplus and a slight drop in net debt relative to the state's economy. It also included unexpected federal windfalls, which Symes defended using to ease cost-of-living pressures – pointing to $18m for food relief as one of her proudest budget items. 'People have asked, 'Couldn't you have had a higher surplus?' Sure. But it wouldn't have felt very good knowing we're not supporting some of those services that people doing it really tough are relying on,' Symes says. Looking ahead to 2026 – the year of the next state election – Symes is optimistic that the cost-of-living crisis that has engulfed Australia will have eased. She says interest rates are coming down, housing supply is growing and, for the first time in years, wages are forecast to outpace inflation. Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email 'All the signs are there. But if we go too early and abandon the people that are still struggling, then I wouldn't feel very proud about that,' she says. She hopes that people will soon be 'feeling more confident and not worrying about the cost of every meal that's going on the table'. 'That's what you want for all Victorians, but that's not the case right now'. Symes also believes that state debt won't dominate the election debate, and that voters will instead be grateful for the infrastructure it's funded, including the Metro Tunnel and West Gate Tunnel, both set to open this year after huge cost overruns. Symes points to Sydney's $21.6bn Metro, which also ran billions over budget but is now popular with voters: 'The day it opened, people were like, 'Oh, actually, this is a worthwhile investment.'' The budget also brought pain for some, with 1,200 public sector jobs set to go, with the treasurer warning more job losses are likely once the government receives the recommendations of a review, a move Symes defends as tough but necessary. 'Do I want people to lose their jobs? No. But I also have a responsibility as treasurer to make sure that we are being cost-effective,' she says. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion At parliament last week, it became clear housing will be a key battleground at the next election. While the premier pledged to get 'millennials into homes' through planning reform and an extension of stamp duty concessions for new apartments, units and townhouses, the opposition announced a revived 2022 policy to abolish stamp duty for first home buyers on properties worth up to $1m. The shadow treasurer, James Newbury, says it would give 'young Victorians the final leg up they need', but Symes is sceptical, questioning both the opposition's costings and the policy's failure to increase housing supply. Stamp duty remains a huge revenue source for the state – forecast to bring in $11bn in 2028-29. But it's loathed by homebuyers and economists. The Grattan Institute's Brendan Coates calls it 'the worst tax in Australia', as it locks people into their homes, discourages downsizing and acts as a 'tax on divorce' – as separating couples will both have to go on to pay it. Many economists have long called for it to be replaced with a broad-based land tax. Asked if she would consider such a move, Symes leaves the door open: 'I'm always open to having discussions about tax reform. I've got the finances to manage so I can't make reckless announcements.' Last week, Symes addressed a post-budget Property Council breakfast, where she faced a tough crowd. Before she took the stage, Lendlease's Adam Williams warned that property taxes would soon make up 47% of the state's total tax revenue. In the Q&A segment, a member of the crowd said tax on foreign investment was 'killing' developers. Symes tried a joke: 'Let's have a show of hands – what's the worst tax? What's your favourite tax?' It fell flat. Newbury called her 'tone deaf' and 'out of touch' and criticised her for previously describing the role of treasurer as 'fun'. But Symes says she's not fazed by criticism, and that she's been underestimated before: told she couldn't be agriculture minister because she wore wedges to a farm and dismissed as attorney general for 'giggling like a schoolgirl'. 'The commentary that actually affects me more than anything else is the young women, particularly high school girls, who say, 'We have a female treasurer. That's so cool.''
