Family sues Fontana police in shooting death of unarmed man in driveway
It was around dinnertime at the family home in Fontana when one of Jaime Valdez's loved ones called 911 to ask for help.
'I have a relative that's not supposed to be here,' the unnamed caller told the dispatcher, according to a recording released by authorities. 'He's one of my cousins that's been coming around, he's on drugs and he's threatening to kill us.'
Police arrived that evening on Nov. 11, 2023, and found Valdez, 33, unarmed and lying in the driveway of the residence, where his mother lived.
Exactly what happened next is under dispute — but Valdez ended up dead after being shot in the back of the head by a Fontana police officer.
While authorities have claimed that Valdez tried to grab the officer's gun and taser, his family alleges police unnecessarily escalated the confrontation, then misled them about the killing.
'[An] officer basically shot an unarmed person in the back of the head and then lied to the family about it for a year or more,' said Bradley Yourist, a lawyer for the Valdez family. 'It's pretty egregious.'
Valdez's mother, Isabel, and his two daughters are now suing the Fontana Police Department in federal court, alleging excessive force.
'I want justice for my son,' Isabel Valdez said in Spanish in between sobs. 'The officer who took his life [should pay] just like any other criminal would pay. Just because he's a police officer he shouldn't avoid jail.'
She claims the police stopped her from leaving her house after the shooting, preventing her from seeing her son's body. The family alleges officers said they would take Valdez to the hospital — but the autopsy report states that he died within seconds of being shot. Valdez's family didn't learn of his death until the next morning, their lawsuit says.
The Fontana Police Department declined to comment, citing the ongoing investigation.
In a social media post more than eight months after the shooting, the department said the officer who fired the fatal shot, Alex Yanez, had been 'violently assaulted' and maintained that he and other officers who responded to the scene did nothing wrong.
Yanez could be heard before the shooting yelling at Valdez to 'Let go of my gun,' according to California Department of Justice investigative records. The department, which launched an investigation two days after the shooting, declined to comment because the probe is ongoing.
Yanez told investigators that DNA testing would corroborate his claim that Valdez had 'gotten ahold of' his gun after disobeying commands and getting into a struggle.
But the DNA results from Yanez's weapon came back inconclusive, state Bureau of Forensic Services records show, and Valdez's family contends that the edited version of body-worn camera video from the confrontation released by authorities leaves several questions unanswered.
Valdez's family described him as a music lover and dedicated Los Angeles Dodgers and Dallas Cowboys fan. He had struggled with meth and heroin addiction, his family said in the lawsuit, which argues that when police found him lying in the driveway that evening he was unable 'to follow commands because of his altered state from drugs and mental health problems.'
The edited body-cam video shows Yanez, who was hired by the Fontana Police Department in 2019, approaching Valdez, calling out repeatedly and receiving no response.
Eventually, Valdez becomes alert enough to tell the officer he wants to 'go back inside.'
The officer replies, 'You're not supposed to be here though. … What's up with you, dude?'
They go back and forth for a few moments before Valdez tells Yanez to 'Go knock on the door, bro.'
'You're gonna be put in [expletive] handcuffs if you keep talking to me like that,' Yanez responds, his words censored in the clip released by police.
Seconds later, Yanez orders Valdez to keep his hands out of his pockets, then tells him to 'put your hands behind your back, dude.'
The video is then interrupted by an onscreen message from the Fontana Police Department: 'The officer attempts to handcuff the suspect and he resists.'
When the clip resumes, Valdez is still on the ground and can be heard telling Yanez to 'chill' as the officer tries to put him in handcuffs.
The video doesn't provide a good view of Valdez at this point, but he can be heard saying 'I'm not doing nothing to you, bro.' The sounds of a scuffle and a dog barking are audible before Valdez says, 'You're hurting me.'
Yanez then repeatedly yells 'put your hands behind your back,' before using his taser.
'Put your hands behind your back,' Yanez yells twice more as Valdez screams in agony.
The video cuts to a message from the police: 'The officer and the suspect begin to struggle over the officer's handgun and an officer involved shooting occurs.'
Three gunshots can be heard back to back. 'Send backup,' Yanez says over his radio. 'I'm hurt.'
Valdez's family members say the police made false statements about the shooting and his condition.
'They lied about everything,' his sister, Rita Brandon, told The Times. 'They came and they told my mom that my brother was gonna be okay, that he'd been shot and he was on the way to the hospital, and the whole time he was outside in the driveway dead.'
The family's lawsuit, filed in December in Los Angeles federal court, seeks damages for a list of alleged misdeeds, including denial of medical care, battery and negligence. The defense has filed a motion to stay the proceedings, with the next court hearing set for April 24.
Michael Carillo, a lawyer for the Valdez family, said that 'what immediately jumped out about the video to me is the immediate escalation of force that was totally unnecessary and led to the unreasonable use of force.'
Carillo noted that Valdez was not physically imposing — only 5 foot 3 and 130 pounds. 'Instead of de-escalating it, calling in a mental health unit or supervisor, the officer escalated and escalated and ultimately shot [him],' Carillo said.
The coroner's report stated that one bullet hit Valdez in the back of his head and the other two hit his left shoulder.
Additional body-worn camera video reviewed by The Times depicts emergency personnel cutting Valdez's clothing away as he lay in the driveway and performing chest compressions in an attempt to revive him before declaring him dead.
The state Department of Justice is still investigating the shooting, as required by law when a police shooting victim is unarmed.
Valdez's teenage daughter — whose name The Times is withholding at the family's request because she is a minor — said she sleeps every night with a digital picture frame that loops photos of him, along with a treasured video of the two of them playing when she was 4 years old.
The girl's biological father left when she was very young, and Valdez — whom she refers to affectionately as Jime — got together with her mother when she was 2. A year later, she started calling him dad.
'I didn't even know what a dad was until Jime came along. My sister didn't come along until years later,' she said, referring to Valdez's biological daughter as tears streamed down her face. 'So it was always us two, so that was all I knew. Jime was my dad.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Kilmar Abrego Garcia pleads not guilty to human trafficking charges
NASHVILLE, Tennessee — Kilmar Abrego Garcia, the Salvadoran national illegally deported by the Trump administration in March, pleaded not guilty Friday to human trafficking charges that federal prosecutors leveled upon his return to the United States. One of Abrego Garcia's defense attorneys, William Allensworth, entered the not guilty plea on his client's behalf at a federal court hearing expected to focus on whether Abrego Garcia should be detained pending trial on the two felony criminal charges he faces related to immigrant smuggling. The not guilty plea came just after Abrego Garcia briefly spoke in court, saying in Spanish that he understood the charges against him. Abrego Garcia, wearing a red jail jumpsuit, entered the courtroom minutes before the hearing began. He got a hug from one of his attorneys, who sat flanking him at the defense table. Two Spanish interpreters were also on hand. The criminal case against Abrego Garcia, lodged secretly through a grand jury indictment last month, preceded Abrego Garcia's abrupt return to the United States last week. That was more than two months after the Supreme Court ordered the Trump administration to facilitate his release from El Salvador's custody. Since then, the administration has resisted efforts by federal courts to provide updates about its efforts to bring him back, cloaking them in assertions of 'state secrets' privilege and assailing judicial demands for more information. While prosecutors and the defense are expected to joust fiercely Friday about whether Abrego Garcia should be detained as he awaits trial, he's unlikely to be released immediately even if U.S. Magistrate Judge Barbara Holmes rules in his favor. Prosecutors could appeal such a ruling and have indicated they would seek to detain him on immigration grounds regardless of his status in the criminal case. The first witness at the detention hearing Friday was Homeland Security Investigations Special Agent Peter Joseph, who detailed a traffic stop of Abrego Garcia on Interstate 40 in 2022 that is the centerpiece of the immigrant-smuggling charges he faces. Joseph was not at the scene that night but as interim U.S. Attorney Robert McGuire played video from a Tennessee Highway Patrol officer's body-worn camera, the federal agent detailed why the episode appeared to involve human trafficking. Abrego Garcia can be heard in the video saying that the people in the Chevrolet Suburban were working construction in St. Louis and were headed for Maryland, but Joseph said there were nine passengers in the vehicle but no construction tools. The state officers asked the men in the vehicle to put their names and birth dates on a piece of paper passed around the van. McGuire asked Joseph how many of the passengers Abrego Garcia was driving were in the U.S. illegally. 'Right now, we're at six of the nine,' the agent said. Abrego Garcia's deportation case emerged as the most prominent early example of the perceived excesses of Trump's mass-deportation policies and of his administration's resistance to complying with court orders it disagrees with. Abrego Garcia entered the United States illegally in 2012 and sought asylum in 2019 after he was detained and faced deportation proceedings. Though his claim was denied, an immigration judge at the time barred ICE from sending him back to El Salvador because of the potential that he might be targeted for violence by a local gang. Despite the court order, which remains in effect, he was abruptly arrested on March 15 and loaded aboard one of a controversial trio of flights that ferried more than 230 foreigners from the U.S. to El Salvador, where they were immediately frog-marched into a notoriously harsh anti-terrorism prison. Many of those men were expelled from the U.S. under the Alien Enemies Act, a wartime authority Trump invoked against a Venezuela gang, Tren de Aragua. While the White House and prosecutors have claimed that Abrego Garcia is a member of MS-13, which his lawyers have denied, Trump's proclamation covered only Venezuelan citizens and Abrego Garcia is Salvadoran. Trump administration officials, including Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem and White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt, initially described his deportation as an administrative error because it violated the immigration judge's order. However, the White House quickly retreated from acknowledging any mistake. About 100 protesters rallied outside the courthouse as the hearing got underway, carrying signs with slogans such as 'Free Kilmar: Support Due Process and Human Rights' and 'Resist ICE.'
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
F. Dennis Alvarez, former Hillsborough chief judge, dies at 79
TAMPA — Frank Dennis Alvarez, who as Hillsborough County's longtime chief judge championed reforms that became staples of the local criminal justice system and helped the careers of many prominent lawyers, died Thursday at home in Tampa. His close friend, Simon Canasi, said Alvarez had been in hospice care. He'd received a heart transplant about 15 years ago and had experienced declining health in recent years. He was 79. 'He was an icon in the courthouse and a great friend,' Canasi said. 'There wasn't a place he could go that people didn't know who he was.' He was a man once said to know politics like a jeweler knows stones, an always smiling, always-hand-shaking statesman who genuinely loved people and the city that made him. Alvarez was born in 1945 in Ybor City. A son of cigar workers with Spanish and Italian roots, he grew up in West Tampa. He dabbled in politics as a kid, putting bumper stickers on cars in support of Sam Gibbons, the late Tampa lawmaker. He mused that he one day wanted to be mayor of his hometown. E.J. Salcines, a former Hillsborough state attorney and appellate judge, got to know Alvarez in childhood. They remained friends their entire lives. 'I'm sure that he looked up to me,' Salcines said. 'He always called me 'boss.'' Alvarez attended Jesuit High School and the University of South Florida. He was in his senior year of college when Salcines campaigned to be elected Hillsborough County's top prosecutor. At a North Tampa campaign stop, Alvarez chatted with his old friend, who asked what he planned to do after graduation. Alvarez said he'd thought about law school. Salcines encouraged him to take the admissions exam and apply. Alvarez became among the first in a long line of future Tampa lawyers to attend Salcines' alma mater, the South Texas College of Law. He began his legal career in 1974 as an assistant state attorney in Salcines' office. He later worked in private practice before running unopposed in 1980 to become a county judge. Four years later, he again ran unopposed for a seat on the circuit bench. In 1988, his fellow jurists elected him chief judge. 'He was an exemplary judge and lawyer because he took his oaths very, very seriously,' Salcines said. Alvarez led the judiciary as the county's population blossomed and its court system became more complex. Colleagues credited his ambition for the successes he had in the dozen years that followed. He helped create the first adult and juvenile drug courts, which aim to address the roots of substance abuse and allow defendants to avoid criminal convictions for low-level drug crimes if they complete a treatment program. It was a novel concept at the time. Drug court's success in Tampa drew national attention and set the mold for future problem-solving courts, like veterans treatment and mental health court. Alvarez also established a special division to address domestic violence cases and a 'rocket docket' to clear a backlog of juvenile cases. As a powerful judge, he occasionally turned up at the center of high-profile cases. He had a minuscule role in the O.J. Simpson saga, when a man in Tampa was subpoenaed to testify in the former football star's murder trial. Alvarez presided over a hearing on the subpoena. He also managed the hotly contested lawsuit over the estate of former Tampa Bay Buccaneers owner Hugh Culverhouse. As the face of the local judiciary, he administered oaths to countless lawyers and fellow judges. He swore into office local legal giants State Attorneys Harry Lee Coe III and Mark Ober. As construction on a new court building began in 2000, Alvarez was among those who pushed to name the new facility for the late George Edgecomb, Hillsborough County's first African American judge. Four years later, the county dedicated the building at the corner of Twiggs and Jefferson streets the George Edgecomb Courthouse. His widow, Doretha Edgecomb, said she knew Alvarez as someone who understood fairness but also stood for what he believed, even if it meant standing alone. 'He was approachable. He loved the law. And I considered him a friend,' she said. Fellow public servants and politicians described Alvarez as man of steadfast loyalty, a confidant whose counsel was in high demand. 'If you are in a war, you want him in the foxhole with you,' former Hillsborough Tax Collector Doug Belden said of Alvarez in 2001. Though he enjoyed a good reputation, Alvarez's last years running the local courthouse became sullied as some fellow judges were mired in scandal. Controversies included allegations of judges raising campaign money for politicians, having affairs with bailiffs and snooping around colleagues' offices after hours. Amid the fallout, a state commission probed his handling of the misconduct, and a grand jury criticized his leadership. He was 55 when he announced he would retire after 21 years on the bench. He emphatically denied that his departure had anything to do with the courthouse controversies, saying he'd long planned to return to private life. A year later, he launched a brief campaign be Tampa's mayor, but the prospect that the court scandals would make for nasty attacks spurred advice to bow out. But there were other factors, too. He'd dealt with heart problems most of his life, undergoing bypass surgery when he was just 34. As he became a senior citizen, he needed a new heart. From a hospital bed in 2010, he told the Tampa Bay Times his health troubles made politics seems less important. 'You get here and you think, man, that doesn't even come into play anymore,' he said. A transplant that year gave him another decade and a half. He worked until the end. Alvarez's robust legal background and influence made him in his later career a much-sought mediator for civil disputes. He remained active in the community. He served as chairperson of the foundation for the Boys and Girls Clubs of Tampa Bay. He was an esteemed member of the Krewe of the Knights of Sant Yago, which seeks to preserve Tampa's Latin heritage. 'The city of Tampa has lost a wonderful person,' said Richard Gonzmart, the restaurateur whose family helped found the Krewe. 'There's so many young attorneys who will go on and practice because of his guidance and leadership.' 'He was one of my role models,' said Ronald Ficarrotta, who served as Hillsborough's chief judge from 2015 to 2023. 'He was definitely a mentor and someone I would call on from time to time for advice.' Chief Judge Christopher Sabella became acquainted with Alvarez in meetings of local government entities in his early career as a lawyer for the Hillsborough sheriff's office. The collaboration between local offices and the courts was something that Sabella said Alvarez engineered. 'I just hope all the judges are able to keep the 13th Circuit where Dennis took it,' Sabella said. Former Mayor Bob Buckhorn said Alvarez embodied, with his blue-collar roots, the values of the city's immigrant families and enduring loyalty to those who knew him. 'He rose to the highest ranks of the legal profession in Tampa, and his imprint on the many young lawyers that he mentored will ensure that his contributions will live on for decades,' Buckhorn said. 'He was my friend and I will miss him.'
Politico
3 hours ago
- Politico
Kilmar Abrego Garcia pleads not guilty to human trafficking charges
NASHVILLE, Tennessee — Kilmar Abrego Garcia, the Salvadoran national illegally deported by the Trump administration in March, pleaded not guilty Friday to human trafficking charges that federal prosecutors leveled upon his return to the United States. One of Abrego Garcia's defense attorneys, William Allensworth, entered the not guilty plea on his client's behalf at a federal court hearing expected to focus on whether Abrego Garcia should be detained pending trial on the two felony criminal charges he faces related to immigrant smuggling. The not guilty plea came just after Abrego Garcia briefly spoke in court, saying in Spanish that he understood the charges against him. Abrego Garcia, wearing a red jail jumpsuit, entered the courtroom minutes before the hearing began. He got a hug from one of his attorneys, who sat flanking him at the defense table. Two Spanish interpreters were also on hand. The criminal case against Abrego Garcia, lodged secretly through a grand jury indictment last month, preceded Abrego Garcia's abrupt return to the United States last week. That was more than two months after the Supreme Court ordered the Trump administration to facilitate his release from El Salvador's custody. Since then, the administration has resisted efforts by federal courts to provide updates about its efforts to bring him back, cloaking them in assertions of 'state secrets' privilege and assailing judicial demands for more information. While prosecutors and the defense are expected to joust fiercely Friday about whether Abrego Garcia should be detained as he awaits trial, he's unlikely to be released immediately even if U.S. Magistrate Judge Barbara Holmes rules in his favor. Prosecutors could appeal such a ruling and have indicated they would seek to detain him on immigration grounds regardless of his status in the criminal case. The first witness at the detention hearing Friday was Homeland Security Investigations Special Agent Peter Joseph, who detailed a traffic stop of Abrego Garcia on Interstate 40 in 2022 that is the centerpiece of the immigrant-smuggling charges he faces. Joseph was not at the scene that night but as interim U.S. Attorney Robert McGuire played video from a Tennessee Highway Patrol officer's body-worn camera, the federal agent detailed why the episode appeared to involve human trafficking. Abrego Garcia can be heard in the video saying that the people in the Chevrolet Suburban were working construction in St. Louis and were headed for Maryland, but Joseph said there were nine passengers in the vehicle but no construction tools. The state officers asked the men in the vehicle to put their names and birth dates on a piece of paper passed around the van. McGuire asked Joseph how many of the passengers Abrego Garcia was driving were in the U.S. illegally. 'Right now, we're at six of the nine,' the agent said. Abrego Garcia's deportation case emerged as the most prominent early example of the perceived excesses of Trump's mass-deportation policies and of his administration's resistance to complying with court orders it disagrees with. Abrego Garcia entered the United States illegally in 2012 and sought asylum in 2019 after he was detained and faced deportation proceedings. Though his claim was denied, an immigration judge at the time barred ICE from sending him back to El Salvador because of the potential that he might be targeted for violence by a local gang. Despite the court order, which remains in effect, he was abruptly arrested on March 15 and loaded aboard one of a controversial trio of flights that ferried more than 230 foreigners from the U.S. to El Salvador, where they were immediately frog-marched into a notoriously harsh anti-terrorism prison. Many of those men were expelled from the U.S. under the Alien Enemies Act, a wartime authority Trump invoked against a Venezuela gang, Tren de Aragua. While the White House and prosecutors have claimed that Abrego Garcia is a member of MS-13, which his lawyers have denied, Trump's proclamation covered only Venezuelan citizens and Abrego Garcia is Salvadoran. Trump administration officials, including Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem and White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt, initially described his deportation as an administrative error because it violated the immigration judge's order. However, the White House quickly retreated from acknowledging any mistake. About 100 protesters rallied outside the courthouse as the hearing got underway, carrying signs with slogans such as 'Free Kilmar: Support Due Process and Human Rights' and 'Resist ICE.'
