Relatives of 1994 Chinook crash victims initiate legal action against MoD
Relatives of intelligence officers and military personnel killed in a 1994 RAF helicopter crash on the Mull of Kintyre have taken the first step in legal action against the Ministry of Defence (MoD).
Twenty-nine people – including officers from MI5, the Royal Ulster Constabulary and the army, along with the helicopter's special forces crew – died after RAF Chinook ZD576 crashed in foggy weather in south-west Scotland on 2 June 1994.
Now, 31 years to the day, lawyers acting pro bono for the bereaved have issued the MoD with a 'letter before action', seen by the Guardian.
The letter formally informs the MoD of the Chinook Justice Campaign's intention to apply for a judicial review of the decision not to hold a public inquiry into circumstances of the crash, citing article 2 of the Human Rights Act, which protects the right to life. It urges the secretary of state for defence, John Healey, to start an inquiry 'without further delay', giving him 14 days to respond.
Last week the Guardian reported the families' demand, in an open letter to the government, for the full release of archive documents that have been locked away until 2094 by the MoD. Their lawyers believe a public judge-led inquiry would have full access to material that previous investigations have not been able to consider.
Sign up to Headlines UK
Get the day's headlines and highlights emailed direct to you every morning
after newsletter promotion
Mark Stephens, of the law firm Howard Kennedy, said: 'The government has a legal obligation to answer the families. Thirty-one years on, there can be no operational reasons for secrecy and the only way to find out the truth is with a judge-led inquiry where the judge can review the so-called 'secret' material and answer the multitude of questions that are left begging.'
Stephens said the families and their legal counsel had seen 'more than enough evidence' to convince them the 'aircraft should never have taken off'.
The most recent review, by Lord Philip in 2011, set out safety concerns but concluded the cause of the crash was unlikely to be ever known, while exonerating the helicopter's late pilots, Flt Lts Richard Cook and Jonathan Tapper, who had been found guilty of 'gross negligence' by the RAF 17 years earlier.
Esme Sparks, from County Durham, whose father, Maj Gary Sparks, was killed in the crash, said: 'We don't want to have to take legal action against the government, but we do want and need answers. What is being hidden? In our view, a public inquiry is key.'
Andy Tobias, who was eight when his father, Lt Col John Tobias, 41, was killed, said: 'It's clear to me that a complete lack of duty of care was given to those passengers because they got on a Chinook that wasn't fit for flight.
'And really, the government need to show their duty of candour and really be open and transparent about what's in those documents and give us the opportunity to really understand anything that's in them that could give us more answers about what happened.'
On Sunday, families attended a private commemoration at the National Memorial Arboretum in Staffordshire. Describing the crash as 'a tragic accident', an MoD spokesperson previously said: 'Our thoughts and sympathies remain with the families, friends and colleagues of all those who died.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
30 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Disgraced Harrods owner Mohamed al Fayed 'bought Princess Diana's old school to groom and rape underage girls', new book claims
Princess Diana 's old school to groom and rape underage girls, a new book has claimed. A former teacher at West Heath School in Kent, England, has revealed how the disgraced businessman bought the school on the promise to protect Diana's legacy - but instead used it to prey on vulnerable school pupils. The former owner of Harrods, who died in 2023 aged 94, raped one school girl, caused the suicide of another, and even fathered a baby with one underage pupil, the bombshell book alleges. In an extract from The Monster Of Harrods seen by The Sun, author Alison Kervin reveals how the depraved Egyptian business mogul targeted vulnerable school girls as well as young players at Fulham FC. Just a year after the death of the Princess of Wales in May 1998, al Fayed bought West Heath School which was teetering on the brink of financial collapse, under the guise of protecting a place which had been so special to the late royal. The Monster Of Harrods alleges that the businessman would regularly wander around the school unaccompanied, chatting to underage pupils. A former teacher revealed his visits always seemed inappropriate and 'creepy'. The former teacher explained he believed al Fayed was grooming the pupils and said he would promise them careers after they had finished and shower them with gifts from Harrods. The former owner of Fulham FC would also allegedly give girls lifts in his Rolls Royce and invite them to his house. He said: 'He shouldn't have been there. Benefactor or not, a man of that age should not be mixing with young girls, offering them lifts in his and chauffeur-driven limo, and buying them presents before inviting them to his house. How is any of that appropriate?'. The tell-all book also claims that one pupil was attacked by al Fayed in a bathroom, ripping her clothes and hurting her after inviting her to Harrods. A former pupil described how her friend was terrified to share what had happened to her: 'He told her that her parents would be told about how she had behaved and all the school would know that she was the one who had closed the school down. She was terrified - she felt like she was to blame, and nothing I said would calm her down.' Author Ms Kervin alleges that the brutal businessman threatened to close the school if the pupil reported him and refused to go to the police or to lawyers until the litany sexual abuse was revealed following his death. The former pupil said she was also aware of at least one other pupil who was raped by the predator and another who gave birth to a secret child. She also believes one woman committed suicide because of her experience with al Fayed. The school told The Sun: 'We do not tolerate abuse or harassment in any form.' In September 2024, in response to the BBC documentary Al Fayed: Predator At Harrods, they commented: 'We have no further information other than what is currently in the news.' And his abuse did not end with the Princess Diana's former school. A former soccer player for the Fulham Women's team al Fayed set up revealed she was humiliated and sexually harassed by the club owner. In The Monster Of Harrods, she alleges that she was desperate to become a footballer and took al Fayed at his word when he promised to help her make the team. She described sharing her hopes with the businessman who offered to speak with her privately in his apartment. But when she arrived, she claimed the conversation was centered around whether she had a boyfriend and if she had lost her virginity. When conversation did turn to football, the promising player said she was asked to show off her legs and despite feeling uncomfortable, took off her tracksuit bottoms at which point al Fayed tried to reach out and touch her. She said he also asked her to take off her underwear but he felt uncomfortable and ran for the door only to find it locked. She said she repeatedly banged on the door while al Fayed laughed at her. After her experience she said she fell out of love with the game and eventually left the club. And the aspiring player was one of several who experienced harassment and abuse at the hands of the al Fayed and despite them all reporting it to the police, they say nothing ever came of it. Mohamed al Fayed was hit with an avalanche of rape and assault claims after at least two former Harrods workers told a BBC documentary they had been raped or molested by the Egyptian tycoon. Meanwhile last year, London's Metropolitan Police revealed they were investigating 40 new allegations against al Fayed and others since the BBC documentary. The 40 new allegations related to 40 alleged victims and were in addition to allegations police were aware of before the BBC's investigation and documentary, Scotland Yard said. Prior to recent media coverage, 21 allegations were made against the late billionaire which resulted in crimes being recorded relating to 21 separate women between 2005 and 2023. The Met has now widened its investigation to look at associates who may have assisted and facilitated the abuse - meaning criminal charges could still be on the cards even though the direct perpetrators have died. It comes as a survivors group Justice for Harrods Survivors says it has 'credible evidence' suggesting the sexual abuse allegedly perpetrated at Harrods and the billionaire's properties 'was not limited to Mr al Fayed himself'.
BBC News
31 minutes ago
- BBC News
Woman arrested after motorcyclist injured in Albrighton crash
A woman has been arrested after a man was seriously injured in a crash between a motorbike and car in hurt motorcyclist, in his 60s, was taken to hospital in Birmingham following the crash involving a Mini on Rushey Lane in Albrighton, near Wolverhampton, at about 17:10 BST on Monday.A 59-year-old woman was held on suspicion of drink-driving, causing serious injury by dangerous driving and failing to stop at a road traffic collision. West Mercia Police said it would like to hear from anyone who saw, or who had dashcam footage of, the crash or either of the vehicles in the minutes before it. Follow BBC Shropshire on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
Daily Mail
31 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Police scour garden after body is found in hunt for missing Polish factory worker Izabela Zablocka
Police are scouring the garden of a house where they uncovered human remains in the hunt for a Polish woman who vanished 15 years ago. A major operation is taking place within an address on Princes Street in Normanton following the harrowing discovery last night as part of an investigation into the case of missing Izabela Zablocka. Police and forensics have been scouring the property since last week after new information came to light in connection with the then 30-year-old's disappearance. Izabela, who moved to Britain in 2009, lived on Princes Street and worked at the former Cranberry Foods Turkey and Chicken Factory in nearby Scropton. She last made contact with her family in Poland on August 28, 2010 and despite their efforts to trace her, she was never found. Formal identification of the remains are yet to take place, but detectives believe they belong to Izabela. A 39-year-old woman who was arrested and bailed on Tuesday was also rearrested last night. Two other women – one aged 39 and one aged 43 – and a 41-year-old man were arrested in connection with the investigation over the course of the last week. They remain on police bail pending further inquiries. Images from earlier today show a large police presence outside the property on Princes Street where police are conducting searches. Aerial shots also show two blue forensics tents erected in the garden of the house, with forensics workers and a digger also seen on site. Detective Inspector Kane Martin, who is leading the investigation, said: 'Izabela's family are at the forefront of our minds following this discovery and, whilst formal identification has not yet taken place, it is our belief that these remains do belong to Izabela. 'As such, we have spoken with Izabela's family in Poland, and they are aware. Our thoughts are with them at this extremely difficult time. 'Identification of the remains is likely to be a lengthy process, but we will issue updates when we are able. 'I know that reports of these findings will send shockwaves through the local community, and I understand the concern of residents. 'Officers will remain in Princes Street in the coming days, and anyone with concerns is encouraged to speak with them. 'A dedicated team of detectives are continuing to piece together information about the days prior to Izabela's death. 'Izabela had friends in Derby, socialised in Derby, and worked in Derby. 'We know that someone out there will have information about Izabela that may help us understand what happened to her, and urge anyone who saw, spoke to, or heard anything about Izabela in July or August 2010 to come forward. 'You may hold the key piece of information that we need to understand the full circumstances of Izabela's disappearance, and to give her family answers on what happened to their loved one. 'Anyone who does wish to make contact, can do so completely anonymously through the charity Crimestoppers who are offering a £20,000 reward for any information which leads to the conviction of someone in the case of Izabela.'
