UK judges sound alarm over AI-fabricated cases
A judge of the High Court of England and Wales has issued a formal warning to legal professionals, cautioning lawyers that relying on artificial intelligence to generate legal arguments containing fictitious case citations may face criminal prosecution.
Victoria Sharp, president of the King's Bench Division of the High Court, along with fellow judge Jeremy Johnson, reprimanded lawyers involved in two separate cases for apparently relying on AI tools to draft written arguments that were submitted to the court without verification.
'There are serious implications for the administration of justice and public confidence in the justice system if artificial intelligence is misused,' she said in the ruling on Friday.
The cases arose after lower courts flagged suspected use of AI-generated arguments and witness statements containing false information.
In the ruling by Judge Sharp, the court revealed that one attorney, in a £90 million ($120 million) lawsuit concerning an alleged breach of a financing agreement with Qatar National Bank, cited 18 non-existent cases.
Hamad Al-Haroun, the client in the case, apologized for unintentionally misleading the court with false information generated by publicly available AI tools, accepting personal responsibility and absolving his solicitor, Abid Hussain.
Sharp said it was 'extraordinary that the lawyer was relying on the client for the accuracy of their legal research, rather than the other way around.'
In another case, barrister Sarah Forey cited five fabricated cases in a tenant's housing claim against the London Borough of Haringey. The lawyer denied intentionally using AI but acknowledged she may have done so inadvertently while conducting online research for the case.
The judge scolded her saying that 'Ms Forey could have checked the cases she cited by searching the National Archives' caselaw website or by going to the law library of her Inn of Court.'
Sharp warned that presenting false material as genuine could constitute contempt of court or, in the most serious cases, perverting the course of justice – a criminal offense punishable by up to life imprisonment.
The judges referred the lawyers in both cases to their respective professional regulators but declined to pursue more severe penalties.
High-profile figures and scientists have raised concerns in recent years over the potential dangers posed by AI.
Researchers warn that artificial intelligence is advancing rapidly, with some models reportedly becoming self-aware and rewriting their own code. Palisade Research reported last month that in recent tests, a powerful AI model 'sabotaged a shutdown mechanism to prevent itself from being turned off,' raising concerns of a potential real-world AI rebellion.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Russia Today
14 hours ago
- Russia Today
Anti-immigrant riots erupt over underage rape case (VIDEOS)
At least 15 police officers were injured during angry protests in Northern Ireland overnight on Monday, following court hearing in which two Romanian-speaking minors were charged with the attempted rape of a local girl. Both have denied the charges. Northern Ireland police have branded the ensuing unrest as racially motivated violence. A vigil in the town of Ballymena involving some several hundred people eventually turned violent as masked protesters reportedly started throwing petrol bombs and bricks at police and attempting to set homes they believed belonged to the families of the accused on fire. Videos from the scene showed the rioters erecting barricades on the streets and setting them alight as well as smashing windows. One person was arrested on 'suspicion of riotous and disorderly behavior,' the police said, according to the Belfast Telegraph. Northern Irelands response tonight (Ballymena my hometown) to a youn girl raped on Saturday by Romanian immigrants The Police Federation for Northern Ireland branded the riots 'totally mindless, unacceptable, and feral.' The alleged victim's family also condemned the unrest but also thanked 'the people who came from far and wide to support us and ask that justice be served in the correct manner.' 🚨ATTEMPTED RAPE BY A MIGRANT IN BALLYMENA, NORTHERN IRELANDThis is going to get very ugly if the government don't they won' will let you be angry so they can point their fingers at you and say YOU are the need deportations have… Assistant Chief Constable Ryan Henderson said the violence 'was clearly racially motivated and targeted at our minority ethnic community and police'. Tensions reached boiling point in Ballymena took to the streets after foreigners attacked a number of people in the area. The homes of those responsible were targeted as the community made it clear they are not welcome. Last year, local police reported a surge in what it called race hate crimes. According to the law enforcement data, the number of such crimes grew by 309 in Northern Ireland between September 2023 and September 2024, an increase of approximately 33% compared with the previous 12 months. The police linked the increase to mass anti-immigration protests in the province and across the UK in early August, following a knife attack at a dance workshop in Southport, England, in July 2024, when a teenager of Rwandan descent stabbed three children to death and injured eight others.
Russia Today
14 hours ago
- Russia Today
Russian tycoon Abramovich ‘done' with professional football
Russian businessman Roman Abramovich has said he no longer intends to be involved in professional football or own any club again, according to a new book excerpt cited by the Daily Mail. Abramovich was forced to sell the football club Chelsea to a US-led consortium shortly after the escalation of the Ukraine conflict. The UK government imposed sanctions on him in March 2022 over his alleged Kremlin ties. The tycoon has denied the allegations and acted as a mediator between Moscow and Kiev on several occasions. In an interview with Nick Purewal, the author of a book titled 'Sanctioned: The Inside Story of the Sale of Chelsea FC', Abramovich confirmed he has 'no interest in any role in a football club, certainly not a professional role.' 'As for ownership or a professional role at a club, I am done with that in this lifetime,' he was cited as saying. He added that he still wishes to attend a Chelsea match in the future 'to say a proper goodbye,' but reiterated he has no plans for further involvement in the sport. However, he expressed a willingness to support initiatives for underprivileged youth if a meaningful opportunity arises. The British government has increased pressure on Abramovich to approve the release of the £2.5 billion ($3.4 billion) proceeds from the Chelsea sale to Ukraine. Last week, Chancellor Rachel Reeves and Foreign Secretary David Lammy warned in a joint statement that the UK is prepared to take legal action if he does not authorize the transfer. 'The government is determined to see the proceeds from the sale of Chelsea Football Club reach humanitarian causes in Ukraine,' the statement read. While the money is frozen in a UK account, Abramovich remains its legal owner and must approve its distribution. According to The Guardian, officials have held extensive talks with Abramovich's legal team but have failed to resolve a 'fundamental disagreement' over how the funds should be used. Abramovich has insisted the proceeds be used to assist victims of the conflict on both sides, not exclusively Ukraine.
Russia Today
a day ago
- Russia Today
NATO chief tells Brits to boost defense spending or learn Russian
British people will have to learn to speak Russian if the UK fails to implement Prime Minister Keir Starmer's plan to drastically boost defense spending, NATO Secretary-General Mark Rutte has said. Moscow has dismissed claims that it plans to invade NATO countries as fearmongering by Western politicians. Last week, Starmer unveiled his cabinet's Strategic Defense Review, promising to invest billions more in weapons factories, drones, and submarines to make Britain 'a battle-ready, armor-clad nation with the strongest alliances and the most advanced capabilities.' London's policy will 'always be NATO first,' he said. However, the prime minister declined to set a deadline for the UK to reach its goal of increasing defense spending to 3% of GDP. Speaking at Chatham House in London on Monday, Rutte said he was 'really impressed' by Starmer's plans. Asked if the UK should increase taxes even further in order to fund the rearmament program, he replied: 'it is not up to me.' 'I mean, what I know is that if we want to keep our societies safe... look, if you do not do this, if you would not go to the 5%, including the 3.5% core defense spending, you could still have the National Health Service, or in other countries their health systems, the pension system, etc., but you had better learn to speak Russian,' he said. Rutte reiterated his claim that Russia could be ready to target NATO countries within the next five years. 'The new generation of Russian missiles travel at many times the speed of sound. The distance between European capitals is only a matter of minutes. There is no longer east or west. There is just NATO,' he said. Russian President Vladimir Putin has rejected allegations that Moscow harbors any aggressive intentions toward NATO countries, calling them 'nonsense' designed to alarm the public and legitimize major hikes in defense spending. Moscow has been increasingly critical of Britain's involvement in the Ukraine conflict. Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov said on Monday that the UK is '100%' helping Kiev to conduct terrorist attacks inside Russian territory.
