
Papers weighing legal options after Wydysh denies FOIL appeal
The Niagara Gazette and the Lockport Union-Sun & Journal are weighing their legal options in light of Niagara County's continued insistence that the news outlets pay costs associated with scanning, redacting and copying public employee timesheets requested in electronic form as part of a Freedom of Information Law request filed in February.
In a letter dated April 10, Niagara County Legislature Chair Rebecca Wydysh, R-Lewiston, denied the newspapers' appeal of the county's FOIL request response dated March 14.
In the county's response, human resources director Peter Lopes identified 1,129 pages as 'potentially responsive' to the newspapers' request for timesheets submitted by attorneys working for the public defender's office between Jan. 1, 2023 and Feb. 10, 2025. In his letter, Lopes indicated that the county could make the documents available at a cost of $356.83. Lopes also proposed a less expensive option, estimated at $282.25, that would allow a reporter to conduct an in-person inspection of physical copies of redacted timesheets. The second option included a requirement that the reporter be accompanied by an assigned county employee, at the newspapers' cost, during the in-person inspection.
'An employee will sit with you while you inspect the records,' Lopes wrote. 'If time exceeds 120 minutes, you will be charged for that employee's time at their hourly rate.'
In an appeal sent to Wydysh on behalf of the newspapers, attorney Michael Higgins from the law firm Ernstrom & Dreste in Rochester argued that the county has no legal right under state law to charge by the page for copies of documents requested in electronic form. He also suggested the county's 'purported inability to scan documents without making physical copies' stretched 'the bounds of credulity.'
Higgins' appeal also asserted that the county's attempt to charge fees for administrative time to prepare photocopies of records is prohibited under state law and that it is 'improper' to charge the newspapers to allow a reporter to inspect records and to have those records redacted.
'Niagara County's attempts to charge for prohibited items and to unnecessarily copy documents to induce a charge is a transparent attempt to frustrate (the newspapers') FOIL request and avoid its obligations under the Freedom of Information Law,' Higgins wrote.
In her response, Wydysh restated the county's position that it is necessary to make physical copies of the requested documents so they can be redacted and scanned because some of the attorney timesheets 'may reflect medical or sick leave that is protected under HIPAA and exempt from FOIL disclosure.'
In addition, Wydysh argued, as Lopes did before her, that based on the volume of records, the human resources department would have to attach each pay period to a separate email, which would require staff time that the county would need to be reimbursed by the newspapers.
'Public Officer's Law requires an agency to send records electronically so long as the effort to effectuate that does not exceed the effort necessary for an alternative method of responding,' Wydysh wrote. 'Because of the necessity of reviewing the timesheets for compliance with HIPAA, and redacting portions of records that contain protected information, before scanning, it would be more labor intensive to scan the timesheets. In that circumstance, an agency is not required to provide the records electronically.'
Wydysh, citing a section of New York's Public Officer's Law, argues that the county is permitted to charge a fee based on the cost of the storage medium used, as well as the hourly salary of the lowest paid employee who has the skill needed to fulfill the request. Wydysh noted that the county advised the newspapers that the rate in this case would be $40.17 per hour.
As to the in-person inspection option, Wydysh indicates that the county would make available copies of the timesheets at a cost of 25 cents per page but would not allow a reporter to take pictures of the records. She also noted that it is the county's position that a staff member would need to sit in on the records inspection and that the newspapers would be charged 'any time over two hours.'
'The human resources department was still willing to satisfy your client's preference to receive records electronically, but your client would be charged for the time associated with copying, reviewing, redacting, scanning in the records and attaching,' Wydysh wrote in her letter denying the newspapers' appeal.
The newspapers can file an Article 78 proceeding in court to challenge Wydysh's denial of their appeal to the county's initial FOIL response.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Natwest to close Wiltshire town centre branch this year
NatWest has confirmed that it will close its Trowbridge branch later this year as it reveals the closing date. NatWest has published a list of branch closures, with a number of Wiltshire branches set to be axed, including Chippenham and Trowbridge. The Wiltshire bank closures are among 55 nationwide, with a swathe of town centres across the UK to say goodbye to vital banking resources. The bank has confirmed the Trowbridge branch at 62 Fore Street will close its doors for good on October 16, 2025. In a document detailing plans for the closure, the bank informed customers its services could be accessed online. The document includes details of the nearest NatWest branches are in Bath, Kingswood in Bristol, and Wells. In addition, NatWest customers will be able to use banking hubs operated by Cash Access UK, including the Westbury branch. Recommend reading: Plant nursery's new owner off to a 'good start' Council is 'not permitted' to install cameras in illegal parking crackdown Town centre shop unit goes on the market According to the Sun, NatWest has more than 19 million customers and it says over 3.5 million customers use online banking. A spokesperson told the paper that the move was driven by more customers 'than ever before' using digital banking. Banking in south west Wiltshire has taken a hit in recent years. In nearby Warminster, the Lloyds bank building closed in December last year, with MP Dr Andrew Murrison lamenting the impact the closure could cause. Last week, Loungers Ltd confirmed it would be turning the high-street building into a lounge bar. Trowbridge also saw banking turbulence earlier this year after a Honda ploughed through the front, forcing the bank to shut for repairs. However, the branch reopened at the end of May, offering in-person banking once again. On the afternoon of Wednesday, May 28, customers could be seen entering the branch and using facilities inside. The establishment's Google Maps page also shows the branch is operating under its normal hours. A spokesperson for Nationwide confirmed the branch reopened on May 19. On Friday, March 14, shortly before 2:30pm, the hatchback smashed into of the branch on Castle Street, Trowbridge. Following the incident, the branch was boarded up, with a notice taped to the front of the bank reading: 'The branch is currently closed, we are working as quickly as possible to re-open'.


Business Wire
2 hours ago
- Business Wire
CoreCare Achieves SOC 2 Compliance, Reinforcing Commitment to Deliver Secure, Trustworthy AI for Post-Acute and Long-Term Care Providers
NEW YORK--(BUSINESS WIRE)-- CoreCare, the leading AI-powered workflow platform for post-acute and long-term care (PALTC) providers, today announced it has successfully completed its SOC 2 audit, affirming the company's rigorous commitment to data security and operational excellence. CoreCare has successfully completed its SOC 2 audit, affirming the company's rigorous commitment to data security and operational excellence. Share 'Securing sensitive data isn't optional, especially in healthcare,' said Mehrdad Shafaie, Co-Founder & COO of CoreCare. 'This audit reflects the discipline and integrity we bring to every part of the platform. For SNF operators, trusting an AI vendor starts with security, and we take that responsibility seriously.' Developed by the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA), SOC 2 is an industry-recognized standard for data handling practices based on five 'trust service principles': security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality, and privacy. CoreCare's audit was conducted by Advantage Partners, with automation support from Vanta, a leading compliance automation platform. The successful completion of the SOC 2 assessment confirms that CoreCare has implemented effective internal controls to safeguard client data - an essential requirement for healthcare providers navigating regulatory complexity and HIPAA compliance. This achievement reinforces CoreCare's mission to help providers harness the power of AI with confidence, compliance and trust. About CoreCare CoreCare is the leading AI-powered workflow platform built specifically for post-acute and long-term care providers. Trusted by thousands of skilled nursing facilities nationwide, CoreCare's Collaborative Revenue Management platform replaces spreadsheets, manual reviews, and disconnected portals with technology that enables expert-level decisions and teamwork at every step of the revenue cycle. Backed by Y Combinator and leading health tech investors, CoreCare is building the infrastructure for AI-powered healthcare operations. To learn more about CoreCare, visit and connect with us on LinkedIn.


Business Wire
8 hours ago
- Business Wire
Thales Launches File Activity Monitoring (FAM) to Strengthen Real-Time Visibility and Control Over Unstructured Data
MEUDON, France--(BUSINESS WIRE)-- Thales today announced the launch of Thales File Activity Monitoring, a powerful new capability within the Thales CipherTrust Data Security Platform that enhances enterprise visibility and control over unstructured data, enabling organizations to monitor file activity in real time, detect misuse, and ensure regulatory compliance across their entire data estate. As the only integrated platform provider that secures structured and unstructured data, Thales provides comprehensive monitoring and auditability for data types that were previously difficult to track. 'As unstructured data grows rapidly across distributed environments, organizations need more integrated ways to track and safeguard their most sensitive information,' Todd Moore, Vice President of Data Security Products at Thales, said. In today's evolving threat landscape, organizations must gain tighter control over unauthorized access and misuse of unstructured data, which according to IDC represents 90% of all worldwide data. File Activity Monitoring enables security teams to analyze and monitor the activity of unstructured data, including unexpected copying, downloading, and sharing of files such as emails, chat logs, media files, and application logs that can contain sensitive data. Real-time alerts, analytics, and encryption tracking further accelerate threat insights and protect sensitive data across the enterprise. This reduces exposure risks, supports compliance with standards like GDPR, HIPAA, and PCI DSS, and strengthens organizations' overall data security posture. 'Thales' innovative approach to File Activity Monitoring tackles key challenges like blind spots in hybrid environments, offering real-time visibility and smart anomaly detection — a potential game-changer for teams overwhelmed by false positives. By striking the right balance of depth and simplicity, FAM shows promise in helping us strengthen the SOC without added complexity. With tighter SIEM integration, it can sharpen response and let teams focus on what matters most. We're excited to see how FAM evolves and enhances our data security,' Leila KUNTAR, Principal Information Security Engineer, Amadeus, said. 'As unstructured data grows rapidly across distributed environments, organizations need more integrated ways to track and safeguard their most sensitive information,' Todd Moore, Vice President of Data Security Products at Thales, said. 'With File Activity Monitoring, Thales reinforces its leadership in enterprise data security by delivering real-time insight, intelligent automation, and unified visibility through a single, powerful platform.' Thales has been a leader in digital security for decades in structured database activity. Building on this extensive expertise, customers can expect the same world-class experience that they've had with Thales, now extended to encompass unstructured data protection. File Activity Monitoring strengthens DSPM by enabling security teams to: Discover, classify, observe, and control sensitive data across on-premises, hybrid, and multicloud environments Pinpoint where sensitive data resides, who has access, and whether it's properly secured, in real time, allowing detection of suspicious behavior including unauthorized copying, downloading, or sharing Transform static classification into dynamic risk intelligence through behavioral context Apply strong encryption and other remediation techniques, including reconstruction of incidents quickly with audit logs in the event of a breach or policy violation and enabling strong encryption, to protect compromised or at-risk data Built-in GenAI tools simplify audits, boost response, and cut complexity To further simplify compliance and security operations, File Activity Monitoring includes a Generative AI-powered Data Security Assistant. This integrated chatbot helps teams query audit data, generate custom reports, and streamline compliance workflows, reducing the burden on IT and security professionals and making it easier to meet regulatory obligations. 'As technology evolves rapidly, our controls must be flexible enough to keep pace without adding complexity,' Moore said. 'Automation and intelligence help overwhelmed security teams scale operations and focus on what matters most. With tools like our chatbot, they can ask natural language questions and get instant, actionable answers, accelerating response times and improving operational efficiency.' About Thales Thales (Euronext Paris: HO) is a global leader in advanced technologies for the Defence, Aerospace, and Cyber & Digital sectors. Its portfolio of innovative products and services addresses several major challenges: sovereignty, security, sustainability and inclusion. The Group invests more than €4 billion per year in Research & Development in key areas, particularly for critical environments, such as Artificial Intelligence, cybersecurity, quantum and cloud technologies. Thales has more than 83,000 employees in 68 countries. In 2024, the Group generated sales of €20.6 billion. Thales Group Cybersecurity Solutions | Thales Group