logo
Papers weighing legal options after Wydysh denies FOIL appeal

Papers weighing legal options after Wydysh denies FOIL appeal

Yahoo17-04-2025

The Niagara Gazette and the Lockport Union-Sun & Journal are weighing their legal options in light of Niagara County's continued insistence that the news outlets pay costs associated with scanning, redacting and copying public employee timesheets requested in electronic form as part of a Freedom of Information Law request filed in February.
In a letter dated April 10, Niagara County Legislature Chair Rebecca Wydysh, R-Lewiston, denied the newspapers' appeal of the county's FOIL request response dated March 14.
In the county's response, human resources director Peter Lopes identified 1,129 pages as 'potentially responsive' to the newspapers' request for timesheets submitted by attorneys working for the public defender's office between Jan. 1, 2023 and Feb. 10, 2025. In his letter, Lopes indicated that the county could make the documents available at a cost of $356.83. Lopes also proposed a less expensive option, estimated at $282.25, that would allow a reporter to conduct an in-person inspection of physical copies of redacted timesheets. The second option included a requirement that the reporter be accompanied by an assigned county employee, at the newspapers' cost, during the in-person inspection.
'An employee will sit with you while you inspect the records,' Lopes wrote. 'If time exceeds 120 minutes, you will be charged for that employee's time at their hourly rate.'
In an appeal sent to Wydysh on behalf of the newspapers, attorney Michael Higgins from the law firm Ernstrom & Dreste in Rochester argued that the county has no legal right under state law to charge by the page for copies of documents requested in electronic form. He also suggested the county's 'purported inability to scan documents without making physical copies' stretched 'the bounds of credulity.'
Higgins' appeal also asserted that the county's attempt to charge fees for administrative time to prepare photocopies of records is prohibited under state law and that it is 'improper' to charge the newspapers to allow a reporter to inspect records and to have those records redacted.
'Niagara County's attempts to charge for prohibited items and to unnecessarily copy documents to induce a charge is a transparent attempt to frustrate (the newspapers') FOIL request and avoid its obligations under the Freedom of Information Law,' Higgins wrote.
In her response, Wydysh restated the county's position that it is necessary to make physical copies of the requested documents so they can be redacted and scanned because some of the attorney timesheets 'may reflect medical or sick leave that is protected under HIPAA and exempt from FOIL disclosure.'
In addition, Wydysh argued, as Lopes did before her, that based on the volume of records, the human resources department would have to attach each pay period to a separate email, which would require staff time that the county would need to be reimbursed by the newspapers.
'Public Officer's Law requires an agency to send records electronically so long as the effort to effectuate that does not exceed the effort necessary for an alternative method of responding,' Wydysh wrote. 'Because of the necessity of reviewing the timesheets for compliance with HIPAA, and redacting portions of records that contain protected information, before scanning, it would be more labor intensive to scan the timesheets. In that circumstance, an agency is not required to provide the records electronically.'
Wydysh, citing a section of New York's Public Officer's Law, argues that the county is permitted to charge a fee based on the cost of the storage medium used, as well as the hourly salary of the lowest paid employee who has the skill needed to fulfill the request. Wydysh noted that the county advised the newspapers that the rate in this case would be $40.17 per hour.
As to the in-person inspection option, Wydysh indicates that the county would make available copies of the timesheets at a cost of 25 cents per page but would not allow a reporter to take pictures of the records. She also noted that it is the county's position that a staff member would need to sit in on the records inspection and that the newspapers would be charged 'any time over two hours.'
'The human resources department was still willing to satisfy your client's preference to receive records electronically, but your client would be charged for the time associated with copying, reviewing, redacting, scanning in the records and attaching,' Wydysh wrote in her letter denying the newspapers' appeal.
The newspapers can file an Article 78 proceeding in court to challenge Wydysh's denial of their appeal to the county's initial FOIL response.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

BoldSign® Wins Developer's Choice in the 2025 Postman API Network Awards
BoldSign® Wins Developer's Choice in the 2025 Postman API Network Awards

Yahoo

timean hour ago

  • Yahoo

BoldSign® Wins Developer's Choice in the 2025 Postman API Network Awards

The Syncfusion® eSignature solution earns top honors for outstanding experience, performance, and community impact RESEARCH TRIANGLE PARK, N.C., June 11, 2025 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- Syncfusion®, Inc., the enterprise technology provider of choice, today announced that its eSignature solution, BoldSign®, won the Postman Developer's Choice Award. Selected by Postman's worldwide developer community, the award spotlights APIs that deliver exceptional user experience, measurable business value, and active community engagement. Syncfusion coming in at number one is a result of its commitment to building tools that developers and businesses trust. 'BoldSign started with a simple goal: give developers an eSignature API that lets them plug in, sign, and ship without friction,' said Daniel Jebaraj, CEO of Syncfusion. 'This award tells us we're on the right path and motivates us to keep raising the bar with features that help our customers move their products forward.' Businesses choose BoldSign due to its: Fast, friction-free signing: Legally binding signatures captured in seconds. Easy implementation: Most teams roll out in under a day with no heavy IT lifting. Web-to-mobile flexibility: Seamless experience for in-office and on-the-go staff. Bank-grade security and compliance: Robust encryption and compliance with SOC 2, HIPAA, GDPR, and eIDAS regulations. Scalability: Usage-based plans stay cost-effective for individuals, startups, and large enterprises. Real-time human support: Direct access to BoldSign experts whenever questions arise. Customer-driven roadmap: Continuous feature drops shaped by user feedback. 'Winning Developer's Choice is both humbling and energizing,' added Jebaraj. 'We're just getting started—look for new features, expanded SDKs, and deeper integrations so teams can scale from 10 to a million documents without switching platforms.' Learn more about the BoldSign® eSignature APIs in Postman. For more information about fast, secure, and scalable eSignature functionality in BoldSign, visit its website. About Syncfusion, in the technology hub of Research Triangle Park, N.C., Syncfusion®, Inc. delivers an award-winning ecosystem of developer control suites, embeddable BI platforms, and business software. Syncfusion was founded in 2001 with a single software component and a mission to support businesses of all sizes—from individual developers and start-ups to Fortune 500 enterprises. Though its pilot product, the Essential Studio® suite, has grown to over 1,900 developer controls, its mission remains the same. With offices in the U.S., India, and Kenya, Syncfusion prioritizes the customer experience by providing feature-rich solutions to help developers and enterprises solve complex problems, save money, and build high-performance, robust applications. Contact: Brittany KearnsPhone: 571-271-7211Email: brittany@ in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data

Smithsonian to review content at all 21 museums to see which is in violation of Trump's orders
Smithsonian to review content at all 21 museums to see which is in violation of Trump's orders

Yahoo

time3 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Smithsonian to review content at all 21 museums to see which is in violation of Trump's orders

All content within the Smithsonian's 21 museums and zoo is currently under review, with the institution looking to eradicate political influence and bias following an executive order by President Donald Trump, according to a report. The Smithsonian's Board of Regents is heeding Trump's executive order, which calls for the removal of 'improper, divisive or anti-American ideology' from the network of museums, The Wall Street Journal reported. The world's largest museum, education and research complex's decision to review its content was made during a closed-door meeting Monday, according to documents reviewed by the Journal. 'The board directed the secretary to assess content in museums and make needed changes to ensure unbiased content, including personnel changes,' a Smithsonian spokesperson said. 'The board requested that the secretary report back on progress and suggested next steps.' While Trump got his way with the review, he was unable to oust National Portrait Gallery Director Kim Sajet, whom he tried to fire via a Truth Social Post on May 30 for her support of diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives – even though it's not within his power to do so. In a statement Monday, the Smithsonian said that it retained power over personnel decisions. A person familiar with the meeting told the Journal no decisions had been made yet about Sajet's employment. Monday's board meeting was the first since Trump issued the executive order in March, and was the first with new members, Vice President J.D. Vance and Florida Republican Rep. Carlos Giménez. Vance and Giménez pushed for the Smithsonian to make the review within three months, but the motion that was adopted did not have a timeline. Still, Giménez told the Journal he thinks it will be completed quickly. Trump's anti-DEI order is unprecedented, considering the Smithsonian has largely operated independently for over 175 years. The order instructs the Smithsonian to focus on promoting 'American greatness,' and comes as Trump alleges objective facts within the museums have been replaced with a distorted, ideologically driven narrative. 'Museums in our Nation's capital should be places where individuals go to learn — not to be subjected to ideological indoctrination or divisive narratives that distort our shared history,' Trump's March executive order said.

DOCS Boosts Client Retention via Workflow Integration and AI Tools
DOCS Boosts Client Retention via Workflow Integration and AI Tools

Yahoo

time4 hours ago

  • Yahoo

DOCS Boosts Client Retention via Workflow Integration and AI Tools

The renowned digital platform for U.S. medical professionals, Doximity, Inc.'s DOCS client engagement and retention strategy is built around deeply integrated, physician-first tools across its Marketing, Hiring and Workflow Solutions. By focusing on clinical utility and streamlining healthcare professionals' day-to-day workflows, the platform has seen high adoption — more than 620,000 unique providers used its clinical tools in the fourth quarter of fiscal 2025. This functional alignment with medical practices enhances relevance and trust, making Doximity an essential platform for providers. DOCS' Marketing Solutions deliver personalized campaigns through newsfeeds, workflow placements and peer messaging modules. Leveraging AI and machine learning, these solutions help pharmaceutical and health system clients reach narrowly defined clinician segments with relevant content. This targeted, data-driven approach consistently delivers measurable engagement, encouraging clients to expand usage across multiple brands or service lines. To reinforce retention, Doximity invests in a strong customer success team that works hands-on with clients to fine-tune campaigns, optimize content and provide ongoing analytics. Clients also have access to a self-serve portal for real-time insights. This approach has helped drive upsell opportunities and long-term client relationships. On the enterprise side, Workflow Solutions like Dialer Enterprise and AMiON have seen significant traction. These tools are now embedded into hospital operations, making transitions away from Doximity less likely. Additionally, recent enhancements such as Doximity GPT, an AI-powered, HIPAA-compliant writing assistant, add further value for clients by reducing administrative burden. This month, GoodRx Holdings, Inc. GDRX launched Community Link, enabling independent pharmacies to directly contract with it using cost-plus pricing. This shift enhances pharmacy engagement by improving pricing control and participation in GoodRx's proprietary offering, Integrated Savings Program. This program plays a key role in the company's efforts to improve pharmacy engagement and retention. Also this month, GoodRx introduced a new erectile dysfunction subscription service — offering virtual consults, transparent pricing and home delivery — streamlining consumer access and promoting recurring use through simplified, stigma-free digital care options. Veeva Systems Inc. VEEV continues to strengthen client engagement through its growing Vault CRM Suite, which unifies medical, sales, and service teams around a shared customer view. In its first-quarter fiscal 2026 results, Veeva Systems highlighted momentum in products like Veeva Link and Crossix, which deliver real-time insights and multichannel engagement metrics. By expanding commercial cloud adoption and investing in data-rich, modular platforms, Veeva Systems reinforces customer stickiness, driving higher retention among top-tier life sciences clients. These innovations support more intelligent, coordinated outreach across the customer journey. Shares of Doximity have gained 9.6% year to date against the industry's loss of 0.9%. Image Source: Zacks Investment Research DOCS' forward 12-month P/E of 39.4X is higher than the industry's average of 14.6X, but is lower than its three-year median of 48.9X. It carries a Value Score of D. Image Source: Zacks Investment Research The Zacks Consensus Estimate for DOCS' fiscal 2026 earnings per share suggests a 3.5% improvement from fiscal 2025. Image Source: Zacks Investment Research Doximity stock currently carries a Zacks Rank #3 (Hold). You can see the complete list of today's Zacks #1 Rank (Strong Buy) stocks here. Want the latest recommendations from Zacks Investment Research? Today, you can download 7 Best Stocks for the Next 30 Days. Click to get this free report Veeva Systems Inc. (VEEV) : Free Stock Analysis Report GoodRx Holdings, Inc. (GDRX) : Free Stock Analysis Report Doximity, Inc. (DOCS) : Free Stock Analysis Report This article originally published on Zacks Investment Research ( Zacks Investment Research Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store