logo
Papers weighing legal options after Wydysh denies FOIL appeal

Papers weighing legal options after Wydysh denies FOIL appeal

Yahoo17-04-2025

The Niagara Gazette and the Lockport Union-Sun & Journal are weighing their legal options in light of Niagara County's continued insistence that the news outlets pay costs associated with scanning, redacting and copying public employee timesheets requested in electronic form as part of a Freedom of Information Law request filed in February.
In a letter dated April 10, Niagara County Legislature Chair Rebecca Wydysh, R-Lewiston, denied the newspapers' appeal of the county's FOIL request response dated March 14.
In the county's response, human resources director Peter Lopes identified 1,129 pages as 'potentially responsive' to the newspapers' request for timesheets submitted by attorneys working for the public defender's office between Jan. 1, 2023 and Feb. 10, 2025. In his letter, Lopes indicated that the county could make the documents available at a cost of $356.83. Lopes also proposed a less expensive option, estimated at $282.25, that would allow a reporter to conduct an in-person inspection of physical copies of redacted timesheets. The second option included a requirement that the reporter be accompanied by an assigned county employee, at the newspapers' cost, during the in-person inspection.
'An employee will sit with you while you inspect the records,' Lopes wrote. 'If time exceeds 120 minutes, you will be charged for that employee's time at their hourly rate.'
In an appeal sent to Wydysh on behalf of the newspapers, attorney Michael Higgins from the law firm Ernstrom & Dreste in Rochester argued that the county has no legal right under state law to charge by the page for copies of documents requested in electronic form. He also suggested the county's 'purported inability to scan documents without making physical copies' stretched 'the bounds of credulity.'
Higgins' appeal also asserted that the county's attempt to charge fees for administrative time to prepare photocopies of records is prohibited under state law and that it is 'improper' to charge the newspapers to allow a reporter to inspect records and to have those records redacted.
'Niagara County's attempts to charge for prohibited items and to unnecessarily copy documents to induce a charge is a transparent attempt to frustrate (the newspapers') FOIL request and avoid its obligations under the Freedom of Information Law,' Higgins wrote.
In her response, Wydysh restated the county's position that it is necessary to make physical copies of the requested documents so they can be redacted and scanned because some of the attorney timesheets 'may reflect medical or sick leave that is protected under HIPAA and exempt from FOIL disclosure.'
In addition, Wydysh argued, as Lopes did before her, that based on the volume of records, the human resources department would have to attach each pay period to a separate email, which would require staff time that the county would need to be reimbursed by the newspapers.
'Public Officer's Law requires an agency to send records electronically so long as the effort to effectuate that does not exceed the effort necessary for an alternative method of responding,' Wydysh wrote. 'Because of the necessity of reviewing the timesheets for compliance with HIPAA, and redacting portions of records that contain protected information, before scanning, it would be more labor intensive to scan the timesheets. In that circumstance, an agency is not required to provide the records electronically.'
Wydysh, citing a section of New York's Public Officer's Law, argues that the county is permitted to charge a fee based on the cost of the storage medium used, as well as the hourly salary of the lowest paid employee who has the skill needed to fulfill the request. Wydysh noted that the county advised the newspapers that the rate in this case would be $40.17 per hour.
As to the in-person inspection option, Wydysh indicates that the county would make available copies of the timesheets at a cost of 25 cents per page but would not allow a reporter to take pictures of the records. She also noted that it is the county's position that a staff member would need to sit in on the records inspection and that the newspapers would be charged 'any time over two hours.'
'The human resources department was still willing to satisfy your client's preference to receive records electronically, but your client would be charged for the time associated with copying, reviewing, redacting, scanning in the records and attaching,' Wydysh wrote in her letter denying the newspapers' appeal.
The newspapers can file an Article 78 proceeding in court to challenge Wydysh's denial of their appeal to the county's initial FOIL response.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Was Jim Cramer Right Backing Sunoco (SUN) as a Reliable Dividend Play Last Year?
Was Jim Cramer Right Backing Sunoco (SUN) as a Reliable Dividend Play Last Year?

Yahoo

time2 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Was Jim Cramer Right Backing Sunoco (SUN) as a Reliable Dividend Play Last Year?

We recently published a list of . In this article, we are going to take a look at where Sunoco LP (NYSE:SUN) stands against other stocks that Jim Cramer discusses. In that older discussion, a caller expressed concern over how ConocoPhillips' acquisition of Marathon Oil might impact other related companies like NuStar Energy L.P., which has known for its generous 9% dividend. NuStar was also acquired by Sunoco LP (NYSE:SUN) during that month. Cramer reassured the caller, saying: 'You know I like them. NS I like. My understanding is they're separate — if I find otherwise, I'll tell you. I think MPLX is a terrific situation and I don't want to back away from it.' A truck parked at a gas station, its fuel tank being filled from a pump. Cramer's cautious optimism around the dividend play held up well with a +6.86% gain. Sunoco LP (NYSE:SUN) is a master limited partnership engaged in the wholesale distribution of motor fuels and operates a network of fuel stations and convenience stores across the U.S. Overall, SUN ranks 5th on our list of stocks that Jim Cramer discusses. While we acknowledge the potential of SUN as an investment, our conviction lies in the belief that some AI stocks hold greater promise for delivering higher returns and have limited downside risk. If you are looking for an extremely cheap AI stock that is also a major beneficiary of Trump tariffs and onshoring, see our free report on the best short-term AI stock. READ NEXT: 20 Best AI Stocks To Buy Now and 30 Best Stocks to Buy Now According to Billionaires. Disclosure: None. This article is originally published at Insider Monkey. Sign in to access your portfolio

Enterprises Trust Flosum for Salesforce Data Protection and Compliance Leadership
Enterprises Trust Flosum for Salesforce Data Protection and Compliance Leadership

Business Wire

time2 hours ago

  • Business Wire

Enterprises Trust Flosum for Salesforce Data Protection and Compliance Leadership

SAN RAMON, Calif.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Flosum, the trusted leader in native Salesforce DevSecOps and data lifecycle management solutions, today reaffirmed market leadership in Salesforce data protection with its top-rated Backup and Archive solution. 'Enterprises and government agencies choose Flosum because we eliminate the complexity of third-party backup tools while helping them meet regulatory mandates with zero friction' - Girish Jashnani, CEO, Flosum. With a 5-star average rating on Salesforce AppExchange and a 4.8 platform-wide rating on G2, Flosum is recognized by enterprise users as the gold standard for eliminating data risk, reducing compliance burdens, and safeguarding critical Salesforce data and metadata. This enterprise-grade solution is the standard for enterprises seeking to reduce regulatory risk, nullify data loss, and protect mission-critical Salesforce data and metadata. Purpose-built for organizations in highly regulated industries, Flosum Backup and Archive delivers a comprehensive, automated solution for Salesforce backup, recovery, and long-term archiving. Flosum Backup & Archive has completely revolutionized backups for Salesforce data with their Composite Backup, which resolves the common issues related to Salesforce backup: 90% reduction in API calls used Full and Incremental backups in just minutes Minimal storage space required for backups and archives Fully automated backup, archive, and restore processes Start restoring data in just a couple clicks Hit your Recovery Time Objective with granular restore options, down to the field level Run on Flosum's hosted infrastructure or your own cloud or physical infrastructure Flosum security is preferred by Enterprises and government agencies 'Enterprises and government agencies choose Flosum because we eliminate the complexity of third-party backup tools while helping them meet regulatory mandates with zero friction,' said Girish Jashnani, CEO, Flosum. 'Our customers achieve instant recovery, faster audits, lower risk exposure, and real savings in both backup times and compliance costs.' Driving Real Business Value and Ensuring Enterprise Readiness Flosum Backup and Archive delivers immediate ROI and empowers enterprise teams by: Automating Compliance: Cut manual effort with policy-based data retention aligned to SOX, HIPAA, GDPR, FINRA, and more. Minimizing Downtime Risk: Enable point-in-time restore for quick recovery from data loss errors, corruption, or failed deployments. Maintaining Audit Readiness: Keep tamper-proof logs and restore histories audit-ready at all times. Scaling for Global Orgs: Proven scalability across large, complex Salesforce environments. Versioning Metadata: Track and restore metadata changes in CI/CD workflows for DevOps teams. Flosum has cemented itself as a leader in DevSecOps and data management thanks to its secure, compliant, and enterprise-ready solutions. Backup and Archive is a cornerstone of that vision, delivering cybersecurity resilience, control, speed, and compliance at scale. Learn more and schedule your demo today. About Flosum Flosum is the leading end-to-end secure DevOps, data management and data protection platform, built 100% natively to Salesforce. Our mission is to enable IT leaders to manage the Salesforce cloud with confidence and empower developers to innovate. Enterprises around the world use the company's platform to accelerate digital transformation by making the release process fast and easy, increase developer productivity and remain secure and compliant. More information can be found at:

Compliance Scorecard Releases Major Platform Upgrade with Enhanced Security Awareness Training, Risk Intelligence, and Compliance Automation
Compliance Scorecard Releases Major Platform Upgrade with Enhanced Security Awareness Training, Risk Intelligence, and Compliance Automation

Business Wire

time2 hours ago

  • Business Wire

Compliance Scorecard Releases Major Platform Upgrade with Enhanced Security Awareness Training, Risk Intelligence, and Compliance Automation

BUSINESS WIRE)-- Compliance Scorecard™, a Compliance as a Service (CaaS) platform provider, today announced significant new features that redefine how MSPs deliver Compliance-as-a-Service (CaaS) – with real-time metrics, streamlined audit readiness and customizable client governance capabilities. 'Our latest release reflects what MSPs have been asking for – less noise, more context, and real metrics that map directly to frameworks like CMMC, HIPAA, FTC Safeguards and SOC 2,' said Tim Golden, Founder and CEO of Compliance Scorecard. 'Our latest release reflects what MSPs have been asking for – less noise, more context, and real metrics that map directly to frameworks like CMMC, HIPAA, FTC Safeguards and SOC 2,' said Tim Golden, Founder and CEO of Compliance Scorecard. 'It's not just a checklist anymore. We're helping MSPs prove compliance with confidence.' Security Awareness Training is no longer a checkbox. Frameworks including CIS Control 14 demand governance, metrics, and measurable outcomes. Compliance Scorecard is the first platform to give MSPs live SAT metrics that are tied to compliance frameworks and fully auditable. Compliance Scorecard's KPI engine allows MSPs and their clients to define custom success metrics including phishing click rate, quiz scores, or training frequency, and see progress over time. Key New Features: Security Awareness Training (SAT) Scorecard: Unified SAT dashboard and KPI tracking across Symbol Security, Huntress, CyberHoot, Phin and others. Metrics tie directly to client policies, SOPs, and user adoption, with CIS Control 14 addressed through policy-backed, real-time insights. Risk and Assessment Automation: Built-in RACI modeling (Responsible, Accountable, Consulted, Informed) for assessment events, audit-aligned evidence fields (Examine, Interview, Test), and seamless connections between control objectives and the Risk Register. Policy and Adoption Engine: Unified policy templates for MSPs and clients, exportable adoption metrics, and customizable client email workflows for user invites, policy approvals and campaign tracking. Enhanced Platform Experience: Role-based access control with collapsible dashboards with persistent settings, and a mobile-optimized Trust Center and Knowledge Base for intuitive filtering and sorting. Compliance Scorecard will showcase the new release at Pax8 Beyond 2025, offering live demos, strategy sessions, and one-on-one consultations with its compliance experts. To learn more, visit or explore the offering in the Pax8 Marketplace. Compliance Scorecard is a leader in governance, risk, and compliance solutions for Managed Service Providers (MSPs). Built with a security-by-design philosophy, the platform simplifies compliance management, empowering MSPs to grow their business while protecting clients. With features such as policy management, risk registers, asset management, and SharePoint integration, Compliance Scorecard helps MSPs manage multiple clients and scale their compliance services with ease. Follow Compliance Scorecard on YouTube, LinkedIn and Facebook.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store