German minister warns Israel that no military goal justifies Gaza deaths
Germany's Development Minister Reem Alabali-Radovan, a refugee born of Iraqi parents, was on the verge of tears on Monday as she called on Israel to stop 'destroying lives in Gaza'.
Newly appointed as a cabinet minister in the post of Federal Minister for Economic Co-operation and Development, Ms Alabali-Radovan demanded full humanitarian access to the besieged territory.
My personal history as a refugee coming to Germany shows the point that if we don't do anything with those crises is that people tend to flee
Reem Alabali-Radovan
'There can and must be no military goal that justifies children starving, mothers being unable to receive treatment for their injured children, or entire families being buried under rubble,' she told the Hamburg Sustainability Conference. 'No political strategy must lead to the blocking of humanitarian aid.'
Warning of a 'man-made humanitarian catastrophe', Ms Alabali–Radovan said an immediate ceasefire must be followed by permanent restoration of aid flows. 'Without a ceasefire, there will be no protection for civilians, no secure supply, and no prospect of political solutions,' she said.
'The continued violence is not only destroying lives, but also any prospect of peace. The Hamas terrorist attack on October 7 was a barbaric act. Protecting one's own population is a legitimate goal – both military and political,' she added. 'But every state action is subject to international law.'
German political culture has been highly supportive of Israel throughout the conflict, with ministers loath to depart from an approach guided by history. Chancellor Friedrich Merz, of the centre-right Christian Democratic Union (CDU), has entered office at a time of crisis in Germany's position on Gaza.
He is reportedly charting a new course with a harder line on aid access. The German leader spoke by phone with Israel's Benjamin Netanyahu to warn of the urgent need to allow sufficient humanitarian aid to flow into the Gaza Strip.
Ms Alabali-Radovan was backed up in her assertions by Cindy McCain, the director general of the World Food Programme, who hit out at accusation of looting and diversion of aid on entry to Gaza. 'In the case of Gaza it is such a catastrophe,' she said.
'These people are not terrorists, they are starving to death. If they see an aid truck coming they want food for their families. I would do anything to feed my family. I think you would too.'
The Social Democrat politician is the first from her Middle Eastern background to have reached the highest rung of German politics. She was born in Moscow, where her Chaldean Iraqi parents were exiled in the Soviet Union, having fled the regime of Saddam Hussein.
The family then moved to Germany, where she grew up. In the early part of her career she worked with refugees before entering politics and working for a spell as minister for integration. Now as a development minister at time when the US and other major allies have cut spending designed to assist the world's poorest, Ms Alabali-Radovan is seeking to use Germany's strong budget for global assistance to build trust.
'It is my job to explain why it is important to Germany that we cope with the crisis we are speaking about,' she said. 'My personal history as a refugee coming to Germany shows the point that if we don't do anything with crises then people tend to flee, they don't want to but they have to, and I give this example to show why it's important.'
Sponsors of the Hamburg conference hope the meeting can provide a counter-balance to the dramatic move by the Trump administration to withdraw from the multilateral international institutions.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Arabian Business
27 minutes ago
- Arabian Business
Bruno Fernandes rejects 'big' Al-Hilal offer to stay with Manchester United
Manchester United captain Bruno Fernandes has reportedly turned down a lucrative offer to join Saudi Pro League 's Al-Hilal and stay with the struggling club, which finished 15th in the Premier League in the 2024-25 season. The Portuguese midfielder was reportedly offered a salary that would have been nearly tripled his current salary with Manchester United. According to several British media outlets, the offered deal was said to be in the region of £80 million-£100 million (US$108 million-US$135 million). The 30-year-old captain was the lone bright spark for United in a dismal season. He scored 19 goals and provided 19 assists in 57 appearances across all competitions for the club last season, and was named the club's Player of the Year for the fourth time. Ahead of Portugal's Nation League semifinal match against Germany, the 30-year-old confirmed the talks and said he decided to stay back to play at a 'higher level' after discussions with United coach Ruben Amorim and his family. 'There was that possibility, the president of Al-Hilal called me a month ago to ask me about it,' Fernandes said. 'It was a big offer, very ambitious. There was a waiting period for me to think about the future. 'I would be willing to do it if Manchester United thought so. I spoke to the coach, who really tried to talk me out of it. The club said they would not be willing to sell me, only if I wanted to leave. 'I spoke to my wife and family, and she asked me what my personal goals were in my career. 'It would have been easy to move there, but I want to keep myself at the highest level, playing in the big competitions and I feel capable of it. I am happy with my decision.' Al-Hilal has not made any statement on the deal. Former United star Rio Ferdinand said on his podcast that the news of Fernandes staying was 'the biggest news for me today, I've got to be honest.' Another former United star, Gary Neville, told Sky Sports that a transfer would not have been a bad deal, financially, for the club, but added: 'He's so important. The fact that he wants to stay, the fact that he wants to go through this and come out the other side – because it would have been easy for him at the end of this season to say, 'Look, I'm done here' – will endear him towards Manchester United fans even more.'
Middle East Eye
34 minutes ago
- Middle East Eye
US-backed Gaza aid group suspends distribution to starving Palestinians for a day
The US and Israel-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), which has been plagued by scandal, has said it will not give out any aid on Wednesday to starving Palestinians. The decision comes the day after Israeli forces killed at least 27 Palestinians as they were attempting to reach a GHF distribution site in Rafah. Crowds had gathered early in the al-Alam area, west of Rafah, seeking basic food supplies, amid worsening, famine-like conditions in the Gaza Strip. Israeli artillery and warplanes then targeted civilians, according to eyewitnesses. The GHF said on Wednesday that it had paused distribution for a day, and asked the Israeli military to "guide foot traffic in a way that minimises confusion or escalation risks" near military perimeters, develop clearer guidance for civilians and improve training to support civilian safety. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters "Our top priority remains ensuring the safety and dignity of civilians receiving aid," a GHF spokesperson said. Meanwhile, an Israeli military spokesperson labelled areas leading to GHF sites 'combat zones', issuing a warning against civilians moving in those areas. The spokesperson did not elaborate on how an aid distribution site was a combat zone, or how civilians were supposed to receive aid without moving in the area. 'Recipe for disaster' The UN and aid organisations have accused the GHF, which uses private American security and logistics workers, of militarising humanitarian aid. The killings on Tuesday marked the latest in a string of Israeli attacks on Palestinians seeking aid at newly established GHF-run distribution points. At least 102 Palestinians have been killed and over 490 wounded in similar attacks over the past eight days since the initiative's launch, according to the Gaza-based Government Media Office. Gaza Humanitarian Foundation appoints US evangelical leader who denied mass killings as chief Read More » "The so-called 'aid' distribution centres, situated in exposed and perilous red zones controlled by the occupying forces, have become bloodbaths. Starving civilians are lured there due to the crippling famine and tight siege," the office said in a statement. "They are then deliberately and coldly shot, a scene that exposes the true malice of the operation and its real objectives." The office described these actions as genocide, war crimes and crimes against humanity, calling for immediate global action and an investigation into the latest Israeli assaults. "The continuation of these crimes, amid shameful international silence, is a stain on humanity and proves that the occupation continues to perpetrate the most heinous forms of genocide under the world's gaze, without deterrence or accountability," the statement concluded. The UN Security Council is due on Wednesday to vote on a demand for a ceasefire in Gaza and humanitarian access into the enclave. It is not yet clear whether Washington will veto the proposal. Malnutrition has become widespread as aid has only trickled into the enclave since Israel partially lifted an 11-week blockade in late May. "It is unacceptable. Civilians are risking - and in several instances losing - their lives just trying to get food," UN spokesperson Stephane Dujarric said. He added that the GHF's aid distribution model was "a recipe for disaster, which is exactly what is going on." The GHF this week named evangelical leader Johnnie Moore, a former adviser to US President Donald Trump, as its new chief. Moore, a former member of the US Commission on International Religious Freedom, has dismissed reports of mass killings at the GHF aid sites as 'fictional massacres'. He was appointed after the initiative's former head, Jake Wood, resigned. Moore has emerged as a vocal advocate for the scandal-plagued initiative, claiming that reports of the killings were 'lies…spread by terrorists,' contradicting eyewitness accounts, footage, and reports by hospital directors and medical staff.
Middle East Eye
34 minutes ago
- Middle East Eye
Exclusive: UK believes Trump may sanction Amal Clooney over ICC Palestine role
The British government believes the US could sanction prominent human rights lawyer Amal Clooney over her role advising the ICC chief prosecutor on arrest warrants for Israeli leaders, Middle East Eye can reveal. In April it emerged that the British Foreign Office had warned senior British lawyers involved in the ICC's war crimes case against two senior Israeli leaders that they are at risk of US sanctions. This came after the Trump administration imposed financial and visa sanctions on Karim Khan, the court's British chief prosecutor, in February. Last November the ICC issued arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former Defence Minister Yoav Gallant on charges of war crimes and crimes against humanity. Trump's executive order, a response to the arrest warrants, warned further measures could follow 'on those responsible for those transgressions'. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters Multiple sources within the British government told MEE that last week the Foreign Office's legal directorate listed Amal Clooney and Lord Justice Adrian Fulford as being potentially at risk of US sanctions. Clooney, a prominent British barrister of Lebanese and Palestinian descent, is the wife of Hollywood actor George Clooney. But she is not an American citizen and could be barred from entering the US if she is sanctioned. 'I believe in the rule of law' Both lawyers served early last year on an independent panel of legal advisors convened by the ICC prosecutor. The panel expressed their support for Khan's decision to seek arrest warrants for senior Israeli and Hamas leaders for war crimes and crimes against humanity, and ICC judges granted his application in November. In a statement published on the Clooney Foundation for Justice (CFJ) website last May, Clooney said she served on the panel 'because I believe in the rule of law and the need to protect civilian lives". Amal Clooney critics humbled as role in Israel-Hamas ICC arrest warrant bid revealed Read More » 'As a human rights lawyer, I will never accept that one child's life has less value than another's,' she added. Adam Keith, a director at Human Rights First, told MEE: "The Trump administration's sanctions programme targeting the ICC is so sweeping that just providing legal advice or input regarding the court's Palestine investigation appears to be sanctionable. "This means it could get any non-American placed on the Treasury Department's financial blacklist and barred from entering the United States." Keith described the programme as "an outrageous misuse of sanctions, and a direct attack on an accountability body that survivors and advocates around the world rely on for justice". The British Foreign Office did not respond to multiple requests for comment. The CFJ was co-founded by the Clooneys in 2016. In 2024 Amal won the Legal 500 Award for international lawyer of the year. And just last week she was photographed backstage at her husband's Broadway play Good Night, and Good Luck with senior Democrats Hillary Clinton and Nancy Pelosi. Trump's order gave the US Treasury and State Department a 60-day deadline to provide recommendations on who else besides Khan should be sanctioned. No further sanctions have been announced, although they may not have been made public. Fulford, named alongside by Clooney by the British Foreign Office's legal directorate, is a former judge of the ICC and former vice-president of the Court of Appeal. In December 2024 he said it was 'vital' that ICC member states should act on the warrant for Netanyahu's arrest. MEE contacted Fulford and the Clooney Foundation for Justice for comment but did not receive a response by the time of publication.
