Harvard to relinquish slave photos to resolve descendant's lawsuit, World News
BOSTON — Harvard University has agreed to give up ownership of photos of an enslaved father and his daughter who were forced to be photographed in 1850 for a racist study by a professor trying to prove the inferiority of Black people to resolve a lawsuit by one of their descendants.
The settlement was announced on Wednesday (May 28) by the legal team representing Tamara Lanier, who had waged a six-year legal battle over what she alleged was its wrongful claim of ownership over photos that were taken without her ancestors' consent.
The photos will not go to Lanier as part of the settlement, but instead will be turned over along with pictures of five other enslaved people to the International African American Museum in Charleston, South Carolina.
"Harvard played a role in the darkest chapter in American history," Lanier said in a statement. "This is a small step in the right direction towards fully acknowledging that history and working to rectify it."
Cambridge, Massachusetts-based Harvard said it had long been eager to place the photos with another public institution "to put them in the appropriate context and increase access to them for all Americans".
"This settlement now allows us to move forward towards that goal," the school said.
The settlement comes as Harvard fights in court against efforts by President Donald Trump's administration to terminate billions of dollars in grant funding and end its ability to enrol foreign students.
The lawsuit concerned images depicting Renty Taylor and his daughter Delia, slaves on a South Carolina plantation who were forced to disrobe for photos taken for a racist study by Harvard Professor Louis Agassiz.
The photos were being kept at the Peabody Museum of Archaeology and Ethnology on Harvard's campus when Lanier sued in 2019.
A judge in Massachusetts initially dismissed the case. But the state's highest court revived it in 2022, saying she had plausibly alleged Harvard was negligent and recklessly caused her to suffer emotional distress.
Justice Scott Kafker, writing for the court, said Harvard "cavalierly" dismissed Lanier's claims of an ancestral link and disregarded her requests for information about how it was using the pictures, including when the school used Renty Taylor's image on a book cover.
He called the pictures' creation "horrific" and said Harvard had "responsibilities to the descendants of the individuals coerced into having their half-naked images captured in the daguerreotypes".
[[nid:718353]]
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNA
17 hours ago
- CNA
Harvard graduation overshadowed by Trump threats
BOSTON: Thousands of Harvard students in crimson-fringed gowns celebrated their graduation Thursday (May 29), as a judge extended a temporary block on Donald Trump's bid to prevent the prestigious university from enrolling international scholars. Trump has made Harvard the central target of his campaign against elite US universities, which he has also threatened with funding freezes over what he says is liberal bias and antisemitism. Judge Allison Burroughs said she would later issue a preliminary injunction that "gives some protection" to international students while the sides argue over the legality of Trump's stance. "Our students are terrified and we're (already) having people transfer" to other universities, Harvard's lawyer Ian Gershengorn said during the hearing in Boston. In an eleventh-hour filing ahead of the hearing, the Trump administration issued a formal notice of intent to withdraw Harvard's ability to enrol foreign students, kick-starting the process. The filing gave Harvard 30 days to produce evidence showing why it should not be blocked from hosting and enrolling foreign students, who make up 27 per cent of Harvard's student body. Burroughs had already temporarily paused the policy, extending that pause Thursday pending the new injunction. She said she would seek to determine whether the actions of Trump's officials had "a retaliatory motive." A law professor present in the packed court said the Trump administration was prolonging the suffering of students. "Harvard is in this purgatory. What is an international student to do?" said the Harvard Law School graduate, who declined to be named. "PRIDE AND APPROVAL" There also remained "this spectre of other actions" the government could take to block Harvard from having international students, she added. The Ivy League institution has continually drawn Trump's ire while publicly rejecting his administration's repeated demands to give up control of recruitment, curricula and research choices. "Harvard is treating our country with great disrespect, and all they're doing is getting in deeper and deeper," Trump said Wednesday. Harvard president Alan Garber got a huge cheer Thursday when he mentioned international students attending the graduation with their families, saying it was "as it should be" - but Garber did not mention the Trump fight directly. He received a standing ovation, which one student told AFP was "revealing of the community's pride and approval." Garber has led the legal fightback in US academia after Trump targeted several prestigious universities, including Columbia, which made sweeping concessions to the administration, hoping to claw back US$400 million of withdrawn federal grants. He has acknowledged that Harvard does have issues with antisemitism and that it has struggled to ensure that a variety of views can be safely heard on campus. Graduating student Uzma Farheen, from India, obtained a Master of Public Health and said the day was one of "love for the global community". "We stand united to powerfully represent what Harvard stands for - truth, integrity, and inclusion," she told AFP. Ahead of the ceremony, at which stage and screen star Rita Moreno was awarded an honorary degree, members of the Harvard band in crimson blazers filed through the narrow streets of Cambridge. In front of a huge stage, hundreds of students assembled to hear speeches, including one entirely in Latin, in a grassy precinct that was closed off to the public for security. Many students from the Harvard Kennedy School of Government carried inflatable plastic globes at the ceremony to symbolise the international makeup of the school's student body. "In the last two months it's been very difficult, I've been feeling a lot of vulnerability," said one such student, Lorena Mejia, 36, who graduated with a Master's in Public Administration and proudly wore robes identifying her as a Colombian.
CNA
a day ago
- CNA
US signals it may back off immediate revocation in Harvard foreign students case
BOSTON: The Trump administration signaled on Thursday (May 29) it might back away from plans to immediately revoke Harvard University's ability to enroll international students and would instead pursue a lengthier administrative process. According to a court filing, the US Department of Homeland Security sent Harvard a notice of intent on Wednesday to withdraw the school's certification under the federal Student and Exchange Visitor Program (SEVP), which allows Harvard to enroll non-US students. Harvard has denied Trump administration charges of alleged bias against conservatives, fostering antisemitism on campus and coordinating with the Chinese Communist Party. It has 30 days to respond to the notice. The notice came ahead of a scheduled hearing before US District Judge Allison Burroughs in Boston over whether to extend a temporary order blocking US President Donald Trump's administration from revoking the Ivy League school's right to host international students. Harvard has said losing that right would affect about one quarter of its student body and devastate the school. Neither Harvard nor DHS immediately responded to requests for comment. Harvard had argued that the revocation violated its free speech and due process rights under the US Constitution as well as the Administrative Procedure Act, which governs agency actions. Its lawyers said DHS regulations required providing at least 30 days to challenge the agency's allegations, and give Harvard an opportunity to pursue an administrative appeal. The revocation announced on May 22 was an escalation of the Trump administration's attack on Harvard. The Cambridge, Massachusetts-based university's lawyers argued the agency's action was part of an "unprecedented and retaliatory attack on academic freedom at Harvard", which is pursuing a separate lawsuit challenging the administration's decision to terminate nearly US$3 billion in federal research funding. Harvard argues the Trump administration is retaliating against it for refusing to cede to its demands to control the school's governance, curriculum and the "ideology" of its faculty and students. The case before Burroughs, an appointee of Democratic President Barack Obama, was filed after Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem revoked the school's SEVP certification. In announcing the decision, Noem, without providing evidence, accused the university of "fostering violence, antisemitism, and coordinating with the Chinese Communist Party." In a letter that day, she accused the school of refusing to comply with wide-ranging requests for information on its student visa holders, including about any activity they engaged in that was illegal or violent or that would subject them to discipline. "As I explained to you in my April letter, it is a privilege to enroll foreign students, and it is also a privilege to employ aliens on campus," she said. Harvard said the decision was "devastating" for the school and its student body. The university, the nation's oldest and wealthiest, enrolled nearly 6,800 international students in its current school year, about 27 per cent of its total enrollment. The department's move would prevent Harvard from enrolling new international students and require existing ones to transfer to other schools or lose their legal status. Trump told reporters in the Oval Office on Wednesday that Harvard University should have a 15 per cent cap on the number of non-US students it admits. "Harvard has got to behave themselves," he said.
Sassy Mama
a day ago
- Sassy Mama
Students At This School Gain A Competitive Edge At Universities With College-level Academics (+ $500 Off!)
Discover how the International Community School's Advanced Placement (AP) courses prepare students for university and beyond through rigorous, college-level academics – with students consistently outperforming global benchmarks! Looking for a school that equips your child with the right skills and foundation for university and beyond? Choosing the right school plays a big part in helping your child reach their full potential, and preparing them for success at the right university is just as important. At the International Community School (ICS) in Singapore, students don't just excel academically, they also grow into confident individuals who are prepared to thrive in any environment. With a globally recognised American curriculum, ICS equips them with the tools, values, and real-world experience they need to thrive. Recognising students' potential for academic success and beyond ICS offers 25 Advanced Placement (AP) courses that challenge students with college-level academic work in high school. With an average score of 4 out of 5, ICS students consistently outperform global averages, giving them a competitive edge when applying to top universities. These strong results also often allow students to earn early college credit. As the Class of 2025 prepares to graduate, their university acceptances reflect not just academic excellence but also personal growth and a readiness to lead in a rapidly changing world. This year's seniors are heading to prestigious universities across the United States, United Kingdom, Asia, and more. Alumni like Sann Nu Wai (PhD from Imperial College London) and Nathan Low, who has earned his B.A., cum laude, from UC Berkeley and his Juris Doctor (JD) from UCLA School of Law, further amplify that ICS prepares students for success in every field. Yushi Liao (Class of 2024) is studying Materials Science at City University of Hong Kong and contributing to sustainability projects. 'ICS taught me that service is action,' she says, emphasising the school's focus on purposeful learning. Personalised pathways with a supportive community At ICS, every student is encouraged to explore their passions and goals. With one-on-one academic counselling, students receive the personalised guidance they need to plan and prepare for university applications. A low student-to-teacher ratio also means students get the individual attention they need every step of the way. The school's supportive community doesn't end at graduation, many ICS alumni stay connected to the community, with some even returning to teach, coach, and guide the next batch of students! Ready to explore how ICS can prepare your teen for university? Sign up for their upcoming virtual Open House on 4 June 2025 to learn more! Join ICS's Virtual Open Houses to enjoy a $500 waiver on your application fee! Secure your spots here. International Community School (ICS), 27a Jubilee Road, Singapore 128575,
