Government 'lost touch', says long-serving councillor
"Good Labour councillors who I've worked with over the years... all that experience has gone."
Speaking earlier this week, John Clarke's frustration at the election results for Nottinghamshire County Council was plain to see.
After Reform UK's decisive victory, other parties have started the inquest into what went wrong for them.
The Conservatives lost control of the authority and have been left with 17 seats - a net loss of 20 compared to the last election - and will now be the main opposition group.
Labour, on the other hand, were reduced to just four seats - the party's worst ever performance in an election for Nottinghamshire County Council, at least in its current form.
Clarke was one of the few who held on to their seats, maintaining a decades-long personal winning streak.
When he was first elected as a Gedling borough councillor in 1989, Neil Kinnock was Labour leader.
He has won every election he has stood in ever since, joining the county council in 1997 and becoming Gedling's leader in 2011.
He claims, however, that he has never been asked by his party what the secret to his success is, and he had considered not standing this year.
Had the election come a year before, when Labour was performing far better in the opinion polls, he said the result would likely have been very different.
"We should've walked into this place, but we haven't," Clarke said.
"I thought we'd do a lot better than that, but I think the government - my government - have lost touch with ordinary people."
He criticised the cutting of winter fuel payments for some pensioners, but stopped short of calling for a full U-turn.
"I think they need to look at it, and fairly obviously some people were taking it for a ride, but in most cases that was part of people's budget," he said.
"I represent a lot of vulnerable people, and they're very very angry. Lifelong Labour supporters who've said no."
There have been similar calls from some Labour MPs, but on Tuesday the government insisted it will not reverse the cuts.
But Clarke claimed the electoral drubbing was not purely down to national factors.
He is an outspoken opponent of plans that could see boroughs like Gedling combined with Nottingham city, and said his concerns were shared by voters in the election campaign.
"That came through loud and clear on the doorstep, on the bus, anywhere else, you could hear people chattering about it," he said.
"They do not want to be joined up with the city."
No decisions have been made over the future configuration of Nottinghamshire councils, but ministers say merging some authorities will help streamline services.
The city council's leader has previously argued the city is "significantly under-bounded" and said "we need to address that imbalance".
There has been acknowledgment from government that the local election results were "disappointing", and earlier this week Health Secretary Wes Streeting told the BBC ministers were "reflecting on what the voters told us".
Clarke, however, issued a stark warning.
"I think the next general election is up for grabs at the moment, unless they start steering in another way."
The Labour Party was contacted for comment.
Follow BBC Nottingham on Facebook, on X, or on Instagram. Send your story ideas to eastmidsnews@bbc.co.uk or via WhatsApp on 0808 100 2210.
Reform councillor steps down after a week
Reform takes control of Nottinghamshire County Council
What now for county council after shock Reform win?
Nottinghamshire County Council
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Boston Globe
4 hours ago
- Boston Globe
Trump budget's caps on grad school loans could worsen doctor shortage
Four years of medical education costs $286,454 at a public school, on average, and $390,848 at a private one, according to the Association of American Medical Colleges. Medical school graduates leave with an average debt of $212,341, the association found. Get Starting Point A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday. Enter Email Sign Up The price of a four-year program in osteopathic medicine is $297,881 at a public school, on average, and $371,403 at a private school, according to the American Association of Colleges of Osteopathic Medicine. The average indebtedness of their graduates is $259,196. Advertisement The proposed loan caps 'will either push students and families into the private loan market, where they take on more risk and have less consumer protection, or simply push people out of higher education altogether,' said Aissa Canchola Bañez, policy director at the Student Borrower Protection Center, a nonprofit advocacy group. Private student loans are also not eligible for Public Service Loan Forgiveness programs, which many students rely on to manage their debt. Students from low-income families may have difficulty qualifying for private loans. Advertisement In a letter to congressional leaders, the American Medical Association asked lawmakers to carve out exceptions in the law for medical education, saying that the current bill would deter good candidates from applying to medical school, discourage physicians from working in underserved areas, and make medical school unaffordable for all but the very wealthy. Critics said it could also drive more doctors away from lower-paying primary care fields, an area of acute need, and into more lucrative specialties. Conservatives have argued for decades that the availability of federal student loans allowed tuition costs to balloon — a proposition rejected by the Association of American Medical Colleges, which instead blames the rising cost of living. Studies examining the relationship between loans and tuition have varied in their conclusions. Sara Robertson, press secretary for Republicans on the House Education and Workforce Committee, said the proposed loan limits 'will drive down the cost of medical school and thus reduce the need for students to borrow in the first place.' She said private lenders would offer students lower interest rates than the government's Grad PLUS program would. The private market, though, has shrunk markedly since the Great Recession, according to Lesley Turner, an associate professor of public policy at the University of Chicago and an author of an unpublished paper that linked loans to rising tuition. In an email, Turner said it wasn't clear that 'the same level of nonfederal funding would be available today.' Because of inflation, she noted, the $150,000 limit for medical students is 'substantially reducing the amount these students can borrow, even compared to the status quo before the Grad PLUS program.' The program was started in 2006. Advertisement Robertson said schools could also help close the gap. 'Nothing in the bill prevents colleges from providing additional financial aid to low-income students pursuing medical school,' she said. That is not an option for schools of osteopathic medicine, most of which are private and not attached to universities with foundations, and which currently enroll almost one-third of the nation's future doctors, said David Bergman, senior vice president of government relations and health affairs for the American Association of Colleges of Osteopathic Medicine. And many academic medical centers, which have lost millions of dollars in research grants abruptly pulled by the Trump administration, are facing severe financial strain. A vast majority of medical students rely on loans, not just those from low-income backgrounds, Bergman noted. Ending federal involvement in administering and subsidizing student loans was one of the goals laid out in Project 2025, the Heritage Foundation's conservative blueprint for overhauling the government. It argued that leaving student loans to private lenders and ending federal loan forgiveness programs would 'allow for market prices and signals to influence educational borrowing.' Trump's policy bill would allow medical residents to defer not only their loan payments but also the interest on those payments, a provision that many medical professionals have supported. But the legislation would prohibit residents from counting those low-paid years of training as public service, limiting their eligibility for a popular loan forgiveness program that encourages young doctors to work in underserved areas. As a result, 'access to much-needed medical care for patients in rural and underserved communities will be diminished,' the American Medical Association's CEO, Dr. James Madara, wrote in the letter to House Speaker Mike Johnson, Republican of Louisiana, and House Democratic leader Representative Hakeem Jeffries of New York. Advertisement The changes will disproportionately affect low-income students with backgrounds that are underrepresented in medicine, who may face more difficulty obtaining private loans, said Dr. Virginia Caine, president of the National Medical Association, which represents Black physicians and which advocates for health equity. In turn, she said, it will limit those students' ability to return to serve in their communities. By 2037, the United States is expected to face a shortage of 187,130 physicians, including 87,150 primary care physicians such as internists and pediatricians who play a pivotal role in the early detection and management of chronic disease, according to the federal Health Resources and Services Administration. (There are currently 933,788 professionally active physicians.) About 75 million Americans live in areas where it is difficult to get access to primary care. The ratio of primary care providers is projected to decline to 76.8 per 100,000 people by 2037, from 81.6 per 100,000 in 2022. This article originally appeared in
Hamilton Spectator
4 hours ago
- Hamilton Spectator
Canada plans huge boost in defence spending to hit NATO target by year's end, Carney says
OTTAWA — Prime Minister Mark Carney tore up Canada's timelines for boosted military spending on Monday and replaced them with an aggressive pledge of $9.3 billion to finally hit Canada's long-standing commitment to the North Atlantic Treaty Organization within a year — half a decade faster than previously promised. The new funding is on top of $53.4 billion in already-expected defence spending in the current 2025-26 fiscal year, and will — among other things — boost military salaries, replace and repair aging equipment, and increase the ranks of the short-staffed Canadian Armed Forces, Carney said. It will also lift Canadian defence spending past the equivalent of two per cent of gross domestic product (GDP), the prime minister said, a threshold the country has failed to achieve since all NATO members agreed to meet it in 2014. Carney said his government would continue increasing defence spending even further as NATO prepares for a summit later this month, where leaders like U.S. President Donald Trump and the alliance's secretary general have forecast talks towards a new defence spending target of five per cent of GDP. In a speech at the University of Toronto on Monday, and later at a news conference at Fort York, Carney declared the new track to hit the NATO target is needed in a world made more dangerous by Russia's aggression in Ukraine, rising competition between great powers and a less reliable United States. Billions of new spending earmarked for the military over the past decade is 'still not close enough to face these mounting risks,' Carney said. 'The brave women and men who are protecting our sovereignty do not have the resources they need for a risker world,' he added, describing how only 'one of our four submarines is seaworthy' and 'less than half our maritime fleet and land vehicles are operational.' The Department of National Defence (DND) reported last year that 51 per cent of its maritime fleet, 56 per cent of its 'key land fleets' and 54 per cent of its air fleets met their definition for operational readiness in 2022-23. In the House of Commons, Conservative MP James Bezan accused the Liberals of 'breaking our military' through underinvestment, and charged that 'nobody believes them' when they talk of boosting defence spending. Jill McKnight, the Liberal veterans affairs minister, responded that defence spending fell below one per cent of GDP in 2014, when the Conservatives were in power. In recent years, Canada has come under intensifying political pressure to hit the NATO target. Russia's invasion of Ukraine in February 2022 prompted calls across the West to rapidly rearm with the return of Cold War-era tensions. Canadian military officials and the federal government have also pointed to China as a potential threat, especially in the Arctic, where the advance of climate change is widely expected to open trading routes and access to resources. Last summer, at the NATO summit in Washington, Canada came under fire from Republican politicians over its relatively low ratio of defence spending. As the Star reported at the time, the government arrived at the meetings without a clear plan to demonstrate how it would hit the NATO spending target. On the final day, then-prime minister Justin Trudeau promised Canada would achieve it by 2032, but did not provide details of how. He also criticized the idea of the spending target, dismissing it as a ' crass mathematical calculation ' that doesn't reflect Canada's true contribution to the military alliance. Trump has railed against NATO members he sees as taking advantage of the huge American military to spend less on their protection — criticism he has levied at Canada and European allies alike. On Monday, Carney repeated his pledges to deepen partnerships with like-minded democracies, including by seeking to participate in the European Union's defence industrial plan, ReArm Europe. He also said DND will 'immediately design a new defence policy' barely one year after it released the last one, which earmarked $8.1 billion in fresh spending over five years — less than the $9.3 billion in a single year that Carney unveiled Monday. The new spending includes $2.63 billion to help recruit and retain soldiers, as the CAF grapples with a persistent personnel shortfall of 13,000 it aims to overcome by 2030. It also includes $2.1 billion for a new 'defence industrial strategy' to build more munitions in Canada, and explore ways to development critical minerals, energy, and communications infrastructure the military needs, according to officials who briefed journalists. On top of that, the government pledged $2 billion to 'diversify' defence partnerships beyond the U.S., with money to be spent on new defence policy advisers who will be sent abroad as part of a diplomatic push, officials said. The $62.7 billion now expected for defence spending in the current fiscal year is mostly budgeted for DND, officials said, but also includes spending from 13 other government departments — like Veterans Affairs and Global Affairs Canada — that is counted toward the NATO target. The government also announced Monday that the Canadian Coast Guard will be used for some defence purposes. Officials said Monday that the government doesn't plan to arm Coast Guar boats, but will use the agency to boost the military's maritime surveillance, especially in the Arctic. Alluding to the ongoing trade war over Trump's tariffs, which Canada deems illegal and unjustified, Carney argued the rapid increase in defence spending is necessary in a world changing so dramatically. The once-reliable U.S., he said, is 'monetizing its hegemony' amidst other threats that require Canada to bolster its military. But Carney also said Monday that there is still room for Canada to deepen its military ties with the U.S., pointing to ballistic missile defence as a possible example. In recent weeks, Carney confirmed Canada is in talks with the U.S. to join Trump's $243-billion 'Golden Dome' missile defence system, although the government has not said how much money it might spend to do so. 'There are many, many reasons for very close, if not enhanced, co-operation between Canada and the United States,' Carney said. The prime minister also defended the new spending, which comes as the new Liberal minority government delays its first budget — normally presented each spring — until the fall sitting of Parliament. Carney said part of the reason to wait is for clarity on Canada's defence commitments. That will come up at this months' NATO summit in The Hague, where leaders are expected to agree to a new spending target. NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte predicted the alliance will endorse a threshold of five per cent of GDP, with more than three per cent on 'hard' defence spending and the rest for 'defence-related' investments. Carney said Monday that he's confident Canada can get there, stating that defence industrial spending on areas like artificial intelligence, critical minerals and quantum computing are already 'in the zone' of 1.5 per cent of GDP. 'Defence, it literally is to keep our citizens secure, and we'll do what's needed,' he said.
Yahoo
6 hours ago
- Yahoo
Two more Welsh politicians defect to Nigel Farage's Reform UK
Reform leader Nigel Farage has used a keynote speech in Wales to announced that two more Welsh councillors have defected. Speaking in Port Talbot, he announced independent councillors Andrew Barry and David Hughes, both members of Merthyr Tydfil council, have joined Reform UK. They were welcomed to the stage during a speech that has given his first glimpses of policies ahead of the election. Mr Farage said the party would allow coal mining again in Wales and says its long term plan is to "reopen the Port Talbot steelworks". Cllr Barry, who has had the cabinet brief for finance, says he has seen "waste" in the system during his time. He said: "The people making the decisions on those hundreds of thousands of pounds are unelected members of the council. READ MORE: Reform UK's Nigel Farage's eight election policies for Wales READ MORE: Huge Winter Fuel Payment U-turn means millions more will get it this year "I see Reform as the only opposition in Wales." You can follow live updates from the speech here. Meanwhile David Hughes, who had previously had the housing and social services brief, spoke of "waste" within councils. "I've come over to Reform because there's so much waste where money is being spent, we need to get into procurement to make sure money is being spent correctly". "It sounds like every Welsh council needs a DOGE," Mr Farage joked. For our free daily briefing on the biggest issues facing the nation, sign up to the Wales Matters newsletter here The most recent poll for Wales suggests Reform is in line to take its first seats in the Senedd at the election in May 2026. Its only representation in Wales at the moment is with councillors, but a YouGov/Barn Cymru poll which asked people their voting intention for the Welsh Parliament in May put Reform UK in second with 25% of the vote. They were only behind Plaid Cymru who were projected to get 30% of the vote and ahead of Labour's 18%. You can read that here. In an opinion piece for WalesOnline, the party leader has given his first glimpses of policies ahead of the election. Mr Farage has said the party would allow coal mining again in Wales and says its long term plan is to "reopen the Port Talbot steelworks". The steelworks, owned by Tata, have not closed but its remaining blast furnaces were closed in 2024, with work now ongoing to build an electric arc furnace which will recycle previously-used steel. Thousands of jobs are being lost as part of the change. The Indian-owned company said the blast furnaces were at the end of their operational lives and too expensive to replace. The Port Talbot steelworks were, the company said, losing £1m a day before the blast furnaces were turned off. Reform UK say it would "use Welsh Development Grants to support real industry. We'll redirect economic funding from consultants and NGOs to actual factory floors, machinery, and industrial jobs in places like Llanelli, Shotton, and Ebbw Vale". Nigel Farage has also said the party would also set up "regional technical colleges" for people to have a "path into proper trade". The party would also, it says, stop any building being used for asylum seeker accommodation, end funding to the Welsh Refugee Council and scrap the Welsh Government's "Nation of Sanctuary". It also vowed to set up an Elon Musk style department to cut costs. "A Reform UK Senedd will also save hundreds of millions each year by cutting bureaucracy, waste and bad management." "The establishment of Welsh DOGE will help us uncover where there is woke and wasteful spending and we will make sure those funds are redirected to frontline services," Mr Farage pledges.
