logo
UK's first trans judge plans human rights challenge to Supreme Court gender ruling that the definition of woman is biological

UK's first trans judge plans human rights challenge to Supreme Court gender ruling that the definition of woman is biological

Daily Mail​29-04-2025

Britain's first transgender judge is planning to take the Government to the European Court of Human Rights over the Supreme Court 's landmark biological sex ruling.
Victoria McCloud - who stepped down last year after making a series of controversial statements - claimed the judgement violated her human rights and left her feeling 'contained and segregated'.
It comes after a unanimous Supreme Court ruling earlier this month that 'woman' and 'man' refer to biological women and men and that 'the concept of sex is binary'.
Ms McCloud said she intends to apply to the ECHR to bring action against the UK for infringement of her Article 6 rights, which guarantee the right to a fair trial in both criminal and civil matters.
She said: 'Trans people were wholly excluded from this court case. I applied to be heard. Two of us did. We were refused.
'[The court] heard no material going to the question of the proportionality and the impact on trans people. It didn't hear evidence from us.
'The Supreme Court failed in my view, adequately, to think about human rights points.'
The Supreme Court can consider outside arguments from 'interveners' at its discretion but rarely allows individuals to intervene and often rejects them if it will hear the same arguments from other groups.
In the biological sex case, the Supreme Court did consider arguments on trans issues from the human rights campaign group Amnesty International.
Ms McCloud, a former High Court Master, said that her Gender Recognition Certificate [GRC], which she obtained after she legally transitioned, should mean she is defined as a woman in law.
This would run counter to the Supreme Court judgement, which clarified that under the Equality Act sex is defined by biology and not a £6 certificate for the purposes of the Act.
Ms McCloud told the BBC: 'Just as the prime minister didn't know what a woman was, actually the Supreme Court don't know because they haven't defined biological sex.
'The answer [in my view] is that a woman in law is someone with the letter F on her birth certificate.'
However women's rights campaigners said the Supreme Court judgement is clear that sex is biological.
Fiona McAnena, director of campaigns at human rights charity Sex Matters which provided evidence in the case, said Ms McCloud's attempt to intervene 'was always misguided because the Supreme Court rarely allows individuals to intervene'.
She added: 'The Scottish Government, the respondent in the Supreme Court case, has already said it accepts the ruling. The case is over and there is no obvious route for [Ms McCloud] to take the UK government to the ECHR.'
Following the ruling the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) has issued new guidance stating unequivocally that in workplaces and places open to the public 'trans women (biological men) should not be permitted to use the women's facilities'.
Ms McCloud claimed that, far from providing clarity, the judgment and subsequent guidance has 'brought chaos'.
'[This judgement] has left me two sexes at once, which is a nonsense and ironic, because the Supreme Court said that sex was binary,' she told the BBC.
'I am a woman for all purposes in law, but [now under this judgement] I'm a man for the Equality Act 2010. So I have to probably guess on any given occasion which sex I am.'
Ms McCloud will have six months to apply to the ECHR and will have to prove that she has suffered been the victim of an alleged violation of the Convention and suffered 'significant disadvantage' as a result.
If she is successful then this would likely provide significant ammunition to Tory calls to leave the ECHR following frustrations at a series of its findings.
Ms McCloud transitioned in the 1990s and became the first transgender barrister and judge in the UK. She stood down a year ago, saying she could not continue her work amid the increasingly fraught public debate.
In her resignation letter last year, she likened herself to civil rights activist Rosa Parks, writing: 'Rosa Parks's choice of seat was political because of the colour of her skin.
'More prosaically, for me, I am now political every time I choose where to pee. Less prosaically, the judiciary, by continuing to let me be a judge, is now at risk of being political.'
It comes as junior doctors at a British Medical Association (BMA) conference today 'condemned' Supreme Court's ruling that sex is biological.
The union's junior doctors, now known as resident doctors, passed a motion which states: 'This meeting condemns the Supreme Court ruling defining the term 'woman'.'
The motion adds: 'We recognise as doctors that sex and gender are complex and multifaceted aspects of the human condition and attempting to impose a rigid binary has no basis in science or medicine while being actively harmful to transgender and gender-diverse people.'
While the motion was passed by the conference it will not become BMA policy unless it is approved by all members at the union's annual meeting later this year.
A BMA spokesman said: 'The BMA respects trans patients' dignity, autonomy and human rights and continues to believe that trans doctors, NHS workers and patients deserve dignity, safety, and equitable access to healthcare and healthcare facilities.'

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Badenoch to call for end to oil and gas windfall tax and ban on new licences
Badenoch to call for end to oil and gas windfall tax and ban on new licences

Glasgow Times

time23 minutes ago

  • Glasgow Times

Badenoch to call for end to oil and gas windfall tax and ban on new licences

The energy profits levy was put in place under the previous Conservative government but extended when Labour entered power. Designed to fund interventions to bring down household bills, the policy has been criticised by those in the industry. Speaking at the Scottish Conservative conference in Edinburgh on Friday, Mrs Badenoch is expected to tout the oil and gas sector, accusing the UK Government of 'killing' it, claiming 'renewing our party and our country means standing up for our oil and gas industry'. She will add: 'When the oil and gas windfall tax, the energy profits levy, was brought in, the oil price was near a historic high, at the exact time as energy bills for the British people were sky-rocketing. 'But there is no longer a windfall to tax. It has long gone. And the longer this regressive tax on one of our most successful industries remains, the more damaging it becomes. 'Labour have extended and increased this tax. They are killing this industry.' If the measure remains in place to 2030 as intended, Mrs Badenoch will say 'there will be no industry left to tax'. She will add: 'So, today, I say enough. Labour must remove the energy profits levy. Labour must speed up the process of replacing it with a system that rewards success and incentivises investment. 'Because we shouldn't have this energy profits levy at all. 'We must scrap the ban on new licences. 'We must overturn the ban on supporting oil and gas technology exports. Kemi Badenoch will say the energy profits levy should end (PA) 'And we must champion our own industry. 'We must let this great British, great Scottish industry thrive, grow and create jobs – ensuring our energy security for generations to come, driving growth and making this country richer in the process.' Mrs Badenoch will address her first Scottish party conference as leader on Friday while her counterpart north of the border Russell Findlay will deliver his inaugural address on Saturday. Responding to Mrs Badenoch, Simon Francis of the End Fuel Poverty Coalition said her comments were 'out of touch', adding: 'Even with the windfall tax in place, the energy industry made over £115 billion in profits in 2024 alone. 'Meanwhile, average household energy bills remain hundreds and hundreds of pounds higher than they were before the energy crisis started. 'While the Government is right to be consulting on reform of the windfall tax, maintaining a profits levy could help fund home upgrades and a social tariff which would bring down energy bills for the most vulnerable in society.' SNP MSP Kevin Stewart said: 'The Tories wrecked our economy, presided over soaring household bills and ripped Scotland from the EU against our will. 'And now they're lurching further to the right as they haemorrhage votes to Nigel Farage. 'This weekend will be an important reminder of how Westminster has failed Scotland. Only the SNP is offering hope and a brighter future as an independent nation.' Scottish Labour deputy leader Jackie Baillie said: 'While the Tories and SNP let energy workers down by failing to plan for the future, Scottish Labour is committed to taking action towards reaching net zero, creating jobs and cutting energy bills. 'The Tories are on the side of oil and gas giants rather than working Scots, but Scottish Labour will work with the UK Government and use devolved powers to deliver a just transition for the industry. 'With Kemi Badenoch desperately attempting to rally the few remaining Scottish Tories, it seems like it won't be long until they can fit all of their MSPs in a single taxi.'

Badenoch to call for end to oil and gas windfall tax and ban on new licences
Badenoch to call for end to oil and gas windfall tax and ban on new licences

Western Telegraph

time28 minutes ago

  • Western Telegraph

Badenoch to call for end to oil and gas windfall tax and ban on new licences

The energy profits levy was put in place under the previous Conservative government but extended when Labour entered power. Designed to fund interventions to bring down household bills, the policy has been criticised by those in the industry. Speaking at the Scottish Conservative conference in Edinburgh on Friday, Mrs Badenoch is expected to tout the oil and gas sector, accusing the UK Government of 'killing' it, claiming 'renewing our party and our country means standing up for our oil and gas industry'. She will add: 'When the oil and gas windfall tax, the energy profits levy, was brought in, the oil price was near a historic high, at the exact time as energy bills for the British people were sky-rocketing. 'But there is no longer a windfall to tax. It has long gone. And the longer this regressive tax on one of our most successful industries remains, the more damaging it becomes. 'Labour have extended and increased this tax. They are killing this industry.' If the measure remains in place to 2030 as intended, Mrs Badenoch will say 'there will be no industry left to tax'. She will add: 'So, today, I say enough. Labour must remove the energy profits levy. Labour must speed up the process of replacing it with a system that rewards success and incentivises investment. 'Because we shouldn't have this energy profits levy at all. 'We must scrap the ban on new licences. 'We must overturn the ban on supporting oil and gas technology exports. Kemi Badenoch will say the energy profits levy should end (PA) 'And we must champion our own industry. 'We must let this great British, great Scottish industry thrive, grow and create jobs – ensuring our energy security for generations to come, driving growth and making this country richer in the process.' Mrs Badenoch will address her first Scottish party conference as leader on Friday while her counterpart north of the border Russell Findlay will deliver his inaugural address on Saturday. Responding to Mrs Badenoch, Simon Francis of the End Fuel Poverty Coalition said her comments were 'out of touch', adding: 'Even with the windfall tax in place, the energy industry made over £115 billion in profits in 2024 alone. 'Meanwhile, average household energy bills remain hundreds and hundreds of pounds higher than they were before the energy crisis started. 'While the Government is right to be consulting on reform of the windfall tax, maintaining a profits levy could help fund home upgrades and a social tariff which would bring down energy bills for the most vulnerable in society.' SNP MSP Kevin Stewart said: 'The Tories wrecked our economy, presided over soaring household bills and ripped Scotland from the EU against our will. 'And now they're lurching further to the right as they haemorrhage votes to Nigel Farage. 'This weekend will be an important reminder of how Westminster has failed Scotland. Only the SNP is offering hope and a brighter future as an independent nation.' Scottish Labour deputy leader Jackie Baillie said: 'While the Tories and SNP let energy workers down by failing to plan for the future, Scottish Labour is committed to taking action towards reaching net zero, creating jobs and cutting energy bills. 'The Tories are on the side of oil and gas giants rather than working Scots, but Scottish Labour will work with the UK Government and use devolved powers to deliver a just transition for the industry. 'With Kemi Badenoch desperately attempting to rally the few remaining Scottish Tories, it seems like it won't be long until they can fit all of their MSPs in a single taxi.'

Kendall to add protections to welfare Bill amid backlash to cuts
Kendall to add protections to welfare Bill amid backlash to cuts

The Independent

timean hour ago

  • The Independent

Kendall to add protections to welfare Bill amid backlash to cuts

The Work and Pensions Secretary will add 'non-negotiable' protections to the Welfare Reform Bill, amid a backlash against planned cuts to benefits. The package of measures is aimed at reducing the number of working-age people on sickness benefits, and the Government hopes they can save £5 billion a year by the end of the decade. The proposals include tightening of the eligibility criteria for personal independence payment (Pip), the main disability benefit in England, and cutting the sickness-related element of universal credit (UC). Dozens of Labour MPs last month urged the Prime Minister to pause and reassess planned cuts, saying the proposals are 'impossible to support'. Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall told the Guardian there will be extra protections added to the Bill when it is published next week. She said: 'When we set out our reforms we promised to protect those most in need, particularly those who can never work. 'I know from my 15 years as a constituency MP how important this is. It is something I take seriously and will never compromise on. 'That is why we are putting additional protections on the face of the Bill to support the most vulnerable and help people affected by the changes. 'These protections will be written into law, a clear sign they are non-negotiable.' A Government impact assessment published alongside the reforms warned some 250,000 people, including 50,000 children, across England, Scotland and Wales, could fall into relative poverty after housing costs as a result of the changes.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store