Ash Regan faces questions over 'ludicrous' costs of prostitution bill
Regan is seeking to criminalise the purchase of sex, something opposed by the sex worker pressure group National Ugly Mugs (NUM) which claims she has significantly underestimated the associated costs.
In a financial memorandum submitted to the Scottish Parliament for her Prostitution (Offences and Support) (Scotland) Bill, the Alba MSP claimed that it would cost as little as 50p to train 17,000 police officers in the new laws if the bill was passed.
The memo said: 'There will also be one-off training costs for Police Scotland to prepare for the introduction of the new offence.
READ MORE: 'Multiple serving MSPs have paid me for sex', former sex worker tells Ash Regan
'The estimated cost of delivering a two-hour training session to all approximately 17,000 Police Scotland officers, assuming the training is conducted in-house during normal working hours, is approximately £17,000 to £85,000.'
At the higher end of the scale, Regan estimates that it would cost £2.50 to train every officer per hour.
But the same document states that Police Scotland estimates the hourly rate of officers at £79.50.
The total cost of enforcing the new laws would be £2.6 million, falling to £2.2m annually thereafter.
Regan estimates that securing charges in a case would take 'on average an additional six hours of police work' and that this would amount to each case costing £477.
NUM said her figures were 'laughably false'.
READ MORE: Former sex worker supports Ash Regan bid to criminalise buying sex
Lynsey Walton, chief executive of NUM, said: 'As the UK's national sex worker safety charity, NUM works with police forces across the country to support sex workers during investigations. This means we know that Regan's estimates of police time needed to enforce her proposed legislation are laughably false, just like her ludicrous claims that it costs just 50p an hour to train officers.
'Sex worker groups, alongside NGOs like Amnesty and the World Health Organisation, oppose the new law on the grounds that it will make life more difficult and dangerous for sex workers, while costing taxpayers millions of pounds a year to enforce.'
Regan was approached for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
10 minutes ago
- BBC News
Biker, 29, dies in Glasgow hospital after Loch Cluanie crash
A 29-year-old biker has died after a crash on the A87 at Loch Cluanie in the Scotland said his Yamaha motorbike was involved in a collision at about 11:25 on man, who has not been named, was taken by air ambulance to the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital in Glasgow but later died from his have appealed for anyone with information about the incident to contact them. Sgt Douglas Scott said the force's thoughts were with the family and friends of the man who added: "I am appealing for anyone who saw the crash and who hasn't already spoken to officers to get in touch."I would also ask anyone who was in the area at the time and may have dash-cam footage which could assist to contact us."
South Wales Guardian
19 minutes ago
- South Wales Guardian
Sarwar says surprise by-election win could help Labour back to power at Holyrood
Mr Sarwar and his party celebrated in the early hours of Friday morning after Labour's Davy Russell was elected as the new MSP for Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse, winning the seat from the SNP. With the votes showing a swing of more than 7% from the SNP to Labour, Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer said on Friday the result showed people have 'voted for change'. The by-election had been held following the death earlier this year of Scottish Government minister Christina McKelvie. When the votes were counted, Mr Russell polled 8,559, SNP candidate Katy Loudon took 7,957 votes, while Reform's Ross Lambie secured 7,088. And although Mr Russell was elected with fewer votes than Labour secured in the seat in the 2021 Scottish Parliament election, the SNP's support fell from just over 46% of all ballots then to 29.35% in the by-election. Reform UK deputy leader Richard Tice insisting they were 'delighted' with coming third – despite speculation prior to the count that they could come in second or may even pull off a surprise victory. Labour's win came after Scotland's First Minister John Swinney – who made numerous campaign visits to the area – had declared the contest to be a 'two-horse race' between the SNP and Nigel Farage's Reform. But speaking at a media event in Hamilton on Friday morning, Mr Sarwar accused the SNP leader of running a 'disgraceful' campaign. Mr Sarwar also insisted the by-election could 'help lead the way' to him becoming Scotland's next first minister in the May 2026 Holyrood elections. The Scottish Labour leader said he believed the victory to be 'even more significant' than the party's win in the nearby Rutherglen and Hamilton West by-election in October 2023 – which he said had been key in helping to secure Labour's general election win in July last year. Mr Sarwar declared: 'I think in some ways this by-election result is even more significant than the Rutherglen by-election result two years ago. 'It is right to say, I believe, the result in Rutherglen helped lead the way in helping to elect a UK Labour Government and I also believe the by-election result here will help lead the way to elect a Scottish Labour government next year.' Looking ahead to that election, Mr Sarwar told the PA news agency: 'I want us to gain scores of seats across the country so we can remove this SNP government from office.' He went on to accuse Mr Swinney of running a 'disgraceful campaign' in the by-election, saying that despite the SNP having been in power for 18 years, 'the best he had to offer was 'vote SNP to stop Farage''. And while Reform UK came in third in the by-election, Mr Sarwar said Mr Farage's party could not win the Scottish Parliament elections. He insisted: 'Nigel Farage is not standing to be first minister. 'It is a straight choice – it is either going to be John Swinney, or it's going to be me.' The Scottish Labour leader continued: 'The choice is stark next year. Our Parliament is not about protests, our election is not about protest, it is about choosing a government here in Scotland. 'The choice is stark – a third decade of the SNP with John Swinney as first minister or a new direction for Scotland with me as first minister.' However, Mr Tice told BBC Radio 4's that the result in Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse was 'truly remarkable'. He said: 'We've come from nowhere to being in a three-way marginal, and we're within 750 votes of winning that by-election and just a few hundred votes of defeating the SNP, so it's an incredible result.' Mr Swinney, meanwhile, said the SNP was 'clearly disappointed' with the result. The party leader said Labour had 'won by an absolute landslide' in Rutherglen and Hamilton West – noting the SNP 'came much closer' this time round. But he added: 'The people of Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse have made clear that we still have work to do. 'Over the next few days, we will take time to consider the result fully.'
Daily Record
20 minutes ago
- Daily Record
Body found during search for 'experienced walker' on Scots island
Roderick MacPherson, known as Roddy, was last seen outside the Sligachan Hotel on the Isle of Skye on Monday, June 2. A body has been found during searches for an "experienced walker" on the Isle of Skye. Roderick MacPherson, known as Roddy, was last seen outside the Sligachan Hotel on Monday, June 2. Officers said the 67-year-old appeared to be walking in the direction of the Sligachan Bridge and has not been heard from since. Sadly, on Friday afternoon, the body of a man was traced by police and local mountain rescue teams in the Cuillins. Formal identification has yet to be made, but Roddy's heartbroken family have been informed. There are not believed to be any suspicious circumstances surrounding his death. A Police Scotland spokesperson said: "On Friday afternoon, June 6 2025, the body of a man was traced by police and local mountain rescue teams in the Cuillins, Isle of Skye. There would appear to be no suspicious circumstances surrounding his death and a report will be submitted to the Procurator Fiscal. "Formal identification has yet to be made. The family of Roddy MacPherson, 67, who had been reported missing from Skye on Wednesday, June 4 2025, have been informed." A spokesperson for the Skye Mountain Rescue Team confirmed they were called out on Wednesday morning to assist following reports that Roddy, who they described as "an experienced walker" had been reported missing. Extensive searches were carried out, mainly focusing on the Red Hills and parts of the Northern Cuillin. On Thursday efforts shifted to the area around Bruach na Frìthe - and around midday on Friday, with improved weather, a body was sighted on a grassy ledge high on the cliffs between Harta and Lota Corries. The spokesperson for the rescue team said: "It was immediately clear that lowering the casualty to safety would be long and technically demanding. A team member was lowered to a position above and confirmed there were no signs of life, and that significantly more equipment would be needed. "Fortunately, Stornoway Coastguard Helicopter R948 was able to return and carry out a direct lift from the ledge—an incredible effort and a huge relief. The helicopter later returned multiple times to help extract the teams and equipment back to Sligachan." They added: "Our deepest condolences to the family and friends of Roderick MacPherson at this very difficult time. While formal identification has yet to be made, we understand this will come as deeply sad news to those that knew him."
