logo
It's Time to Kill Siri

It's Time to Kill Siri

WIREDa day ago

After almost 10 years, Google Assistant was recently axed in favor of Gemini. Siri gets a bad rap—now is the time for Apple to make a change too.
If you've had a passing interest in Apple over the past year, you've likely heard of the company's struggles in the AI race. Apple Intelligence, which arrived slightly late after the launch of the iPhone 16, fell short of expectations, and Apple has yet to deliver the much-improved Siri it promised at WWDC 2024. Siri got a new look and an integration with ChatGPT, but its ability to understand your personal context via emails, messages, notes, and calendar was 'indefinitely' delayed earlier this year as Apple is reportedly facing several challenges.
Even if Apple delivered a better Siri, would people use it? Despite arriving first, Siri has long been derided by iPhone owners, often the butt of a joke, as Google Assistant and Alexa rose to the top. But if Apple wants its customers to take the supposed improvements coming to the voice assistant seriously, it should consider taking a page from Google and killing it off for something new.
Google has no problem with pulling the plug when things aren't working, or priorities change. In fact, the search giant has a history of killing so many of its services that there's a website dedicated to tracking all the gravestones. One of its most recent terminations? Google Assistant. Photograph: Julian Chokkattu
Nearly 10 years since its debut, Google Assistant is in the process of being phased out from every ecosystem it was a part of. Wear OS smartwatches? It's being replaced soon. Android Auto? In the coming months. It's already no longer the default assistant on Android phones. By 2026, it's unlikely we'll see the branding anywhere anymore. So ends the reign of arguably the most effective voice assistant of its time, gone without a care in the world.
But Google's decision to kill it, instead of keeping the Google Assistant name, may have been smart. 'It's primarily branding,' says Chris Harrison, who directs the Future Interfaces Group at Carnegie Mellon's Human-Computer Interaction Institute. 'But it underlines a technology reason, which is that the previous generation of these assistants really weren't very much like assistants. Asking for the weather and setting a timer—not very sophisticated. You wouldn't really ask a personal assistant for those mundane tasks.'
Gemini is completely different. It can rummage through your emails to find the location of your kid's soccer match, parse through large documents, and when paired with a camera-enabled device, can understand what you're seeing and offer help. Its capabilities are vastly superior to what Google Assistant could do. Apple's goal is to achieve similar results in a more privacy-friendly way—so that when you have Siri connect to ChatGPT, your data is not passed off to OpenAI.
'Apple thought Siri's capabilities would grow, but that didn't really materialize; Siri kind of atrophied out of the gate," Harrison says. 'Now, we're in this new generation of things that are really much more like assistants—they can do reasoning, personalization.' But while Google Assistant and Gemini both have voice interfaces, and at a first glance, they may share a similar look, they're two different applications. 'Simply renaming it Google Assistant 2.0 would not spur people to use it in a fundamentally different way.' It seems that switch to Gemini has been key to moving customer understanding along.
However, it's fair to say that Apple and even Amazon's Alexa have had a cultural cachet that Google Assistant never enjoyed. It wasn't unusual to hear Siri or Alexa's name in a movie or TV show; they were much more recognizable than Google's generic-named voice assistant. This may be why Amazon decided to keep the Alexa branding and simply add a '+' icon to denote the new souped-up version of Alexa powered by the latest large language models—and perhaps why Apple is still hanging onto Siri. Photograph: Julian Chokkattu
This might have all been OK if Apple actually delivered on its promise and released a functioning, much-improved Siri when it originally said it would. With a massive marketing push to put Apple Intelligence in everyone's mind (maybe a regretful move), it would have been a great opportunity to wow users with a much-improved Siri. Months later, customers are left wondering why Siri—new look and all—still lags behind.
But the broader problem affecting all large language models isn't just the branding, but the user interface. Harrison compares it to the days of command-line computing and the shift to the graphical user interface (GUI) in the '80s and '90s. It wasn't the graphics that made the latter more popular, but the discoverability and explorable interface. In the command-line era, you had to remember how to do anything. With GUI, you could put anyone in front of a computer, and they'd be able to figure out how to navigate the operating system.
If you put someone in front of ChatGPT or Gemini, say it's an incredible tool, and tell them to ask it anything, they'll just stare blankly at the blinking prompt. 'It's like we've gone back 30 years in interface design. They have no idea what to do or say." Harrison says he did this exact experiment with his parents: They asked what the weather was tomorrow, and the AI responded that it didn't have that information.
'We've regressed in discoverability," he says. 'A regular person, not the tech people, if all they've been doing is setting timers with Siri for the past 10 years, and now they have to think about it in a fundamentally different way—that's an extremely hard problem. Some sort of renaming of the application is going to be important."
Saying goodbye to Siri would be a big move for Apple—after all, it has spent more that a decade investing in it. But most people today still use it for playing music, checking weather, and setting timers, and aren't even pushing the boundaries of its current, relatively limited, capabilities. It's hard to see that changing anytime soon, even if Siri's feature-packed next generation arrives as promised.
'For 99 percent of the planet, this kind of AI revolution has totally gone over their head," Harrison says. Like the 10-year transition from command line to graphical user interfaces, rethinking the way we use these personal voice assistants will take time and education, but maybe a new name will help Apple with the transition.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Study finds little agreement between Republicans and Democrats on media sources they trust
Study finds little agreement between Republicans and Democrats on media sources they trust

Boston Globe

time28 minutes ago

  • Boston Globe

Study finds little agreement between Republicans and Democrats on media sources they trust

Get Starting Point A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday. Enter Email Sign Up ENTERTAINMENT Advertisement Disney to pay almost $439 million to take full control of streaming service Hulu Hulu began in 2007 and quickly evolved into as a service backed by entertainment conglomerates who hoped to stave off the internet with an online platform for their own TV shows. Gabby Jones/Bloomberg Disney will pay Comcast's NBCUniversal nearly $439 million for its stake in Hulu, taking full control of the streaming service. The move closes out an appraisal process that's dragged on for a few years. Disney said in November 2023 that it was acquiring a 33 percent stake in Hulu from Comcast for at least $8.6 billion. That amount reflected Hulu's guaranteed floor value of $27.5 billion, according to a regulatory filing. Disney has run Hulu since 2019, when Comcast ceded its authority to Disney and effectively became a silent partner. Hulu began in 2007 and quickly evolved into as a service backed by entertainment conglomerates who hoped to stave off the internet with an online platform for their own TV shows. Disney joined in 2009, planning to offer shows from ABC, ESPN, and the Disney Channel. A decade later, Disney gained majority control of the business when it acquired 21st Century Fox. — ASSOCIATED PRESS Advertisement ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE Meta is creating a new AI lab to pursue 'superintelligence' Meta headquarters in Menlo Park, Calif. David Paul Morris/Bloomberg Meta is preparing to unveil a new artificial intelligence research lab dedicated to pursuing 'superintelligence,' a hypothetical AI system that exceeds the powers of the human brain, as the tech giant jockeys to stay competitive in the technology race, according to four people with knowledge of the company's plans. Meta has tapped Alexandr Wang, 28, the founder and CEO of AI startup Scale AI, to join the new lab, the people said, and has been in talks to invest billions of dollars in his company as part of a deal that would also bring other Scale AI employees to the company. Meta has offered seven- to nine-figure compensation packages to dozens of researchers from leading AI companies such as OpenAI and Google, with some agreeing to join, according to the people. The new lab is part of a larger reorganization of Meta's AI efforts, the people said. The company, which owns Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp, has recently grappled with internal management struggles over the technology, as well as employee churn and several product releases that fell flat, two of the people said. Mark Zuckerberg, Meta's CEO, has invested billions of dollars into turning his company into an AI powerhouse. Since OpenAI released the ChatGPT chatbot in 2022, the tech industry has raced to build increasingly powerful AI. Zuckerberg has pushed his company to incorporate AI across its products, including in its smart glasses and a recently released app, Meta AI. — NEW YORK TIMES Advertisement REAL ESTATE Judge refuses to block NYC broker-fee law starting June 11 Tenants in New York City have long been forced to pay costs incurred by landlords to hire the brokers who list their properties, which can add thousands of dollars to housing costs. Katherine Marks/The New York Times A federal judge refused to block a New York City law that would require landlords — rather than their tenants — to pay fees for hiring listing brokers, clearing the way for the measure to take effect on Wednesday. US District Judge Ronnie Abrams on Tuesday denied a request by the Real Estate Board of New York, the New York State Association of Realtors and others for a court order halting the new measure while their lawsuit proceeds. The ruling is another setback for the real estate industry's legal fight against the measure and allows the city to begin enforcing it starting Wednesday. The City Council adopted the measure in November to end the longstanding practice of tenants being forced to pay costs incurred by landlords to hire the brokers who list their properties, which can add thousands of dollars to housing costs. The real estate industry argued the new law branded brokers as villains and would force landlords to raise rents to cover the costs of hiring them. In her ruling, Abrams said the city 'made it clear that it sought to address a specific harm: the detrimental impact on housing mobility caused by the practice of imposing brokers' fees on tenants.' She also dismissed most of their claims that the law violated their constitutional rights. — BLOOMBERG NEWS Advertisement GENETICS 23andMe customers did not expect their DNA data would be sold, lawsuit claims A 23andMe DNA kit. Tiffany Hagler-Geard/Bloomberg Twenty-seven states and the District of Columbia have sued the genetic-testing company 23andMe to oppose the sale of DNA data from its customers without their direct consent. The suit, filed Monday in US Bankruptcy Court in the Eastern District of Missouri, argues that 23andMe needs to have permission from each and every customer before their data is potentially sold. The company had entered an agreement to sell itself and its assets in bankruptcy court. The information for sale 'comprises an unprecedented compilation of highly sensitive and immutable personal data of consumers,' according to the lawsuit. 'This isn't just data — it's your DNA. It's personal, permanent and deeply private,' Dan Rayfield, the Oregon attorney general, said in a statement. 'People did not submit their personal data to 23andMe thinking their genetic blueprint would later be sold off to the highest bidder.' The DNA company, which at one point in 2021 was valued at $6 billion, ran into financial trouble and filed for bankruptcy in March, with its CEO, Anne Wojcicki, resigning shortly afterward. It is poised to be acquired by Regeneron Pharmaceuticals for $256 million, according to the lawsuit. Regeneron is a biotechnology company that uses genetic data to develop new drugs. A backup bidder for the auction is TTAM Research Institute, a California nonprofit, the lawsuit says. The company was founded by Wojcicki. — NEW YORK TIMES LABOR Video game performers on strike for almost a year over AI issues reach a tentative deal SAG-AFTRA signage is seen on the side of its headquarters in Los Angeles. Richard Vogel/Associated Press The union for Hollywood's video game performers has reached a tentative contract with several video game companies that may bring an end to an almost year-long strike tied to the use of artificial intelligence. Members of the Screen Actors Guild-American Federation of Television and Radio Artists went on strike in July 2024 after negotiations with game industry giants came to a halt over artificial intelligence protections. SAG-AFTRA said that the unregulated use of AI posed 'an equal or even greater threat' to performers in the video game industry than it does in film and television because the capacity to cheaply and easily create convincing digital replicas of performers' voices is widely available. The performers were worried that unchecked use of AI could provide game makers with a means to displace them — by training an AI to replicate an actor's voice or to create a digital replica of their likeness without consent. SAG-AFTRA said that it anticipates that the terms of a strike suspension agreement will be finalized with the companies soon. Union members will remain on strike until such an agreement is reached. The tentative contract deal still needs approval by the National Board and ratification by union membership. — ASSOCIATED PRESS Advertisement

Pixalate's May 2025 Top Grossing Mobile and CTV Apps in North America: ‘PocketFM' Ranked No. 1 on Google Play Store in Canada; ‘Hulu' No. 1 Across Roku, Amazon Fire TV, Samsung Smart TV, & Apple TV in the US
Pixalate's May 2025 Top Grossing Mobile and CTV Apps in North America: ‘PocketFM' Ranked No. 1 on Google Play Store in Canada; ‘Hulu' No. 1 Across Roku, Amazon Fire TV, Samsung Smart TV, & Apple TV in the US

Yahoo

time29 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Pixalate's May 2025 Top Grossing Mobile and CTV Apps in North America: ‘PocketFM' Ranked No. 1 on Google Play Store in Canada; ‘Hulu' No. 1 Across Roku, Amazon Fire TV, Samsung Smart TV, & Apple TV in the US

According to Pixalate's research, the app 'Happy Color' in Canada generated an estimated $295K in open programmatic ad revenue on the Apple App Store; Hulu led on Apple TV with $106K in estimated open programmatic ad revenue in Canada London, June 10, 2025 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- Pixalate, the leading global platform for ad fraud protection, privacy, and compliance analytics, today released the May 2025 North America Top Grossing Apps Reports for the United States and Canada. The reports cover mobile apps from the Apple App Store and Google Play Store, as well as Connected TV (CTV) apps from Roku, Amazon Fire TV, Apple TV, and Samsung Smart TV stores. The reports highlight the estimated top-grossing apps in open programmatic advertising revenue for mobile and CTV apps. In addition to the reports for the United States (U.S.) and Canada, Pixalate has released Top Grossing Mobile & CTV Apps reports for Mexico, Brazil, China, Japan, Singapore, India, Australia, the United Kingdom (UK), Spain, France, Germany, Israel, Ukraine, and the Netherlands. Top Grossing Mobile and CTV Apps in May 2025 - North America U.S: 'Mobile: Weather - The Weather Channel' led ($5M estimated open programmatic ad revenue) on the Apple App Store, and 'PocketFM' ($7M estimated open programmatic ad revenue) is No. 1 on the Google Play Store CTV: Hulu led on all four CTV platforms: 'Roku' ($82M estimated open programmatic ad revenue), Apple TV ($29M), 'Amazon Fire TV' ($39M estimated open programmatic revenue), and 'Samsung Smart TV' ($21M estimated open programmatic ad revenue) Canada Mobile: 'Happy Color by Numbers Game' ($295K estimated open programmatic ad revenue) led on the Apple App Store, and 'PocketFM' was No. 1 on the Google Play Store ($99K) CTV: ' was No. 1 on Roku ($100K) in estimated open programmatic revenue, 'Hulu' led on Apple TV ($106K), 'Bloomberg' was No. 1 on Amazon Fire TV ($84K), and 'Samsung TV PLUS' led on Samsung Smart TV ($19K) In May 2025, Pixalate's data science team analyzed over 27 billion global open programmatic impressions from over 6 million Apple App Store and Google Play Store apps. For this research, Pixalate also examined over 6,000 CTV apps and 2 billion global ad impressions across various platforms, including Apple TV, Amazon Fire TV, Roku, and Samsung Smart TV. Download the Global Top Grossing Mobile & CTV Apps Reports: Mobile U.S. Canada Mexico Brazil China Japan Singapore India Australia United Kingdom Spain France Germany Israel Ukraine Netherlands CTV United States Canada Mexico About Pixalate Pixalate is a global platform specializing in privacy compliance, ad fraud prevention, and digital ad supply chain data intelligence. Founded in 2012, Pixalate is trusted by regulators, data researchers, advertisers, publishers, ad tech platforms, and financial analysts across the Connected TV (CTV), mobile app, and website ecosystems. Pixalate is accredited by the MRC for the detection and filtration of Sophisticated Invalid Traffic (SIVT). content of this press release, and the May 2025 North America Top Grossing Mobile Apps Reports (the 'Reports'), reflect Pixalate's opinions with respect to factors that Pixalate believes can be useful to the digital media industry. Any data shared is grounded in Pixalate's proprietary technology and analytics, which Pixalate is continuously evaluating and updating. Any references to outside sources should not be construed as endorsements. Pixalate's opinions are just that, opinions, which means that they are neither facts nor guarantees. Pixalate is sharing this data not to impugn the standing or reputation of any entity, person or app, but, instead, to report findings and trends pertaining to programmatic advertising activity across mobile apps in the time period studied. CONTACT: Nina Talcott ntalcott@

Applied Digital (APLD) Soars 103% on AI Hosting Deal With CoreWeave
Applied Digital (APLD) Soars 103% on AI Hosting Deal With CoreWeave

Yahoo

time32 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Applied Digital (APLD) Soars 103% on AI Hosting Deal With CoreWeave

Applied Digital (APLD, Financials) surged 103% last week after announcing a long-term hosting agreement with CoreWeave, an AI infrastructure firm backed by Nvidia (NVDA, Financials). Warning! GuruFocus has detected 10 Warning Signs with APLD. The deal, valued at $7 billion over 15 years, will see Applied lease space at its North Dakota facility to host CoreWeave's expanding AI compute stack. The move accelerates Applied's pivot deeper into AI data center infrastructure. Shares closed Friday at $13.86, tripling over the past 12 months amid strong interest in AI-adjacent plays. Both Applied and CoreWeave count Nvidia as a key backer, linking them to the broader AI rally. Technical analysts flagged a bullish cup-and-handle breakout, with price clearing key resistance last week. Volume confirmed the move, and momentum indicators show strength. This article first appeared on GuruFocus.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store