Thousands of dead fish dumped on seabed after getting caught in trawl nets
Scottish environmentalists are calling for urgent action to protect marine life after a video shared with Sky News showed the alleged illegal dump of wasteful bycatch.
Warning: This article contains images of dead fish
The film shows the seabed littered with thousands of dead fish, shellfish, and critically endangered flapper skate. Environmentalists say it is an insight into the true environmental cost of bottom-trawling for scampi.
Large volumes of fish and other marine life are routinely caught in bottom-trawl nets used to sweep the seabed. Charities say the unintended bycatch is a particular problem in prawn trawl fishery due to the small mesh size of the nets.
The fisherman, who took the video and asked not to be named, said it did not look like a one-off.
"It appears to be multiple dumps because the fish are in varying stages of decomposition."
"I felt a deep sadness especially when I saw the dead flapper skate, when I saw the rope on the base of its tail. The sadness quickly turned to anger for the wastefulness involved and mistreatment of this beautiful creature."
Skippers are required by law to release flapper skate caught accidentally. Although bycatch is not a crime, the law does require all skates and rays to be released immediately.
"This clearly did not happen here, as the flapper skate had a rope tied around its tail," explains Nick Underdown from the charity Open Seas.
"This shows the wasteful bycatch of other species caught in the trawl nets, which is often discarded at sea, hidden from public view."
Open Seas called on the Scottish government and supermarkets to do more.
"The scampi industry and the supermarkets have made a lot of profit selling consumers a product that is often branded "responsibly sourced" while failing to do anything to actually resolve this issue," said Mr Underdown.
"As a priority, the Scottish government must reinstate sensible spatial limits on this type of fishing in our coastal seas."
The charity also called for restricting trawling in sensitive sea lochs and coastal areas and bringing in better vessel monitoring to identify hotspots of harm.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scotsman
2 hours ago
- Scotsman
Can you afford not to have a cyber insurance policy?
Scott McLuskey helps clients find the cyber insurance policy that's right for them Cyber attacks cost Scottish businesses £386m annually – but most firms still aren't insured, warns Scott McLuskey Sign up to our Scotsman Money newsletter, covering all you need to know to help manage your money. Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Recent high-profile cyber incidents involving major UK institutions including Marks & Spencer, Harrods, and the Co-op are a stark reminder: no business is immune to attack. I first spoke about the importance of cyber insurance at the inaugural Cyber Scotland Week six years ago, an initiative supported by the Government to promote cyber resilience. Since then, the threat has only accelerated – today, a cyber-attack occurs every 44 seconds in the UK. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Yet despite the scale of risk, many business leaders remain confident that their organisations are protected. Antivirus software, cloud backups, an in-house or outsourced IT Manager and a general belief that they're 'covered' often mask the reality: these measures alone are not enough. It wasn't just a cyber attack, it was an M&S cyber attack that cost millions (Picture: Adobe) Reports surrounding the recent attack on British retail heavyweight M&S suggest that the attack will cost an estimated £300 million and was not the result of poor systems, but of human error – a tale as old as time and the weakest link in any cyber defence strategy. Smaller businesses are also firmly in the firing line. Vodafone estimates Scottish SMEs are losing a combined £386m a year to Cyber Attacks, with 40% of SMEs falling victim last year alone. Costs following an attack can be significant: from forensic investigations, legal advice, regulatory notifications, and PR management, to lost revenue, extortion demands, credit monitoring, and potential lawsuits. The good news is that a cyber insurance policy offers a risk transfer solution to address these costs and assist recovery. Today's leading cyber policies also go beyond simple risk transfer – they include value-added services like vulnerability scans, penetration testing, and employee training. While not a substitute for a dedicated cybersecurity provider, these tools provide vital early protection and peace of mind. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad However, buying cyber insurance isn't always straightforward. With over 30 readily available cyber insurers – plus Lloyd's of London – and each provider offering a different proposition with their own minimum cyber security based acceptance criteria, the market can feel impenetrable. Unlike traditional insurance policies, cyber cover is still relatively new, with the first policy written in the late 1990s - the market and crucially insurer's loss data is continually developing. Compare that with buildings insurance, first developed in the wake of the Great Fire of London in the 17th century. As a result, there's wide variation in policy coverage, pricing, and – most importantly – what policyholders need to do to ensure claims are valid. Too often, businesses only realise this after a breach, when it's too late. There are promising signs. Leading providers like CFC Underwriting report a claims payout rate of over 99% and industry-wide improvements are being made in clarity, claims handling, and support services. But challenges remain – particularly for small and medium-sized businesses. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad A UK Government report found that 50% of businesses suffered some form of breach in the past year, rising to 70% among medium-sized firms. Yet just over half of all companies have cyber cover. Scotland's economy, built on a vibrant mix of SMEs, family-run firms, and fast-growing tech businesses, is particularly exposed. As the majority of organisations have digitised operations, even modest breaches can have a disproportionate impact – not only on individual companies, but on supply chains, customer trust, and investor confidence across the sector. Cyber resilience is no longer just a technical issue; it's an economic imperative. The Association of British Insurers has also identified a communication gap: cyber insurance is too often presented as a standalone 'product,' when in reality it's an ongoing service that begins before a breach and supports the business throughout. At Monteith, we're working to bridge this gap. We help clients understand their cyber exposure, decode policy language, and choose the right level of cover. Most importantly, we walk our clients through the fine print – ensuring they know exactly what's required to stay compliant, so their insurance delivers when it matters most. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The threat isn't going away. Business leaders must go beyond firewalls and backups. They need to take proactive steps – including securing expert cyber insurance advice – to protect against what is now one of the most persistent and costly risks in modern business.
Glasgow Times
2 hours ago
- Glasgow Times
Here's what Scotland's jail staff says about overcrowding
The Prison Officers' Association published a survey with the views of more than 400 members. In it, they warned that the system is on the verge of collapse as there is not enough staff, training opportunities and space in Scottish jails. When asked, 95.5% of respondents agreed that rising prisoner numbers make the facilities more dangerous for staff and residents. 86.6% stated that due to the overcrowding, there is more sickness and absence among workers. Also, 80.21% said there are not enough employees to cope with the volume of inmates. READ NEXT: 'Battle' against drug-smuggling drones wages on at Glasgow's Barlinnie Inside Barlinnie as inspectors give verdict on notorious jail Here's what Scotland's jail staff says about overcrowding (Image: Newsquest) Barlinnie, Glasgow (Image: Colin Mearns) One responder suggested: 'Do not house prisoners like battery hens.' Another said: "Increase prison spaces by physically building more spaces.' A third wrote: 'Scotland must critically examine the root causes of its high crime rates and explore how community-based initiatives can create a safer, more equitable society.' A fourth added: 'There are not enough public mental health facilities, especially for women. People are being sent to prison as a place of safety due to their mental health. "This is not an acceptable practice' A fifth commented: 'Staff recruitment needs to be scrutinised and those currently in a position need to be held accountable for the poor choices being made when recruiting." Several participants noted that the retirement age should be lowered from the current 68 to 60, in line with other emergency services. Some argued that the stress of the job is reducing employees' life expectancy. Many responses also highlighted that the justice system needs to explore community-based disposals as an alternative to short-term sentences. (Image: Colin Mearns) HMP Glasgow plan (Image: SPS) In a recent report, His Majesty's Inspectorate of Prisons in Scotland concluded that overcrowding is Barlinnie's main issue. During 2023/24, the average annual population was 1367, despite having been designed to house 987 men. Its larger replacement, HMP Glasgow, is currently under construction and is expected to be operational by 2028. A Scottish Prison Service spokesperson said: 'Our staff are our greatest asset. Every day, prison officers do outstanding work in the most challenging circumstances, and it is crucial that their voice is heard. 'This important report demonstrates the risk they face from a rising and complex prison population, the impact this has on their health and wellbeing and on their ability to do their jobs effectively. 'We need to see a reduction in our population, so that our staff can fully support people in our care, to reduce their risk of reoffending, and help build the safer communities we all want to see.' The Scottish Government was approached for comment.
Scotsman
3 hours ago
- Scotsman
Gender row Scotland: Public 'none the wiser' about Police Scotland's gender ruling stance
Concern raised over public confidence in Police Scotland and its stance on the gender ruling from the Supreme Court. Sign up to our Politics newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... People are still 'none the wiser' as to how Scotland's national police force has amended its policies in light of the landmark Supreme Court ruling on gender, according to a board member of the Scottish Police Authority (SPA). The comment made at a SPA committee meeting on Tuesday comes amid warnings the force's stance risked impacting its operational impact and public confidence. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Katharina Kasper said while Police Scotland was working in a 'dynamic environment', she had a 'degree of frustration' that after the Supreme Court ruling, its position was still unclear. Celebrations outside the Supreme Court in London after the ruling on gender. Picture:Addressing a meeting of the SPA's policing performance committee, which discussed the ongoing review in relation to sex and gender within Scottish policing, Ms Kasper said: 'For a member of the public at this stage looking at this, I don't think anybody is still none the wiser as to whether or not the Supreme Court judgement, which was very, very clear, has been adopted into Police Scotland's policies 'When it comes to recording the sex or gender of people who come into contact with the police, what is the current policy?' Asking if there was a 'policy vacuum", Ms Kasper, who also chairs the SPA's complaints and conduct committee, said while she understood the reasons for the process taking time, she had misgivings about the knock-on effects. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Police Scotland officers | PA 'I am concerned about the operational implications on this,' she said. 'I'm concerned about the public confidence in Police Scotland because this process has been taking so long, and I'm also concerned about the impact on officers and staff.' The force's deputy chief constable, Alan Speirs, said last month that Police Scotland planned to bring forward an 'extensive and advanced' document to this week's SPA meeting. But the six page-long document in question does not set out a definitive stance, noting the force was continuing with its ongoing review. The report, prepared by Assistant Chief Constable Catriona Paton, states: 'It is critical that we take time to consider all relevant legislation, national guidance and stakeholder feedback, to ensure our proposals are well-informed and evidence based. Our aim is to conduct this review carefully and to do it right and in a way which builds trust and confidence across all communities.' Reflecting on the report, Ms Kasper said she was 'a little bit disappointed' by it. She said: 'We had been promised a substantial product by DCC Spiers and having read this paper, it is an interim update on all the work that's been done. But I'm still none the wiser as to the actual substance of the issue.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Responding to Ms Kasper's criticisms, Ms Paton stressed 'context is everything', telling her: 'I appreciate your comments around the approach we've taken and I certainly acknowledge aspects of your frustration around pace. 'I think the Chief [Constable Jo Farrell] also acknowledged the desire for people to move quickly in this space, and the importance to get it right when we do that. Policing is not immune to the reality and the complexity of this, around how our terminology and understanding, as it is related to sex and gender, has changed, has at times been used interchangeably.
