Dunbar flat owner loses bid to carry on letting
A Dunbar flat owner who claimed the majority of her guests were 'professional' and letting her property was good for the local economy has lost her appeal to carry on renting.
Leanne Montgomery appealed to Scottish Ministers after East Lothian Council refused to grant a change of use for her second floor flat on the High Street to a short term let.
She told them use of the holiday flat 'helped the economy', however the Scottish Government Reporter ruled its local impact was irrelevant.
And they said the flat owner had provided no evidence that it was mainly used by professionals, as had been claimed.
Dismissing the appeal, they said: ' In assessing the appeal I am only able to consider whether or not the use as a short term holiday let represents a material change from the legitimate established use of the property as a flat.
'Any assessment which considers the merits of the use would need to take place through an application for planning permission.'
East Lothian Council refused the application for a certificate of lawfulness, which would mean planning permission was not needed, to operate the holiday flat, because they said a shared stairwell with other residents in the block meant it was a material change of use.
And the Reporter agreed with their position saying the frequent arrival and departure of guests in the flat would impact on residents who used the same hallway.
They also dismissed claims that the majority of guests at the flat were 'professionals' who were there to work in the town.
They said: 'The appellant contends that most visitors are professionals who visit the area to work a nine to five job for a the very short period of time they are in the area.
'I have been provided with no specific reasoning as to why the property would appeal to professionals in particular and I have been provided with no evidence to substantiate this claim..'
The Reporter ruled the impact of guests at the short term let was a material change of use and the council had been correct to reject the application for the certificate.
By Marie Sharp Local Democracy Reporter
Like this:
Like
Related
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
Reform chairman QUITS & says helping Farage become PM is ‘not a good use of my time'
Insiders said that the chairman had felt 'shafted' into running the party's DOGE efficiency unit WALKS OUT Reform chairman QUITS & says helping Farage become PM is 'not a good use of my time' REFORM was plunged into a chaotic civil war last night after its chairman Zia Yusuf announced he's quitting the party. Mr Yusuf announced on social media that after 11 months in the job 'I no longer believe working to get a Reform government elected is a good use of my time'. Advertisement 2 Reform chairman Zia Yusuf announced he's quitting the party Credit: PA Insiders said that the chairman had felt 'shafted' into running the party's DOGE efficiency unit, aimed at slashing waste in local authorities. He also earlier on Thursday clashed with Reform's newest MP, Sarah Pochin, over the idea of a burqa ban. Mr Yusuf said: 'Eleven months ago I became Chairman of Reform. 'I've worked full time as a volunteer to take the party from 14 to 30 per cent, quadrupled its membership and delivered historic electoral results. Advertisement Read More REFORMER REGRET I was excited to get Aldi's pilates machine but 1 issue has me returning it 'I no longer believe working to get a Reform government elected is a good use of my time, and hereby resign the office.' Mr Yusuf was seen as a rising star in the party and close ally of Nigel Farage. While not an MP, the entrepreneur fronted several of the parties press conferences. He worked as chairman in a voluntary capacity. Advertisement This comes after Farage earlier this week blasted "net stupid zero" for obliterating the UK's oil industry, ahead of a showdown Scottish by-election on tomorrow. The Reform chief drew battle lines against the SNP as he warned Scotland is "literally de-industrialising before our eyes". In Aberdeen Mr Farage slammed the nats, led by First Minister John Swinney, for sacrificing an entire industry and thousands of jobs at the alter of green diktats. He claimed neighbouring Norway is "laughing" as it watches ministers import Scandinavian fossil fuels while dismantling local industry. Advertisement Against the shouts of protesters, at a posh fish and chips restaurant the Reform leader said: "We can con ourselves as much as we like. "There will be more coal burned this year than ever before in the history of human kind. The same applies to oil and gas. 'Even the most adren proponent of net zero has to accept the world will still be using oil and gas up until 2050 and beyond. 'And yet we've decided to sacrifice this industry as a consensus around Net Zero has emerged.' Advertisement Mr Farage added that the fight to save oil and gas is "almost the next Brexit". He said: 'Believe me, the scales are falling from the eyes of the public when it comes to Net Zero. "They realise we are putting upon ourselves a massive cost, let alone the opportunity cost of what we're missing... 'When we closed down refineries.. and steelworks... all we're doing is exporting the emissions of CO2 with the goods then being shipped back to us. Advertisement 'The public are waking up to this." It comes ahead of a Hoylrood by-election in Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse on Thursday, described by Reform Deputy Leader Richard Tice as an "absolute cat fight" with the SNP and Labour. Mr Farage acknowledged it would be an "earthquake" level shock if Reform's candidate wins the seat. But activists have reported being surprised at levels of support on the doorstep. Advertisement Mr Farage insisted the Reform "can replicate success in Scotland". 2 He said: "I no longer believe working to get a Reform government elected is a good use of my time' Credit: AFP More to follow... For the latest news on this story keep checking back at The Sun Online is your go-to destination for the best celebrity news, real-life stories, jaw-dropping pictures and must-see video. Advertisement Like us on Facebook at and follow us from our main Twitter account at @TheSun.
Scotsman
2 hours ago
- Scotsman
New Scottish distillery officially opens - bringing whisky-making back to riverside region
The event was headlined by a special appearance from Robert Robertson and Fergus Munro from the popular Scottish band Tidelines, who had the honour of cutting the ceremonial ribbon to formally open the distillery. Guests were piped through to the ribbon-cutting by Callan MacEachern, son of the distillery's founders, adding a heartfelt, family touch to the day's festivities. Levenbank Distillery is the latest venture from husband-and-wife team Euan and Fiona MacEachern, the passionate owners of the multi award-winning Loch Lomond Brewery. Drawing on their deep expertise in brewing, the MacEacherns are bringing a unique flavour-forward approach to whisky-making, creating bold, characterful spirit from day one. This has been a dream in the making for a long time," said Euan MacEachern. "With our background in brewing, we've always believed that the foundations of great whisky are laid in the early stages of production. We're excited to bring that philosophy to life here at Levenbank." Although the official ribbon-cutting has taken place, Levenbank had already begun distilling earlier this year. Graeme Macdiarmid, Euan MacEachern, Robert Robertson, Fergus Munro, George Wotherspoon At the event, a number of investors had the opportunity to sign or fill the casks they'd purchased, cementing their personal connection to the distillery's journey from the very beginning. 'This isn't just the start of a distillery, it's the start of a community,' added Fiona MacEachern. 'We're incredibly grateful to everyone who's supported us, from family and friends to our investors and local partners.' Levenbank Distillery looks forward to welcoming visitors in the coming months, sharing its journey as the spirit matures. Levenbank Distillery is the Lowland's newest whisky distillery, located in Dumbarton near the banks of the River Leven. Founded by Fiona and Euan MacEachern, the visionary team behind the acclaimed Loch Lomond Brewery, are bringing a fresh approach to whisky-making by blending traditional distilling methods with a brewer's expertise, creating a range of innovative, flavour-forward spirits. With over a decade of brewing excellence, Fiona and Euan have garnered recognition for beers like the multiple award-winning 'Silkie Stout.' They will now use their expert understanding of malt and yeast to explore how using different malting levels and yeast strains can affect the flavour profile of whisky. Levenbank's experimental ethos includes utilising specialty malts such as crystal and chocolate malts, traditionally reserved for brewing, to impart complex flavours to their whiskies. This approach challenges conventional whisky production methods, placing a greater emphasis on the new make spirit's intrinsic character alongside cask maturation. Also creating a range of innovative single grain whiskies, Levenbank will adapt recipes from robust beer styles such as imperial stouts, barleywines, and wee heavies to provide the wash from which they will then distil.
Glasgow Times
2 hours ago
- Glasgow Times
Clyde Metro possible routes and cost known by 2027
Consultants are currently developing a case for investment which is seen as an 'essential' step towards providing a 'mass transit' system. Glasgow Labour has claimed the Metro scheme is a 'stalled plan dressed up as progress' — with no start date and no funding committed. READ NEXT:Glasgow's drug consumption centre is working says health secretary Transport spokesman Cllr Saqib Ahmed said: 'Clyde Metro should be Glasgow's next great infrastructure revolution — but right now, it's just another SNP soundbite.' A spokesman for the city's SNP group said the cross-party Glasgow City Region cabinet has allocated £12m to advance the business case, which Strathclyde Partnership for Transport (SPT) is progressing. 'That's a considerable amount of spend and effort for a soundbite,' he added. The funding, which will support the development of the case for investment (CFI), is from the City Deal, a more than £1bn infrastructure programme funded by both the UK and Scottish governments. Council officials have said the CFI will identify the funding strategy for 'subsequent stages of the Clyde Metro programme'. READ NEXT:'Don't blame us': Taxis hit back in Glasgow city centre transport row They also said 'one of the key objectives is to improve the sustainable transport access to Glasgow Airport' and this will 'continue to feature as a key priority in all the options we are exploring.' At a council meeting on Tuesday, Cllr Kieran Turner, Labour, asked whether there would be potential routes and costs at the end of the CFI process. An official said: 'Yes, absolutely. At the moment, as part of the initial engagement, we have four network options which were presented. 'Those network options will then get synthesised into a preferred network.' The process will involve deciding on which modes of transport will be included, such as heavy rail or tram, as well as a recommendation on 'what the first move needs to be'. Cllr Turner added: 'Until people start to see something that is a little more concrete, even in terms of option selection, there are still going to be questions in our constituents' minds around if any of this is ever going to happen. 'Is lots of money just getting spent on consultants? And will anything come of this?' The official said there will be answers at the end of the case for investment, including potential timelines. It will be 'absolutely critical' for securing 'a commitment from government to give funding', he said. Public consultation on the project could be held in spring or summer next year. After the meeting, Cllr Ahmed said: 'Communities have waited too long for transformation. Instead, they've been left behind by a government more focused on branding than building. 'Glasgow Labour will keep fighting for real investment in our transport network.' Labour want a commitment from the Scottish Government to fund phase one of the Metro project and a 'clear, costed and deliverable' construction timeline. The SNP spokesman said Clyde Metro is 'an agreed national transport priority'. 'Labour's failure to deliver the type of modern transport system developed by our peers during their time in power in Glasgow is why we have decades of missed opportunities to catch up on. 'If Labour councillors want to start being constructive perhaps they can insist from their party colleagues that we received a share of the £15bn the Chancellor is allocating to English cities for major transport projects.'
