TikTok skin care routines ‘harmful' and ‘problematic' scientists discover in new study
A team of scientists found that viral skin care routines popularised by young girls on TikTok could be harmful to teens - and many of the products may actually lead to allergies
Elaborate skin care routines shared on TikTok by teenagers are actually harmful and could be putting young girls at risk of developing a lifelong allergy, a new study has found.
Skin care has become increasingly popular in recent years and concerns have been raised over the popularity of certain products among tweens and teens. Scientists at Northwestern Medicine in the US found that girls between the ages of seven and 18 are using an average of six different products on their faces - with some using more than a dozen.
The team discovered these products tended to be marketed heavily towards young people and carried a high risk of skin irritation and allergy.
In fact, the top-viewed videos on the platform contained an average of 11 potentially irritating active ingredients. This puts young people at risk of developing allergic contact dermatitis, which can limit the type of soaps, shampoos, and cosmetics they can use for the rest of their lives.
Dr Molly Hales, a board-certified dermatologist and corresponding author of the study, said: 'That high risk of irritation came from both using multiple active ingredients at the same time, such as hydroxy acids, as well as applying the same active ingredient unknowingly over and over again when that active ingredient was found in three, four, five different products.'
The financial impact of these teen skin care routines was also found to be astounding - with a daily regimen costing an average of $168 a month. Some cost more than $500, the study, published this week in the journal Pediatrics, found. However, only 26% of these popular daytime skin care routines included sunscreen, which is one of the most important products for any age.
Dr Tara Lagu, the study's senior author, said: 'We saw that there was preferential, encoded racial language in some cases that really emphasised lighter, brighter skin. I think there also were real associations between use of these regimens and consumerism."
Ultimately, the study found that these TikTok skin care videos offer 'little to no benefit' to the young people they are targeting. Hales explained that it was also 'problematic to show girls devoting this much time and attention to their skin'.
She added: 'We're setting a very high standard for these girls. The pursuit of health has become a kind of virtue in our society, but the ideal of 'health' is also very wrapped up in ideals of beauty, thinness and whiteness. The insidious thing about 'skin care' is that it claims to be about health.'
For the study, the scientists created a new TikTok account and reported themselves to be 13-years-old. They used the app to collect demographics of content creators, the number and types of products used, and the total costs of the skin care regimes. The team also created a list of the active and inactive ingredients in the products and identified ingredients with an elevated risk of inducing allergic contact dermatitis.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
3 hours ago
- Daily Mail
I still breastfeed my three-year-old daughter - people say it's disturbing but it has saved her from stunted growth
A mother-of-two who breastfed her daughter up until she was three years old has hit back at criticism from trolls as she claims her decision has helped her child's development. Madison Simpson, who has documented her breastfeeding journey on TikTok, where she has more than 28,000 followers, has been told her approach is 'disturbing' and criticised for 'confusing' her daughter, Amaya. Known online as 'The Breastfeeding Momma', the 22-year-old, who appears to hail from the American South, advocates for 'extended breastfeeding'. Content creator Madison, who is from the US, posted a video of her blissfully breastfeeding her little girl earlier this year - when her daughter was approaching three - but it received a very negative reaction. One person commented: 'It's time to STOP! This is disturbing seeing how that child is bigger than you.' In the 30-second clip captioned 'Comfort nursing and bonding after the journey is over is okay too', Madison is holding Amaya in her arms and swaying to music as her daughter suckles on her breast. Amaya, who was born with Intrauterine Growth Restriction (IGR) weighed just over four pounds at birth and was expected to develop into a tiny child. Although Madison struggled to breastfeed her first child, son Amirion, she didn't have any issues with her daughter. And, at one month old, Amaya was already exceeding the growth expectations of her medical team, with Madison attributing her daughter's quick and impressive progress to breastfeeding. Madison, who is herself very petite, decided to continue in the same vein, nursing Amaya well beyond her second birthday - always breastfeeding and never giving her a bottle. The mother has also acknowledged that breastfeeding soothes her daughter, telling People that she puts Amaya 'on the boob and [lets] it be like a human pacifier.' TikTokers were largely unimpressed with Madison's video, with some vehemently opposed to her 'extended breastfeeding' approach. One person commented: 'It's time to STOP! This is disturbing seeing how that child is bigger than you.' Reacting to Amaya's height, which appears to be above average for a toddler, Another added: 'At that point you're nursing a whole child'. A third was especially judgmental, writing: 'Insecurity if a kid that age still needs a boobie for comfort. Clearly she has already developed food issues.' Referring to Amaya, a fourth said: 'Very confusing for her'. While a fifth person commented: 'She's a big girl. Does she eat solids or strictly breast milk?' One person, however, leapt to Madison's defence, adding: 'I am so sorry you are receiving such hateful comments. What a blessing it is to have given your baby three years'. Yet, unperturbed by all the negativity, Madison hit back at her detractors in a subsequent video posted on TikTok five days ago. She responded directly to US comedian and actor Brandon Trusso, who publicly mocked the young mother when he said: 'That is not a child. 'It has a 401 (k) plan and a reverse mortgage.' A 401 (k) plan is a type of retirement plan offered by US employers to their employees to help them save for when they've left the workforce. Madison strongly defended her choice when she said: '[Amaya] is three years old. 'I quit breastfeeding around four or five months ago and she is no longer breastfed. 'It doesn't look normal to you because I am literally the size of a 12-year-old. I am 4 feet 11 [and] 90 pounds soaking wet.' She went on to criticise Brandon for 'trying to down a mother for breastfeeding and giving away her body to a child.' Madison said: 'Do you know how many years of hard work and dedication that it took to breastfeed her?' The mother also noted in the video that it's normal in some countries to breastfeed up until seven. She ended the clip by pointing out that she helps 'a lot of moms' with her page - and that Brandon was also putting them down for breastfeeding their children. Madison then showed a picture of her daughter and said: 'Now does she look like she's off to college with a 401 (k) plan? She's three.'
Scottish Sun
5 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Do vitamin gummies actually work and should you give them to your kids? We grilled experts and tested them to find out
Two thirds of us take some kind of daily supplement, many of them the chewy kind - and celebs like Kourtney Kardashian have their own brands - but do vitamin gummies really do anything to boost our health? CHEW IT OVER Do vitamin gummies actually work and should you give them to your kids? We grilled experts and tested them to find out THEY'RE sweet, brightly-coloured and come in every shape going - from teddy bears to stars and berries. But do vitamin gummies really do anything? Or are they just another gimmicky wellness product? Advertisement 10 Two thirds of people in the UK take some kind of daily supplement - but are they a waste of time? Credit: Getty 10 Celebrities like Kourtney Kardashian have released their own lines of vitamin gummies Credit: Lemme 10 Wellness queen Gwyneth Paltrow also sells supplements through Goop Credit: Getty Vitamin supplements have been around for decades, and the chewable kinds have been on pharmacy and supermarket shelves since the 1990s. They promise to give us more energy, better sleep, thicker hair, healthier skin, stronger nails, improved digestion and boosted immunity. Thanks to TikTok trends and influencer shoutouts, these daily chews have become must-have accessories. And brands are seriously cashing in - the UK vitamins and supplements market is said to be worth £520million. Advertisement READ MORE ON HEALTH HEART OF IT Lacking key vitamin in childhood may raise risk of heart disease in later life Celebs are also jumping on the gummy train, with many coming out with their own lines. Kourtney Kardashian, for example, created lemme gummies, which are advertised as doing everything from reducing stress to promoting vaginal freshness. And obviously you can't talk about supplements without naming wellness queen Gwyneth Paltrow, who has her own gummies through Goop. With such big-name backing, it's easy to forget boring old pills and assume gummies are the glam way to stay healthy - but is this backed by science? Advertisement Do we really need to take vitamin supplements? TWO thirds of people in the UK take some kind of vitamin, mineral or supplement every day, according to Mintel. 'But a lot of people take these, especially multivitamins, when they don't actually need to,' Bahee Van de Bor, registered paediatric dietitian, tells Sun Health. To supplement or not- The top 10 vitamins and minerals that are vital for health - and the best sources for each one 'The only exception is vitamin D, which is recommended for most people in the UK. 'If you're concerned there might be gaps in you or your child's diet, it's always worth looking at how your food choices could be improved first, ideally with the support of a registered dietitian.' Advertisement Dr Rachel Ward, NHS GP (@drrachelwardGP), adds: 'The best way to get the vitamins we need is through a healthy, balanced diet and this would always be the way I would advise people to stay well. 'However, if you feel this is not possible - if you're excluding certain foods, for example - then supplements can be helpful. 'An exception is vitamin D. We get very little of it in our diets and we produce most of it in our skin when it is exposed to sunlight. 'We know that, especially in winter, many people in the UK become deficient in vitamin D and the NHS recommends that everyone takes supplements during autumn and winter and those at risk take them all year round.' Advertisement 10 Kourtney's products claim to reduce stress and promote to vaginal freshness Credit: Instagram/@kourtneykardash 10 Experts say pills are better than gummies as they don't contain sugar or sweeteners Credit: Getty Do vitamin gummies work? 'AS long as the gummies provide the correct dose and the manufacturer routinely tests their levels, they can be just as effective as a vitamin or mineral supplement in powder, spray or liquid form,' Bahee says. 'Gummies are often developed for children with sensory feeding difficulties or picky eaters, who may be more likely to accept them over other formats. Advertisement 'If a supplement is genuinely needed, tablets or capsules are often preferable as they tend to contain fewer flavourings and other extras. 'Gummies, by design, usually require more ingredients like sugars, flavourings, gelling agents, and sometimes emulsifiers to achieve their chewy texture and appealing taste. 'I don't take gummies myself — I prefer a tablet or spray that I can swallow. 'These formats often contain fewer added ingredients, though checking the label for specifics is always important.' Advertisement How to choose a healthy supplement ONE of the biggest questions you might have is about sugar and artificial sweeteners. These gummies must contain more sugar than a pill, but is it something to be worried about? According to Bahee, context is everything. It's not just about what's in the gummy, but how often you're taking it and what your overall diet looks like. 'That said, if a gummy is the only form you or your child will consistently take, the good news is that the amount of additives, like emulsifiers, is generally very small,' she says. Advertisement 'There have been some studies in animals suggesting that high, repeated intake of certain emulsifiers, such as polysorbate 80 and carboxymethylcellulose, may alter gut bacteria or trigger inflammation in the gut. 'But these were at much higher doses than you'd find in a typical supplement, and we don't yet have strong evidence that this is a concern for humans at normal intake levels.' I did notice some health benefits. I slept like a baby and definitely had more energy! Lily Ruaah Dr Ward adds: 'Vitamin gummies are very varied in the supplements they contain and the added sugar and colourings and so on. 'Therefore buy them from a reputable pharmacy, who can advise which is best for your needs. Advertisement 'Always opt for the low sugar version, especially for children.' The top 10 vitamins and minerals Vitamin A - for vision and immune health in children and adults over 50+. B vitamins - for red blood cell formation, neurological function, and DNA synthesis. Vitamin C - for the immune system, collagen production, and antioxidant function. Vitamin D - for bone health, immune function, and calcium absorption. Vitamin E - to protect cells from damage and support immune function. Calcium - for bone health and muscle contraction. Zinc - for immune function, supports wound healing and DNA synthesis. Iron - for red blood cells and oxygen transport in the body. Magnesium - for muscle function, bone health, and energy production. Potassium - to regulate fluid balance, nerve signals, and muscle contractions. My test I'VE always been a die hard vitamin pill taker. Even when I was a kid, my parents would give me the edible teddy bear vitamins which, let's be honest, tasted like chalk. So I was keen to try something a bit tastier — enter gummies. Advertisement Vitamin gummies are all over my 'for you' page, as I'm sure they are for everyone on #WellnessTok, and I've been dying to try them. When I was thinking about what vitamin gummies to choose from, there were a number of key factors. I wanted something that would: Taste great Benefit my needs as a woman And not break the bank! Because of course, we'd all love to try the Kardashian gummies, but at $30 per bottle it's not the right option for everyone! After a little web browsing, I chose the Nutriburst Women's Multivitamin - a seemingly good all-rounder. Advertisement They're vegan, sugar free, gluten free, halal certified, kosher permitted, and have no artificial flavours or colours - so basically tick all the boxes! These gummies promise to boost energy, fight fatigue, support a woman's hormonal balance, strengthen bones and boost immunity. A lot of promises for a tiny little chew! Once I got my hands on a bottle (for £12.99 on Amazon), I could see exactly what's inside. 10 Sun writer Lily Ruaah tried taking a gummy multivitamin every day Credit: Lily Ruaah Advertisement 10 She chose one that was sugar-free, with no artificial flavours or colours Credit: Lily Ruaah 10 Lily had more energy and slept better as a result Credit: Lily Ruaah Stand out qualities for me? Alongside the usual vitamins and minerals, the gummies contain biotin and vitamin B12, both of which I usually have to take separately, even when using a multivitamin pill so that was a major win for me. However, I did notice they didn't contain any vitamin D - as experts suggest - so it meant I still had to buy vitamin D tablets, which was a shame. Advertisement Other than the absolutely aesthetic bottle, my first thoughts were: these taste great! I've had candy gummies in the past (not vitamin ones) and these taste even better than those. Move over Haribo, I'll have a Nutriburst gummy. The texture is good and they're not too sweet. You need to have two per day, and I'd happily have more. 10 Advertisement My verdict PERHAPS surprisingly, I did notice some health benefits. The best for me was sleeping better. I slept like a baby and definitely had more energy! I definitely fell asleep faster, which is something I usually struggle with. I also had more energy to exercise during the day. It was easier to get myself up and about - for swimming in particular - which can sometimes feel like a chore. Advertisement But I can't promise that wouldn't have happened with a vitamin pill, which feels like it can be better value for money — and like I'm having unnecessary sweets all day (sorry, teeth). Either way though, I think I'm going to stick with taking some kind of vitamin, especially vitamin D! 10 Advertisement
Daily Mirror
12 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
NHS GP shares life-saving check 'everyone' should do monthly
Dr Shireen explained how to complete the check that everyone is recommended to complete on a regular basis An NHS doctor has highlighted an easy check "we should all be doing" as it could help diagnose cancer and save lives. GP and medical educator Dr Shireen has reminded her TikTok (@doctorshireen) followers to check their breasts following Jessie J's cancer diagnosis. The 37-year-old singer has revealed she's been diagnosed with "early breast cancer" and plans to undergo surgery. Praising the Price Tag singer, Dr Shireen said: "Jessie J has very bravely shared that she's been diagnosed with early breast cancer. "In her video, she says that she's holding on to the fact that it was diagnosed early, and she's absolutely right in doing so. The earlier we diagnose breast cancer, the better the prognosis, i.e., the better the outcome." "I'm a GP and today I'm going to share with you what we should all be doing to ensure if we were to get a breast cancer, it'd be picked up early, and that is self-checking," Dr Shireen shared. "Don't forget that breast cancer can affect men, too. So we recommend everyone to check their breasts once a month at least. It's really important for us to know what's normal so that the second that things might start becoming abnormal, we can pick it up quickly." In her video, the GP explained how to complete the check in a few steps. "The first thing you need to do is look, and it's not just looking at the breasts, it's also looking all the way up to the collarbone and into the axilla. "You're looking at the skin, you're looking for any tethering, any puckering, even any eczematous changes. Looking at the nipple for any inversion, any sign of any potential discharge, any changes like that," she said. Dr Shireen continued: "Next is feeling. So again, when we are palpating, we need to go all the way up and all the way into the axilla area. "But if we think about the breast as a round ball, you want to cut it into four quadrants, and you want to palpate each quadrant separately. So the way to do it is you push on one side, and then you literally just feel the area, and you're feeling for any lumps, any swellings, anything new that you're unsure about." The doctor urged people to speak to a GP if they have any health concerns. "If you do notice any of these changes, please make an appointment to speak to your GP. We refer patients to the urgent breast clinic all of the time, and more than 90% of the time it's nothing. But it is really important that if it is a breast cancer that is picked up early, because prognosis is so dependent on that," she said. The NHS explains that how serious breast cancer is depends on how big the cancer is, if the cancer has spread, and your general health. Advice on how to check your breasts is available on the NHS website. It says: "Checking your breasts or chest regularly helps you learn what looks and feels normal for you. This makes it easier to notice any changes that could be a sign of a condition such as breast cancer. You should try to check your breasts or chest about once a month."
