France ordered to compensate family of jogger killed by toxic algae
A French court on Tuesday, June 24, ordered the state to compensate the family of a 50-year-old man who died in 2016 during a run after inhaling poisonous gas emitted by rotting green algae piled along the country's western coast. The Nantes appeals court found France liable for the death of Jean-René Auffray, citing its "negligence" in enforcing environmental regulations to protect its waters and prevent toxic green algae blooms.
For more than five decades, tons of green algae have washed up annually on Brittany's beaches in western France, releasing hydrogen sulphide gas as it rots – a toxin that can prove deadly in high concentrations. Auffray, a keen trail runner, died of sudden respiratory failure while jogging in the algae-choked Gouessant estuary near the city of Saint-Brieuc.
His family sued over his death, but in 2022, a court rejected the claim, ruling there was insufficient evidence to link the toxic algae to Auffray's death. Tuesday's decision reversed that ruling, marking the first time France has been held liable for the health risks posed by deadly green algae blooms along its coast.
The court "holds the state liable for negligence due to its failure to implement European and national regulations designed to protect waters from agricultural pollution," which is "the main cause of the proliferation of green algae in Brittany," it explained in a statement. The court found Auffray's death was caused by a rapid pulmonary oedema – a condition in which there is too much fluid in the lungs – which could only be explained by fatal poisoning from inhaling hydrogen sulphide at very high concentrations.
"For the first time, a French court has recognized the link between a person's death and the state's negligence in these green algae cases," said the family's lawyer, François Lafforgue. The deceased's family will receive partial compensation, as the court found the state 60% liable, noting that he had taken a personal risk by jogging in the estuary.
The state has been ordered to pay €277,343 to the jogger's wife, €15,000 to each of his three children, and €9,000 to his brother. According to a 2021 report from France's top audit court, around 90% of Brittany's algae blooms are caused by agriculture, where the use of nitrogen fertilizers has increased significantly since the 1960s.
Intensive farming – especially pig farming – and the resulting nitrate pollution have been linked to the spread of green algae in the area.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Local France
4 hours ago
- Local France
Who qualifies for free-at-point-of-delivery healthcare in France?
Yes, it is not actually free. It is paid for in taxes and social charges, and most of us will contribute via deductions from earnings. But while most medical care in France is done via a reimbursement model, sometimes there is 'free at the point of delivery' care. This is known as tiers payant (third-party payment) and it means the medical costs are paid directly via national insurance system - rather than the more common model of the patient paying the doctor or pharmacist upfront and then being reimbursed some or all of the cost later via the state Assurance maladie model. Advertisement People or treatments covered by tiers payant are 100 percent covered, but involve no upfront payment at all. Because it's France, this is complicated, but essentially there are some groups of people covered by the tiers payant system for all of their medical costs, then there are certain treatments that come under tiers payant , for everyone. People The following groups are covered, for all of their medical needs Lower-income households who have government-backed complémentaire santé solidaire (CSS or C2S) health cover Refugees and asylum seekers Pregnant women (from the first day of the sixth month of pregnancy to the 12th day after the birth) People with long-term health conditions – known generically as an Affection Longue Durée (or ALD) Treatments There are also certain types of treatment that are covered, even if you don't fit into one of the above groups; Treatment for workplace injuries or occupational illnesses Care for injuries received during an act of terrorism Anyone under the age 26 consulting a medical professional for contraception Abortions Health screening options such as cancer screenings, pap smears or general health checks once you hit a particular age range - once you are registered in the French health system you are periodically invited to these. Everyone else For people and treatments not covered by tiers payant , there is the reimbursement model. In this case the patient pays the doctor/pharmacist/physio/other health professional the cost of the procedure or drug, which in most cases is set by the government. Advertisement Those registered in the French national health system then hand over their carte vitale - health card - and the government then reimburses some or all of the cost of the treatment, directly into their bank account. The reimbursement usually takes only a couple of days. How much of the cost is reimbursed by the state depends on the type of treatment, the type of doctor you see, and personal circumstances. Cancer treatments are reimbursed at 100 percent, as any health matters during pregnancy, while dermatology treatment or a cosmetic dentistry procedure would be reimbursed at a lower percentage. To cover the remaining percentage, most people in France have 'top up' insurance known as a mutuelle. READ ALSO Health insurance: How to choose a 'mutuelle' in France Advertisement Changes to tiers payant In response to a significant number of cases of fraud and misuse of medication, the health officials in France have toughened up the terms and conditions for using it. In day-to-day terms, you probably won't notice any difference, particularly if you carry your carte vitale with you as a matter of course. But, it is now mandatory to present your card – in physical or digital form – in order to be eligible for third-party payment ( le tiers payant ). READ ALSO Mutuelles: French health insurance costs set to rise in 2025 In agreement with the pharmacists' unions, the French Health Insurance now makes it mandatory for people to present their carte in order to receive this instant payment. This measure applies in particular to 'sensitive' drugs (narcotics, certain anti-diabetic drugs, or expensive treatments). Dispensing without a Vitale card will only be possible in exceptional circumstances, for example for infants under three months old or elderly people in nursing homes. Without the card, the entire cost has to be paid upfront, and then reclaimed via a paperwork survivor of the days before computers known as a feuille de soins . READ ALSO What's a 'feuille de soins' in French healthcare and what do you do with it?
Local France
4 hours ago
- Local France
Eurostar trains cancelled after cables cut in northern France
Eurostar on Wednesday was advising passengers to postpone their trips if possible, with several trains cancelled or delayed after more than 600 metres of cables were vandalised in northern France, the company and French railway operator said. "More than 600 metres of cable were stolen or severed south of the Lille Europe station" on the way between the two capitals, French railway operator SNCF said. French high-speed TGV and local TER services are impacted, as well as Eurostar routes between Paris, Brussels and Amsterdam. Advertisement Around 15 workers, including cable makers, were dispatched to solve the issue, the operator added. "Trains are being redirected via secondary routes, which increases travel times," said Eurostar spokeswoman Juliette Clement. "Eurostar advises those who were supposed to travel today to postpone their trip, with free exchanges and refunds available," she added. All trains between Paris and Lille - including the French high-speed TGV services, local TER trains and the Eurostar - were halted on Tuesday evening after a person was hit by a train and killed close to Lille. Local paper La Voix du Nord reported that the accident happened in the afternoon and caused some disruption, but then a second fatal accident saw the Paris-Lille line closed in both directions. Some passengers were forced to sleep at London St Pancras station after the final trains back to Paris were cancelled.
Euronews
5 hours ago
- Euronews
Eurostar faces severe delays and cancellations after cable theft
Eurostar passengers are facing a second day of major delays and cancellations after two people died on the track in France on Tuesday, and then cables were stolen near Lille on Wednesday. There are 'severe delays and last-minute cancellations' in both directions between London and Paris. Trains between London St Pancras and Paris Gare Du Nord were either delayed or cancelled until 12:30 CEST. The predicted delays range from 40 minutes to 2 hours. Trains that are running are also being forced to take alternative routes, causing extended journey times. Services on the London-Brussels-Amsterdam route are running without delays. Cable theft is causing travel chaos Today's delays were caused by the theft of around 600 metres of copper cables overnight, according to reports in French media. It comes after the LGV Nord high-speed line between Lille and Paris was closed for much of Tuesday following the deaths of two people on the line. Eurostar said disruption from this first incident continued into Wednesday morning, then the cable thefts compounded the problem. Stations in London and Paris are very busy with stranded or delayed passengers and the operator said it is handing out water to passengers on delayed trains. What should you do if you are travelling with Eurostar today? Eurostar has advised passengers to cancel or postpone their trip. 'We're deeply sorry to confirm that two fatalities occurred yesterday on the high-speed line between Lille and Paris. Disruption has continued due [to] displaced trains and a separate cable theft near Lille,' the international rail operator said in a post on X. 'SNCF Réseau teams are working hard to restore the damaged infrastructure, with one track already opened. This will allow trains to run in both directions until full repairs are completed, expected by around 4pm.' It said that impacted passengers can change their travel plans for free or request a full refund.
