Minister asked to comment on detention of Irish politician in Egypt
The partner of an Irish politician who was detained in Egypt has called on Ireland's Foreign Affairs Minister to make a statement on the matter.
People Before Profit-Solidarity TD (MP) Paul Murphy said he had been detained in Egypt while attempting to march to the Rafah crossing into Gaza as part of a large demonstration and effort to get aid into the region.
The opposition politician said his phone and passport were confiscated on Friday before being put on a bus to Cairo airport for deportation.
His partner, Councillor Jess Spear, appealed to Foreign Affairs Minister and deputy premier Simon Harris to make a public statement.
In a statement, she said: 'Paul was detained for hours this afternoon and forced onto a bus to be brought to Cairo airport for deportation. Paul's phone has been taken but he was allowed to call me briefly this evening.'
She added: 'It is a serious matter for a member of the Dail to be detained in Egypt and forcibly deported just because he was participating in a peaceful march to try and get humanitarian aid into starving people in Gaza.
'I appeal to the Tanaiste to make a public statement calling on the Egyptian authorities to release Paul and all the others detained and to let them continue their humanitarian mission to Gaza.'
Mr Murphy flew to Cairo on Thursday and set off towards Gaza on Friday.
Prior to his phone being taken, he said his passport had been confiscated by the Egyptian army along with the passports of other people in the group who were stopped.
He said those being detained were being asked to board a bus and he believed they were going to be deported.
Mr Murphy told the PA news agency that several other Irish citizens were among those who have been stopped.
In a video, he said: 'It's looking worrying that the Egyptian authorities are going to act to prevent our peaceful march to Gaza, to demand that Israel's blockade of humanitarian aid, of food, of water, of medical supplies, is ended.
'I'm just asking people to redouble their efforts, to get on to your own government, in Ireland's case get on to (Foreign Affairs Minister) Simon Harris, your local TD, ask them to pressurise the Egyptian regime to allow us to engage in our peaceful march.'
He added: 'The world has watched a horrific genocide for the past 20 months. Since March, a total attempt of starvation.
'And that this is a peaceful march to demand that it be ended and demand that western governments stop their complicity.'
Mr Murphy then posted a livestream video on X in which Egyptian authorities could be seen forcibly dragging some of the participants away from a sit-down protest.
The livestream abruptly ended after his phone was taken, a People Before Profit spokesman said, adding that he had been put on a bus for Cairo airport.
A post by an administrator on his X account says: 'We urgently need Minister for Foreign Affairs Simon Harris to intervene, demand he is freed, his passport and phone returned and the protesters are allowed to peacefully march to Gaza.'
On request for a comment, a spokesman for Mr Harris referred to a statement from the Department of Foreign Affairs.
The statement said the department was 'closely monitoring the situation' along with its embassy in Egypt.
'Embassy officials are engaging with the relevant local authorities and are in contact with EU and other partners regarding the situation.
'The department is in contact with a number of citizens and is providing advice and guidance.
'As set out in our travel advice, the vicinity of the Rafah border crossing is particularly dangerous at the moment and the border crossing is currently closed.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
4 hours ago
- Daily Mail
MARK ALMOND: Benjamin Netanyahu can smell the air - and Tehran reeks of weakness
Dazzling as Israel 's initial 48 hours of bombing Iran 's nuclear installations, military leadership and key scientists have been, victory in this war requires much more than precision strikes. Iran is a huge country and might absorb a lot of such punishment before cracking. Unlike America's 'shock and awe' attack on Saddam Hussein's Iraq in 2003, the Israelis are not intending to use their amazing aerial superiority to invade Iran. It is because Tehran's terrorist ally Hezbollah has been defanged – following Israel's invasion of the group's stronghold in southern Lebanon last year and its audacious detonation of pagers used by Hezbollah fighters – that Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu has felt emboldened to strike Iran now. Nonetheless, Israel's army is bogged down fighting Iran's other insurgent ally, Hamas, in Gaza and needs to control millions of Arabs in the occupied West Bank, so it is not looking for another front further to the east. But on Friday night, Netanyahu indicated that this campaign was about more than just disabling Iran's nuclear weapons capability. He directly called on ordinary Iranians to 'rise up' and overthrow the 'evil and oppressive regime' in Tehran. Fomenting a revolution from 50,000 feet is a tall order but Netanyahu can smell the air – and Iran reeks of weakness. At 86, its Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Khamenei, hasn't many years left, and his response to this attack has been inept and scattergun, with the vast majority of his drones and missiles destroyed by Israeli defences. Operational incompetence aside, for years billions have been squandered on terrorist proxies abroad like Hamas and Hezbollah and weapons systems that don't work well enough to deter Israeli missiles. Meanwhile economic sanctions eat away at living standards of ordinary Iranians. For this reason, they have chafed at their rulers' priorities, taking to the streets in several uprisings since 2009. Yet the regime's thugs have suppressed them viciously – until now. Insurrection in Iranian cities could well pressure the Brutuses within the regime to act. But Israel must be careful what it wishes for. If the regime implodes, Khamenei – a leader who specialises in making bad military decisions – could be replaced by someone infinitely more able. The Ayatollah has spent decades marginalising slightly less hardline, but rather more competent, rivals. Veterans such as Mir Hossein Mousavi, the prime minister who steered Iran through the war with Iraq in the 1980s, but lost office when Khamenei came to power in 1989. In leading the protest movement in 2009, Mousavi's anti-Khamenei credentials are sound and he could be a plausible 'moderate', but he is an old man himself at 83 and an advocate of an Iranian atomic bomb. Having kneecapped the country's nuclear programme, could the West and Israel live with that? Under Donald Trump, pragmatism reigns. Since Syria's pro-Iranian dictator, Bashar Al Assad, was toppled last December, Washington has cosied up to the country's new ruler, Ahmed Al Sharaa, on whom it had placed a $10 million bounty as an Al Qaeda terrorist. So the Trump Administration could deal with a new Iranian regime made up of old enemies provided they reverse course. An ex-Islamic Republic insider, cynical enough to pull the plug on the incompetent fanatics running Iran, could be the best way out for Israel and the West. A bloodless coup at the top is one thing, but chaos throughout the country could endanger the safe-keeping of its nuclear technology and chemical weapons, so some kind of orderly transition is vital. It won't be ideal. Certainly not for those Iranians who have borne the brunt of the Ayatollah's cruelties and hardships. But it might well be the fastest way to end this war and offer some hope of a better future.
The Independent
4 hours ago
- The Independent
Trump considering adding another 36 countries to his no travel list including African and Caribbean nations: report
The Trump administration is considering implementing travel restrictions to 36 more countries, including some major U.S. partners such as Egypt and Djibouti, according to an internal memo seen by the Washington Post. The memo, signed by Secretary of State Marco Rubio and sent to U.S. diplomats on Saturday, says the governments of the listed nations have 60 days to meet new requirements established by the State Department. The State Department alleged that the countries mentioned have not met various benchmarks, such as 'no competent or cooperative central government authority' to provide reliable identity documents or a large number of citizens who have violated the terms of their visas. The list of countries, which could face visa restrictions, travel bans, or other restrictions, includes 25 African countries: Angola, Benin, Burkina Faso, Cabo Verde, Cameroon, Côte d'Ivorie, Democratic Republic of the Congo, Djibouti, Ethiopia, Egypt, Gabon, Gambia, Ghana, Liberia, Malawi, Mauritania, Niger, Nigeria, Sao Tome and Principe, Senegal, South Sudan, Tanzania, Uganda, Zambia, and Zimbabwe. Several Caribbean nations are on the list as well: Antigua and Barbuda, Dominica, Saint Kitts and Nevis, and Saint Lucia. Four countries in Asia: Bhutan, Cambodia, Kyrgyzstan, and Syria; and three countries in Oceania: Tonga, Tuvalu, and Vanuatu Those countries have until Wednesday at 8 a.m. to provide the State Department with an initial plan of action to meet the new requirements.
Telegraph
5 hours ago
- Telegraph
Netanyahu's race against the clock to go ‘full Hezbollah' on Iran
'I must govern the clock, not be governed by it.' So said Golda Meir, one of Israel's founders and its first and only female prime minister. Now, some 50 years later, the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) may have realised her insight. Indeed, they have taken the clock and blown it to smithereens, neutralising its power to contain them once and for all. For the mullahs of Iran, this could spell curtains, or at least a long and painful 'Hezbollah-isation' stretching over weeks and months. The clock has always been central to Israeli military planning, with its strategists at the Kirya in central Tel Aviv long regarding it as important as guns and manpower. There are two big drivers. First, the IDF is reliant on reservists, so once a war starts there is an immediate social and economic imperative to move quickly. But much more influential – since the Yom Kippur war of 1973 and the global oil crisis it sparked – has been the 'diplomatic clock' and Israel's reliance on the US and its allies for military and diplomatic support. Once any new conflict started, the clock of international opinion would start ticking, with the US generally moving to bring things to a close as soon as possible. The prospect of the Middle East going up in flames and oil prices spiking ruinously has always trumped Israel's longer term security interests. Even after the Oct 7 massacre, Israel's military establishment feared it had only a limited window to deal with Hamas in Gaza and Hezbollah in the north. Manuel Trajtenberg, then executive director of the Institute for National Security Studies (INSS) in Tel Aviv, told The Telegraph at the time that the IDF was racing against 'several different clocks, all of them ticking down'. 'There's the military clock itself in terms of manpower and capacity but also the hostages, international pressure and even economic pressures,' he said. Looking back now, it's hard to determine what the worry was. While the 1967 Arab-Israeli War was famously wrapped up in six days, the latest conflict has been raging for nearly two years. Hamas has all but been blasted to extinction, ditto Hezbollah in Lebanon. The IDF is acting at will against anything it judges a threat in Syria and moves with impunity over Yemen. Now Iran – 'the head of the octopus' – is firmly in its sights. Part of what's changed things is the psychological shock of Oct 7 and the sense of existential crisis in Israel it has created. 'The diplomatic clock is a fraud, and Israel's leaders must see through it', urged Nave Dromi, director of the Israel Victory Project in the wake of the massacre. 'There can be no specific time limitations on responding to the murder, rape and butchery of 1,200 people, the wounding of thousands of others and the vicious kidnapping and humiliation of 240 Israelis and foreigners'. But as important in the destruction of the clock is Benjamin Netanyahu and his willingness to take on US presidents – a theme since he confronted Barack Obama over his 2015 nuclear deal with Iran from the floor of the US Congress. The Israeli prime minister then tied Joe Biden in knots over Gaza, and then Lebanon, for the final 15 months of his term. And he has now almost certainly cocked a snook at Donald Trump, who, by most accounts, wanted more time to renegotiate a nuclear deal with Tehran. 'Trump had sought additional time from Netanyahu for nuclear talks, and Netanyahu did not give it to him,' said Daniel Shapiro who served as US ambassador to Israel from 2011 to 2017, in an interview with Foreign Affairs magazine on Friday. For Iran, Netanyahu's great foe of more than 30 years, this could be very bad news indeed, with nothing obvious to stop Israel's bombing campaign against it grinding on for weeks and months. Sima Shine, a senior researcher at INSS, said there was 'no significant international pressure' to wrap things up – quite a thing for a former Mossad official and Iran specialist who spent decades battling the clock. 'There is little sympathy for the Iranian regime', she said. 'Everyone recognises its negative role in the war in Ukraine, its involvement in the Middle East conflicts, its brutal suppression of protesters – especially women – and the fact that no one wants to see it possess nuclear weapons.' At a briefing for journalists on Saturday, a senior IDF official turned things around 180 degrees, conjuring up a very different figurative clock. 'We are prepared for more … an aerial road to Tehran has effectively been opened', he said. 'Our goal in these operations is to remove an existential threat; to remove a ticking time bomb.'
