Big questions loom over Trump's announcement of Israel-Iran ceasefire deal, World News
WASHINGTON — When President Donald Trump sent US bombers to strike Iran's nuclear sites last weekend, he was betting he could help ally Israel cripple Tehran's nuclear programme while keeping his long-standing vow to avoid entanglement in a protracted war.
Just days later, Trump's surprise announcement on Monday (June 23) of an Israel-Iran ceasefire agreement suggests he may have bombed Tehran's rulers back to the negotiating table.
But a long list of big unanswered questions remains, not least whether any ceasefire can actually take effect and hold between two bitter foes whose years-long "shadow" conflict had erupted into an air war marked by the past 12 days of strikes on each other's territory.
Also still unknown and unmentioned in Trump's effusive social media post announcing an imminent "Complete and Total CEASEFIRE" are the terms the two sides have agreed to; whether the US and Iran will revive failed nuclear talks; and the fate of Iran's stockpile of enriched uranium that many experts believe may have survived the US and Israeli bombing campaign.
"The Israelis have accomplished much of their objectives... and Iran was looking for an off-ramp," said Jonathan Panikoff, a former deputy US national intelligence officer for the Middle East. "The US hopes this is the beginning of the end. The challenge is whether there is a strategy for what comes next."
Questions also remain about what has actually been agreed to, even as Trump's declaration raised hopes for the end of a conflict that has prompted fears of a broader regional war.
There was no immediate confirmation from Israel of a ceasefire deal, and the Israeli military said it had detected missiles launched from Iran towards Israel in the early hours of Tuesday. Four people were killed in a missile strike on a building in Beersheba, Israel's ambulance service said.
Soon after, Trump said the ceasefire between Israel and Iran was "now in effect" and urged both countries to not violate it.
While an Iranian official earlier confirmed that Tehran had accepted a ceasefire, the country's foreign minister, Abbas Araqchi, said there would be no cessation of hostilities unless Israel stopped its attacks.
But that did not stop Trump and his loyalists from touting what they see as a landmark achievement of a foreign policy approach they call "peace through strength."
Trump had endorsed Israel's assessment that Iran was getting close to developing a nuclear weapon, which Tehran has long denied. US intelligence agencies said earlier this year they assessed that Iran was not building a nuclear weapon and a source with access to US intelligence reports told Reuters last week that that view hadn't changed. Iran's calibrated response
Trump's announcement came just hours after Iran launched missiles against a US air base in Qatar, causing no casualties, in retaliation for the US dropping 30,000-pound (about 13,607kg) bunker-buster bombs on Iranian underground nuclear facilities over the weekend.
[[nid:719411]]
Trump administration officials deemed Iran's response on Monday to have been calibrated to avoid further escalation with the US, according to sources familiar with the matter.
Trump called for talks with Israel and Iran, and a senior White House official said Israel agreed to a ceasefire so long as Iran did not launch fresh attacks. Iran signalled that no further strikes would take place, the official said on condition of anonymity.
Trump spoke directly to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, and Vice President JD Vance, Secretary of State Marco Rubio and US special envoy Steve Witkoff were involved in the direct and indirect communications with Iran, the official said. Qatar also helped broker contacts with the Iranians.
Iran was also amenable to the ceasefire because it was in a severely "weakened state," the White House official said. The Iranians had faced days of Israeli bombardment of nuclear and military sites as well as targeted killings of top nuclear scientists and security commanders.
Trump in recent days had also mused publicly about the prospects for "regime change" in Iran.
Earlier on Monday, three Israeli officials had said their government was looking to wrap up its campaign in Iran soon and had passed the message on to the US but that much would depend on Tehran.
"Now that Trump declared 'world peace,' it will be hard for Netanyahu to publicly contradict him," said Laura Blumenfeld, a Middle East expert at the Johns Hopkins School for Advanced International Studies in Washington. Trump's big gamble
For his part, Trump's unprecedented decision to bomb Iran's nuclear sites marked a step that he had long pledged to avoid - to intervene militarily in a major foreign war.
In the biggest and potentially riskiest foreign policy move of his presidency, Trump was betting not only that he could take out Iran's key nuclear site at Fordow but also draw only measured retaliation against the US
There have been fears that Tehran could respond by closing the Strait of Hormuz, the world's most important oil artery, attacking multiple US military bases in the Middle East and activating proxies against US and Israeli interests worldwide.
If Trump is able to defuse the Israel-Iran conflict, he may be able to calm the storm of criticism from congressional Democrats and appease the anti-interventionist wing of his Republican MAGA base over bombings that ran counter to his own campaign pledges.
It would also allow him to re-focus on policy priorities such as deporting undocumented migrants and waging a tariff war against trading partners.
But Trump and his aides won't be able to ignore Iran and the lingering questions it poses.
"Can the ceasefire hold?" asked Dennis Ross, a former Middle East negotiator for Republican and Democratic administrations. "Yes, the Iranians need it and the Israelis have largely now acted against the (Israeli Defence Force's) target list."
But obstacles remain. "Iran is greatly weakened but what is the future of its nuclear and ballistic missile programmes? What happens to its stockpile of highly enriched uranium? There will be a need for negotiations — and these won't be easy to resolve," Ross said.
[[nid:719431]]
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNA
27 minutes ago
- CNA
'Not happy': Trump accuses Israel, Iran of breaching truce
US President Donald Trump accused both Israel and Iran of violating a ceasefire on Tuesday (Jun 24), hours after he announced it, expressing particular frustration with Israel which had announced plans for major new strikes on Tehran. Speaking to reporters before leaving for the NATO summit in The Hague, Trump said Israel "unloaded" right after agreeing to the deal. Trump said he was not happy with Iran, "but really unhappy with Israel". "Israel, do not drop those bombs," he said. "If you do it is a major violation. Bring your pilots home, now." He added that Israel had to calm down. "I gotta get Israel to calm down now," Trump said as he left the White House. "Israel, as soon as we made the deal, they came out and they dropped a load of bombs, the likes of which I've never seen before, the biggest load that we've seen." "We basically have two countries that have been fighting so long and so hard that they don't know what the f*** they're doing." CEASEFIRE? Israeli Defence Minister Israel Katz earlier said he had ordered the military to strike Tehran in response to what he said were missiles fired by Iran in a violation of the ceasefire announced hours earlier by Trump. The minister said in a statement he had ordered the military to "continue high-intensity operations targeting regime assets and terror infrastructure in Tehran" in light of "Iran's blatant violation of the ceasefire declared by the President of the US". Iran denied violating the ceasefire. The armed forces general staff denied that there had been any launch of missiles towards Israel in recent hours, Iran's Nour News reported. Both Israel and Iran had confirmed the ceasefire after Trump's announcement. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said his country had achieved the goals it set in launching its Jun 13 surprise attack on Iran - to destroy its nuclear programme and missile capabilities. "Israel thanks President Trump and the US for their support in defence and their participation in eliminating the Iranian nuclear threat," Netanyahu had said. Iran's top security body, the Supreme National Security Council, said its military had forced Israel to "unilaterally accept defeat and accept a ceasefire". Iran's forces would "keep their hands on the trigger" to respond to "any act of aggression by the enemy", it said. Iran's Foreign Minister Abbas Araqchi had said that Iran would halt its retaliatory strikes provided that Israel stopped attacking as of 4am in Tehran. In the last reported strikes before the ceasefire, missiles killed four people in the southern Israeli city of Beersheba, the Israeli ambulance service said. Iranian officials said nine people, including a nuclear scientist, were killed in a strike on a residential building in northern Iran. GLOBAL RELIEF Despite the early threats to the ceasefire, the response across the region and wider world was largely one of relief at the prospect of an end to the biggest direct confrontation ever between the two foes. Global stock markets surged and oil prices tumbled after the ceasefire announcement, in the hope it heralded a resolution of the war two days after the US hit Iranian nuclear sites with huge bunker-busting bombs. "We're happy, very happy. Who mediated or how it happened doesn't matter. The war is over. It never should have started in the first place," said Reza Sharifi, 38, heading back to Tehran from Rasht on the Caspian Sea, where he had relocated with his family to escape strikes on the capital. "I was so worried that Iran would end up like Syria or Iraq," said Maryam, 41, who stayed in Tehran because her family had no money to travel. "I want my two children to grow up in peace. I want them to live their childhood happily." Israel attacked on Jun 13, hitting Iranian nuclear sites and killing the top echelon of its military command in the worst threat faced by the Islamic Republic since war with Iraq in the 1980s. During the campaign, Israel said it was prepared to topple Iran's clerical rulers if necessary to achieve its aims and struck symbolic targets unrelated to the military, culminating on Monday with a strike on Tehran's Evin prison. Iranian officials say hundreds of people have been killed in airstrikes. Full information about the extent of the damage cannot be confirmed independently, with media tightly controlled. Iran's retaliatory missile strikes killed 28 people in Israel, the first time large numbers of Iranian missiles have penetrated its defences. Trump entered the war on Saturday with strikes on Iranian nuclear sites buried under a mountain using huge bombs that Israel does not possess. A senior White House official said Trump had brokered the ceasefire deal in a call with Netanyahu, and Israel had agreed so long as Iran did not launch further attacks. "On the assumption that everything works as it should, which it will, I would like to congratulate both Countries, Israel and Iran, on having the Stamina, Courage, and Intelligence to end, what should be called, 'THE 12 DAY WAR'," Trump wrote on Truth Social. Qatar's Prime Minister Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al Thani secured Tehran's agreement during a call with Iranian officials, an official briefed on the negotiations told Reuters. US Vice President JD Vance, Secretary of State Marco Rubio and US special envoy Steve Witkoff were in direct and indirect contact with the Iranians, a White House official said. Iran had responded to the US participation in the airstrikes by firing missiles on Monday at the biggest U.S. military base in the Middle East, located in Qatar. No one was hurt in that strike, with Iran's retaliation apparently calibrated to allow de-escalation afterwards. Trump thanked Tehran for warning the US in advance to avoid injuries, and called the strike "a very weak response, which we expected, and have very effectively countered". The US had been negotiating with Iran to agree curbs to its nuclear programme, after Trump quit a previous agreement in 2018. Iran has always said its nuclear programme is peaceful.
Straits Times
32 minutes ago
- Straits Times
In New York mayoral primary, progressive upstart aims to spoil Cuomo's comeback bid
The result will offer an early reading on the direction Democrats believe the party should take in countering Mr Trump on the national stage. PHOTO: REUTERS NEW YORK - Four years after sexual misconduct allegations led Andrew Cuomo to resign as New York governor, the combative political veteran is expected to take a big step forward in his comeback bid by winning the primary to determine the Democratic candidate for New York City mayor in the November election. Mr Cuomo, who served 10 years as governor before stepping down in 2021, has a narrow lead in the latest poll released on June 23, facing a spirited challenge from 33-year-old Zohran Mamdani, a relatively unknown state lawmaker who has pulled away from 10 others in a crowded field of candidates. With voting ending on June 24, the two frontrunners present a clear choice: Mr Cuomo, an experienced moderate backed by the establishment, or Mr Mamdani, a progressive newcomer who promises a break with the past. Coming months after President Donald Trump began rolling out his sweeping agenda, the result will offer an early reading on the direction Democrats believe the party should take in countering Mr Trump on the national stage. "The outcome of this race could show whether NYC voters feel that more centrist policies ... or a broader socio-political movement is the path forward for Democrats nationally," Basil Smikle, a political analyst and professor at Columbia University's School of Professional Studies, told Reuters. If Mr Cuomo prevails, it will also suggest voters are willing to forgive or at least forget misconduct accusations that the former governor has long denied, as well as allegations that he misled the public during the 2020 coronavirus pandemic. Former Governor and New York City mayoral candidate Andrew Cuomo holds a rally at the Carpenters Union on the eve of the Democratic primary on June 23. PHOTO: AFP It may take weeks to determine the winner due to a complicated ranked-choice system for counting votes. Either way, the victor will become the favorite to take the general election in a city where Democrats dominate. The current mayor, Eric Adams, will also appear on the November ballot, but a series of corruption scandals and his perceived ties to Mr Trump have weakened his standing. The Republican candidate is Curtis Sliwa, a radio host best known as the founder of the Guardian Angels anti-crime patrol. New York City Mayor Eric Adams speaks during a press conference at City Hall in Manhattan on June 3. PHOTO: REUTERS The 67-year-old Cuomo, whose father served three terms as governor in the 1980s and 1990s, has attacked Mr Mamdani for his relative lack of experience, both in confronting Mr Trump and dealing with the issues of crime, housing and infrastructure. "He has never done any of the essentials, and now you have Donald Trump on top of all of that," Mr Cuomo said at a debate earlier this month. "He has never dealt with what I think is the greatest national threat that we face." Mr Cuomo, who emerged as a vocal critic of Mr Trump during his first term as president, has won the endorsements of former President Bill Clinton and former New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg, a billionaire who poured US$8.3 million (S$10.6 million) into a political action committee that supports the former governor. Despite their differences in the past, Bloomberg said Mr Cuomo is the right person to protect New York from the impact of Mr Trump's policies. Muslim born in Africa Born in Uganda to a family of Indian descent, Mr Mamdani, a Muslim, has a history of pro-Palestinian activism. He was elected to a state assembly seat in New York's Queens borough only four years ago. New York City mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani speaks in Queens on May 17. PHOTO: ANGELINA KATSANIS/NYTIMES A self-described democratic socialist, Mr Mamdani has garnered the support of US Senator Bernie Sanders and Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, two of the country's most prominent progressives. 'We need new leadership that is prepared to stand up to powerful corporate interests and fight for the working class,' Mr Sanders posted on X. Burnishing his grassroots credentials, he has received more small donations than any candidate for New York City mayor in the past three decades and more than twice as many as Mr Cuomo and Mr Adams combined. Mr Cuomo has more individual donors among retired New Yorkers and residents in some expensive Manhattan neighborhoods, a database of donors on the New York City Campaign Finance Board website shows. Mr Mamdani's support surged to 32 per cent in a June 18-20 poll conducted by Emerson College, up from just 1 per cent in February. He remains behind Mr Cuomo, who held steady at around 35 per cent. But Mamdani wins 52 per cent to 48 per cent in round 8 of the ranked-choice voting simulation, the pollster said. 33-year-old Zohran Mamdani is a relatively unknown state lawmaker who has pulled away from 10 others in a crowded field of candidates. PHOTO: EPA-EFE In a June 9-12 reading by the Marist Institute for Public Opinion, Mr Cuomo stood at 43 per cent versus Mamdani's 31 per cent, which gave him a 55 per cent to 45 per cent victory in the seventh round of voting. The ranked-choice system allows voters to pick candidates in order of preference. In each round, candidates who trail are eliminated, and their votes are redistributed to the second choice marked on the ballots of their supporters. The process is repeated until one candidate achieves 50 per cent of the total. The system could give the biggest boost to Mr Mamdani, who cross-endorsed Brad Lander, the New York City comptroller who is polling around 10 per cent. Both progressives urged their supporters to rank the other as second choice. Democratic mayoral candidate Brad Lander prepares to participate in a Democratic mayoral primary debate on June 4. PHOTO: REUTERS An outspoken opponent of Mr Trump's immigration crackdown, Mr Lander caught the public's eye last week when he was briefly detained while escorting a defendant out of an immigration court. Mr Mamdani has sought to counter the criticism over his relative lack of experience by portraying Mr Cuomo as an old-school has-been with stale ideas for running the city. To further highlight the differences between him and the former governor, Mr Mamdani has also taken aim at Mr Cuomo for the allegations of sexual impropriety. While accepting "full responsibility", Mr Cuomo has denied wrongdoing for what he characterised as ill-conceived attempts to be affectionate or humorous. At the debate, Mr Mamdani sounded unsympathetic. "I have never had to resign in disgrace," Mr Mamdani said as the audience cheered. "Because I'm not you, Mr Cuomo." REUTERS Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Straits Times
32 minutes ago
- Straits Times
Thai party plans no confidence vote against embattled PM
Next week's planned motion will be the first parliamentary test for Thailand's Prime Minister Paetongtarn Shinawatra. PHOTO: REUTERS BANGKOK - Thailand's Bhumjaithai party, which left the ruling coalition last week, said on June 24 it will seek a parliamentary no confidence vote against Prime Minister Paetongtarn Shinawatra and her Cabinet, in another blow to the embattled premier. Next week's planned motion will be the first parliamentary test for Ms Paetongtarn, 38, since coming under intense public pressure over her handling of an escalating border row with neighbouring Cambodia, which has left the ruling alliance led by her Pheu Thai party hanging on to power by a thread. Bhumjaithai withdrew its support for the government on June 18 citing the risk of a loss of Thai sovereignty and integrity from the leak of a phone conversation between Ms Paetongtarn and Cambodia's former premier Hun Sen. During the call, Ms Paetongtarn kowtowed before the veteran Cambodian politician and criticised a Thai army commander, a red line in a country where the military has significant clout. She has apologised over the leak. 'We have a party resolution to file a no confidence motion against the prime minister,' Bhumjaithai spokesman Boontida Somchai said, adding that the party was inviting other opposition groups to back the move. 'When Parliament opens, first thing, we will petition a no-confidence motion.' Bhumjaithai has 69 seats and would need the support of another 30 lawmakers to launch the motion when Parliament reconvenes on July 3. Mr Sorawong Thienthong, tourism minister and Pheu Thai party secretary-general, said the government was not concerned as it had the backing of more than half of the house. 'We are not worried. This is the duty of the opposition,' Mr Sorawong told Reuters. Facing an unprecedented crisis in her young political career, Ms Paetongtarn has refused to back down. On June 24 she said the coalition was strong, and the government had settled on a Cabinet reshuffle, while approving US$3.5 billion (S$4.48 billion) worth of infrastructure projects aimed at boosting the flagging economy. 'It's settled, I've spoken to all party leaders,' she said. 'Coalition parties have been fully supportive.' REUTERS Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
