Staff at RTÉ call on broadcaster to oppose Israel's participation at Eurovision this year
STAFF AT RTÉ have called on the broadcaster to oppose Israel's participation at this year's Eurovision song contest in Basel.
Members of the National Union of Journalists in at RTÉ have written to the station's board of management to request that it adds its voice to other European public service broadcasters in opposing Israel's participation.
Israel's participation in the annual song contest has been a point of contention among performers and members of the public over its retaliatory offensive on Gaza – following militant group Hamas' attack on the country in October 2023 – which has killed at least 52,500 people, the majority of them civilians, according to the region's health ministry.
Public broadcasters in Iceland, Slovenia and Spain have publicly opposed Israel's participation this year over its failure to uphold international humanitarian obligations in Gaza.
NUJ staff at RTÉ are calling on their employer to do the same.
Israeli journalism's 'failure' to impartiality
In a letter addressed to RTÉ Director General Kevin Bakhurst, staff at RTÉ address the Israeli blockade on Gaza and its airstrikes on densely-populated areas within the region.
It says Ireland has already recognised these acts as breaches of international humanitarian obligations.
'Ireland's formal stance on Israel's actions is further highlighted by its filing of a Declaration of Intervention at the International Court of Justice in South Africa's case against Israel under the Genocide Convention on 6 January,' the letter to the RTÉ boss states.
Tensions between Israel's contestant and other acts were made clear to the press in Sweden last year.
Alamy File Image
Alamy File Image
The EBU previously banned Russia from the competition over its national broadcaster's failure to uphold public service media standards when reporting on its country's invasion of Ukraine.
Staff at RTÉ argue that Israeli station KAN has made similar breaches in its failure to highlight its government's ban on journalists in Gaza and its indiscriminate targeting of reporters inside densely-populated region.
The NUJ members believe that 'by failing to provide this impartial coverage, KAN's newsroom is no longer functioning in a way which meets its public service obligations, thereby breaching EBU membership rules', the letter states.
It adds that there is a 'moral imperative to act' and request that the station 'in line with other state broadcasters' call on the EBU to suspend Israel's appearance at Eurovision this year.
Advertisement
Killing of journalists in Gaza
Speaking about the letter, RTÉ NUJ chair Trevor Keegan said that the issue was 'pressing' this week, but even more pressing since Israel's pronouncements to conquer Gaza yesterday.
'The formal stance of the Irish state is reflected in strong public sentiment across Ireland, which abhors Israel's actions,' Keegan said. 'We believe that RTÉ should reflect this opposition in its actions within the European Broadcasting Union.'
Chair of the NUJ's Dublin broadcasting branch Emma O'Kelly said that the view from its members were 'clear', that Israel should not be allowed participate in this year's competition and that RTÉ should adopt the same view.
The funeral of journalist Ahmed Al-Louh, who was killed by an Israeli airstrike on Gaza when working in the region in December 2024.
Alamy
Alamy
She added: 'As journalists, we note Israel's targeting and killing of Palestinian media workers, who provide photographic, video and online content to newsrooms across the EBU in the absence of international journalists gaining access to Gaza.
'As well as the loss of life we are deeply concerned at the impact of this on media freedom and the EBU's stated values.
'Considering all of the above, we are requesting that RTÉ, in line with other state broadcasters which have already done so, publicly and as a matter of urgency call on the EBU to suspend Israel's appearance at Eurovision,' she said.
Tensions made clear last year
Last year saw a campaign by pro-Palestine groups to have the country excluded by contest organisers the European Broadcasting Union.
After the first semi-final in Sweden, tensions between performer Eden Golan and other acts were made clear to the press,
The Journal
reported.
There was
audible booing in the Malmö Arena last year as the country's singer and her dancers took to the stage
. There were also loud cheers for her performance throughout her time on stage, including from groups of Israeli fans.
Israel has continued with its offensive in Gaza and plans to contest the Eurovision this year.
On 18 March this year,
Israel breached ceasefire orders between its military and Hamas and resumed strikes on Gaza
– killing more than 2,600 people in the weeks since, many of them women and children, according to local health officials.
A boy wounded after an Israeli army strike is carried into the Al-Shifa hospital in Gaza City yesterday.
Alamy
Alamy
Yesterday, the country's security cabinet announced plans to launch
a full 'conquest' of the region
.
Israel has also
imposed a full blockade on Gaza since 2 March
, with almost every humanitarian aid group operating in Gaza, including the UN, raising the alarm over the dwindling level of food and resources in the region and the risk of famine.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
44 minutes ago
- RTÉ News
Against EU market rules to refuse Israel bond sales, says Makhlouf
The governor of the Central Bank will tell politicians that it cannot refuse to facilitate the sale of Israel war bonds as doing so would break EU capital markets rules. Gabriel Makhlouf is due to outline the position to the Oireachtas Committee on Finance and Public Expenditure this afternoon. In a written opening statement to the committee, which has been seen by RTÉ News, Mr Makhlouf is expected to say the Central Bank is "absolutely appalled" by what is happening in Gaza. However, he will say that "we are required to perform" certain actions under EU rules, and that "we are established by law, we are empowered by law, and we must always act within and in line with the law". Specifically, Mr Makhlouf will say that "one of the powers assigned to us is to perform the functions of a competent authority under the European Prospectus Regulation" and that "this means we must approve a prospectus once certain conditions are met". He will say that: "We are required to approve a prospectus where it meets the standards of completeness, consistency and comprehensibility under the legislation. "Our legal obligations are clear and we do not need guidance to follow them. "For the avoidance of doubt the Central Bank does not issue, sell, trade or list these bonds. And in the case of Israeli sovereign bonds, we do not authorise or supervise them and they are not listed on a stock exchange we regulate. "Under the Prospectus Regulation, it is up to the third-country sovereign to choose one EU member state to apply to for approval of its prospectus. "The competent authority of the chosen member state is then obliged to discharge the relevant duties within the Prospectus Regulation. In effect the Central Bank is carrying out a role mandated by EU law." Mr Makhlouf is also expected to say that while sanctions against Israel have been discussed in the Dáil, "the Central Bank has no mandate to impose sanctions on any state or person for breaches or alleged breaches of international law". He will say: "Unlike the EU sanctions against Russia after its invasion of Ukraine, the EU has not, at this time, adopted sanctions against the state of Israel. "The Central Bank would of course implement any sanctions adopted by the EU that are applicable to the Central Bank's functions, as we have with Russia." The Central Bank's meeting with the committee is taking place on the same day as the Dail votes again on whether to ban the facilitation of Israeli war bonds in Ireland. The cross-party motion was tabled during the Social Democrats speaking time this morning, with a Government counter-motion outlining the actions the Coalition has taken so far due to be voted on tonight. During this morning's debate, Social Democrats deputy leader Cian O'Callaghan said "genocide, let's be clear, is taking place with the sale of Israeli war bonds" and that the Central Bank should "stop facilitating these bonds". He was supported by a number of party colleagues, including Gary Gannon, who said he believes the Government's view is that "genocide is happening but Ireland must do nothing to affect GDP". Sinead Gibney said whatever the rules may be "we have to try" as it could create a "domino effect" among other countries. Sinn Féin Spokesperson on Finance Pearse Doherty described the Government's position as "shameful", alongside party colleague Sean Crowe, who responded to recent Coalition comments that Ireland's position is leading to tangible results. "Gaza is flattened to the ground, people are starving, and you say you're getting tangible results?," he said. "Ireland cannot be a conduit for blood money." Labour TD Ged Nash said regardless of EU rules Ireland should not facilitate Israeli war bonds and should instead "challenge the state of Israel to take us to the international courts", a view repeated by Solidarity-People Before Profit TD Ruth Coppinger and Independent TD Catherine Connolly who said Government is engaged in "cognitive dissonance". Responding to the Opposition's remarks, Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe said there were "far more issues we agree on than do not agree on", before saying if he "refrained from charges of naivety" against some opposition TDs, then he would like them to "refrain from charges or complicity or collaboration" against Government. Minister Donohoe said Government is in his view working "relentlessly" to "build a diplomatic coalition" on the issue, and outlined a number of measures the coalition has taken so far. Responding to the key point being discussed, he said: "I want to again set the record straight, the Central Bank does not oversee the sale of Israeli war bonds" and that the opposition motion "wouldn't be consistent with EU law, it would undermine our obligations with the EU". That view was also outlined by a number of Government TDs, including Fianna Fáil TDs Paul McAuliffe and Robert Troy. Independent TD Barry Heneghan, one of a number of Independent TDs who are supporting Government, voted against the coalition on a similar motion last month. During the Dáil debate, he said the world is witnessing "one of the darkest moments in modern history" in Gaza. He said when a person living in his constituency, who is from Gaza and whose relatives are still there, asked him what Ireland is doing to end the violence, "I couldn't look him in the eye and say I was doing all I can". "We've all seen the images. Gazan children are being starved to death, in full view ... It's not about a technicality, it's about us doing the right thing," Mr Heneghan said.
Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Netanyahu's government faces possible collapse as opposition aims to dissolve it
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's government faces a major test after the opposition submitted a bill to dissolve it, with his ultra-Orthodox coalition partners threatening to support the measure and force early elections. The ultra-Orthodox parties are furious that the government has failed to pass a law exempting their community from mandatory military service, an issue that has bitterly divided the Israeli public during the war in the Gaza Strip. While many expect a last-minute compromise, the vote is the most serious challenge to Mr Netanyahu's government since Hamas' October 7, 2023, attack, the biggest security failure in Israel's history. Benjamin Netanyahu (Abir Sultan/Pool Photo via AP) The opposition submitted a bill to dissolve the Knesset, Israel's parliament. In response, coalition members submitted numerous bills, packing Wednesday's schedule and buying time for last-minute negotiations. The dissolution vote, if it is not pulled, is expected to take place late at night. Separately, Argentina's president Javier Milei will address the Knesset on Wednesday. Even if the bill passes, it could take weeks or months for new elections to be called. If the bill fails, another vote for dissolution cannot be brought again for at least six months. The opposition could pull the bill if there is not enough support and submit it again in the coming weeks. Mr Netanyahu's coalition includes two ultra-Orthodox parties, and both would need to support the dissolution bill for it to pass. On Tuesday, top Haredi rabbis issued a religious decree emphasising their stand against military service, which complicates the Haredi politicians' ability to negotiate. Military service is mandatory for most Jews in Israel, but the politically powerful ultra-Orthodox, who make up roughly 13% of Israeli society, have traditionally received exemptions if they are studying full-time in religious seminaries. The ultra-Orthodox, also known as Haredim, or 'God-fearing' in Hebrew, say that integrating into the army threatens their traditional way of life. Israel is engaged in the longest active war in the country's history, which has stretched its military to the breaking point. The Haredim's widespread refusal to serve, and threats to topple the government during wartime, have enraged many Israelis, especially those who have served multiple rounds of reserve duty. Since the start of the war, 866 Israeli soldiers have been killed.
Irish Independent
2 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Central Bank ‘cannot impose sanctions on Israel', Oireachtas committee to be told over approval of Israeli bonds
Governor Gabriel Makhlouf is to tell the Oireachtas Finance Committee that it is up to international bodies including the UN and the EU to respond to breaches of international law by Israel, and to determine if sanctions are necessary. 'The Central Bank cannot impose sanctions on Israel – for example by refusing to approve the Israeli bond prospectus – in circumstances where the EU has not imposed any such sanctions itself,' he will tell TDs and Senators. The Committee is to question the Central Bank over its role in approving a prospectus – a legal document that bond issuers are required to prepare. To be sold in the EU, bonds from non-EU countries must have their bond prospectus approved by an EU country. Israel traditionally had its European bond prospectuses approved in the UK, but turned to the Central Bank in Ireland for authorisations after Brexit. In his opening statement to the Finance Committee, Mr Makhlouf will say he is 'absolutely appalled by the horrific loss of life and destruction we are seeing in Gaza and the occupied Palestinian territories.' But he says the EU is responsible for trade policy: 'The Central Bank cannot impose sanctions on Israel – for example by refusing to approve the Israeli bond prospectus – in circumstances where the EU has not imposed any such sanctions itself,' he says, 'Unlike the EU sanctions against Russia after its invasion of Ukraine, the EU has not, at this time, adopted sanctions against the State of Israel. The Central Bank would of course implement any sanctions adopted by the EU that are applicable to the Central Bank's functions, as we have with Russia,' he says. He will dismiss opposition party claims that the Central Bank could refuse to approve the Israeli bond prospectus on the basis the International Court of Justice ruling that Israel's presence in the Occupied Palestinian Territories is unlawful. 'This is incorrect,' his opening statement will say. 'The Central Bank cannot decide to impose sanctions for breaches or alleged breaches of international law.' The Bank 'must carry out the statutory tasks and functions' assigned to it, he will say. 'We have to work within the law and the prospectus issued by the State of Israel meets the standards of completeness, consistency and comprehensibility required by the law. We will continue to carefully and comprehensively discharge our obligations under the EU Prospectus Regulation.'
