Google must pay South African media over $27mn annually
Google should pay South African media houses between R300 to 500 million annually over 3-5 years to address lost revenue and the imbalance in shared value. These were the findings of the Competition Commission's Media and Digital Platforms Market Inquiry (MDPMI) provisional report, which was released on Monday.
The report called for action against search engines like Google and social media sites like Meta. The MDPMI was created and empowered by the Commission to establish an inquiry to investigate if there are features that may prevent and impede competition in the South African media landscape.
Paula Fray, a panel member at the commission explained search engines like Google play a major role in helping and hurting South African media organisations. She explained that Google receives between R800 to R900 million from South African news content. The search engine, however, destroys around R160 to R200 million in potential value for South African media.
'Our assessment is that the imbalance in the share of total value is around R300 to R500 million annually,' Fray said.
The inquiry also found that there is a definite bias in Google's algorithm, and this disadvantages South African media organisations in favour of international news outlets.
The MDPMI found that a majority of South Africans use social media as their primary news source. The report found that platforms like X, TikTok, Meta, and YouTube drive news consumption in the country. Fray said that Meta and X have deprioritised South African posts with links and this reduces referral traffic.
The report also found that South African news outlets are struggling to monetise views on YouTube in particular.
James Hodge, the MDPMI chairperson said that South Africa needs to impose a 5-10% digital levy or tariff on social media and AI companies to compensate SA media for their loss in revenue. He said that search engines need to also restore referral traffic.
Google needs to adjust search algorithms to support SA news media and reduce bias toward foreign platforms, Hodge explained. These search engines also need to help support monetisation. He said that Google for example needs to share anonymised user data and provide SEO assistance.
In terms of direct compensation, Hodge said that Google should pay SA media houses between R300 to 500 million annually over 3-5 years to address lost revenue and the imbalance in shared value.
He also added that Meta needs to stop deprioritising news on the Facebook feed to restore referral traffic to the media from its peak with at least a 100% increase in referral traffic. It is important that Meta and X also stop deprioritising news posts with links in the user feed.
Lastly, Hodge said that YouTube needs to improve the ability of the media and broadcasters, including the SABC, to monetise their content on its platform through increases in the revenue share to 70% and active promotion of higher value direct sales by the media.First published by IOL
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Russia Today
20 hours ago
- Russia Today
Ukraine sentences exiled Zelensky critic to 15 years in jail
A Ukrainian court on Tuesday sentenced Spain-based journalist Anatoly Shariy, a vocal critic of Vladimir Zelensky, to 15 years in prison in absentia on treason charges. Shariy dismissed the verdict as a sham trial driven by political motives and executed by a judiciary loyal to Kiev. Shariy, who was granted political asylum in the European Union in 2012, initially supported Zelensky's 2019 presidential campaign but later turned against the administration, accusing it of drifting toward authoritarianism and aligning with radical nationalist elements. He gained prominence for his political commentary on YouTube, where he has amassed more than 3.3 million followers. The Security Service of Ukraine (SBU) highlighted the conviction in a statement, emphasizing that it presented crucial evidence to the Vinnitsa city court. The agency noted the 'unprecedented' section of the ruling that ordered the confiscation of Shariy's YouTube channel. Shariy said the case centered on a single video he posted in May 2022, which included a partially redacted interview with a Ukrainian soldier held in Russian custody. He prefaced the segment with a warning urging viewers to approach it critically. The soldier had accused Ukraine's military leadership of abandoning troops during the battle for Mariupol. The SBU alleged that Shariy advised Russian forces on how to film similar interviews for greater impact. The agency also claimed he obtained the footage from a former police chief in Vinnitsa, who was convicted of treason in the same trial. Shariy accused the court of denying him a fair defense, claiming his legal team was ignored throughout the proceedings. Zelensky's administration has long been accused of silencing dissenting voices by labeling critics and independent media as 'pro-Russian.' The country's National Security and Defense Council, chaired by Zelensky, has imposed personal sanctions on exiled opposition leader Viktor Medvedchuk, former President Pyotr Poroshenko, and Aleksey Arestovich, a former presidential aide who later became a vocal opponent of Zelensky. Ukrainian lawmaker Evgeny Shevchenko has been detained since November on suspicion of spreading 'pro-Russian propaganda.' Another MP, Artyom Dmitruk, fled Ukraine after reportedly drawing Zelensky's ire by publicly opposing the government's crackdown on the Ukrainian Orthodox Church.
Russia Today
30-05-2025
- Russia Today
Russian MP lays out terms for YouTube's return
YouTube can only resume full operations in Russia if it fulfills a series of legal and technical conditions, State Duma member Anton Nemkin has told RIA Novosti. Although not officially blocked, YouTube has been largely inaccessible in Russia since last year, when its loading speed began slow dramatically. Authorities blamed a lack of server maintenance following Google's exit from the country in 2022. Later, officials partially confirmed the slowdown was also linked to YouTube's failure to comply with Russian law. Nemkin said on Friday that YouTube needed to deal with abandoned equipment, settle outstanding fines, and establish a legal entity in Russia before the platform's functionality in the country can be fully restored. The MP also called on YouTube to restore access to blocked Russian accounts. The platform has removed some media outlets, including RT and Sputnik, and has repeatedly taken down channels run by Russian bloggers, journalists, and artists. Moscow says the removals target content that reflects views diverging from those prevalent in the West. 'Without these steps, it's impossible to speak of any 'easing' – this is not about politics, but legal compliance,' Nemkin said. In March, it was reported that Russian-registered Google LLC owed national broadcasters $1.16 quintillion in fines for failing to restore their YouTube channels. In January, RBK said the international Google corporation owed more than $22 undecillion. The Kremlin described the figures as symbolic, intended to pressure the company into complying with Russian law. Nemkin said dialogue with global platforms such as YouTube could only happen on Russia's terms. 'This is not about bans for the sake of bans, but about equal rights,' he said, adding that companies must comply with local laws, pay taxes, and store user data in Russia. The lawmaker called for an end to the era of unchecked power for major IT companies. If foreign platforms are restored, 'there is no going back to the old dependence.' 'We've learned a harsh but valuable lesson: we cannot build our digital future on platforms that can flip the switch at any moment,' he said, adding that YouTube should no longer serve as the foundation of Russia's internet landscape. Nemkin pointed out that Russia is now developing its own infrastructure – search engines, cloud storage, video hosting, and ad systems – in support of its 'digital sovereignty.'
Russia Today
29-05-2025
- Russia Today
AI CEO issues stark warning
Artificial intelligence could eliminate half of all entry-level white-collar jobs within the next five years, the CEO of American AI research company Anthropic, Dario Amodei has warned. In a statement to Axios published on Wednesday, Amodei, who co-founded Anthropic and is a former OpenAI executive, said he hopes to jolt the US government and fellow developers into preparing for the consequences of rapid automation. AI could spike unemployment in the US to 10-20% in the next one to five years, he warned. AI development companies are already working on systems that could soon replace workers in technology, finance, law, consulting and other white-collar professions, particularly entry-level positions, Amodei claimed. The public and politicians are still 'unaware' that a major shift is about to happen and insisted that companies and officials needed to stop 'sugar-coating' what lies ahead, particularly for younger workers. Earlier this month, a report by the Linux Foundation, commissioned by Meta, found that open source AI is already transforming the economy by boosting efficiency, innovation, cost savings, and revenue gains. However, Amodei has expressed concern that people could continue to stay ignorant of the threat of being replaced by AI, especially if the US government chooses to stay silent on the issue out of fear of spooking workers or falling behind China. Soon, 'almost overnight,' business leaders will see savings in replacing humans with AI and implement a change 'en masse.' They will stop opening new jobs or backfilling existing ones, and replace human workers with automated alternatives, Amodei claimed. He has proposed several mitigation strategies, including a special index to track AI's impact across occupations, and briefings for lawmakers to raise awareness. He also suggested a 'token tax' — a system where a percentage of AI-generated revenue would be redistributed by the government. Amodei's warning comes as a number of major companies have recently started laying off a considerable amount of workers, which some believe is being done in anticipation of major shifts due to AI. Earlier this month, Microsoft fired some 6,000 workers, mostly engineers, despite reporting strong sales and profits. Walmart has cut 1,500 corporate jobs to 'simplify operations' while Crowdstrike - a Texas based cybersecurity company - has slashed 500 positions citing 'a market and technology inflection point, with AI reshaping every industry.'
