Cats coach: ultra-conservatives should lay off Smith
The AFL's "ultra-conservative" finger-waggers should lay off polarising Geelong recruit Bailey Smith, his coach says.
Cats coach Chris Scott has shrugged off Smith's latest stint in the headlines as trivial.
Smith, after Geelong defeated his former side Western Bulldogs, responded to a comment on his Instagram profile asking whether he had 'nose beers' - a common reference to cocaine - to celebrate.
Smith replied: 'Na bro, after the flag maybe tho.' before later deleting the comment.
AFL chief Andrew Dillon said bluntly of Smith's interaction: "We wouldn't want to see it again."
But coach Scott said the issue barely created a ripple inside Geelong.
"The simple way of describing the interaction between our key people and Bailey has been one where he has kind of approached us and gone: 'I wish I hadn't of done that'," Scott told reporters on Thursday.
"And we're like: 'We're a bit the same. But it's not a hanging offence'.
"But in the end, I just don't think we need ultra-conservative people wagging their finger at Bailey."
Scott then added sarcastically: "I appreciate your help, but we have got it covered."
The Cats coach reiterated his stance against sanctions.
"Things like warnings and when it extends to penalties just remind me of the way teachers treat little kids," he said.
"There's always going to be that other side of the world where people enjoy seeing people get punished.
"And even if I take it a bit further - and this is my personal view, I am not necessarily representing the position of the football club - but I am not sure we should be tipping in to these people that choose to bait players or prominent people and take glee when they see them get punished.
"I am not playing that game."
Scott was also asked about his name being mentioned in speculation surrounding the AFL's new Tasmanian entity.
"I think it would be enticing for a coach. But not as enticing as Geelong," he said.
The fifth-placed Cats (seven wins, four losses) travel to play West Coast on Sunday with Brownlow medallist Patrick Dangerfield (hamstring), Jhye Clark (concussion) and Jack Bowes (hamstring) to miss.
Scott said Dangerfield was likely to return for the June 7 clash against Gold Coast in Geelong with Bowes "a couple of weeks after that".
Veteran Cam Guthrie, who returned in VFL ranks last weekend, would remain in the state league for at least another fortnight.
Guthrie has played only 10 AFL games since 2023 - the most recent was in round 11 last year - because of various injuries, the latest an achilles problem.
The AFL's "ultra-conservative" finger-waggers should lay off polarising Geelong recruit Bailey Smith, his coach says.
Cats coach Chris Scott has shrugged off Smith's latest stint in the headlines as trivial.
Smith, after Geelong defeated his former side Western Bulldogs, responded to a comment on his Instagram profile asking whether he had 'nose beers' - a common reference to cocaine - to celebrate.
Smith replied: 'Na bro, after the flag maybe tho.' before later deleting the comment.
AFL chief Andrew Dillon said bluntly of Smith's interaction: "We wouldn't want to see it again."
But coach Scott said the issue barely created a ripple inside Geelong.
"The simple way of describing the interaction between our key people and Bailey has been one where he has kind of approached us and gone: 'I wish I hadn't of done that'," Scott told reporters on Thursday.
"And we're like: 'We're a bit the same. But it's not a hanging offence'.
"But in the end, I just don't think we need ultra-conservative people wagging their finger at Bailey."
Scott then added sarcastically: "I appreciate your help, but we have got it covered."
The Cats coach reiterated his stance against sanctions.
"Things like warnings and when it extends to penalties just remind me of the way teachers treat little kids," he said.
"There's always going to be that other side of the world where people enjoy seeing people get punished.
"And even if I take it a bit further - and this is my personal view, I am not necessarily representing the position of the football club - but I am not sure we should be tipping in to these people that choose to bait players or prominent people and take glee when they see them get punished.
"I am not playing that game."
Scott was also asked about his name being mentioned in speculation surrounding the AFL's new Tasmanian entity.
"I think it would be enticing for a coach. But not as enticing as Geelong," he said.
The fifth-placed Cats (seven wins, four losses) travel to play West Coast on Sunday with Brownlow medallist Patrick Dangerfield (hamstring), Jhye Clark (concussion) and Jack Bowes (hamstring) to miss.
Scott said Dangerfield was likely to return for the June 7 clash against Gold Coast in Geelong with Bowes "a couple of weeks after that".
Veteran Cam Guthrie, who returned in VFL ranks last weekend, would remain in the state league for at least another fortnight.
Guthrie has played only 10 AFL games since 2023 - the most recent was in round 11 last year - because of various injuries, the latest an achilles problem.
The AFL's "ultra-conservative" finger-waggers should lay off polarising Geelong recruit Bailey Smith, his coach says.
Cats coach Chris Scott has shrugged off Smith's latest stint in the headlines as trivial.
Smith, after Geelong defeated his former side Western Bulldogs, responded to a comment on his Instagram profile asking whether he had 'nose beers' - a common reference to cocaine - to celebrate.
Smith replied: 'Na bro, after the flag maybe tho.' before later deleting the comment.
AFL chief Andrew Dillon said bluntly of Smith's interaction: "We wouldn't want to see it again."
But coach Scott said the issue barely created a ripple inside Geelong.
"The simple way of describing the interaction between our key people and Bailey has been one where he has kind of approached us and gone: 'I wish I hadn't of done that'," Scott told reporters on Thursday.
"And we're like: 'We're a bit the same. But it's not a hanging offence'.
"But in the end, I just don't think we need ultra-conservative people wagging their finger at Bailey."
Scott then added sarcastically: "I appreciate your help, but we have got it covered."
The Cats coach reiterated his stance against sanctions.
"Things like warnings and when it extends to penalties just remind me of the way teachers treat little kids," he said.
"There's always going to be that other side of the world where people enjoy seeing people get punished.
"And even if I take it a bit further - and this is my personal view, I am not necessarily representing the position of the football club - but I am not sure we should be tipping in to these people that choose to bait players or prominent people and take glee when they see them get punished.
"I am not playing that game."
Scott was also asked about his name being mentioned in speculation surrounding the AFL's new Tasmanian entity.
"I think it would be enticing for a coach. But not as enticing as Geelong," he said.
The fifth-placed Cats (seven wins, four losses) travel to play West Coast on Sunday with Brownlow medallist Patrick Dangerfield (hamstring), Jhye Clark (concussion) and Jack Bowes (hamstring) to miss.
Scott said Dangerfield was likely to return for the June 7 clash against Gold Coast in Geelong with Bowes "a couple of weeks after that".
Veteran Cam Guthrie, who returned in VFL ranks last weekend, would remain in the state league for at least another fortnight.
Guthrie has played only 10 AFL games since 2023 - the most recent was in round 11 last year - because of various injuries, the latest an achilles problem.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sky News AU
an hour ago
- Sky News AU
Tasmanian election could compromise plans for proposed AFL team
Stepmates Studios' Mark Nicholson mocks the upcoming Tasmanian election and whether it affects the proposed Tasmanian AFL team. 'Please, I need another little baby team with some really young talent that barely know how to play football,' Mr Nicholson told Sky News host Chris Kenny. 'I need it terribly … you'll just need another team to stream roll, but North Melbourne desperately need this.'
News.com.au
2 hours ago
- News.com.au
Kane Cornes apologises for ‘misleading' AFL umpire comments
A controversial footy analyst has apologised after a quartet of top-level AFL umpires contemplated legal action against three Channel 7 stars after being 'falsely accused of lying and misleading the AFL'. Comments from former AFL players Kane Cornes, Dale Thomas and Luke Hodge regarding the umpires' handling of Lachie Schultz' Round 9 concussion were at the centre of the potential legal proceedings. FOX FOOTY, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every match of every round in the 2025 Toyota AFL Premiership Season LIVE in 4K, with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Get your first month for just $1. Limited-time offer. The remarks were made on May 13 during The Agenda Setters program and were subsequently promoted online. On Thursday night, Cornes apologised via his radio platform SEN. The other two are expected to apologise on TV over the weekend. 'On May 14th edition of SEN Sportsday I accused field umpires who were officiating that round nine match between Fremantle and Collingwood of misleading the AFL and that they had not seen the incident in which Collingwood's Lachie Schultz suffered a concussion,' Cornes said. 'I made some of those comments having seen two initial statements made by the AFL with regards to the matter on Friday May 9th, and then also on Tuesday May the 13th. And further comments after seeing the additional statement made by the AFL, readdressing their initial statements. 'Now in light of the additional statement, which made it clear that the umpires had not misled the AFL, I acknowledge that the allegations made by me on this show were false and I withdraw them. 'I understand the umpires truthfully told the AFL that they saw the incident and did not mislead the AFL. So I unreservedly apologise to Simon Meredith, Craig Fleer, Justin Power and Martin Roger for making these false allegations.' Meredith, Fleer, Power and Rodger were the officiating umpires in the clash between Fremantle and Collingwood, in which Schultz was concussed during the final quarter. After the Magpies forward collided with Docker Jordan Clark, a notable amount of time passed before play was stopped to allow trainers to safely remove the forward from the field of play. The handling of the incident led to conflicting interpretations between the AFL and the officiating team. The league initially stated that the umpires had not seen the injured player and therefore didn't stop play. However, broadcast footage and accompanying umpire audio, aired by Seven, included one official stating: 'Got an injured player in the middle. I'm watching. We are OK. We are OK.' An umpire was then soon heard telling a player: 'We can only stop the play if the ball is coming near or if they instruct us to.' This was in direct contrast to the AFL's statement the day after the clash in Perth, which 'the umpires did not see the injured player at the time, so play continued'. The umpires were then accused of providing deceitful information to the league, but were later cleared of any wrongdoing as the league cited a miscommunication within the umpiring division. The AFL's error left the umpiring quartet susceptible to a mountain of backlash, inclusive of the Channel 7 personalities. 'It (the consideration of legal action) all stems from comments from three weeks ago, and the umpires remain filthy,' Morris reported on Nine's news bulletin, before elaborating later on Footy Classified with a statement from AFL Umpires Association chief executive Rob Kerr. 'The four umpires involved in the Schultz debacle three weeks ago … are considering taking legal action against Kane Cornes, Dale Thomas and Luke Hodge for comments that they made on (Seven) on May 13.' Speaking on Triple M, Thomas said, as of Wednesday morning, that he 'hadn't received any formal documents from anyone'. He added: 'While I am aware of the statement that's been made and the report, I honestly can't say anything more until more information or anything else is brought to light. 'Unfortunately I can't give any greater insight to it, but that's as much as I can say.'
The Advertiser
2 hours ago
- The Advertiser
Suns' top-four spot on line in Geelong 'litmus test'
Damien Hardwick doesn't know how much progress he's made in attempting to turn Gold Coast into genuine AFL finals threats, and ultimately flag contenders. But the three-time Richmond premiership coach feels he's about to find out. Stung by a tough home loss to Fremantle, the Suns (8-3) take on Geelong (8-4) at GMHBA Stadium on Saturday in what shapes as another huge examination of their credentials. "It's a great litmus test for our group and how far we've come," Gold Coast coach Hardwick said on Thursday. "Every game is another opportunity to improve and build on our identity piece, and we're really looking forward to the challenge. "They're an outstanding football club - well-coached, well-drilled and very experienced in what they do and how they operate - so it's going to be a great test for us." Hardwick declared last week's 11-point defeat to Fremantle a "gift" that highlighted some shortcomings the Suns need to work on. At the top of the list was giving up easy scores, with Hardwick admitting his side paid too much "crap goal tax" early in the match. "We gave up about four goals that are unlike us and unfortunately we paid the price," he said. "What we have learnt though is that in every game we give ourselves an opportunity. "Our system keeps us safe and it's an arm-wrestle and then hopefully eventually we come over the top. "The great thing about our season thus far is we've done that more times than not." Hardwick, a veteran of 548 AFL games as a player and senior coach, will venture to Geelong's Kardinia Park ground for just the fifth time since his debut for Essendon in 1994. The 52-year-old is still searching for his first victory at the venue, where the Cats are rarely beaten. So too are the Suns, who are winless in eight attempts. It will be Gold Coast's first trip to GMHBA Stadium since August 2021, when they were thrashed by Essendon in front of empty stands at the height of the COVID-19 pandemic. "People often talk about how skinny the 'Cattery' is, but it's the length, in my view, that generally challenges you the most," Hardwick said. "You've sort of got to play to the ball, not the markings on the ground. "What the Cats are very good at is getting marks inside-50, so we've got to make sure we understand they don't want to kick long and they're not going to kick long. "We've got to make sure we defend those little lead-ups." Hardwick changed the dimensions of Gold Coast's training ground to match those of GMHBA Stadium in preparation for Saturday's contest. Damien Hardwick doesn't know how much progress he's made in attempting to turn Gold Coast into genuine AFL finals threats, and ultimately flag contenders. But the three-time Richmond premiership coach feels he's about to find out. Stung by a tough home loss to Fremantle, the Suns (8-3) take on Geelong (8-4) at GMHBA Stadium on Saturday in what shapes as another huge examination of their credentials. "It's a great litmus test for our group and how far we've come," Gold Coast coach Hardwick said on Thursday. "Every game is another opportunity to improve and build on our identity piece, and we're really looking forward to the challenge. "They're an outstanding football club - well-coached, well-drilled and very experienced in what they do and how they operate - so it's going to be a great test for us." Hardwick declared last week's 11-point defeat to Fremantle a "gift" that highlighted some shortcomings the Suns need to work on. At the top of the list was giving up easy scores, with Hardwick admitting his side paid too much "crap goal tax" early in the match. "We gave up about four goals that are unlike us and unfortunately we paid the price," he said. "What we have learnt though is that in every game we give ourselves an opportunity. "Our system keeps us safe and it's an arm-wrestle and then hopefully eventually we come over the top. "The great thing about our season thus far is we've done that more times than not." Hardwick, a veteran of 548 AFL games as a player and senior coach, will venture to Geelong's Kardinia Park ground for just the fifth time since his debut for Essendon in 1994. The 52-year-old is still searching for his first victory at the venue, where the Cats are rarely beaten. So too are the Suns, who are winless in eight attempts. It will be Gold Coast's first trip to GMHBA Stadium since August 2021, when they were thrashed by Essendon in front of empty stands at the height of the COVID-19 pandemic. "People often talk about how skinny the 'Cattery' is, but it's the length, in my view, that generally challenges you the most," Hardwick said. "You've sort of got to play to the ball, not the markings on the ground. "What the Cats are very good at is getting marks inside-50, so we've got to make sure we understand they don't want to kick long and they're not going to kick long. "We've got to make sure we defend those little lead-ups." Hardwick changed the dimensions of Gold Coast's training ground to match those of GMHBA Stadium in preparation for Saturday's contest. Damien Hardwick doesn't know how much progress he's made in attempting to turn Gold Coast into genuine AFL finals threats, and ultimately flag contenders. But the three-time Richmond premiership coach feels he's about to find out. Stung by a tough home loss to Fremantle, the Suns (8-3) take on Geelong (8-4) at GMHBA Stadium on Saturday in what shapes as another huge examination of their credentials. "It's a great litmus test for our group and how far we've come," Gold Coast coach Hardwick said on Thursday. "Every game is another opportunity to improve and build on our identity piece, and we're really looking forward to the challenge. "They're an outstanding football club - well-coached, well-drilled and very experienced in what they do and how they operate - so it's going to be a great test for us." Hardwick declared last week's 11-point defeat to Fremantle a "gift" that highlighted some shortcomings the Suns need to work on. At the top of the list was giving up easy scores, with Hardwick admitting his side paid too much "crap goal tax" early in the match. "We gave up about four goals that are unlike us and unfortunately we paid the price," he said. "What we have learnt though is that in every game we give ourselves an opportunity. "Our system keeps us safe and it's an arm-wrestle and then hopefully eventually we come over the top. "The great thing about our season thus far is we've done that more times than not." Hardwick, a veteran of 548 AFL games as a player and senior coach, will venture to Geelong's Kardinia Park ground for just the fifth time since his debut for Essendon in 1994. The 52-year-old is still searching for his first victory at the venue, where the Cats are rarely beaten. So too are the Suns, who are winless in eight attempts. It will be Gold Coast's first trip to GMHBA Stadium since August 2021, when they were thrashed by Essendon in front of empty stands at the height of the COVID-19 pandemic. "People often talk about how skinny the 'Cattery' is, but it's the length, in my view, that generally challenges you the most," Hardwick said. "You've sort of got to play to the ball, not the markings on the ground. "What the Cats are very good at is getting marks inside-50, so we've got to make sure we understand they don't want to kick long and they're not going to kick long. "We've got to make sure we defend those little lead-ups." Hardwick changed the dimensions of Gold Coast's training ground to match those of GMHBA Stadium in preparation for Saturday's contest.
