Paddleboard guide jailed for 10 years over deaths of four people in Wales
A former police officer has been jailed for 10 years and six months after leading a paddleboarding expedition on a rain-swollen river that ended in four people losing their lives.
Nerys Lloyd, 39, pleaded guilty to four counts of gross negligence manslaughter and a Health and Safety at Work offence over the tragedy on the River Cleddau in Haverfordwest, south-west Wales.
Morgan Rogers, 24, Nicola Wheatley, 40, Andrea Powell, 41, and Lloyd's co-instructor Paul O'Dwyer, 42, a former soldier, died in October 2021.
Mrs Justice Stacey told Swansea crown court she would be released no later than two-thirds of the way through her sentence and the remainder would be served on licence in the community.
The judge told Lloyd the group had put its trust in her but she had failed to check the state of the weir and it would not have been possible for a paddleboard to navigate the structure when the current was so strong and volume of water so large.
Stacey said that after falling from their boards, the party was caught in a 'hydraulic spin', comparing it to a washing machine.
She highlighted that none of the participants had the right sort of paddleboard leash for the conditions they faced – they had ankle leashes rather than quick-release waist ones.
Stacey said that as a firearms officer and an RNLI volunteer Lloyd should have been 'well versed' in health and safety issues. 'You knew what you should do but failed to do it.'
In a statement to the judge, Lloyd said she took 'full blame' for the failures but David Elias KC, for the defendant, said the plan had not been for the party to go over the weir but get out and walk around it.
The judge disagreed this had been the plan – otherwise she would have told the group this was what was going to happen. 'There was no clear plan to walk around,' the judge said.
Stacey said Lloyd had painted a 'false narrative' of what happened and tried to 'disproportionately' blame O'Dwyer for the tragedy. 'You were the owner [of the paddleboard business]. He lost his life trying to save others,' the judge said.
During an emotional two-day sentencing hearing at Swansea crown court, relatives of the victims claimed Lloyd was arrogant to guide the group despite the stormy conditions and her lack of expertise, and said she had shown no remorse over her failings.
Lloyd, who had been at the front of the party, managed to navigate a weir in the river by shooting through a fish ramp.
But other participants fell from their boards after plunging 1.3 metres over the weir. The court heard almost 2 tonnes of water was crossing a 1 metre-wide section of the weir crest every second. O'Dwyer scrambled out but died after going back into the water to try to save the others, who were all described as either beginner or intermediate paddleboarders.
The court heard that Lloyd was suspended from South Wales police at the time of the tragedy after accepting a caution for a fraudulent insurance claim involving a vehicle.
She had advertised the River Cleddau trip on Facebook for £149 a person to include overnight accommodation and supervision by two 'fully' qualified instructors.
But Lloyd did not carry out risk assessments or obtain next-of-kin details for the victims – leading to a delay in contacting some family members, the court heard.
The incident led to calls for regulations around paddleboarding to be tightened.
Darren Wheatley, the husband of Nicola Wheatley, said: 'Losing Nicola has devastated our family and two young children lost their mammy.
'Nicola died in circumstances that were completely avoidable and should not have happened. Decisions made by Nerys Lloyd, and only Nerys Lloyd, led to the four lives lost.
'Any sentence served by Nerys in prison will never ease the pain of losing Nicola, and our lives will never be the same again.'
One woman who was part of the group but survived, Melody Johns, told the court: 'Paddleboarding is largely unregulated and boards are still being sold without quick-release leashes that can save lives. Many people are continuing to buy boards without much thought about safety. Something needs to change.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
5 days ago
- Yahoo
The French are the true enemy
Ecoutez! The annual summer surge in Channel crossings is upon us, and with it, some interesting sights and sounds. Stand on the Kent coast and stare out to sea, and you may well spot the RNLI 'taxi service' bringing in another boat load of migrants. Put a shell to your ear and you will hear the sound of the French authorities doing absolutely nothing. As the number of asylum seekers making the crossing reaches almost 1,200 in a single day, our Prime Minister seems unable to do anything more than parrot the same empty words about 'smashing vile people-smuggling gangs.' As a strategy, it is hopelessly misconceived, for as long there's money to be made from the trade, new people traffickers will spring up to fill any gap. How about Sir Keir Starmer declares war on a much easier target – namely the French? Having spent the last month prostrating himself to Brussels in the name of 'resetting' the UK's relationship with the EU, the last thing that Starmer will want is a diplomatic row with our neighbours. However, as the gendarmes stand idly by on the beaches of Dunkirk, watching hundreds of migrants board boats with a giant Gallic shrug, it is time for the Prime Minister to face facts. So far from being our allies, the French are perilously close to becoming the enemy in this fight. During his premiership, Rishi Sunak dramatically increased the amount of money we throw at the French to help us deal with the crisis, announcing a £500 million deal with president Emmanuel Macron. The cash, to be paid over three years, was earmarked for 500 extra French police officers and a new detention centre. Naturally, the French lapped it up as eagerly as onion soup. More than two years later, what is there to show for this colossal investment? The square root of rien. To the surprise of absolutely no-one, the £12.5 million detention centre, which was supposed to be operational by the end of 2026, is already a year behind schedule. Given French labour laws and general lackadaisical attitudes to work, Starmer will be lucky if he is still in Number 10 when it finally opens. In the meantime, the French aren't even doing the small stuff. Gendarmes seem curiously reluctant to disable dinghies even when there are no migrants or people smugglers in the vicinity of the boats. It would take no more than a few minutes to puncture the vessels that are regularly (and very obviously) moored along the River Aa, which leads to the French Channel, yet patrol cars have been filmed gaily driving by. If that is too adventurous, how about erecting some simple fences? Sure, there is a long coastline to patrol, but those familiar with key departure points say physical barriers would make a big difference at certain hotspots. If the Americans can put up more than 1,000 miles of forbidding barbed wire fences, sensors, cameras and other surveillance equipment along the US-Mexico border, surely the French could come up with the odd crash barrier? Yesterday a French politician blamed us for this unholy mess, citing our 'very weak asylum policy.' Eleonore Caroit also suggested that if we want to stop migrants abusing our generosity, we stop rolling out the red carpet in the form of lavish accommodation and benefits. She is absolutely right – but it would be spectacularly helpful if her compatriots also stopped taking us for a ride. Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.
Yahoo
5 days ago
- Yahoo
Missing Girl's Body Found in River After She Entered Water with Young Boy: 'A Community in Grief'
A missing girl's body was found in the River Thames in England on Saturday, May 31, Kent Police said The previous day a young boy was rescued from the water and hospitalized after the two entered the river together "At the heart of this is a family and community in grief," local politician Lauren Sullivan wrote on social mediaA missing girl's body has been found in the River Thames in England after she entered the water with a young boy the day prior. At around 1:46 p.m. local time on Friday, May 30, Kent Police was alerted by the Port of London Authority that there were concerns about the welfare of two children who had entered the river via Royal Pier Road, Kent Police shared in a news release. The boy, who remains in the hospital, was retrieved from the water after patrols, H.M. Coastguard, the RNLI (Royal National Lifeboat Institution) and South East Coast Ambulance Service rushed to the scene. In the evening, the search for the missing girl was suspended, but Kent Police's Marine Unit and H.M. Coastguard continued on Saturday. They recovered her body from the river near Gravesend at around 11:40 a.m. that day with assistance from the RNLI. The child's 'death is not being treated as suspicious at this stage and a report will be prepared for the coroner,' Kent Police said. She was formally identified by her next of kin. It's believed the girl was aged 9, while the boy is 7, local media outlet Kent Online reported. The outlet added that the pair are thought to be cousins and they were reportedly playing near the water when the girl slipped and got into difficulty. A spokesperson for the nearby Gravesend Rowing Club said a man used a life ring to swim out and retrieve the boy, but was unable to help the girl as he lost sight of her, per Kent Online. The boy is now at a local hospital in a 'stable condition," according to Kent Police's news release. Gravesham MP Lauren Sullivan shared her 'deepest condolences' on the Facebook following the tragic incident. 'I am deeply saddened to hear that a body has been recovered in the search for the girl who went missing in the River Thames in Gravesend yesterday,' she wrote. 'I would like to thank emergency services, including the coastguard, Kent Police, the RNLI, and PLA many others for their efforts in the search." Never miss a story — sign up for to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. 'I know there are many opinions circulating at this time about the circumstances surrounding this tragic event and from speaking to the authorities it is right that there is an investigation, as with all sad circumstances such as these, but at the heart of this is a family and community in grief which I hope everyone can respect,' she added. 'I send my deepest condolences to the family and friends of the child, and keep them all in my thoughts at this time.' PEOPLE has reached out to Kent Police and Gravesend Rowing Club for further information. Read the original article on People
Yahoo
6 days ago
- Yahoo
Man describes rescuing boy from Thames at Gravesend - after body found in search for missing girl
A man has described how he rescued a boy from the River Thames - after a body was found in the search for a girl who went missing during the same incident. George Karnovski says he pulled what he said was an "11-year-old" boy out of the river after he got into difficulty near the Royal Terrace Pier in Gravesend in Kent. He said once he had the child on a buoy, he was "just screaming" as he struggled in the water. Kent Police and the RNLI (Royal National Lifeboat Institution) recovered the body of the missing girl at around 11.40am on Saturday. Witnesses suggest she was the boy's younger sister. Formal identification by the girl's next of kin has taken place, and the death is not being treated as suspicious, police said. Emergency services were called on Friday afternoon after concerns were raised for the two children who had entered the river at nearby Royal Pier Road. Mr Karnvoski said: "At the same time as pulling him out, I was looking around, like, where is she, where is she? "I'm shouting, saying 'there's one more, there's one more'. I'm looking around, [but] for love nor money, I cannot see the little girl." Mr Karnovski, 37, who is a member of the RAF, had been visiting his family who live in the town. He said they had been out on a walk when they heard that children were in trouble in the water, which he said had "a strong current". His brother Jack, who lives in the area, said he had seen his wife "scream, and point at the river. I assumed it was my children. I went running and shouted to my brother". The pair discovered there was only one life ring, and so only George, who said he had previously had lifeguard training, could enter the water for safety reasons. Jack said that when George jumped in, he "said he never felt the bottom. We had to run down the jetty because the tide was running up". "The jetty is quite long. By the time you ran down it, it was deep water," he added. George said the conditions in the water at the time were "tough", even for an experienced adult swimmer. By the time he entered the water, he says the children were about 40 to 50 metres (131 to 164 feet) away, and it took him about two minutes to get to them. "I started swimming. I went quite hard to begin with, but then started running out of steam," he said. Read more on Sky News:Two dead in violence after finalBritain 'has lost control of borders'Two Britons shot dead in Spain Jack, who was on the pier directing George in his efforts to rescue the children, said the children were travelling quickly with the strength of the water. "In terms of the current, they'd fallen off the jetty. They were about 50 metres away, going towards London. By the time my brother had caught up with them, I'd say he was 150 to 200 metres (492 to 656 feet) away. So that gives you an idea. In a couple of minutes, they'd gone 100m (328 feet) or more down the Thames," he said. The brothers said other organisations helped the rescue efforts, including the RNLI and the London Port Authority (LPA). The LPA said in a statement they "are continuing to support police with their inquiries into exactly what happened, and where and how the children entered the water. It is so sad and the thoughts of the whole of the LPA are with their loved ones".
